no responce deserved
tdaniel
>
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
no responce deserved
tdaniel
>
Re: no complaining
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Actually you said "I could do an article on my concerns but that would not do anything toward solving the problem would it?"
I am glad you have decided to write the article.
Good Lord, people, let up ............
Ruth Niles
>on poor Joe. All he said was in his own, personal, private opinion he did not feel a magazine that intimidated him was worth $45 a year. The AAW is not a religion and Joe did not say he didn't believe in God! He said he would probably join WHEN he's ready, he said he knows the AAW does good things, he in no way, shape or form "bashed the AAW". just chill
Martha, before you lambast me, I have been a member of the AAW for years and love the organization. It's not my religion but I embrace it. I don't belong to a club. I have one very big complaint about the AAW and the National Symposium, they should have free coffee in the mornings for the attendee and vendors; I need my coffee in the morning and standing in line to pay $3.50 for a small cup of coffee really does not start my day on a happy note! Other than that, the AAW is the PERFECT organization....for woodturners.
There are tons of good things the AAW offers but you can still learn how to turn without being an AAW member. I'm a member and I know 3 guys who are not and they are a lot better turners than I am! Joe can buy videos, books and I'll bet there are turners who are not members of the AAW who will talk to him and help where they can to get Joe to the point where he's confident in his turnings.
Seriously folks, bombarding a guy who expressed his opinion is just not fair.
Re: Amazing!
Stuart Johnson
>What is amazing is how this thread resurfaces each year about the time it is to vote for officers. And each year it starts off in a civil mode and then deteriorates with words like bull and prove yourself and other what I consider personal attacks tossed in.
For what it is worth I do not belong to AAW or any other group and my reasons are only my business. This type of thread that seems to turn into a flame war is my business because of the space it takes up on what is normally a very civil group.
I love you Ruth
tdaniel
>You hit the nail on the head, again. Why do people not get it? Some people want to see the AAW be a promoter of woodturning? Is that nasty? What would you expect of an organization of turners? Folks, this is not a carvers group; it is a turners group. There is not a thing wrong with carving; it is just not what turners are about.
I am sorry.
Joe Pack
>You don't know me except from my writings, and I know you only in the same way. In fact, if not for the response to my original post, I would not recognize your name. I hold no animosity toward you. I am writing this only because I am confused...confused as to why an intellectual discussion seems to be turning into a "right-wrong" discussion.
Please believe that I do nothing unwittingly, including writing a carefully thought out post to my friends at WoodCentral; I am nobody's dupe, nor will I be taken for one. I may be intimidated by woodworking projects, but never by any living human being. I have bashed no person or organization, only expressed the opinion of one person - me. And I readily suggested that, as in the past, my feelings may change. I do not speak for "the novice," only for this novice. Any suggestion that my writings represent a large class of people gives me far too much credit, and poorly represents a large class of people are perfectly able to speak for themselves. Implications to that end serve no purpose.
I have the highest regard for associations like AAW, and for the many volunteers who make such an outstanding organization work. Likewise, I have the greatest respect for the many people who make WoodCentral a friendly, familiar place to engage in dialogue, both woodworking related and collegial. I visit WoodCentral to be with friends, not make enemies.
It is apparent that I have touched a nerve by expressing my honest feeling, making at least some friends feel that scolding for my opinion is in order. Touching that nerve was never my intent. At the same time, I apologize to no one for holding my opinion. Opinions can be, and should be, expressed and taken for what they are...opinions. Not edicts, not "right v. wrong," not "me v. you."
If I have caused someone, anyone, to feel that they must be on the defensive, I truly apologize. It may be true that the pen is mightier than the sword, especially when an indeterminable distance lies between the parties involved. Maybe some day we can enjoy a meal or beverage together and shorten that distance.
Best wishes.
Joe
Thank you, Carol
Joe Pack
>Thanks for the positive note, Carol. You make some very good points, points that I will consider. As I have indicated, I have not said "never," just "not at this time." I have no ax to grind with AAW, just comparing cost/benefit of membership the same way I do with other organizations from BASS to Nature Conservancy.
Actually, I'm sorry I got involved in this conversation. I had no idea that expressing a different opinion would generate so much animosity. Your kind note is much appreciated.
Joe
No, Joe, I am sorry .....
Ruth Niles
>you were treated and responded to so unfairly. It does sort of make you think twice before posting anything, doesn't it? Well, I'm on your side that you should feel comfortable among friends to say "I don't like vanilla" without them saying you're wrong.
Re: A total novice's take...
keith tompkins
>Joe, until we formed a local aaw group, I had to drive 2.5 hours each way to go to club meetings. And, it required taking time off from work to get there on time. It was one of the best things I could have done.
Re: AAW Board Canidates
Dick Hines
>As that great man Rodney King once said, "Can't we all just be friends".
Dang, I go away for a few days and was looking forward to reading all the great post what were added while I was gone and what do I get strife. I think I am going back to the mountains.
I'll buy the first cup of coffee.
Joe Pack
>Thanks, Ruth. As much as I love my wife, we still get into little spats that don't make sense later. Of course, she is the one who is always wrong. :-)
Hope friends get to meet in person some day.
Joe
Re: A total novice's take...
keith tompkins
>Hey Joe, Thinking about my comments, I don't want you to think I'm taking your thoughts lightly or with any disrespect. Before I found out about the AAW, I was turning "in the dark", with nobody to relate to.
I've had some success as a turner, and I will tell you that the AAW has played a huge part in it....I strongly believe the 1.5 hour trip to meetings will pay huge dividends....your turning skills will improve dramatically, and in a much shorter peroid of time than by learning alone.
Thanks, Keith
Joe Pack
>Don't worry, I took your comments in the vein they were intended. I appreciate the encouragement. I'm sure I would learn a lot being associated with experienced turners. I find turners, and most any woodworkers, to be more than willing to share their expertise with others.
I'm so dense, Martha, (not Ruth!)
Joe Pack
>I'm sorry, Martha, I referred to you as Ruth in my last message. Please chalk that one up to a "senior moment." My apologies.
I give up; can't keep friends straight. Bed time.
Joe Pack
>
Re: Thanks, Keith
Bill Crommett
>A point that has not been fully addressed : One of the highest forms of any membership is the dues- paying member without whom no progress can be made. Even the top of the pile, the working and organizing member, cannot function without the dedicated dues-paying member. The attitude of "what's in it for me" is short sighted and smells like a politician's mantra.
.
Joe Pack
>
Re: AAW Board Canidates
Juergen
>Here's a no cost suggestion for the for the AAW powers to be. Have each of the candidates post a video to the AAW website which gives a summary of educational, professional, and turning qualifications (The information provided in Woodturning were superficial at best). Additionally, have each candidate answer a slate of questions solicited from the membership on the AAW website forum. The candidates can also enlighten members about their respective goals for AAW during their tenure.
After all we are in the 21st Century and have a lot of social networking resources available on the net.
Re: Invite them to Wed night chat
RevDoug
>Carole, that's a great idea. TD had the manufacturers on who would take the time. By having the candidates on, we could hear from the horses' mouths what they have to say concerning the direction they would like to take the AAW. I understand that it would be a difficult thing if they are not good typists, but our fearless leader Steve, could moderate the board and ask the questions that we submit. Wouldn't be much of a discussion that way, at least until all the questions could be responded to, but at least we could hear/read what they have to say.
Turn 'em round,
Done !
tdaniel
>I sent the article today.
Re: ???????!
russ Fairfield
>I would suggest sending a check along with that article. They won't publish it if you are not a member??
I don't give a rat
tdaniel
>I did what I was asked to do, now it is their turn.
Re: ???????!
Dinyar Chavda
>Russ:
If that really is their policy, it is unbelieveably myopic!