Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

JD round scraper- here is my..

Posts

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#26

Yes but...

Ron in Drums PA

>The edge won't last long the metal is too soft.

The last tool I use is a cabinet scraper to aid in cleaning up the outside curve.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#27

DRW-I bet I can guess what ......

Jamie Donaldson

>... the problem is with your swept back grind catching! Is there a continuous slightly convex line from the cutting tip to the end of the wing, with no hump or dip right behind the cutting tip? Many users inadvertantly grind away part of the tip profile as they rotate the tool on the grinder, and the reason is because the tool steel is thinner there and grinds away faster than the side wings.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#28

p.s. Metric grades

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>These two common metric grades are approximately equal to the US grades:

Metric 8.8 = Grade 5

Metric 10.9 = Grade 8

Both types can usually be found in any well-stocked hardware store, especially in rural areas (farm equipment use). Most home centers only carry the US grades.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#29

Re: Tantung Source?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Checked ENCO and McMaster, but not listed.

Like to know who sells it and in what shapes, etc.

Thanks

mm

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#30

Re: Tantung Source?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>http://www.agivrwesson.com/tantung.php

Try this....

Wally

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#31

Thanks, Wally

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#32

Re: DRW-I bet I can guess what ......

dwr

>Jamie,

I will take a look-see. My bet is you are correct. I gotta' figure this out before I ruin another large blank.

So, the fix is to just make a light pass when rolling the gouge over on the side to avoid making a bevel on the wings?

Thanks!

Dave

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#33

Re: DRW

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You should take a look through the Grinds Library here on the left margine.

mm

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#34

Re: DRW-here is my "Big Dummy....

Jamie Donaldson

>... How Not to Grind" bowl gouge I use for teaching. It has just about every error possible (highlighted in red) for grinding a deep flute gouge, many due to not using, or not using correctly, a jig. The side wings should never extend in front of the tip/bevel, caused by grinding on the thin area of the gouge at the tip. And the side wings should have a flat(straight) or slightly convex cutting edge, never concave as illustrated. The misground tip area is the usual culprit when dig-in's are the problem.


img

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#35

Yeah...

dwr

>... that seems to be in order.

I have free-handed all my tools for nearly 30 years, but with the Thompson tools I figured it was time to try the "jig" approach and see what all the hulla-buloo was about the swept back grinds.

I will admit that the swept back grind is a real workhorse and not necessarily a "finesse" grind... (except the unique way Doug Thompson grinds his personal tools...which were a pure joy to work with!)

I am also thinking that I need to consider the speed as well as all the other elements. I am running my custom bowl lathe and can turn BIG pieces for the first time.. so there are a lot of elements to get use to for the first time... need to adjust my expectations!

Thanks,

Dave

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#36

Re: DRW-here is my "Big Dummy....

Don in Central Illinois

>Jamie, is that a blue background or has my monitor gone crazy?

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#37

Re: Tantung Source?

Mike Nelson

>Wally, I called them, they are wholesale only. Do you know of another?

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#38

Re: Tantung Source?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Sorry, I don't...maybe a machine shop could order some for you.

Unless you have the right equipment, I doubt that you could machine this yourself. I tried to drill a hole in a piece of it....forget it.

Wally

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#39

Steve Kubien

I'll have to try that

Steve Kubien

>Are you talking about a regular curved card scraper? I'll have to give that a try.

Thanks,

Steve Kubien

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#40

Re: Yeah...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Dave, I think Jamie is right, a dip between the nose angle and the wing could cause your problems. Stick to the basic grind because it does everything well. The 5/8V should be the main tool on larger work, including some finish cuts.

A safe way to touch up the cutting edge, start on the wings then blend the nose angle to the wings.

Do you have pictures of the grind?

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#41

Re: I was wondering if......

Jamie Donaldson

>.... anyone noticed the dark blue mount board I used for a background??? ;-))))

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#42

You cannot machine with conventional tools

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>You can grind it or burn a shape with an EDM but that is about it. It pretty much needs to be cast to shape.

Ray

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#43

I just...

dwr

>... set the Wolverine to the bevel on the tool and had at it. I think I might have spent "too much time" on the wing and caused the profile to change.

I will try to get a pic tonight and post. I get great finishing cuts with a fresh edge but always screw up the transition from wall to bottom. I think the tool rest might be a tad too high and the wing might be catching the approaching wall... but things happen too fast to see for sure...;)

Dave

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#44

Re: Tantung Source?

dwr

>Mike,

CS USA sells them. Just one size/shape. $35+ for one.

Dave

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#45

Re: I just...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Dave, to get that slightly convex curved profile on the gouge, lay it, flute side down on the grinder toolrest. Then just grind the profile that you want. When you grind the sidegrind keep that profile.

When using the gouge your toolrest should be a little below center so that with the handle down you're cutting a bit above center. Having the rest too high can cause problems.

Wally

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#46

Thanks Wally...

dwr

>... I was scratching my head about not getting a concave bevel. Makes sense. I will rework them tomorrow.

I read Roy Child's article and got some good insights as well. I am encouraged and ready to attack the next Big'un.

Dave

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#47

Re: Ric, the Dollar and Pound...

Tim GC

>Hi folks,

You are right about the prices and the currency fluctuations ... at the moment I am busy spending every penny I can get away with on tools, pen kits, blanks etc etc from firms in the US. Even with shipping and our bloodsucking Govt. Import Taxation policy it is still cheaper than buying comparable stuff here!! A year or 18 months time it will be the other way round or at least a close run thing. I will always go for the US stuff though if I can. The service and quality is far far better.....

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#48

Re: Thanks Wally...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Dave take a look at the second page fig. 3 of this article, this is the shape your looking for.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=turning&file=articles_132.shtml

If your grind is way off start over by shortening the tool by a 1/16 to 1/8 inch, regrind like Wally discribed.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#49

Re: Tantung Source?

Mike Nelson

>I talked to the sales rep in Dallas, he gave me a number of dealer will call today and get back on prices. Mike

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#50

Doug...

dwr

>... here are a profile and tip picture. I set the jig up using the picture you left in my shop and a 1.75" extended tool tip.

I am using 6" wheels as you recall. The wings are about swept back about 3/4".

Do you see any issues?

Dave


img