Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Question for you alcohol soakers

Posts

Question for you alcohol soakers

#1

Bob Moffett

Question for you alcohol soakers

Bob Moffett

>I am considering trying Dave Smith's method for drying bowls. That is soaking them in alcohol and then allowing them to dry. My shop is in the basement of our house as is the gas hot water heater. My question is, how flamable is a bucket of denatured alcohol? A cover would be on the bucket except for when the bowl is draining out the alcohol. I hadn't really thought about that until my wife asked me.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#2

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

Barry Scotton

>I have my containers of alcohol outside. Alcohol is very flamable, and i suspect fumes indoors would be a very poor idea, particularly around machinery or other sources of sparks.

Regards... Barry Scotton... on SaltSpring

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#3

Steven Antonucci

Ditto-

Steve Antonucci

>Same idea here, plus one more idea.

It was 9 degrees Fahrenheit this AM when I started the car. The bucket of DNA is next to the driveway, and it was fine. better safe than not.

Steve

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#4

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

Pat Taylor

>I have mine in the garage, and would not use it indoors. The stuff is very flammable.

Also, the fumes from just the bowls after soaking will be enough to make an indoor work area unpleasant and probably unhealthy.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#5

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

John Lucas

>That's one of the many reasons why I just rough turn bowls and put them up to dry. I'm not willing to put up with buying, storing, handling, and disposal of all the various chemical methods for working with green bowls.

I've talked to Dave and I may try it on boxes where I don't need so much alcohol.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#6

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

Ron in Drums PA

>Since I don't don't drink, I really don't know about these things!

But!

If you have a liqueur cabinet fill of booze, there is a good change you have more alcohol in that cabinet than you would have if you had a 2 gallon bucket of DNA sitting around.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#7

Well....

Reality Check

>that�s what we all need, a five gallon vat of highly flammable alcohol in our woodshops all with �HOPES� of making a a bowl blank dry a bit faster, not even mentioning after soaking, the blank remains a fire bomb, until the flammable, and unhealthy smelly vapors evaporate & completely dissipate. There is some evidence that soaking blanks in DNA has little real benefit than to just air drying, I believe it was Fred Holder of More Woodturning Magazine, who did detailed experiments that indicated that it was not worth the trouble.

Bob, This was a simple but good question, and am glad you asked it, because you got a few good answers from users that at least are trying to use some common sense. I have a big problem with experienced turners who jumped on the DNA bandwagon talking about the �perceived� benefits knowing inexperienced or ignorant turners are taking this advice and sloshing bowl blanks around in a five gallon DNA firebomb in there woodshops.

Now the reality check; woodturning/woodworking in general, for many obvious & some unobvious reasons is a very hazardous practice. Having said that, we can reduce the hazards dramatically by understanding the dangers, using proper safety equipment, taking the extra time and steps to do thing safely, and above all, use common sense. Common sense tells me, NOT using DNA, improves my odds of making my shop all that much safer. You need to ask, is the little �possible� benefit worth the risk & trouble?

Now some quick advice, what I know works; If you must dry blanks fast, Micro wave drying will dry your blanks much faster than air drying, there are still some potential hazards with this, but can be done safely if you don�t rush it. The problem with some who tried it, they try to rush the process by overheating the blanks. For it to work, it is a troublesome process, (I have slowly heated & cooled some pieces as much as 20 times), and it can�t be rushed or failures and dangers will follow. There are some good write-ups on micro drying you should read, because there are techniques to the process however, only by doing a lot of experimenting will you get a feel for it. Then once you understand it, it does work well. One last drawback on this is ( I believe) it may cut down the chatoyance of some woods, perhaps due to cell rupture (speculation).

Now the RC practical advice and best advice of all; IF you take a little time, periodically make some blanks, and perodically KEEP THIS UP; after a short while you will always have dry blanks, and won�t ever have to resort to dangerous, troublesome, and time consuming practices, and guess what? it will also give you more time to turn��..Does this make sense?

The Liquor cabinet analogy was somewhat a good point, however, the truth is most (not all) liquors are not as flammable as DNA, and actually difficult to light, even if one wanted to, also exposing the fumes & exposure of pouring a shot glass, compared to say, opening a container of several gallons of DNA or the DNA soaked blank, somewhat nullifies the correlation. Just reduce the hazards and you will increase your safety. IMO the risk and trouble are not worth the possible benefit.

Be safe

Reality Check

P.S. and OT, about last weekend�s exchange discussion, I thought the �Lurkers� and �NON-friends� that came out, showed a lot of class and forgiveness� . Rules are Rules, and that�s all I�ll say about that, because to be anymore honest, will only get the whole post removed.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#8

Bob Moffett

Thanks for the advice

Bob Moffett

>Based on what I have learned from these posts, I think I will just keep putting my roughted out bowls & stuff in paper grocery bags stuffed with shavings. I have had good success with that. As I have learned sometimes a short cut is not worth it.

Thanks everybody.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#9

Re: Thanks for the advice

Reality Check

>Your very welcome, if you didn�t mind advice from just one known as �Reality Check� (some are offended if they don't see a post signed by a Bob or Tom). You will go a long way because you weighed all things out, and used your common sense.

Work safe & good luck friend

Reality Check

PS. keep up with making those blanks

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#10

Re: Thanks for the advice

John Lucas

>Bob I quit using the shavings a long time ago. I found that they didn't slow the drying time down that much and usually caused mold that sometimes stained the piece so I couldn't use it. I tend to use cardboard boxes instead of paper bags but that's just because I have them. The idea is to retard the air movement around the piece so the drying is more even.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#11

Re: Thanks for the advice

dtewell

>Being a fairly new turner, less than 2 years, I have had good success with boiling. I know it can be a PIA but it works. I have done this on a half dozen bowls and no cracking yet. Maybe it's just beginners luck.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#12

Re: Well....

Jerry from Lapel In.

>I DNA all my bowls.Just dryed (12 to 15 % with moisture meter) a 18 in elm (dripping wet with sap) in 3 weeks. Followed Dave method to the tee. Bowl has 1 in. side walls and only warped little over 5/8 of in. After talking to Dave about the different brands of DNA and size to turn to I have not had a failure since Oct of 2006. I turn a lot of bowls. My drum set out in the other part of the barn ,not close to my shop.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#13

Steven Antonucci

It's certainly a worthwhile experiment

Steve Antonucci

>I have been doing it with rough blanks for a couple of years, and here's some detailed observations:

1.) It works. Period. Some people will argue against science, but truth be told, it dries blanks much faster than not using DNA. 2 weeks vs. 6 months.

2.) Fumes, danger, and risk are all really bizarre arguments? Is DNA any more dangerous in a 5 gallon bucket than it is in the store at Home Depot? They've got 100's of gallons sitting there waiting to explode... Do you store your other solvents in the shop/garage? I do. My DNA bucket sits outside because I need the room and because it tends to slosh around when I toss bowls in it. I'm not scared, but I'm also not going to take any unnecessary risks.

3.) DNA is used to thin shellac. If you'd finish a bowl with shellac, then you shouldn't be worried about DNA soaking.

Based on other posts, I think it's safe to guess that Reality Check is probaly not Dave Smith, huh?

Steve

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#14

Re: It's certainly a worthwhile experiment

Ruth Harding

>I was told recently that I could use car window wash containing antifreeze (commonly sold up here in Canada on Bowen Island close to Saltsrping)as a cheaper alternative to DNA as it is alcohol based.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#15

Re: It's certainly a worthwhile experiment

Bill Neddow

>Do not use it to soak anything that will be in contact with food. it is very poisonous. Stick with denatured ethyl alcohol -- not methel alcohol. There was a case in Ontario this winter where people died because some "punch" mixed at home was transported to a party in some windshield washer containers that had not been properly cleaned.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

Dick Hines

>I have been useing DNA to dry my turnings for overa year and would not go back to air drieing. I can have a bowl roughed to 3/4" dry and ready to return in less than a month. I also have had better luck with my bowls not cracking. I try to turn all my pieces wet. It is faster and easier on me and my tools.

Haveing said that I also do it safely. The vat I use is in the back of my shop away from heat and sparks. I am more conserned with a spark from grinding touching off a fire from dust or wood chips. It is also a good thing to have an fire extinguisher or three in your shop.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#17

Re: It's certainly a worthwhile experiment

Bill Howatt

>Based on a reference I found, the alcohol content is probably around 40-45% with the rest of the solution being water and detergent. Just how effective it would be, I have no idea but maybe you would be getting the best of both worlds - alcohol soaking and detergent soaking!

Bill Neddow is right, methanol is nasty stuff and is known to cause serious neurological disorders. Do yourself a favor and get some denatured ethanol if you want to pursue alcohol drying.

Bill

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#18

FYI !!!

RevDoug

>This fellow, "Reality Check" has recently been baned from at least 2 discussion groups that I know about. Ron, I think you were the one who recognized him last time. He has the same tired discussion and arguements.

I'm not saying that what he says isn't true, Just that his arguement gets real argumentative and personal if you don't agree with him.

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#19

Re: As far as the DNA working,

Allen Neighbors

>to make bowls dry faster... I have proven it to myself... It's easy to do a test. Make two bowls from the same fresh tree. Keep one in the wet shavings, while you soak the other one. Then put the two of them side by side on a shelf. Weigh them daily at the same time. You'll see which one dries the quickest.

I don't care how long it takes to dry them. I just don't like for them to crack. That's why I use the soap method. I get less cracking with the soap.

Cheers,

AN

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#20

Leo Van Der Loo

I've heard all the claims before, if the LDD

Leo Van Der Loo

>as everyone was claiming at one time or the boiling that was such a success, then why does everybody now change to the alcohol soak, it seems the wood is still shrinking, and is that not the cause of checks/splits ??

Also why would anyone go through all the trouble doing the wood that's almost bulled proof in drying, does the perceived quicker drying really need the added work, cost and yes also some extra risk.

I continue my way of drying as has been done for centuries, tried and true, works foe me.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#21

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

Terence Rice

>Is "Reality Check" also the Rodent (MM) on another site?

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#22

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers *LINK*

MIke from St. Clair Shores

>Bob,

I use the DNA method and like it alot. You just have to take safety precautions like anything else. I met Dave Smith at the Indy-Fest last year and he is totally concerned about the safety hazards of DNA. If you checked out his web site you would see this. He has spent much time trying to find out the chemicals percentages in denatured alcohol. He feels that the lowest % of methanol in DNA is better. Alcohol sold as denatured can be anywhere from 100% methanol to 5 %. Ethanol can be anywhere from 0 to 95%. Some brands that sell the safer DNA are Sunnyside, Parks, and True Value. I really don"t know how valid someone's opinion about this can be if they never tried it. Check out the link below and read all the instuctions including how to wrap the bowl after soaking. When I tried to talk about the benefits of DNA soaking last year at a club mtg., someone yelled out, "If Weyerhauser isn't doing it, obviously it's not a good idea". and that was that.

Good Luck, and be Safe,

Mike


DNA Bowl Drying

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#23

Re: FYI !!!

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Rev,

looks Like Some One's DNA just evaporated..

:-)

take care,

Jim

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#25

Ruth where have you been?

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>I haven't seen a post of your in a coons age. I see you are back in BC again.

I would not use windshield washer fluid of soaking bowls. I know denatured ethanol is available in Canada. Check with Harvey Brooks down in Victoria maybe he can point you to a local supplier. Harvey has been using the alcohol protocol since I published it 2 years ago. You can also check out the Alcohol Soaking blog for more information.

Good to see your post again.

Dave Smith

Too much flat work recently in Longview, WA.