Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Turning Thin.....

Posts

Turning Thin.....

#1

Turning Thin.....

Wally Dickerman

>Here on WC there have been several threads on turning thin VS not turning thin. There seems to be a general agreement that funtional pieces usually should not be turned thin. However, there is a difference of opinions on why even art form pieces shouldn't be turned thin, such as: gallery owners say it doesn't sell, it's a fad, it's a form of showing off, and a lot more.

Those who seem to disapprove of thin turning should have been at the auction which followed the banquet dinner at the Portland AAW symposium. There was a piece in the auction which is one of most outstanding pieces that I have ever seen. It was a piece which was a collaboration by the late Frank Sudol and by Binh Pho. Both of these turners are known for turning very thin pieces, followed by a great deal of surface enhancing.

This very thin and very beautiful piece sold at auction for $30,000!!!.... The fortunate person who bought this piece has to know that in time it will be worth a great deal more.

Wally

Re: Turning Thin.....

#2

Steven Antonucci

Almost anyone can turn thick...

steve antonucci

>I think that there is a right balance between thick and thin in functional bowls, but for an art piece- thin is in! The skill of the turner is paramount in cutting a piece once you get below 1/8".

I wouldn't want a 1/8" functional bowl, but a hollowform for sure needs to be thin to be taken seriously.

Steven

Re: Turning Thin.....

#3

Re: Turning Thin.....

TDaniel

>Wally, the only fatality that I know of from woodturning came as a result of thin turning. A student at a high school blew up a thin platter and a ragged edged piece severed his main artery in his neck. Thin is for the experienced. It may sell well but it can be very dangerous to turn for someone who is not yet ready to go there.

Re: Turning Thin.....

#4

Re: Turning Thin.....

Donna Banfield

>Sometimes, I wish I were a collector instead of a woodturner. I would be financially well off, and I would still have a lot of woodturnings (which would look a lot better than my own)!! ;^)

Re: Turning Thin.....

#5

Thin is appropriate for certain pieces

Craig Daymon

>Bin's decoration really becomes much more difficult with thicker pieces. I've seen him demo and used the tool he uses to pierce his pieces. Thicker work would make this very difficult as well as possibly damaging an expensive tool.

I'm not a master of thin and most of my thinner work is because I was correcting issues with a thicker piece, but ideally I like to get a piece to the point where it doesn't "feel" heavy/clunky as well as doesn't feel like I have to tie it down to keep it from floating away. I think even Bin leaves some mass in the bottom where he does not intend to pierce.

Bin's a great guy and it's good to hear that his work garners so much attention. He really is an artist, but the medium for his work is thin vessels. Jacques Vessery (sp?) does phenominal work that I doubt if it ever involves thin pieces, but then his work is heavily carved.

Wally, please post a picture of the piece if you have one, I'd love to see it.

-Craig

Re: Turning Thin.....

#6

Re: Turning Thin.....

IAN

>donna, as for being a collector, I'm sure any of us would be glad to sell you a piece or two. and you already are a collector, you collect the pieces you turn until you find someone who likes it better than you do.

as for turning thin, for most things 1/8 to one 1/4 is thin enough, thinner than that has to have a purpose, ie rangerider hat, for a bowl or platter they warp to bad and look terrible.

IAN

Re: Turning Thin.....

#7

Re: Thin is appropriate for certain pieces

Bill Crommett

>I turn thin all the time. And then I take the two pieces and put them in the burn pile . Then I chuck up another block of wood and turn it thin into two pieces again. Man is that ever fun. Not satisfying, but fun.

Re: Turning Thin.....

#8

Re: Turning Thin.....

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Wally,

For both Frank Sudol and Bihn Pho the quality of their work in a collaboration like this had to be right on. Both of their names on one piece is also a MAJOR PLUS. I'm sure the piece was beautifully done and amazingly thin. But one has to wonder if the piece had been made from a 2x4 by these two talented individuals how much less would it have sold for.

JMHO,

Mike

Re: Turning Thin.....

#9

Re: Turning Thin.....

john lucas

>I like the way John Jordan put it. Turn a really thin piece and then get over it. He didn't mean that you should not turn thin, he simply meant that each piece needs to be a certain thickness based on the piece. If you can turn thin and know you can then you are free to make a piece thick or thin depending on the design criteria.

While Binh Pho's and Frank Sudol's work is thin Jack Vessery's work is quite thick, especially for their size. They both sell work in the $10,000 and above. Some people really like thin and some don't. I guess it boils down to your market and of course your name.

Re: Turning Thin.....

#10

Re: Turning Thin.....

john lucas

>TD I don't want to argue about thick or thin or what is the most dangerous but I've seen a piece from a thick platter stuck in the ceiling. That piece could have just as easily killed someone if it hit them right. The person turning it simply got lucky and it didn't hit them.

Re: Turning Thin.....

#11

IAN, if I had the money..

Donna Banfield

>I would own your southwestern style hollow form that I admired in the Instant Gallery at the Yankee Symposium....and I would have one of Molly Winton's hollow forms, one with the primitive horses...and let's see, anything by Clay Foster....and oh yeah, one or two of the pens made by eaglesc... Hey, I can dream, right?

But I'm a woodturner, and as many of you can attest, it's not an easy way to make a good living....so, I'll have to put all those pieces on my 'wish I could'list.

Re: Turning Thin.....

#12

ROFL! Thanks for the laugh, Bill

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Turning Thin.....

#13

Re: Turning Thin.....

Wally Dickerman

>TD, a freak accident like that shouldn't deter someone from turning thin if that's what they want to do. I'd rather be hit by a flying 1/2 oz. piece from a broken thin piece than a 1 lb. piece from a thick turned piece.

Wally

Re: Turning Thin.....

#14

Re: Thin is appropriate for certain pieces

Wally Dickerman

>Craig, I only wish that I had a pic...I brought my camera to the instant gallery and took a lot of pics. Sadly, I was too late for the pieces that were to be auctioned off. They had already been picked up. I'm working on getting a pic from Binh.

Wally

Re: Turning Thin.....

#15

Re: Turning Thin.....

Wally Dickerman

>Hard to say Mike....The fact that this was possibly Frank's last piece had something to do with the cash value...My guess is that the buyer could sell it to a big time collector for twice what she paid for it.

Wally

Re: Turning Thin.....

#16

Re: Turning Thin.....

Wally Dickerman

>IAN, most of what I turn that is less than 9 inches is turned 1/16 in. or so. They don't warp and I really don't think that they look terrible...

Wally

Re: Turning Thin.....

#17

I agree completely John

Rick Davenport

>

Re: Turning Thin.....

#18

Re: Turning Thin.....

Stephen Mushinski

>Here is a photo of the turning that Wally is talking about. It is only a quick snap shot and you do not see the back. This turning needs to be seen from all sides.

If you go to the AAW web site under the 2007 symposuim link you can see the auction.

It was so wonderful to finally meet you Wally. Wish there would have been more time to chat.

Steve


img

Re: Turning Thin.....

#19

I agree completely John - Me too! Well, put indeed

nailshooter

>

Re: Turning Thin.....

#20

Re: Turning Thin.....

Jorge Castaneda

>wally,

At that small thickness the built in stresses are not a issue anymore?

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Turning Thin.....

#21

Re: ROFL! Thanks for the laugh, Bill

john lucas

>Me too Bill. It would be even funnier If I hadn't just done it Sunday morning.

Re: Turning Thin.....

#22

Re: Turning Thin.....

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi all,

Like some others, I think it all "just depends" :) I have a cherry bowl I use to eat popcorn out of and it is about 9 inches across and a half an inch thick. It has a nice shape and heft in the hand. I've knocked it off the couch and didn't think anything of it except I had spilled my popcorn!

On the other hand, I've turned some Norfolk Island Pine down to under an 1/8th of an inch to get the translucent effect. That bowl sits on the mantle and is not "used" per se. Similarly for hollowforms, I try to get them very thin, but leave a little mass in the bottom for stability.

For me, it also depends on the size of the hollowform as to how thin I want to (and can) go. I am comfortable taking a small (3-4 inch diameter) hollow form down to less than an 1/8 of an inch, but some of the bigger ones I've turned I've left a bit thicker. The really thin big ones get me nervous :) I keep pushing the envelope a little bit there, but the progress is slow for me.

So, to me, the piece can help decide how thick/thin it should be. I like hollow forms to be thin. I like some bowls to be thin, but for functional bowls, I like them to have a little heft to them. I like the illusion that they might look heavy, but then are very light when you pick them up. Wally's pieces are like that. They can look heavy but they are wonderful to hold.

Interesting thread,

Mike

Will turn thick or thin in Apex, NC!

Re: Turning Thin.....

#23

Re: Almost anyone can turn thick...

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Steve,

Sometimes, I find that it is harder to turn a really good thick bowl than a thin one. By that I mean a bowl say that is 9 inches across and 3-4 tall or so and by thin I mean the same size across, but less than a 1/4 inch thickness. If I want to leave it thick, say, 1/2 an inch or so, I have a harder time matching the external shape on a thick bowl than a thin bowl. When I turn thin, it always just seems that the inside shape is really dictated by the outside shape, so as long as you get a good outside, you are ok on the inside. For thicker bowls, it seems you have to really create two bowls, one on the out and one on the in. Getting those two to match up in a nice appealling manner can be tricky for me.

For the longest time I turned everything thin, less than a 1/4 inch thin, not crazy 1/16 thin. My thoughts were that anything thicker would be clunky and unappealling. Then, seeing some of the wonderful thicker pieces posted here, gave it a try and found that not only did I like it, but it was as technically challenging, if not more so in some cases, than turning the thinner bowls.

I do agree, however, that at its very basic level, it is easier to turn to a thick bowl than a thinner bowl because it can survive a catch better, not as likely to crack, etc, but for me to turn a really good thick bowl can be just as hard as turning a thin bowl, but for different reasons.

I was happy to see that you are heading to Bill's for the 5 Barns picnic. I'll see you there!

Mike

Through thick or thin, turning away in Apex, NC!

Re: Turning Thin.....

#24

John and Wally

TDaniel

>I turn some items thin too but like y'all I have been turning a few years and almost never have a catch. I caution my students to not go less sthan 1/4 inch in thickness until they no longer get catches, especially on platters with wide rims. Hollow forms are much safer when they blow up. Those wide rimmed platters can be like throwing daggers when they blow up. Of course the best advice to anyone is "stay out of the line of fire"; you don't have to stand where the pieces will go.

TD (who has blown up a few thin and a few thick pieces, :)

Re: Turning Thin.....

#25

Turning Thin

Raymond Overman in SC

>That's a wonderful piece and very artfully done. The collector who purchased it has a prize.

One of the questions I have about thin turnings is sustainability? Many curators of art museums fight to archive paintings and other works due to environmental changes and general deterioration. How will a thin piece hold up over time and will the collectors fight against humidity and seasonal changes be harder than if the piece was slightly thicker?

Don't read my question as a negative against thin turning. I like to practice turning pieces down to a point of seeing through them (which quite often ends up with me making two or more individual pieces) but I do wonder how these pieces will hold up over 50 or 100 years of air conditioning and heat pumps. I would imagine that serious collectors have the means to regulate their collections environment and is aware of the steps it takes to maintain their investment. However, I would think that the average McMansion owner who has a fetish for turned wood won't think further than the, "Keep it away from your heat registers," that we include on our care and feeding sheets. Are they going to end up with a piece that won't hold up to be passed down to their children and grandchildren?

I'm sure someone has thought about this and written something about it over the years. I just haven't run across it. If someone has a resource, please let me know. I'd like to read it.