>Jamie, I only expect an organization that I support to do things that benefit me as a turner. I see no reason to support an organization that does not represent my interests. I am sorry that you disagree but that is my take and I am sticking to it. The AAW neeeds to listen to its membership and respond accordingly. I do not feel that the AAW listens to the 90% that are not in the artsy category. I am sorry that you disagree.
>AAW is supposed to represent all woodturners. It is not doing that. I turn artistic turnings. However, I recognize that there are many turners who do not. I admire a well turned table leg. If AAW wishes to appeal to all turners then they need to recognize that all of us do not just turn art forms. Some of us turn table legs, bedposts, porch columns and such. Who represents those who do not do artistic turnings?
>vote for people who understand the problems as you stated them. Think about what I wrote about Temple Blackwood. He is a hard-worker who does production spindle turning. I don't recall him doing the artsy work that sets you off. The AAW nominating committee recognized his value when they put him on the short list, so they aren't blind pigs looking for acorns.
>the artsy crowd runs the show. Keep in mind that I am part of the artsy crowd. I turn art pieces. What I am trying to say is that turning existed as a craft long before it was an art. Many turners only want to learn to turn a nice looking table leg or bedpost. I am not against art turning, I just think there is a lot more to the field than what I do.
>.... that "90% of the mag is dedicated to 10% of the audience." Would you care to identify the source for these statistics? I'm not interested in debating you TD, but I am interested in the exchange of accurate and factual information.
>Interesting dialog. At this moment, there are 31 listings. Eight of them (approx. 25%) are from someone who is not an AAW member because his interests are not served. He's an artist turner who dislikes the artsy direction of the association. I say, quitchurbitchen. Rejoin AAW and run for Director. You have the ability to be involved and can influence changes that you see as best for the majority of us turners out there. You can't do it through this forum. Go for it man! Quit being one of the 90%.
>Hello all, I would think instead of posting your likes and dislikes just on a forum, you need to contact the AAW and let your feelings be known that way most of all. I see here what they are, but I'm not sure if all the AAW Directors and officers will see them here. You can contact me any time and I will make sure the organization gets your meessages. I'll also be at Indy Fest and you can talk to me there.I also agree that if you don't like they way something is, get involved and work at making changes. There are a lot of great ideas out there that never get heard. Have a great holiday, Sean
>I read it here. An earlier post stated that 90% of the mag was geared to 10% of the readers. I think that is a relavent statement though not an accurate statistic based on solid research. If it was more factual it would probably be 95% of the mag was geared to 5% of the readers but who is counting?
>This same thing was hashed out not quite a year ago. At that time I did an informal survey. This is what I posted:
"The AAW magazine has often been criticized because of its "non-traditional content". I just finished going back through the last 5 issues. In every one there is a variety of styles from the basic, traditional classic work to the bizarre (not a negative). The articles range from basic to advanced. There is something for everyone just as it should be. I have never received an issue that didn't contain interesting, informative material. Just because I may not agree or appreciate everything does not mean there is anything wrong with the content. How boring would it be if every issue was aimed at one group of turners? "
I really don't see any change since then. It is still a good magazine that reaches many different types and levels of turning.
>this was directed to you but posted under Barb. Read the post. Did I mention any numbers? Where do you come up with this bull? I gave no numbers, no statistics, nada.
>My wife and I are members of the AAW. I am a BOD member of the Carolina Mountain Woodturners and she is newsletter editor. We both volunteered at Louisville. We are both fairly new turners but we work to learn more and also to teach others.
We both still struggle to JUST turn a bowl. We do not give a RIP about how to pierce it or carve it. We do not like to see God's beauty covered up with paint or total burnings. But we both realize that many others do enjoy enhancements. In a few years when I am bored with turning plain bowls I may get into enhancements. But I doubt it.
The AAW needs to print more basic info. How many of the members have traveled far enough in their turning experience to try all the artsy stuff? I think that Mr. Pho's work is pretty awesome and wonderful, but I will never try it. I agree with TD: Does my shipping ambrosia maple to a friend on the west coast spread disease? The AAW should give us this information!
>Why are you making ANY statement for or against the AAW organization?
You've already rejected the group, and your continued bashing only makes it apparent you wish to get people to join your club.
Isn't this why you conducted your own 'gathering'?
I suggest that your behavior is counter productive to your need for followers.
And if you hate the AAW with such passion, why do you continue to appear at AAW club sponsored functions, WITHOUT paying any registration fee, rudely placing your work in the Instant Galleries, and then bitch and sob about how people are treating you?
>Are you kidding? Wow, a whole $100 bucks, thats about one turning tool. If someone is so passionate about a subject why not do it for free? I'm with the guys that like a mix of information not all one sided. Basic stuff for the beginner and advanced stuff if someone chooses to strive towards the artistic( probally came about anyway after a happy accident) and trying to fix it. Anyway a good debate is a good way to clear the air and have everyones feelings on the the table so you know where you stand and than if you chose to you can start fresh or say the hell with it!!! Happy turning to all, DonL
>Several years ago Nick Cook invited me to the Unicoi symp. He told me to bring some turning wood and a piece or two of my work and I could sell wood from my truck and put my work in the instant gallery and visit the vendor area and attend the auction without registering. I did not take wood to sell but I did go over on Saturday and attend the auction. I did not take any classes. My work was displayed while I was there. Last year a new member of our club wanted to go over and check it out and he asked me to go with him because he had never been to a symp before. I took a piece of my work as I did before and registered it before putting it on the table. A while later it was missing. When I asked I was told it had been removed because I was not registered. I am sorry, I was not aware that there had been a rule change.
Last year at the SSS the same thing happened. (by some of the same people). I have registered several times at the SSS as you know but last year I had a show to do on Saturday so I just ran over on Friday afternoon to check out the supplies and see the instant gallery. I thought this was ok to do, am I wrong? I took a couple of my pieces in and explained to the person in charge of the gallery area that I was not registered and would not be staying long; I asked if I could display my pieces and was given permission to do so. My pieces were different and they drew a crowd. A short time later I was asked to remove them. The year before and last year there was a Molly Winton piece displayed on the table although she wasn't even there. I never had any problems at these shows until I rented two booths a few years ago to sell woodturning equipment and supplies and was then told as I was unloading that I could not sell what I brought because someone else had the same brand. I offered to put the stuff back in the truck if my expenses were re-imbursed. That person walked off in a huff but then another of the organizers told me I was fine to stay. I was never told before my arrival there that there were certain brands of lathes that I could not sell in my booth. It seems that too many rules are being made at the door to suit certain people. Now that I know the rules I no longer rent a booth there or anywhere else if I am told that there are protected vendors who I cannot compete with.
I don't understand your remark at all about the Gathering. We have done this before but with a smaller group. Several turners who I met on the internet and invited to come to the SSS have for several years been coming by and spending a few days here at my shop and then going to the SSS. Last year was bigger but in no way was it designed to steal the show. It allowed a good number to attend both events who would not have attended the SSS otherwise. What is the beef here?
>I am not, by any stretch of the imagination, an "artistic" turner. I make my living strictly from woodturning, mostly spindle work (most of you already know this). I will never be an artistic turner mainly because I can't afford all the classes, extra tools and equipment but more importantly it's not on my list of "must do".
That said, I am totally qualified to respond. The Journal is geared a LOT% to artistic and a TINY% to spindle, that's fine, it's a magazine to show what can be done, what is being done by whom and it's eye candy. I read Better Homes and Gardens gardening books, there's no way I'm going to come close to those homes.....I have a double wide modular, for Godsake! But I love looking at the pictures and I do get little ideas. Well, it's the same with the AAW Journal, I might get an idea for a coffee scoop handle from a finial on a pierced, airbrushed, dyed, carved hollow form lid. It also shows new products, there's ads (ahem!)for fantastic bottle stoppers (ok a little brazen). *one ad makes me smile; "Chick and Duck Mfg."......not the ad but the name......cute.
As to the "direction" the AAW is going.........that's the same nonsense as "listening to the wood". The AAW is NOT going in any direction, it's a nice organization of a bunch of woodturners with a group of 6 or 8 people (who WE elect) trying to organize kids things, adult (which the majority of us are) things, have contests free for any of us to enter, etc.
AND, AND, AND the AAW exhibit for the Symposium in VA next year is "Turned for Use II".........key work USE = definition: ain't artistic only. And I can enter.... 85 times! : ) (I know there's really a limit, don't take everything I say serious, after all I am 127 1/2 yrs. old).
I am confussed TD. You are like myself, if a group or magazine does not interest me or support my direction I move on to something else to keep my interests. You have been very clear that you are not interested in the AAW, yet you continue to voice your dissapointment in what you state about them. I can't say that every thing I see in the AAW magazine or at the instant gallery during symposiums interests me either, but I like looking at the variety of work and enjoy learning about how they are made, the stories they tell if they do and also about the person. Heck they even allow pens!
If you don't like the AAW, it's simple, you have choices, you can move on, find another group that supports your direction, or get involved as has been suggested and do something about it and stop being a victim. I think your time is very valuable to you and you should be using that time to enjoy your hobby, not wasting it on negative energy, and, it's healthier for you too.
>I am not anti AAW. I was a member until 2 years ago and I founded an AAW club. I have contributed a lot. My decision to drop out was not a declaration of war; I merely made the statement that there needs to be more "balance" in the content of the mag; others think it is fine like it is. I am not talking about the AAW organization, just the contents of the mag. If there is very little in a magazine that interests me I do not renew my subsciption. That is all that is going on here. If the magazine started doing articles about things that were of interest to me I would renew my subscription.
I have contacted the members of the board and the officers of AAW expressing my concerns as a dues paying AAW MEMBER that we were becoming a carving association. All I got for my time and effort was a very rude email from Lawrence J. Genender, M.D., FACS AAW Board Member telling me - and I quote: "Get used to it". The board does not want to hear from a member that disagrees with the art/caving direction the AAW has taken and if it were not for needing the insurance to demo basic turning to the local clubs after having received this email I would drop my membership. If you really want to help you need to make sure the board knows there are more turners out there that want to turn then carve - ask yourself why so many local club members will not join the AAW!! If you count all the local club members that are not AAW members, the numbers given by Terry are going to be awful close!!
>TD, could you please tell us what your interests are? You have mentioned that the AAW magazine doesn't interest you. You say you are a professional, artistic wood turner, but yet you are irritated that most of the content is geared towards the artistic end of wood turning. You say that something you are concerned about is the shipping and hauling of wood all over the country, yet we all witnessed at your gathering the exchange and swapping of all sorts of wood and not a mention of how to do this properly was ever talked about that weekend that I'm aware of. It was a wood exchange free for all. Please once and for all tell us what you are looking for. Bullet points would be nice instead of a blurry overview.