Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Critiques

Posts

Critiques

#1

Critiques

Russ Fairfield

>I have some strong opinions about critiques in general, and on-line critques in particular, that nobody seems to agree with. Here is where I am coming from.

The biggest problem we have when we ask for a critique is the meaning of the word. "Critique" means different things to different people. To us as woodturners, the critique in a public forum has become nice people saying nice things about our work, and ignoring it if they can't.

We may not like that definition, but we have done that to ourselves. Whoever does the "critique" at a national or regional symposium always picks up the good stuff that they can say nice things about, and ignores everything else. Whoever does the critique at a large club meeting does the same thing. Wood Central and the other forums are no different. We make nice comments about the good stuff and we ignore the rest.

We may not like that definition of a "critique", but that is the way we have defined it in practice. We have been doing that for a lot of years, and THAT what people expect.

I was the moderator on this forum for 3 years. During that time, I read every post and looked at every picture. There were many who posted ONE photo, received adverse comments, and disappeared. Those who received nice comments always came back. I never thought it was the purpose of the Wood Central forum to drive people away.

I have also seen new folks come to a club meeting, receive criticism from one of the club experts, get mad, and never come back again. I have even seen the experts come to blows over a critical comment that one of them had made about the other. There were several flaming wars of words on this forum that were started over a critique, and the disagreement that followed. Again. those who participated in the war got PO'd and left forever. Some people don't accept criticism well.

Times and the membership have changed. If you folks think think that giving a hard critique here is a good idea, go for it. Be aware that there might be unintended consequences. Keith will be here to pick up the pieces and try to smooth the ruffled feathers.

Re: Critiques

#2

Re: Critiques

Ron in Drums PA

>First I want to say I understand where you are coming form and that you made some very valid points. Nobody wants to disappoint a new turner with an obvious problem. So we say Atta Boy!

But, the critiques that we did in the chat room with photos worked. I learned a great deal from those critiques.

Maybe I'm different, I always wanted honest critiques and when they where given, I always learned allot. I didn't always agree with them. There where times it that it took a couple of years before I tried/understood them. But I listened and learned.

I remember the first honest criticism I received. "Nice Ron, But the bottom flairs out to much." There was gold in them there words.

Or your first comment about my first segmented piece, "Why did you do the bottom like that? It doesn't look right." I'll tell you, I spent I month just thinking how I was going to make it look right. I tried a couple of turnings that where failures. But I finally got.

By not giving an honest critique, the only thing that happens is everybody tries to copy lousy work because they think it looks good.

Re: Critiques

#3

Re: Critiques

eliot d

>I agree wholeheartedly with Russ. One of the problems with a critique in a public forum, too, is that the maker wants to have some feeling that the critic is a a position to make a useful judgment. An experienced turner who has been accepted to juried shows, galleries, etc. may not take too seriously a critique from someone less experienced. On the other side, one may feel a bit silly critiquing a piece by some master turner, who he/she just didn't happen to know about. When I was a complete beginner, I once told a turner I didn't know and just I met at a craft show that I thought his vessel shapes gave me a lift; so it was a critique. The turner thanked me. It was John Jordan.

Re: Critiques

#4

Re: Critiques

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I too understand what you are saying Russ. However I agree with Ron. The critiques I have received here and on WOW have really helped me. If I ask for a critique, I expect exactly that. If someone is so insecure that a suggestion of how their work could be improved is going to cause them to leave the site or even quit turning then there is a good chance it would have happened eventually. The bottom line should be if a critique is requested then critiques are appropriate; if none is requested then we should either say nothing or stroke the ego.

Re: Critiques

#5

New, and in favor of REAL critiques

Pat from MD

>I'm new to this forum and turning, and I want as much criticism as I can possibly get. How else will I leverage the experience of the other people? I've posted photos of my first 2 bowls just this week, and I've gotten lots of very valuable comments, positive and negative. I need to know what to keep doing right, and what I need to change. Otherwise I'll keep making the same mistakes.

I disagree with your assessment so far; I asked directly for suggestions and I've gotten lots of positive and negative comments, and hope that I continue to do so. No ruffled feathers here, because nobody has been rude or arrogant while making comments, just being honest.

Re: Critiques

#6

Re: Critiques

David Breth

>What I would add to Russ's comments is that I think it is somewhat incumbent on the turner requesting a critique to indicate their level of experience, along with mention of technique or form you struggle with that relate to that particular piece.

It would afford potential critique-ers the opportunity to better decide whether or not to write something, and would help them target comments specific to that turner.

David B.

Re: Critiques

#7

Re: Critiques

Russ Fairfield

>The Chat Room critiques were good and they had two advantages over what goes on here on the forum. There is the ability for instant and continuing conversation with questions and answers. It is also a more restricted access, there is a listing of the participants, and we each have the ability to keep Bevis and Butthead off of our screen when they are lurking in the shadows. Besides that, their words are eliminated as soon as we sign off, and there are no outcries about censoring their right to say anything they want anytime they please.

I hope that whoever takes over the Chat Room will try the same thing again and often.

Re: Critiques

#8

Re: Critiques

gary s clarke

>I agree with Russ. The dictionary defined it this way:One entry found for criticize.

Main Entry: crit�i�cize

Pronunciation: 'kri-t&-"sIz

Function: verb

Inflected Form(s): -cized; -ciz�ing

intransitive verb : to act as a critic

transitive verb

1 : to consider the merits and demerits of and judge accordingly : EVALUATE

2 : to find fault with : point out the faults of. To be helpful to fellow turners one should use definition one. There are three sides to every story, yours, mine, and the facts. :)

Re: Critiques

#9

Re: Critiques

Bruce Forrest

>I agree with you Barbara, except for one thing. You said that if comments were not requested, then we should say nothing or stroke the ego.

I don't believe that we should stroke the ego at all. If you don't like it, don't say anything. Period. Maybe then it will dawn on the poster that all is not well, and they will seek out some honest opinions.

I think that stroking the ego is doing a big disservice both to the poster and to the woodturning community in general. As was stated it skews the general perception of what is "good", and could hurt the development of many turners.

Re: Critiques

#10

Re: New, and in favor of REAL critiques

Barry Irby

>A couple of comments some general and specific specific.

I understand the comments about Critiques offending the thin skinned and sendng them packing, but I also understanding wanting and needing honest criticism, shall we say constructive criticism.

We need to remain civil and not dis people's attempts just to be rude or becasue we can get away with it or for whatever reasons there might be.

Those of us receiving the critiques also need to get a handle on who is offerinbg them and what they are worth. Just like most of the time we have little information on the skill level of the "newbie" or person not well known on the forum's skill level, the reciever may not have a clue aobut the qualifications of the person offering the critique.

OTOH, you don't have to be a world class turner to offer an excellent criticism.

So perhaps we should have some rules to protect the thin skinned from the abrasive and obnoxious.

Pat, those were really good pieces you posted. Really. For a first effort they were wonderful. Your finishing techniques are fabulous. Now for the "but". As you have been told, you need to study "forms". (I would say that to almost everyone here including myself. And most of us would admit we are still studying Form and will continue to study it forever) You need to know what constitutes "good forms" and then work on your techniques for getting there. Things like using your body as much as your hands. This is the endless hobby or avocation. You can get better and better, but you may never complete it and have the ultimate skill set, complete set of tools, the ultimate lathe, Etc. Enjoy. You are way ahead of where many of us were when we started. Wood Central can be a big help as can a local club, videos, books and mentors and classes.

Re: Critiques

#11

Re: Critiques

Arch

>To critique a turning should be to offer kind criticism, that's helpfully critical, not a harsh judgement of worth. To have a turning critiqued should be to receive helpful criticism and be thankful for it. Whether this happens or not depends on both the 'critiquee' and the 'critiquor'. On a net forum neither can truly evaluate the other's personality or the position they are coming from. It seems to me that if there can't be some face to face give and take re a particular turning then, given the many unknowns, it's better not to ask for or to offer criticism on an impersonal public forum. Better to ask someone whose opinion you value, privately. BTW, we turners give advice freely, but we should remember that a truly useful critique has a value.

IMHO, there are enough instant galleries and pics of of good and bad turnings on this and other sites that if turners want a critique and cannot have a 'face to face' they intuitively know what they like and can evaluate what is 'good' or 'bad' about a turning for themselves. A newbie turner isn't necessariy a newbie critic. How to correct a perceived 'bad' turning to make it 'good' has more to do with craft than critique.

..and while you all are thinking about all the ways I'm totally wrong, I'll add another. Critques are often a recital of current style and prevailing fashion. If you want to be recognized as a leading woodturner maybe you shouldn't follow the crowd. :)

All best, Arch

Re: Critiques

#12

Re: New, and in favor of REAL critiques

Pat from MD

>I agree with your comments about critiques, except the part about rules. I think that here (like most places) the rules of common sense apply. It seems that regulating this type of thing would be difficult at best and possibly prevent honest exchanges.

As for my first bowls, thanks for the compliment. I also appreciate the suggestions, and have gathered similar ideas from the other comments I've received. I've mainly focused on mechanics so far, so these comments help remind me to look at the bigger picture and think forward more to the end product. Thanks for taking time to comment.

Re: Critiques

#13

Russ got it right..

david

>in my opinion, anyway. I would like to add that a critique can be constructive criticism without being mean-spirited. We don't need any of that in this forum. I post occasionally, and I don't recall ever offering an opinion when comments were not solicited. If I didn't care for a piece, I felt better not saying anything. I don't mind adding my voice to the many accolades on an outstanding piece, but to offer only kind words as a general practice to me is not constructive.

Re: Critiques

#14

Re: Critiques

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Bruce, you are right. Ego stroking doesn't really help anyone.

Re: Critiques

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Critiques

keith tompkins

>Arch, I have to admit I find myself in total agreement with you here.

Many recognized turners came up with "signature" techniques because there was nobody around to teach them the right (only) way to do something. They had no choice but to improvise....and become trendsetters.

How most of us learn to turn is by the example of others. We study with known turners, and perhaps subconciously copy what we learned. No wonder so many turnings exhibit the same predictable qualities while the plagiarism topic just won't go away. What begins as one turner's opinion or suggestion soon becomes a rule, then a law that must be obeyed.

Turners wishing to "find their own voice" won't do it by playing it safe and following the rules. Breaking away has its pitfalls.... don't expect the majority of turners to like what you do.

Re: Critiques

#16

Re: Actually Keith, I would hope....

Jamie Donaldson

>... that everyone play it safe while they are breaking away! But you mostly right!!

Re: Critiques

#17

Re: Critiques *LINK*

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>Russ F. is right about �critique� meaning different things to different people. Our opinions on turnings will be different from person to person also. I don�t think it�s important what word we use just more important is how or should we make comments on the work of others.

I feel that if a turner requests public comment/critique that turner should be prepared for the good and the bad as long as it is constructive. If the turner does not agree with the critique they should not take it as a personal offense. The turner asking for comment can also take the comments for what they are worth depending on whether they know the person making the comments. Nobody knows me or knows my work unless I post or knows my club. I think people would respect Russ F�s comments because they may know him and his web site. I would. I would hope people would take my comments and others as positive also. The last thing any of us want to do is see someone leave the forum. We all can learn from each other no matter what their level of turning. Therefore it is important that comments be made constructively and taking into consideration ones level of experience, if known. What Russ F. might consider �hard� critiques are to be avoided. I am all in favor of �constructive� criticism.

Without the good and the bad how are we to improve our work?

I also know it is difficult to critique a piece from one picture no matter what the quality of the picture. My first critique was on WOW and received positive comments on my work and was told by Lyle Jamieson my photography needed a lot of work. He did not like my blue wood. I learned something from that. A picture is all we have to go by online here. I shouldn�t say this but a lot of my stuff looks better in pictures.

No matter what we think I know critiques/comments or whatever word we use will continue. I hope it will be constructive, positive and above all helpful.


Some of My Stuff - Critique as always is welcome

Re: Critiques

#18

Oooops, sorry Jamie

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>It was Jamie Donaldson that critiqued my photography, not Lyle.

Re: Critiques

#19

Re: I'm glad you blamed ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... Lyle Jamieson for those blue background comments!!!!

Re: Critiques

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Critiques

keith tompkins

>Thanks Russ! Speaking of ruffled feathers, I'm still trying to preen my own. Luckily, some of the missing ones are beginning to grow back in.

The critique can be a great asset online....turners can have their work analyzed by far more turners than could otherwise be possible, and a wealth of knowledge and experience could be shared. I believe that subjects such as the critique are important to the continued growth of the site.....if we fail to grow, we stagnate, reverting back to the safe, bubblegum and lollypop topics.

Here's the biggest problem with the critique process, as I see it. We turners tend to fall into two neatly divided categories: the traditional turner, and the artsy turner. These two groups look at turning from different perspectives, and the resulting critiques will reflect that. I know from personal experience that some on this site, and some turners in general, have no respect of the artist's viewpoint, and will challenge their opinions at every opportunity.

This has happened all to frequently on this site in the past; a simple critique disintigrates into a brawl between opposing viewpoints....and becomes highly personal in the process. When this happens, we all lose. Personally, I have been hesitant to post photos of my work, offer critiques, or discuss design concepts at all for quite some time now because of this.

If we can learn to respect one another, the critique process can work, and work quite well. I have spoken with Ellis on this same topic at some length....ALL VIEWPOINTS are welcome and encouraged on this site. Intolerance is not.

Re: Critiques

#21

Re: Critiques

robert davis

>thank you russ! everything you said is so RIGHT. our clib, the kansas city woodturners , has show and tell but never a " critique". there is plenty of constructive advice on a one to one basis if anyone seeks it.

Re: Critiques

#22

IMHO

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>IMHO, online critiques of woodturnings are about as useful as a snowshovel in Mexico. As Russ so eloquently stated, it is not possible to properly critique any piece from a photograph. A two dimentional photograph of a three dimensional bowl is just a representation without substance. How can a person judge, evaluate, critique something three dimensional that they cannot hold and experience with their senses? I do not believe it is possible.

For that reason, I have not nor will I ever ask for a critique of a photograph of one of my turnings. I also won't offer a critique of anyone else's turning online. I will, however, write that I like a piece Now, don't go thinking that I'm closed minded. I love to share what I am doing, and really appreciate it when someone says they like it, but I'm not looking for a critique. If I want a critique, I will enter the piece in an instant gallery, juried show, etc. where someone is going to really experience it. Then, if I'm really lucky, I might get a real critique.

This is what I believe. If you don't agree, that is your right.

keithz

Re: Critiques

#23

I disagree :)

Carole Valentine

>I think online critiques can be extremely helpful. I know they have been for me, especially when dealing with transitions, collars, finials and feet. With a decent photograph, you can see proportions and curves. True, you cannot feel the finish, look inside a hollow form or feel the weight and balance, but there are many other aspects that can be observed.

Re: Critiques

#24

how I do a critiqe and why I don't do it here

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I rarely post here and when I do it is often in reference to my background as a traditionally trained patternmaker. What I rarely mention is that I also have an MFA in spatial art and have taught 3-diminsional design at the university level.

When teaching 3-D the initial critiques are done mostly by myself until the students begin to learn a critical vocabulary. Just because they can make art does not mean they nessesarily know how to talk about it. The old saying " I don't know much about art, but I know what I like" translates to " I is stupid and I'm not afraid to use it" As the students begin to develope the skills and vocabulary for a critcal discourse I encorage and expect them to participate in the critiqes. I usually set the tone in the first critiqe by only using good exaples of what I am talking about and never poor examples. This is also similar to training an animal by only using positve reinforcement. Ultimately it is fater and easier that using a punishing model, which is best left to women with rulers and dressed in black. when looking at the work from the class as a whole it is easier to talk about the strong points that than when looking at one piece. there may not be one good piece in the room but most likely one can be made by talking about the component parts of several and in this way the students can learn from more than what is actully there in the room. Also, 3-D is an intro level course and some of the egos and confidence levels are shakey to start.

as far as critiqing here I have intentionally stayed away for several reasons. first is the chat room or forum medium and the lack of being able to see expressions and tone of voice. second is that there is often a lack of knowledge of the backgrounds, and expectations of both the critiqer and the critiqee. and lastly for me there is also a only a certian amount of free profesional advise I am willing to give and it is usually only in general terms. It is similar to the amount of free legal, medical, or profesional engeneering advise you see in these same forums. Like a lawer my expertise came at the expense of 7 years of college. Unlike a lawer the world if filled with amature artists. I view this as a good thing and encourage any person I meet to pursue any artistic endever and offer sugestins for training when asked. But unlike the Dr. I meet at a recent party who introduced himself as an amature wood worker I do not introduce myself as an amature neuro surgon. that last bit is a joke, see there's that tone of voice thing. I'm sure many will be offended by what I have written but it is precicely that which I am takling about. To give truely good instruction and critque one needs to be in person. What I have to offer was not gathered in a single or even a series of e-mails but over many years of intesive study. For those that are unfamilar with what an MFA is, it is the terminal degree in studio art and involves the same amount of time and similar process as an educational doctorate.

Robin Corell

Re: Critiques

#25

Re: IMHO

Russ Babbitt

>It's hard to believe but some turners do not belong to a club or have friends who are turners. Online may be there only availability of critique of any kind. Other than spouses or friends, but remember they like everything. Online critique may not be the best but we make do with what we have. Just like in our tools and skills.