Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Question for you alcohol soakers

Posts

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#26

Hey, Leo and others, I agree that doing it the ol

Don Henthorn

>the old way is the right way if that is the way you want to do it. But let's face it, no matter what Reality Check said, and I am not disparaging what he said since it works for him, the alcohol method has been tried by enough of us that we know it works. May raise the hackles of some who thinks the new ways can't be good, but for a guy my age I can't sit around forever waiting for bowls to dry, especially if I get a very special piece, else I might not be around to turn it. Science backs the process up which is the reason Dave tried it, I am sure. As for the fire hazard, if adult woodworkers can't handle a little alcohol in the shop, I'm not sure they should be handling sharp tools. j

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#27

Hi Dave, yup it's me

Ruth Harding

>Back in BC but not lathe capable yet. I brought back teh tool post for one lathe and the tool rest from anoter when I returned from CA. Anyway, I am hoping to buy a new lathe soon so am back in the action.

r

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#28

Re: Yerright, Don.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#29

Leo Van Der Loo

I don't need George (reality check) to tell me

Leo Van Der Loo

>what to believe, But I have never seen any scientific evidence, just opinions, and hearsay.

You have any place where I can find the Scientific evidence ??, if so I would like to read that, I'm maybe old but not to old to learn.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#30

Reality Check reference

Stuart Johnson

>Okay did I miss something? Several messages have referred to Reality Check but I don't see his/her post. Was it deleted?

Re: Question for you alcohol soakers

#31

Which part needs scientific proof?

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Before publishing the article on Drying Roughed Bowls Quickly in More Woodturning, I did a literature search on line to see if I could find any reference to the process. What I found was a large number of articles about using ethyl alcohol to remove water from archaeological finds. The process in a nutshell is to soak a wooden piece in an alcohol bath until the solution alcohol reached equilibrium at a lower percentage. Then the piece is put into a fresh bath of alcohol in order to remove more water from the wood. The process is repeated until the alcohol percentage of the bath no longer decreases. Then the piece is placed in a bath of larger molecule alcohol similar to polyethylene glycol. The process is repeated until the volatile alcohol is replaced with a more room temperature stable alcohol thus preventing the cells from collapsing.

There are several large molecule alcohol products on the market for stabilizing punky wood. I have yet to see anyone question the science behind the product. I tried one of the products and I was not favorably impressed with the results. Long before I started turning I read about soaking green burls in polyethylene glycol to stabilize the wood before the burl was cut into chunks or slabs. In order for this to work the polyethylene glycol must exchange place with the water in the wood.

It is the property of miscibility which makes the process possible. Miscibility means the solutes will mix to a uniform concentration without any agitation. It is the reason why alcohol and water in a bottle of wine never separate. If they did separate there would be no need for the costly distillation process to separate alcohol and water.

The science behind water in wood exchanging with alcohol in soaking solution is sound. I doubt there is much incentive in the academic world to do research on alcohol soaking and drying bowls quickly. So I would not hold my breath waiting to read a dissertation on the subject.

Dave Smith

Sunshine this morning, is this really Longview, WA?