Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

To bolt or not to bolt

Posts

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#26

Re: If you remove four words...

Clem Wixted

>I was.

Thanks for your email and apology.

Clem

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#27

Lyle Jamieson claims...

Craig Daymon

>...that you can remove the majority of the vibration by locating which foot of the lathe is not making proper contact with the floor. At the demo I saw him give, he places an eccentric/out-of-balance piece (doesn't have to be very big) on the lathe and starts it spinning until it begins to vibrate. Then he walks around the lathe and pushes down on each of the feet of the lathe with his foot until he finds the lathe foot that, when pressed, dampens the vibration. That is the foot that needs adjustment to make proper contact with the floor.

That will help. I don't believe that bolting it down will impact the bearings any more than letting it vibrate. I think either one will cause some undue wear on the bearings. I have a 3520 with an additional 300 pounds of balast and I'm thinking of bolting it down. (Though I still need to try the Jamieson trick.) Better than having it walk when I have that big piece on there and I didn't pay attention to the speed setting.

-Craig

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#28

My Jet mini is not bolted

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#29

leveling a lathe

john lucas

>There isn't much argument that leveling a lathe bed and making sure that all the legs sit squarely on the floor will reduce a lot of vibration.

Since I've gotten into metal working I've been reading anything I can on setting up the machines. They all say to level the machine. When I recently moved my powermatic I decided I would level it as well as check for rocking. It seemed to make a difference although it might have been in my imagination. Before this I would crank the feet out until they all contacted the floor with the same amount of torque on the nut.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#30

That's exactly how I do it

Carole Valentine

>Works much better for me than trying to cut the blank perfectly round to begin with. You just barely want to touch the tailstock to the wood when you are finding balance because if you put a hole in there and have to adjust just a tad, it's nearly impossible to stay out of that previous hole.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#31

Re: leveling a lathe

Bill Howatt

>John,

I once posted (somewhere) about saying that it would be better to have the lathe in the same plane rather than "level" which is what you were doing when you adjusted the 4 feet to have the same torque. Somebody replied pointing out that a definition of level covers that and does not have to be level in the sense we usually use the word.

I did find a reference supporting that definition but I can't locate it now.

Bill

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#32

Re: That's exactly how I do it

Barry Irby

>Carol, Try using a cup center with out the point. You can move it easier in small increments that you can the pin. Not my idea, learned it from Barbara Dill. Come to thing of it, she might have excellent knowledge on the topic. Check out her current article on Eccentric turning in the AAW Mag. I don't know much about eccentric turning, but I suppose it is always out of balance and probably requires moving the centers in various increments.

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#33

Re: leveling a lathe

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>My Nichols lathe sits on four heavy duty leveling jacks and is not meant to be bolted down. The lathe also has a leveling bubble built in. A great feature is that when the leveling jacks are retracted the lathe sits on wheels. The lathe weighs 800 lb. and at one time I had 400 lb. of sand in the built in sand reservoir.

Wally

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#34

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Eliot, I figured it was a joke on your part, but I could not resist the temptation to needle you just a little bit. ;-) That was a great discussion I thought. I thoroughly enjoyed it. We'll have to do it again!

Bill

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#35

Re: leveling a lathe

gtwilkins

>Level in the absolute definition means square to plumb, we use the term "level" rather loosely as Bill mentioned.

I have the same dilemma with my Vic 300, in the literature it says to bolt with a rubber pad under the bases. I am on concrete so getting to the "same plane" is easy with the "leveling" adjusters, however the big improvement was putting strips of old conveyor belt under the bases which decreased the vibration.

Plus the frame is hollow so you can put sand in the ends for added mass which I haven't done as I don't have enough time on the blue beast to know whether or not I need to.

For other Vic owners what have you done?

Trevor

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#36

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

eliot d

>Hi Bill,

I've emailed everyone who has taken some issue with my quip and have had some very interesting and satisfying discussions with these fine folks. So all is well -- I hope. I have to confess that my ignorance of the Bible leaves me confused about your particular quote and follow-up remark about "relatives" listening. I don't know if you mean my very right wing, Neo Con, 83 year old WW II veteran, brother, who thinks I'm a crazed, wild , Communist Liberal, or "relatives" in some broader , mystical, biblical sense.(The latter would be far more poetic.) My brother even went so far , using real money, to get me a subscription to The Weekly Standard!

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#37

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

David Walsh

>I turn on a oneway 2436. I did not have it bolted to the floor initially. When a piece of a large blank came off the lathe began to "walk" as the legs lifted. I was afraid the lathe might tip over as I was trying to get to the switch. It is now bolted to the floor. Although I always adjust my speed to avoid any sway I hope the bolts will hold the lathe should another piece come apart or at least give me more time to get to the switch.


img

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#38

That is one Big blank!

Carole Valentine

>How much did that rascal weigh?

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#39

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Now That's Woodturning! Do you have a picture of the finish product?

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#40

Re: To bolt or not to bolt - - conclusions

Pete in Holland, MI

>All right guys. Lots of information firing back and forth, and a little finger pointing.

From my engineering background, and what has been said here, this is what I have concluded:

1) Bolting a lathe to the floor does aid in the stability and ability to turn out of balance wood.

2) Weighting a lathe does aid in its stability, but can still allow some degree of movement on really out of balance work.

3) Out of balance work does run the risk of lathe movement, thus stress & wear on the spindle, bearings & housing.

4) Out of balance work does run a greater risk of damage to the lathe.

5) Out of balance work will pre-maturely age a lathe (and any machine for that matter).

6) This pre-mature aging of a lathe depends on the condition of the machine, the amount of out of balance, hours, and a lot of other variables. On an apples-to-apples test of 2 machines, a smooth running machine (and not forced to run smooth just because it is bolted down), verses an out of balance machine, the smooth running machine will always last longer. Simple machine know-how.

7) Most likely, none of us really understand how long our lathes would last turning a smooth piece, verses constantly turing out of balance. I don't think a study has ever been done.

Questions to all of us: Do you want your lathe to last as long as it possibly can, or are taking some risks to the life of your machine to create some interesting work worth taking some life out of your machine????

Most of us often take that kind of risk. I know I do and do push my lathe once in a while doing it.

Pete

Re: To bolt or not to bolt

#41

Re: To bolt or not to bolt - - conclusions

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Good points Pete. I know I am one for turning out of balance pieces fairly fast. Of course, a lathe with a Robust design should hold up quite well. (nudge nudge wink wink) :-)

Bill