Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

workshop heating

Posts

workshop heating

#1

workshop heating

john lucas

>I know we've been through this a bunch of times but I just filled up my can of Kerosene and it cost me $18. I only get about 3 days of heating from that. last year it was about $14. Propane runs about $10 a bottle and heats for about 2 1/2 days but my heater doesn't put out as much heat as the Kerosene, at least totally warming the shop kind of heat.

At that expense I will only be able to heat the shop on the weekends. I've tried the smaller radiant heaters and they aren't bad if you are standing at the lathe but I tend to move around the shop a lot so I gradually just get colder and colder until I have to quit. Apparently I just don't tolerate the cold like I did when I was 20. At least I think I remember that far back.

Wood heat is out of the question from an insurance stand point. Electric heat is a long term goal but right now running a bigger line and box to the shop is not a possibility.

What do you all use. I'm heating a 24x24 foot area.

Re: workshop heating

#2

Re: workshop heating

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>I just open the big overhead door at the front,(North), and the back, (South), doors and let the gentle breeze blow through. Although this A.M. the temp dropped into the lower 40's and we may not even reach 70 today. May have to keep the Tee shirt on all day. There may be a few days when I will be forced to wear long pants and a long sleeved shirt, mostly in Dec. and Jan. Of course July and August do at times present a few temperature problems.

Re: workshop heating

#3

Re: workshop heating

Paul Zerjay

>My shop is a 24x32 freestanding polebarn framed building. Insulated and drywalled. I use a woodburning stove and have no issues with insurance. The stove is on a thremostat but that only works the blower. So when its 70 degrees and the blower kicks off, the metal stove still radiates heat, bringing the temp up that much higher. I have had to open doors in twenty degree temps to cool the shop. My shop is much cleaner in the winter.

Re: workshop heating

#4

Re: workshop heating

Stuart Johnson

>I use a propane radiant heater in a double car garage. It will bring the heat up to around 65� with no problem. I then shut it down and let it cool down before I turn it back on. The outside temp is usually above 40�.

Re: workshop heating

#5

Re: workshop heating

JohnKJordan in East TN

>John,

I have a similar problem in my garage shop. I also use the kerosene and propane (radient) heater at times. Mostly I use insulated overalls over longjohns and thick socks. Doesn't help the hands, though.

I do find the shop warmer if I go work outside for a while!

JKJ

Re: workshop heating

#6

Re: workshop heating

eaglesc

>I too have been using either propane or Kersosene but only when I am in the shop.

MAny years ago I saw an article in Mother Earth News about a "solar heat grabber"

Essentialy a solar heater that works on the thermo syphon principal.

If you have windows on a souther exposure you might want to check it out.

The BTU's are free.No electricity involved to run it.

Re: workshop heating

#7

Re: workshop heating

Mike Jones

>My former shop was a 2 car garage...uninsulated, and there was no way to keep it warm cost efficiently. I rigged a curtain partition with PVC pipe, ceiling hooks, shower curtain hooks and silver tarp. The tarp reflected light, kept the heat in the "lathe room", and helped immensly with dust control.

Mike

Re: workshop heating

#8

Re: workshop heating

Barry Irby

>John, I am in a one car garage in the basement, but with two sides exposed to the weather. I have a radiant heater that clamps onto a propane cylinder. It is entirely too big and will run you out. I also have a little electric "barn" heater. So, If the shop is cold, I fire off the propane for about ten or fifteen minutes and heat it up. Then turn it off and let the electric keep it as warm as it can. On really cold days I may run the propane once in a while. After it warms up, it holds fairly well.

I also have a "Little Buddy" propane heater and a fifteen foot hose for it. The plane was to put the tank in the shed?closet of the air compressor and DC and run the hose inside to the heater. Have not gotten around to it. This heater is substantially smaller than the radiant one so it should be running in longer bursts, but I have not bothered to hook it up. Came from Lowes at the end of the season. Got it cheap.

Re: workshop heating

#9

from PA and a 30' x 24' shop

Ruth Niles

>Our winters are a wee bit cooler than yours, right, John? My shop is approx. 30' x 24' with 10 1/2' ceiling (yuk), free standing bldg, well insulated, concrete floor (which stays covered with chips all winter).

Last year I used the kerosene, it worked but ...... I just got a propane, unvented, free-standing (or wall mount) 30,000 BTU heater with a blower, $230. Had the propane co. bring 100-gal. tank, run the line, hook up the heater, test it and fill the tank all for $295.95. $526 initial set up plus heat for the winter. Each year now will only cost whatever fuel I use.

I keep it on low constantly, shutting it off used more fuel to heat up all that iron in the shop to get it to 60 degrees (my comfort zone). Low keeps the shop at about 40 - 45 degrees all night.

At $18 for 3 days of heat, IF you heated it everyday, that's $720 for 4 months. wow

Re: workshop heating

#10

Re: workshop heating

Andy Blackwell

>John - I have a 20X40' shop that has a propane heating system but the shop is not heated when I am not in it. When I first enter the shop I have a heater that can use 8 different fuels which I turn on to initially warm the shop. I use offroad diesel in this heater because it does not have the federal tax on it and that makes it cheaper than kerosene. Additionally, you don't get that overpowering smell that you get from kerosene. After the initial warm up I use the propane system to keep the temp. at 68�.

Re: workshop heating

#11

Solar link

eaglesc

>http://www.motherearthnews.com/Green-Home-Building/1977-09-01/Mothers-Heat-Grabber.aspx

Re: workshop heating

#12

Re: workshop heating

RevDoug

>I'm using an overhead propane heater. I keep saying that I want to insulate my roof. I know that it will make it warmer and I'll use less propane too. As it is I use less than 100 gallons/yr.

Turn 'em round,

Re: workshop heating

#13

Re: workshop heating

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>John

Why do you say wood is not an option? Insurance should allow wood if it is aclosed heater like you use in a home.

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: workshop heating

#14

Re: workshop heating

eaglesc

>John, I want to thank you for bringing this up BTW.

I cranked up the kerosene heater the other nite and noted the shop didn't warm up as fast as it used to.

My"shop" was built to house a riding lawn mower and do little projects.

Basically it is just stud framed walls with polyurethane panel for a ceiling.

I had cut a hole in one end and ran a gable vent to it to get some kind of ventilation in the summer.

I had forgotten to cover up the vent hole.

A strip of R-mat took care of the problem.

Amazing how much of a difference it makes.

Is your shop insulated?

Re: workshop heating

#15

You are just plain mean!

Steve Mushinski

>

Re: workshop heating

#16

Heat Pump

Gil Jones

>John,

The heated/cooled shop space is 26' X 54', with R-19 walls (2x6), and R-30 ceiling. I found a used, Carrier, 2-ton, split-system, heat pump in one of those community advertiser papers, and installed that with all the ducting and such. The electric heat strips were shorted out with broken resistance coils, so that part is removed (for now). It seems to work quite well here, but then this is far southwest Georgia. I think that insulation material is the best investment to start with.

Gil

Re: workshop heating

#17

Re: workshop heating

George Van

>Hi Bill, if I could find a company to provide coverage with wood heat in any kind of UL Approved furnace in my shop I would have it. At present I have been refused with all the companies I checked with. The fireplace in the living room is not a problem.

At present I heat my 30x40 shop with propane and in-floor heat. It is very comfortable heat at 60 degrees and your feet are never cold. It is very economical heat with the on demand wall mounted boiler. Others up here use hotwater heaters for their boiler.

Re: workshop heating

#18

Roger in MO

Re: workshop heating

Roger in MO

>John, my shop is 24x24x10 ceiling, free standing, stud wall, well insulated, sheet rock, concrete w/ vinyl tile floor. It is part of a larger building so there are non-heated rooms on the west and south sides.

I keep the temp at about 50 degrees at chest level with a wall hung non-vented propane heater. (have stool and lavatory so freezing would be an issue.) This level of heat will require 75 to 100 gallons of propane in a season. (Due east of Kansas City)

I do have a wood stove in an adjacent room (my metal shop) with a fan in the wall. I light this when working in the shop.

The propane will heat the area except on very cold windy days, but will require more propane.

I've had no problems with moisture from the unvented propane heat.

Roger

Re: workshop heating

#19

Re: workshop heating

john lucas

>That's funny John. So I need to go outside every 15 minutes or so. As soon as I start to get cold inside I should run outside. Should I take of all my clothes. Nah, it would make all the other men envious. :)

Re: workshop heating

#20

Re: workshop heating

john lucas

>I was going to put in passive solar but ran out of money this year. I have a south facing wall that would make a great collector. I saw a great set of plans in Mother earth news. It looked like I could do it for $200 to $400. That would pay back quickly if I could spend more time in the shop making things to sell. I could add an awning to roll out during the summer to shade it.

Re: workshop heating

#21

Re: workshop heating

john lucas

>Mike I had planned to put plastic curtains near the lathe to stop all the shavings from flying around the shop. If I keep them down on cold days I wouldn't have to heat as large an area. I'll get cold when I step out to do other tasks but there have to be give and take for every heating option. Thanks for reminding me of that.

Re: workshop heating

#22

Re: Solar link

john lucas

>Thanks I printed that out and may build it shortly. Any heat at all will be a help.

Re: workshop heating

#23

Re: workshop heating

john lucas

>I agreee with George. We have a lot of arson in our area so fire coverage is difficult. I checked with several companies a few years ago and none of them would insure my shop if I used wood. It sucks because I've used wood heat for a long time and I know I can do it safely.

Re: workshop heating

#24

Re: John, I heat my shop...

Allen Neighbors

>with a pot-bellied stove, using my scrap wood, from all my chain-sawing. The heater is about 10 feet from my Oneway. My eaves are open all around. I have a fan hanging in the rafters to circulate the heat. Plus, I have an exhaust fan running all year round in the SW window of my shop. I still have to wear warm clothing some days, but basically it works pretty well. The only time the cold is unbearable is when some fool North of Amarillo leaves the gate open. :)

I don't see how you folks can afford kerosene or diesel type oil heat. I'd have to just sit out the winter by the fireplace in the living room.

I'd rather turn than close in the eaves, but I'm not getting any younger, and can't deal with the cold as well, so I may have to go to work and do it.

I don't have insurance on my outbuildings, so I don't have anyone telling me what I can or cannot do.

Re: workshop heating

#25

Re: workshop heating

john lucas

>roger Maybe that's the trick. I'll add the 10 foot addition that I want and make it a metal shop. Then I'll tell the insurance agent that I'm heating a metal shop with nothing flamable there. Then I'll pump the heat into the wood shop side.