Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Posts

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#26

Re: It's a male lathe? probably : )

Ruth Niles

>Eddie, I did turn the spindle by hand several rotations but didn't feel anything obvious. Since I've never done this before, I don't know what to compare it to; like if it feels different. There are no rough spots. When you asked if I thought I damaged the spindle stop pin so that it "is just rubbing the detent ring?"..... what's a detent ring? What would it be rubbing on?

Do I have to take the headstock apart?

They're having a great sale on needlepoint supplies.........

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#27

Re: Run it and check....... how long?

Ruth Niles

>Jake, how long should I run the lathe before I would feel any heat. I tried it for about 4 min., no heat, should I run it longer?

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#28

Re: It's a male lathe? probably : )

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>I'm calling the detent ring the part on the spindle that has a notch for the detent pin. You'd see it if it were rubbing.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#29

Any chance the belts are rubbing on something?

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#30

Nothing rubbing from index pin

Ruth Niles

>Jen, I will call Christian if I need to. He's the one who helped me, over the phone, replace the reeves drive unit in my General 160, three times!

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#31

Thanks, Eddie, I'll check tomorrow.

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#32

Re: Test results thus far

Ruth Niles

>When I took the belt off the motor, it ran quiet and smooth = motor is ok, it's in the headstock.

Turned the hand wheel several rotations, no rough spots or "grabbiness" = ?

The noise does go faster and slower with the change of speed = ?

I cannot see anything rubbing from the broken index pin, I pulled the whole thing out when it snapped.

I don't think the belts are rubbing on anything, there isn't anything for them to rub on, they only touch the motor pulley and the spindle pulley.

Ken, I didn't have a length of hose, only thing I had was an empty toilet paper tube = noise sounded like it was in a toilet paper tube.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#33

Keith Tompkins

Re: Test results thus far

keith tompkins

>Ruth, check the set-screw that secures the step pulley to the spindle shaft...it could have worked itself loose with all the stress. The spindle lock appears to be a press-fit onto the shaft..I doubt you loosened that! Check for spindle movement, although I doubt you'll find any.

Rotate the motor by hand....feel how smoothly it spins....Now, rotate the spindle the same way. It should feel just a smooth, no notches as it rotates, no roughness. A worn or damaged bearing will normally make a whirring sound that changes frequency with speed.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#34

For what it's worth...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>My Jet mini was making strange noises in the headstock. Turned out that one of the set screws had come out of the pulley. I put a new set screw in and the noise disappeared.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#35

Re: Use a screw driver stethoscope

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Get a BIG screw driver, like 18 inches. Touch the blade close to the end of motor or head stock. Push the handle end against your ear and close the ear flap with it. With the thing running the bearing should sound with a "clean" whirling noise. Any scrapes, pings, clunks, pops etc mean a damaged bearing. BE CAREFUL WHERE YOU STICK THE SCREWDRIVER. Do not get it close to moving parts.

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#36

Re: Test results thus far

Carole Valentine

>"Ken, I didn't have a length of hose, only thing I had was an empty toilet paper tube = noise sounded like it was in a toilet paper tube."

Ruth, I wish I could help but I can't. Maybe it will help a little for you to know that, despite the possible seriousness of your problem, you have made me laugh, which I haven't done much lately! Thanks!

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#37

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

jeff myroup

>Sounds like a motor bearing, with the belt off there is no load on the bearing. This can cause the sound to go away with just the motor running. How old is the general? Some old motors have lubrication points on them. Good news is the can be easily replaced by any motor repair shop. Hopefully it is just a loose pulley either on the spindle or motor. Good luck

Jeff

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#38

Yeah, That's a good suggestion.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#39

The General is 4 yrs. old

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#40

I Have The Answer!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>This was sent to Ruth by e-mail but since it was such a good answer she asked me to post it here. :-) :-)

"I think the General is just pissed that you shoved ice

up his ### and the set his face on fire and that was

after all the other indignities he suffered. :-)"

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#41

Re: Use a screw driver stethoscope

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>Bill's on the right track with the screw driver sugestion. You can also use a length of hard wood dowel or any stick of scrap will work, though tone woods like walnut or mulberry do work a bit better but are not necessary. you should be able to place the stick on the lathe and as you get closer to the source of the problem the noise will get louder. this is an old time mechanics trick.

Robin Corell

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#42

Re: It's a male lathe?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Eddie-I maybe old, foolish and even whacko but I have enough sense left to not allow a woman who can bend a pipe wrench,( probably made by Rigid), to manhandle my spindle, detent groove, stop pin or bearings. I only made it to Sargent so I guess I am O.K. No Brass on me.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#43

Still having trouble sleeping, eh?

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#44

What about errant oil spray on the pulley.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Just curious if you indeed spryed WD-40 on the faceplate and maybe got some on the spindle pulley. If this got on the belts they would squeal a bit.

Well, I'm going to hit the sack now too.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#45

Good one!

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>So Ken O. resorted to a private e-mail to get his point across?

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#46

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Juergen

>Have you loaded the spindle bearing? Take a scrap piece of wood and mount it like a spindle turning snug up the tailstock. Tighten and loosen the tailstock tension while the lathe is running at different speeds. Does the noise vary in pitch. Also check the drive belt deflection (about 1/4-1/2" max at the belts center point between the pulleys).

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#47

Have no fear about replacing bearings

wilbur

>I have a lathe and a bandsaw that are both close to 60 years old that I bought used. On both machines a noise developed that was nearly identical to what you describe, and on both machines I had to deal with the bearings.

Bearings are pretty inexpensive. Replacing the bearings on the lower axle of my bandsaw ran me a whopping $15, including shipping. My lathe headstock bearings were more problematic, as they were a nonstandard size, and the lathe has been out of production for a number of years. I wound up soaking the bearings in naphtha to clear off the old grease and contaminants, and packing them with automobile wheel bearing grease.

Given that your lathe is 4 years old, and is in current production, finding replacement bearings should be easy. You don't even have to go back to General to get replacements, if you don't want to. There should be a part number stamped on the bearing that will help you find a replacement. If, for some reason, there isn't, all you need is are some measurements: the bore (where the shaft fits), the outer diameter, and the width of the bearing. You should be able to find any number of places that can get you a replacement, including eBay.

And lest you think that I'm some sort of mechanical genius, I'm not. My day job is being a pediatrician.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#48

Picture

Mac

>Ruth, I have this picture of you in my head now,Short,petite lady,dowel sticking out of one ear,screwdriver and piece of hose out the other,using bent index pin to do needlework.....

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#49

..and don't forget...

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>...all this while apologizing to the General for being so mean to him!

:)

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#50

Barbara!!!!!! : ) I love this

Ruth Niles

>