Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

AAW Board Canidates

Posts

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#51

Re: AAW Journal and "direction"(?)

Mark Wollschlager

>Ruth,

You will probably enjoy the latest issue because it has 4 spindle turning articles, one on making tools, making a drying kiln, tool storage ideas, some stuff about Portland.

Among a bunch of regular features.

There are a couple articles about artsy turning and one about selling to galleries.

The pictures are a lot of eye candy.

There could be a better distribution of style choices in the selling in galleries article to better represent the body of work out there but not a show stopper for me.

Maybe if you count all of the pictures the % might be more arty, but the articles are always in balance with the diversity of style and techniques in Woodturning.

BTW

The article on multi-axis spindle turning by Barbara Dill is great. She also does a good demo of the process, she might be demoing in Richmond. Don't miss it.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#52

Re: AAW Board Canidates

Sean Troy

>Wilford, and anyone else who wants to see a change, you have to do more than express yourselves on a forum or get discouraged after one e-mail. Send them to me and I'll make sure your concerns get heard.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#53

Re: AAW Board Canidates

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Sean,

I hope you don't get too many responses, I like the AAW just the way it is. After turning for a year most people should know the basics and be ready to move on to more challenging turning. I like to see all the new ideas in the magazine, demos, and at the symposiums.

Like one club member told me a week ago, he like our recent demo since he never mentioned rubbing the bevel once. Once you learn it why dwell on it? I'm all for making my pieces as "artsy" (pretty) as I can. In short, I think the AAW is a wonderful group of people that put out a great magazine.

Gary

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#54

Re: WHAT ARE TD's INTERESTS?

tdaniel

>My interests:

I love wood. I love to unlock the beauty in a burl or a crotch cut or find those interesting patterns in spalting. I find the art in the piece of wood. After many years of turning I still learn new things. (I just recently found that spalted wood will take dye on one side of the spalt line but not the other.) IMHO it takes much more time to learn to work with wood than to work on wood. I see the trend developing that reduces the required knowledge of the wood. So many of the newer turners are using the wood like a canvas and many pieces that I see could just have easily been made from plastic. I like enhancements. Anything that can be done to bring the beauty out I am all for. I don't like turnings that destroy the character of the wood. Now I don't expect everyone to have the same likes and dislikes as me and that is why I keep using the word "balance".

I would like to see some of the money from our dues go to some research. I stopped shipping ambrosia maple years ago because I did not want to cause damage to maples in other parts of the country where they do not have the beetle. I did what I could to learn which areas of the country and which wood species were most dangerous and I got the word out as best I could. It is true that wood was traded at the Gathering. Wouldn't it be nice to know that you could put a piece of wood into a plastic bag and add a chemical that would insure the wood be safe to ship and use? I am no chemist; I might find something that would kill the bugs but it might also kill my customers. That is why I keep urging the AAW to do the research and inform its members. I would read the mag if subjects as important as this were covered. How about follow up articles on personal injuries? I would rather read about an injury than experience one. Has anyone done an article lately on the dangers of grinders? These are examples of what I would like to see done.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#55

Mark, I don't want to see.............

Ruth Niles

>articles on spindle turning. I'm happy with looking at the artsy stuff. I've been doing spindle turning for 17 yrs. and, not that I can't learn something, but it's more entertaining to read about what I do not do.

I got my issue yesterday and haven't read anything yet, just looked at all the pictures and made sure my ad was in there.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#56

Writing Articles....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Most magazines have a paid staff of writers who will do the research and develop stories on subjects such as shipping infested and diseased wood. The American Woodturner does not. It depends on knowledgable members who are willing to spend the time and effort to write articles and submit them.

I agree that articles on wood and it's many variables is a subject that would no doubt be well received by the magazine editor. TD, since you are very interested and concerned in the possible dangers of shipping wood around the country and even abroad, (So am I), I suggest that you write an article and submit it. Not as an expert yourself, if you don't feel that you qualify, but expessing your concerns and asking for knowledgable people to come up with some answers. You would be doing a service to all of us.

I'm a charter member of AAW and have every issue of American Woodturner. The first two or three were just mimeographed newsletters. There have been periods when the magazine did in fact get away from the basics of woodturning and possibly lost members because of it. I feel that more recently the magazine has been very balanced in addressing the interests of the majority of the members. In order to maintain this balance the editor does have to depend on members who will submit articles that will be of interest to most of the members. Hey, even with my limited writing skills they have published a couple of my articles.

Wally

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#57

Good Post Wally

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Ok Terry, it is time to put up. You have done the research and have the passion; now write the article. I will be looking for it.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#58

A total novice's take...

Joe Pack

>I have read this thread with a bit of interest, particularly with regard to the "direction" taken by AAW. I am in no way qualified to pass judgement on ANY political or orientation aspect of the AAW, because I am not a member. My reason for posting this is to explain why I am not yet an AAW member.

I do not belong to AAW because (1) the nearest group to me is a 1 1/2 hour drive away and meets at a time that is very inconvenient for me, (2) AAW membership is $45, for which I would receive 4 issues of the AAW magazine per year, a cost of $11.25 per issue and (3) the several AAW magazines I have looked through are largely filled with articles that are so far above my skill level that they intimidate me; I see no reason to pay $11.25 for a magazine that, at least for now, is not "for me."

I readily admit that #3 may change as I improve my turning. I had the same take on Fine Woodworking when I first saw it years ago. When my woodworking skills were limited to a hammer, circular saw and 10 penny nails, Fine Woodworking was far to "artsy" for me, filled with articles on carved wood, space-age design, etc. Plus, it was by far the most expensive woodworking magazine I had come across - too expensive to justify spending money on something that had very little information at my level. It still has some of that, but I have gained a great deal of experience since my first exposure and I can appreciate what I see there, even if I don't have the skills or appreciation to do that work. I now subscribe to Fine Woodworking, and enjoy it.

What got me more involved in wooodworking, though, were more basic magazines such as Wood, Popular Woodworking, etc. that featured more basic, practical projects and techniques that I needed - information at MY level - plus a couple of articles that were a "reach" for me. Gradually that "reach" became longer. My skills improved to the point where many of the articles became redundant, and, even if I didn't build them, the articles that used to be a "reach" became the more important ones to me. In short, the more basic magazines filled a need for me early in my woodworking experience while Fine Woodworking's bent toward more "artsy" projects pushed me away. I grew as a novice woodworker, but not because of the more sophisticated Fine Woodworking that had, maybe, one basic article per issue, but because of the magazines that were filled with information at my level, with a "teaser" toward more sophisticated work.

Right now, the AAW magazine has the same feel for me as a turner as Fine Woodworking did as a flat worker. There is absolutely nothing wrong with the AAW magazine, it just does not fill my needs. The few articles covering what I need and can absorb seem to be far outnumbered by articles beyond my limited experience and ability. There are too many "reaches" for me to justify spending $11.25 per issue, at least at my level of experience and ability.

I told a fellow WC member that I wasn't going to post anything here. Sorry, I have a hard time keeping quiet on anything. But I hope my take on this is appreciated for its intent...not to take sides, but to explain a point of view. And, for what it's worth, this forum is the most valuable woodworking resource I have ever had the pleasure of sharing. To learn new ideas and make new friends almost daily is precious.

Joe

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#59

Re: Writing Articles....

tdaniel

>Wally, your answer is very much appreciated. I could do an article on my concerns but that would not do anything toward solving the problem would it? Perhaps getting people talking about the problem might get the ball rolling but I really think it would be better if we got a trained expert to look into what we are doing and show us a better way. I have already sent a message to Sean regarding this and I will do whatever I can do.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#60

Well said Joe!

tdaniel

>

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#61

what "dues"? you're not a member

Mike Talton - St. Paul

>You have no voice, nor rights of an AAW member UNTIL YOU BECOME A MEMBER.

Put your money where your mouth is -- if you're interested in voicing a direction for AAW, THEN JOIN AND BECOME PRODUCTIVE MEMBER.

Until then, your AAW=bashing serves no constructive purpose, other than to demonstrate your intension to undermine the work of very dedicated and generous AAW members.

Stop compensating for your own limitations by attempting to drag others down!

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#62

Cop Out

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>TD said:

"Wally, your answer is very much appreciated. I could do an article on my concerns but that would not do anything toward solving the problem would it?"

Of course it would. You have a computer, use it and do enough research to write a concerned wood turner's article.

Then TD said:

" Perhaps getting people talking about the problem might get the ball rolling but I really think it would be better if we got a trained expert to look into what we are doing and show us a better way."

What better way to reach turners than with our magazine. I am sure someone knows the circulation figures. Each AAW club has a liaison between the AAW and the club membership (at least the Richmond club did). By publishing a letter of concern you will reach thousands of people. TD, quit complaining and do something constructive.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#63

Amazing!

Martha Roberts

>It is 'amazing' what some people expect from a volunteer organization.

"I pay my dues so I expect them to serve me!"

or "If they don't do what I want, then they are bad"

or "Why bother joining when I can get all the benefits anyway?"

These tiny little people who scream so loud, yet do nothing to contribute, do not deserve the time of day!

Martha

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#64

Re: A total novice's take... *LINK*

Ed Davidson

>Well said, Joe...if you change your mind and decide to join the AAW, you could always apply for an Educational Opportunity Grant (EOG) to start a new chapter closer to home. Here's a link to the AAW webpage on starting local chapters, below.


Starting a Local AAW Chapter in Your Area

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#65

Bull!

Martha Roberts

>I'm a novice, or I was more of one before getting help from fellow club members.

So many generous members walked me through tasks that would have taken me much longer to learn by myself. And they never asked for anything in return. Not one dime!

My joining AAW was one of the things I could do to give back to all those kind souls who shared their time, patience and skills with me. My dues goes into projects that the AAW fund. Since I have no skills to contribute to the membership (yet), at least I can contribute with my dues.

I get a lot out of the AAW Journal (just the pictures alone). Although I might not yet fully comprehend the techniques used in some of the articles, with all the educational opportunity that AAW presents, I am certain I will. If the Journal was only geared for me and my skill-level, I soon would become very bored with a simplistic and boring publication.

And one last thing, as our club president said, the AAW is dedicated to Youth Education. I am thrilled to contribute my dues to such a worthy cause!

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#66

Re: Whether the field is science....

Jamie Donaldson

>... or philosophy, sometimes the most important part of the discovery process is postulating the initial question. There can be no answer without the question, and to start the ball rolling would be a good and necessary place to start. The AAW of course does not have the financial resources to fund such research, but members who reside in the halls of learning could have access to and interest in the answer if the question was to be presented to them. As example, the Emerald Ash borer is a very important concern in this area at present, and it's movement South has huge significance in the forestry and many related industries. So TD, do something constructive and try asking some questions in a receptive forum.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#67

Martha...

Carole Valentine

>Don't know you and am not sure I have ever seen your name, but I like you and I like your style. Well said.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#68

Re: A total novice's take...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Joe, I'm afraid that I don't understand your attitude on not being a member of the AAW. Way back in the 70's I subscribed to and avidly read Fine Woodworking. There were a couple of articles published on David Ellsworth showing a lot of photos of the wonderful, thin walled hollowforms he was turning. At that time no one else in the world was doing what he was doing. The were no tools available and no one except David had acquired the knowledge and techniques and had made tools to do that kind of work. Understand, there were no websites, no instructors that I knew of, no AAW, no clubs, and no way to learn how to do that kind of work. I was inspired by what I saw and read and determined that I was going to learn how do that myself. It took me quite awhile but I did teach myself how to turn hollowforms. Not anywhere near what David was doing but I developed as time went on. At that time I didn't even know any other turners.

My point is, that with all of the help that is available to turners today through websites, DVD's, the AAW, etc. you really put yourself down by saying that you're not ready for what's in the American Woodturner magazine. It's one of the best learning tools that I know of.

Wally

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#69

I'm glad you enjoy AAW

Joe Pack

>I'm glad you enjoy AAW, Martha. I'm sure I would also if I had a club available. Being able to learn from friends would be invaluable. That, at least to me, is the heart of AAW or any such group. The people make the group. Perhaps I will someday live close enough to a group of nice people such as yourself to take advantage of all that AAW has to offer.

I'm sorry you felt that my post was "Bull." It was meant to present a view, my view, of a product that is available, but a product that I feel is not quite right for me. I fully respect that many will not agree with me, but I am surprised that someone would denigrate an opinion that was gently, honestly and sincerely expressed and free of malice toward anyone.

Best wishes,

Joe

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#70

Thank you, Ed.

Joe Pack

>I actually have thought about that, Ed. I would love to be associated with a group of turners, and would even be an active member, but I'm not sure someone with zero skills is the person to start a new club. :-) I will check out the information, though, just because I am curious.

I appreciate your kindness.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#71

Well Said!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I like your style!

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#72

Thanks Wally.

Joe Pack

>Thanks, Wally. You probably have more faith in my ability than I have. :-)

I would never say that I would not join AAW, just that, with having no club near enough to me to enjoy the benefits of the group, the magazine alone is not worth $45 per year for 4 issues. The few AAW magazines I have gotten hold of had a bit of interesting, useful information for me, but most was far beyond my skills, or those I might logically develop in the near future. As with Fine Woodworking and my flat work, as my turning skills grow, likely will my interest and need for more sophisticated reading material grow. I'm just not at that point yet.

As you point out, there are numerous sources of turning information available today that were not available just a few years ago. If there was no other source, I might likely feel different about the price of the AAW journal. And as I find a need for more detailed information on more advance work, I may finally choose to go the AAW route.

If I had a woodturning group nearby, I would join in a flash, AAW or other. From what I have experienced here and elsewhere, turners are a most sociable group!

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#73

Re: I'm glad you enjoy AAW

Martha Roberts

>Joe --

You are confused on what the American Association of Woodturners (AAW) is. The following is from: http://www.woodturner.org/org/mbrship/

"The AAW is an international, nonprofit organization dedicated to the advancement of woodturning. Our mission is to provide education, information and organization to those interested in turning wood."

Note on the web site what the membership benefits are (especially Educational Opportunity Grants (EOG), POP and the Journal).

Membership to a local club is separate from the AAW. Most local clubs have their own membership dues, and although most do not require membership to the AAW, they highly encourage it because the AAW supports local clubs with many benefits, such as insurance coverage, grants, help in forming a club, etc.

Joining AAW has no mileage limitations.

And although you may yet to see advantages of a AAW membership (and perhaps it will never be a cost-effective investment for you), you have unwittingly added your voice to the AAW-bashing, representing the Novice, which was then 'seconded' by TD. To that I say "bull".

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#74

Re: Thanks Wally.

Carole Valentine

>Joe, like you I have no turning groups within driving distance and there are no turners anywhere near that I know. (Well, there is one, but he's too busy to bother with a novice and appears to resent the possibilty of any competition, but that's another story.) Anyway, I taught myself and am still teaching myself with the help of my Internet friends, books, videos and yes, AAW. I understand that you may not feel it has anything to offer you at this stage in your turning, but I believe it does. (One article that comes to mind was one on sharpening and grinds, but there have been many other that would benefit a new turner.) When I first subscribed, it was more out of the fascination of seeing what COULD be done. I kept every issue and as my skills improve, I go back through them for inspiration and tips that may not have meant anything to me in the beginning, but do now. Like Martha, I think one of the best aspects of AAW is their attention to youth programs. Have you noticed how old most of us are? Just look at the pictures of the Symposium! LOL If we don't encourage the next couple of generations to take up turning, it is quite literally going to become a dying art. I support AAW to support the craft, and as a side benefit, I get a nice magazine, a directory of turners from around the world, the choice to meet many of them at annual Symposiums and a forum where I can ask questions, take part in discussions, chat, etc. I am thinking about having my shop insured under the AAW umbrella. To me that's a lot for $45 a year.

Re: AAW Board Canidates

#75

no complaining

tdaniel

>Barb, I have offered to do the article. I have sent my concerns, actually enough to do the article but if more is needed I will gladly send it. I have fully explained my concerns to a board member of the AAW. Is there anything else that you think I should do?