Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Posts

Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#1

Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Ruth Niles

>When the fact plate was stuck, someone had posted about hoping I didn't damage the bearings. Please say the noise I'm hearing is not something major! but I bet it is.

It sounds like something rubbing in the motor and when I shut it off it sounds like yeeeeeoooowwwww slow and low. It's major, isn't it. I knew I shouldn't have tried each of everything suggested with that face plate!!!! : (

Oh, and I tried calling someone to listen to it on the phone, I had a phone in the shop right next to the General. Well, one day I was digging along the house to plant flowers, there's this junk bush right under the grey phone line box, the "root" was really hard so I jumped on the shovel, I grabbed the "root" and pulled, expecting to pull that bush up and it was a big round taped wire, severed just as clean as could be. Yep, the shop phone line.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#2

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Hello Ruth, Don't panic, yet. Take a look around the headstock area and check to see that you didn't bump a cover out of alignment, rubbing on a turning part, which could be causing your lathe to make noise. You were leaning on a lot of parts of the lathe to exert force so your knee or hip may have knocked something off a bit.

For a bearing problem turn the spindle by hand slowly and "feel" for any little signs of resistance or just a "roughness" to the way the spindle rotates. You would have had to smack that spindle pretty hard, or really heat up the bearings to cause severe bearing damage. I don't recall reading that you did something like that.

Good luck.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#3

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ruth,

I had a bearing problem with mine soon after I bought it. It just so happened to be a faulty bearing from the factory. I called Quebec and talked to Christian. He was so helpful. I did the same as you were going to do. I put the phone up to the spindle as it was turning. He confirmed that yes, it was a bearing. It was like that from the time I bought it and it wasn't until I had a big Badger Pond party at my house that some of the other folks pointed it out. I had never owned a large lathe so I just thought that was what it was suppose to sound like. The place that I ordered it from here in Indy (Winner Woodworking) ended up being worthless as far as support, so I ended up shipping the entire headstock back to Quebec and they sent me an entirely new one. If you have a cell phone, I'd call up there and have Christian listen to it. I sure hope you didn't goof up the bearings. I can't imagine that you would have. It's not like you were banging on it from the front to loosen that face plate? I can't remember if you heated it up or not...but even if you heated the faceplate...I can't imagine that would have damaged the front bearing. You would have had to of really heated that thing up. I do recall you saying that you snapped the index pin off. Check that gizmo to make sure nothing is rubbing from that thing?

Argggh!

Jen

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#4

Run it and check.......

Jake Niedling

>for excessive heat near the bearings. Usually when a bearing is going bad, the housing around the bearing and sometimes the shaft will feel hot or very warm.

I agree to check for others things that might have been moved during the process of unjambing your face plate.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#5

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Ruth, you need to differentiate between motor bearing noise, and spindle bearing noise. Find a short length of garden hose, put one end to your ear and move the other end around the headstock area while the lathe is running. Not trying to advise you to do something dangerous, I'm not familiar with the lathe but I'm just saying you can use a hose or a piece of pipe or tubing as a crude "stethoscope" to pinpoint where the sound is coming from. If you can disconnect the belt from the motor and spindle, that would help. If the running motor is still complaining, you've eliminated the spindle. If the motor sounds OK try turning the spindle by hand, you might be able to feel and even hear if there is a bad spindle bearing. You would feel some resistance as you turned it, little sensations of "grabiness".

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#6

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Jake (SoMN)

>No worries,

If it is the bearing, the headstock is fairly easy to take apart. I just had my 20" General apart a couple of months ago. Replacement bearings can be purchased from a bearing supply house for a fraction of what General will charge you. If you need somebody to walk you through taking apart the headstock let me know.

Jake

(remove the 2 for e-mail)

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#7

Ric Taylor

Whack it with a Bent Pipe Wrench ..... :)

Ric Taylor

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#8

HAVE YOU THOUGHT ABOUT NEEDLEPOINT AS A HOBBY ?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#9

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ruth the motor is far enough away on these that you should be able to tell if it's coming from the motor of spindle bearings.

Jen

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#10

Either a very brave or foolish statement

Stuart Johnson

>to someone whose love (the general) is in a mid life crisis and who bends monkey wrenches with her bare hands.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#11

I would say *foolish* for sure!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Brad Vietje

>Hi Ruth,

Coat-tailing on Eddie's response, I'd even take the belt off to do this so you can turn the shaft by hand, and then the motor, and see if you can isolate the noise that way.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#13

Shouting your ignorance *LINK*

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>without seeing Ruth's website and realizing what a waste of talent it would be if she DID take up needlepoint is a mistake, my friend.


RUTH'S WEBSITE

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#14

ROTFLMAO!!!!!

Molly Winton

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#15

Ruth, Do You Make These Things Up...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>and sit back and grin at all of the reaction you get?

Wally

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#16

Mike Stafford

Don't bad mouth needlepointers, my wife is one...

Mike Stafford

>I would be very careful about how I speak of needlepointers. They have sharp needles and scissors and know how to place them strategically...I never insult women who can bend monkey wrenches or who carry around sharp implements....

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#17

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

Ruth Niles

>Following Eddie and Brad's suggestion, I guess it is the motor. With the belt off the motor, he hummed just like always.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#18

Dick Hines

Re: Ruth, Do You Make These Things Up...

Dick Hines

>Wally, I think you had better keep your head down. I don't think she is the mood for jokes like that.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#19

Re...Think that'll work, Ric? I can do that!

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#20

Many time, Ken, more now than ever before! : )

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#21

Ken, more now than ever, after I fix the phone!

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#22

It's a male lathe?

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Ruth, if that's the case then no telling what the strange noise is! You may have gotten way too close when your were uh, un-fastening that face plate....:-)

OK, you said you took the belt off the motor and now it sounds like normal with just the motor running? Then, off hand, it looks like the spindle may be the problem. Give the spindle a gentle turn with your hand on it for a full revolution or more and check for any sensations (don't think it Ken O.) that the bearings may be running rough. You don't think you could have damaged the spindle stop pin a bit so that it is just rubbing the the detent ring?

Let us know what you find.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#23

Wally................. I only wish I

Ruth Niles

>made up these things. I didn't get to read all the posts here until after 9 p.m. I was out in the shop, listening to the motor and spindle, heard my neighbor (friend but a ditz) mowing on her riding mower, she came over to my yard (nice gesture and I love her for it), I didn't want to mess in the yard until I had the General figured out, I went out, got my push mower to do the trimming. Now last week I had to make a new well cover, well is right next to my house, my son gave me a bundle of deck spindles (the straight things) I spent 5 hrs. building a box, cross sections, corner angles for support that fit perfectly in the well opening, then screwed about 28 of the spindles together for the top, put a few pots of plants on it. The ditz mowed OVER two sides, broke 3 boards, broke 1 plant, said "oops", now I have to fix that before noon tomorrow because my two small grandsons are coming for the day!

I couldn't "make up" the things that happen to me. By the way, do you know how to put a new phone wire in the box the phone co. puts outside the house?

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#24

He's really a nice guy.......

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>A bit whacko at times, but generally (no pun intended) nice overall.

Re: Oh dear, the General is making funny noises!?!

#25

Re: Wally................. I only wish I

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Can't help on your yard stuff, but at the Lowes or HD they sell these little thing of ma jigs, made by IDEAL, that are used to spilce phone lines. They are little colored plastic thingies that are hard to see in our age group, but they work very well. They have different types for different situations and some have a gell inside to make the joint water tight. HD has them in the section where they carry all of the phone/lan items.