Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

JD round scraper- here is my..

Posts

JD round scraper- here is my..

#1

JD round scraper- here is my..

Jamie Donaldson

>... shop made version of the Sorby Multi-tip scraper, which they have recently priced out of sight! The 2 useless tips which they now include certainly didn't justify raising the price from $34 to $74!!My version is a 3/4" cold rolled rod from Lowes, and a HSS shaper blade from the hardware bargain table-3 for $5! Grind a flat, drill and tap for a bolt- makes is adjustable for use as a shear/scraper that cuts very smoothly when rolled on side to about 45 degrees. And the total price is right!


img

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#2

Re: Tool prices

Jeff from MA

>Nice work on the tool. How well does it hold the edge? I was considering making scrapers from HSS stock that I will need to harden. I am curious if it will be worth the extra effort?

I'm afraid we are in for lots of bad news with respect to turning tool prices because so many of them come from UK/EU. The price of good steel is way way up, in some case more than double. The cost of international freight is way up, and the US / UK exchange rate is really hurting us also. As the current supplies in stores and warehouses get depleted, and they need to be replaced it is going to get ugly.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#3

Re: Tool prices

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I could make something like that... round and you grind to shape.

Put on to do list.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#4

Re:This brings up the question....

Jamie Donaldson

>... about exotic alloys for all tools- how hard is too hard for the intended purpose? A carbon steel scraper will roll a uniform burr and not be as brittle at the cutting edge as a high alloy tool steel such as M 4, A 11, etc. Where is the best middle ground for alloys that best accomplish a specific task and remain cost effective?

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#5

Re:This brings up the question....

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>This is a good question and I hope someone could answer it.

Jamie, you did a good job... with a little time and effort you have great tool.

OT from this post - Tool prices are set on what the market will bear. Example P&N sells the detail gouge for a lot more than the bowl gouge because people like the detail gouge. What costs more to produce... the bowl gouge. Steel prices do vary month to month but it doesn't jump like oil... it's a slow steady rise. Were not talking copper either.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#6

Grade 8 Washers

Ron in Drums PA

>I made a few tools like Jamie with Grade 8 washers as cutters.

They last long enough and they are cheep so you can have a half a dozen sharpened and ready to go when you need them

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#7

Re: Grade 8 Washers

Stuart Johnson

>Ron, are these regular hardware store washers? If not where do you get them?

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#8

Tantung Steel...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Doug, have you had any experience with tantung steel? The professional turners on the Oregon coast who turn myrtlewood for the tourist trade use tantung steel scrapers brazed onto mild steel shafts. The reason that the little scrapers that Dennis Stewart sells are so expensive is that they made of tantung. I'll pay the price because they work so well, and last so long. An edge will outlast HSS by quite a bit. It is between HSS steel and carbide in hardness and it will take a better edge than carbide and can be sharpened on your grinder. Takes a lot of grinding to reshape it.

Wally

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#9

Lowes

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: Tool prices

Mike Stafford

>Jeff has it right about prices over in the UK/EU. My son is living there and he says that the price for anything is basically the same as it is in the USA except you are substituting the the pound symbol for the $ symbol. So something that is priced here for $10 is 10 pounds there which works out to more than $2 to the pound or more than $22. Sorry I don't know how to insert the symbol for British pound....

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#11

Re: Grade 8 Washers

robert davis

>what are grade 8 washers?

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#12

Ric Taylor

Re: Tool prices

Ric Taylor

>Hmmm.... I'm confused. I must have been absent from math class that day ..... :)

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#13

Re: Grade 8 Washers

Cyril Griesbach

>Grade 8. Here is my limited information on that. Some applications require hardware that can take higher stresses and wear and Grade 8 indicates that such hardware is made to that higher standard. It's supposed to resist bending, breaking and wear through because it's hardened. To what level I have no idea. Hopefully someone with an actual working knowledge of this will chime in and give us both the right answer.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#14

Re: Tantung Steel...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>From what I read tantung is the best and need to find out what properties it has to hold up so well. I have very little feedback on the CPM 10V as a scraper... how much longer the burr will last over HSS is a good question.

This will go on the to do list that is getting long.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#15

Steel prices are crazy!

Ruth Niles

>Sort of OT, but stainless steel March of 2006 was $2830 a ton in May of 2007 it was $6286 a ton. In a little over a year the price of SS increased 222%. Thank goodness oil isn't like stainless steel!!!!!

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#16

Re: Grade 8 Washers  *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>


link

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#17

Ric, the Dollar and Pound...

dwr

>are on a 1:1 ratio relative to their respective currencies however, the exchange rate to convert USD to Pounds Sterling is a 2:1 ratio in value, so 10 Pounds Sterling is roughly equal to $20 USD... meaning the Pound is stronger than the dollar... as is the Euro...

International exchange rates vary hourly...

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#18

Wally...

dwr

>... what angle do you grind your Tantung? I am about to grind mine and was wondering. I am using a 6" high speed grinder.

I am also assuming the blade does not come ground, as the edge is way too smooth to have any burr or cutting capability.

You done anything with the Curly Walnut blank?

Dave

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#19

Re: Wally...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Hi Dave,

I grind all of my scrapers at 60 deg. (30 if you're measuring the other way). Tantung is really hard stuff but it keeps an edge for a long time.

I don't rough turn until it cools off a bit. Still in the 100's here. I'll get at the walnut, along with some camphor burl, some zebrano and some madrone burl that I got from Gilmer, in October when it starts to cool.

Have you done some big turning on the monster lathe yet?

Wally

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#20

Steve Kubien

Could you use....

Steve Kubien

>Any reason a person couldn't use a piece of an old beat up plane iron? I've got a few around that are beyond their intended use but I never got around to throwing away.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#21

Looking forward...

dwr

>... to seeing what you do with the Walnut. If you need some light colored finial/collar material, I have some Holly... Fiddle Back Maple, among others.

I have turned several pieces on the Big-un, but only have one piece of spectacular Walnut crotch to show for the efforts. All the rest reside in various configurations of spontaneous disassembly.

I have never had problems with catching until I ground all my bowl gouges to swept back grinds with the Wolverine Jig. I Love the jig, the grind and the Thompson tools, but keep getting some amazing catches. Makes me feel like I need to go back to bowl turning 101 after nearly three decades!

I am going to re-grind some of the "basic" grinds for use inside. Also making a few more tool rests from contoured flat stock rather than round because the round stock accentuates the downward forces.

Between these two efforts, I hope to get back to completed pieces rather than custom mulch.

Looking forward to assembling a NW Gathering next year. Will keep you updated. Have a great place lined up already! Hope to bring along the Monster and two other spinners.

Stay cool Wally! (and let me know about the wood...)

Dave

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#22

Re: Could you use....

john lucas

>A plane iron is probably not High speed steel. I don't think it would hold an edge very long and would be awfully easy to over heat. Makes great carving tools if you cut it up and re harden etc.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#23

Bolt Grades

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I knew I had this info, it just took a while to locate it. The grade refers to the strength of the bolt/nut/washer. The higher grades are a stronger steel and are heat treated. The ratings are:

Un-graded bolts: Minimum tensile strength is 70,000 psi.

Grade 5: Minimum tensile strength is 120,000 psi.

Grade 8: Minimum tensile strength is 150,000 psi.

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#24

steel

JKJ in East TN

>>...a 3/4" cold rolled rod from Lowes

If planning to make several tools, you can purchase steel stock far cheaper from a steel supply house or fabrication shop. Most stock comes in 20' lengths, but the supplier will often make a cut or two for free to make it easier to haul. You can probably get a 20' piece for what the box stores charge for a few feet.

Also, some suppliers and many fabrication shops sell offcuts at scrap prices. Machine shops are great places to get short pieces. At one fab place I use, I pile what I want in a heap on the floor and the guy comes out and eyeballs it and gives me a price. Another supplier weighs each piece.

JKJ

Re: JD round scraper- here is my..

#25

Steve Kubien

Re: Could you use....

Steve Kubien

>Thanks John. I kinda though along those lines myself.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien