>Everyone( except religious right types) knows that every force has an equal and opposite force. So, if a lathe has something out of balance turning on it, there are all kinds of forces, which can even walk the lathe down the floor. Now, the big question is: do you bolt the lathe to the floor( or , more or less accomplish the same thing with heavy weights) ? Or not? If you bolt it or use heavy weights, then the bearings will have to take the load. If you don't, then it just vibrates or moves a little -- but the bearings are spared. Which do you do?
>I think it is better to have a lathe which has bearings and welds which can withstand the stresses of turning out of balance wood. Bolt vs weight vs nothing (actually nothing can be slowing the lathe down). You can also counter balance your wood.
When I turned wood on a smaller lathe I would balance a hunk of wood on a coke bottle to find the balance point for mounting a faceplate. That made a huge difference in turning irregular hunks of wood. Of course working off the balance points limits design options.
Mount the blank on the lathe and use the tool rest to gauge where the out of round spots are, take electric chain saw and start sawing down high spots until you get it much closer to balanced. This is with the lathe off. As you get it closer to round with the saw you can hold a marker on the tool rest at the outboard end of the blank and mark a circle, or if you can turn the lathe on low speed and use a gouge to mark a circle to use as the saw guide.
>... then the bearings are still taking a beating. Balance the blank as best you can, then keep the speeds that vibrate under control until the piece is balanced and higher speeds are allowed. Bolting the lathe down can jeopardize the castings and possibly torque the bed alignment.
>I've never felt the need to bolt a lathe to the floor. I've had lathes get a little excited, but never had one walk away from me.
Adding weight is a tricky question. Not all forms of added weight are equal. A solid and rigid weight simply adds mass, which helps reduce the amplitude of the vibration. On the other hand, sand bags add mass AND help to damp the vibration. Lead shot does the same thing, which is why it is added to tool handles. I've used containers of sand on several lathes to improve their stability.
>the best way to handle the problem is to avoid it. I debated bolting, but didn't. Now, when I have an out of balance load, I just turn the speed down lower to handle it until I acheive balance.
Once we're round, we're golden!
That being said, I loaded the balast box with gravel (since I had it) and keep my marine battery, and 60# bags of water softener salt on the shelf.
>A (relatively non-religious) friend of mine used a relatively light-weight lathe to turn some relatively amazingly heavy-weight out-of-balance large pieces for years. He used clamps to attach the lathe rigidly to the wall of his shop.
>With my Jet Mini I decided to live with the walking. It makes for an exciting ride if you stand on the support frame (just kidding.)
I also discoverd that for most un balanced peices turning the speed up a bit will reduce the vibration quite a bit. With variable speed it's quite easy to find a sweet spot.
I've been puzzling as to why this is, but have decided my last encounter with physics is too far back to be recalled, and I'll be darned if I care enough to look it up.
>I fastened my Oneway to my wooden floor. When it vibrates from something out of balance, I slow it down 'til it quits vibrating, and then get it in balance, and then speed it up. Never looked back. :)
>This question comes up once or twice per year. The simple answer is that bolting the lathe down CANNOT increase the stress on the bearings, but will reduce it if the lathe would otherwise rise off the floor and hammer back onto it every revolution. Hammering greatly increases stresses. Think loose cannon! Note that if there is not enough unbalance to lift the lathe off of the floor then it does not matter whether the lathe is bolted down or not. Dennis
>The answer to this one depends on the weight and strength of the lathe. The lathe must not move when it is used to turn wood. Your asking this question tells me that you are having a problem with the lathe moving. The easy answer is to start turning smaller pieces of wood that better fit the capabilities of the lathe you have. If you don't want to do that, there are two choices - a bigger (heavier) lathe, or bolt this one to the floor (or table). If bolting it to the floor causes damage to the lathe, then you needed a heavier lathe. If the new lathe is heavier, you may not need to bolt it to the floor.
There can be a problem with turning large and/or unbalanced pieces in a lathe that is bolted to the floor. If the wood wants to move and it cannot, something else will �give�; and that is usually a fracture in the bolting pads at the floor; but it could be a failure of the spindle bearings. For this reason, many will advise that the lathe should NOT be bolted to the floor because that will let the entire machine move as a warning.
>Some very interesting answers. The consensus seem to go for a large enough lathe, proper balancing, vibration reduction, but not much for bolting. My lathe is a fairly heavy PM 2530A. But it will still rattle around when turning an out of balance work piece. Slowing down won't get it roughed to true very easily. Mine isn't bolted down. I guess I should add that my little Jet Mini is bolted to the heavy table it sits on. And , for that matter, it is certainly -- by design -- bolted to the stand that I purchased for it when I travel with it. So the plot thickens!
>My friend John Roberts turned pieces with holes in the sides. To turn smooth he ran the lathe at high speed and even though these were only 8" pieces that were 4 or 5" deep they would make his Powermatic 3520 walk across the room. He installed some large heavy angle iron "stabilizers" under the fee. These were probably 4" on the sides, 3/8" to 1/2" thick and 4 to 6 feet long. It stopped the walking. I thought about installing the same thing to mine but my shop is so crowded I would be forever tripping over them.
>There is also the issue of how the lathe sits on the floor. You should have equal weight (at rest) between the front and rear feet.
If A is the left front foot and B is the left rear foot and C is the right front foot and D is the right rear foot.
The weight supported by A should be equal to the weight supported by B
The weight supported by C should be equal to the weight supported by D
If you place the weight of the headstock, banjo, toolrest, tailstock in the middle of the lathe then the weigh supported by A, B, C, D should all be the same.
Any imbalance in this support of the weight of the lathe will be magnified by an out of balance piece of wood spinning on your lathe.
Balance is the key. There are times when you want to express your work as unbalanced. If this is the case then you need to counter balance the workpiece.
Kel McNaughton used to make a balancing device that would mount on the spindle and then present a spindle for you to mount your workpiece on. I tried to get one of these a while back without success.
I have heard of some folks mounting a board on the outboard side of the lathe with weights to establish balance. Not an option for a sliding headstock lathe like the PM 3520 as the motor gets in the way of most outboard options.
I know you are a fan of Keith Clark. I suspect that he would be a good resource to create a balancer which would work on your lathe.
If you decide to bolt the lathe down you might consider shimming the feet with lead so that the bolting doesn't put torque into the bed of the lathe.
>I used to turn on a light weight lathe on a flimsy stand. It would walk around the shop at the least provocation. We laughed about chasing the lathe until the piece was balanced. Sold the lathe and moved up a notch or two.
If you turn heavy out of balance blocks creating lots of vibration, you are really stressing the lathe. That loading or stress has to go somewhere. The physics of all this is complicated. Weight helps, but as others mentioned it can be solid or granular like the sand or shot. In either case it dampens or absorbs some of the vibration and does not allow the machine to walk around as readily, but it probably means that even more stress is being applied to the bearings. So, Adding mass to the stand works on the effect of the vibration, not the cause. So does bolting it down, attaching it to the wall, jambing it against the ceiling, and putting wider feet on it. If you did a really good job of any of the above, you could put a huge block on and either snap the shaft or tear up the bearing, but the lathe would not move.
To reduce the stress on the bearing and shaft, you have to slow down the rotation or balance the block better.
I watched a demo by Lyle Jamerson. He starts everything between centers and then uses faceplates, not chucks. He does an excellent job on the drive spur. I believe he said he sometimes drills a socket for them. then he puts the block Ont he lathe and brings up the tailstock. with the lathe off, he lets the piece rotate so that the "heavy" side hangs down. Loosens the tailstock and raises/tips the piece straight up, tightens the tail stock. Lets it rotate again and keeps adjusting it until it doesn't rotate on it own anymore. Might give it a nudg or two see it you found the balance spot. Then cranks in the tailstock really tight. He had some pretty nasty looking blanks and they ran true (balanced) for him. He cranked the speed up, way up, and then roughed the blank. I was amazed that those blanks would run that fast without wrecking the lathe or flying off. (Lyle is the guy that turned those feminine forms and they were all out of balance and he strapped/bolted weights on them. That is, he has experience with large out of balance blanks.)
So, balancing the blank by cutting it better as others have suggested and tipping it to find the center of gravity, either with the coke bottle method or the one Lyle showed us, will reduce the stress on the lathe. It does limit your creativity, I guess. Not sure about that. It might be you were not going to save the good part anyway.
>"Everyone( except religious right types) knows that every force has an equal and opposite force."
Too bad you don't know we "religious right types" also have science degrees! One must have balance in their life and in their lathe. If not, it tends to dance around aimlessly much like the "non-religious left types."
If the moderator chooses to delete this post due to PC then those who choose to demean Christianity should be dealt with in the same manner. We are not going to just sit by and let these slams towards our faith go unchallenged.
>Having worked with a number of engineers, I know that they tend to design in a huge CYA factor. I figure if they put mounting tabs on the base, they don't expect the spindle bearings to encounter forces that they can't handle.
My Woodfast has the old style stand which is just a narrow rectangle. I had it bolted down in its old home and when I moved it to the new shop, it got bolted down again. I don't think it would dance with an out of balance piece if it weren't bolted down. I think it would just fall over. 8^]
>And a man's enemies will be the members of his household... Matt. 10:36 NASB
Careful Eliot, your some of your relatives might be reading!
But on to that bolting thing. I used to tell people not to bolt their lathes down. Something else will become the weak link. but I have recently found myself with two powerful lathes bolted to the floor, at least for the time being. The Vega will probably always be bolted because the footprint is small compared to the wood it will handle, and with the speed at which I like to turn. The Robust is bolted down because it is "slick" enough on its pads to skate on my old garage floor. Rubber pads will hopefully take care of that when I get the time to try them out.
I would say that if you are judicious about the speed of any particular piece, bolting the machine down can be an advantage. I remember your shop, but I do not remember if the floor is wood, concrete, reinforced or regular construction. Some folks with wooden floors can introduce flex just because of the piece spinning on the lathe.
>Years back when I got my Oneway they said NO BOLT. Later they changed and say to bolt it down.
One must use reasonable thought as to what speed to run a lathe with out of balance work mounted on it. Just because you bolt down that does not meen that you have to stress the machine. Start slow and ramp up the speed until you get viberation. Then as you get the piece to a better balance up the speed to viberation.
We must use common sense for safety sake. I start almost all of my work between centers and I just don't like it when it goes flying.
>My off-handed remarks about the religious right rejecting Newton were only meant to poke a bit of fun at those who would deny carbon dating. I was actually thinkiing about our fascinating discussion, Bill, about the Bible, evolution and carbon dating. I sent an apology to Eric; so here's another one to you and Jack Riley. By the way, I have looked into carbon dating a little, and , indeed, although the mathematics is extremely straightforward, I see that there is room for legitimate controversy about the underlying assumptions in the physics. ( Which is what you were trying to tell me at my place.) What I see is that constancy of the ratio of C-12 carbon to that of the C-14 radioactive carbon in the atmosphere does indeed pose a problem. How do we know that this ratio has been constant? That this ratio can change through time is a serious problem for the theory. I have to look into what the scientific community says about that( also why they get wildly different ages for stuff sometimes!) As you know, I keep an open mind. Not everyone does.