Not blamed....credited, thanks
Russ Babbitt
>
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Not blamed....credited, thanks
Russ Babbitt
>
That really helps explain...
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>why people who have a strong "Art" background rarely do critiques here. I've always wondered why, and now I understand.
Re: how I do a critiqe and why I don't do it here
Ron in Drums PA
>Hi Robin
I too have an art degree. The main part of my business is design.
I think an important part that you missed is that the greater majority of the people on WC turn as a hobby. Yes, there are a few who are professionals and even some who may make a profit turning.
For the rest of us, to be able to steal away for a few hours a day (or a week) and turn for pleasure, is a great way to get away from the daily grind.
That is not to say that we do not want to get better at our hobby. Many of us do not have the privilege to study art full time. Most of us have jobs, business and most importantly, family that takes the greater part of our daily lives.
I can understand if you do not want to give away free professional advice. Remember, turning isn't rocket science, for most of us it is just a passion. Helping someone with design is a small way to help friends.
Re: I am astonished that Robin ....
Jamie Donaldson
>.. claims to have spent so much time in academia and didn't learn to spell? However, there is much relevance to some of his comments- here in cyberspace there is no way to ascertain the credentials of a poster, so we ought to have a sceptical view of commentary until the veracity of the source is known. So critiques are still worth what you pay for them! Consider the source.
Re: I am astonished that Robin ....
Ron in Drums PA
>Robin is the real deal
Why does this get debated to death?
Steve Antonucci
>Some people want a valid opinion (all opinions are valid...). If you ask what someone thinks, be prepared to hear it. If you can't stand the possibility that someone might have something "negative" to express, then don't ask for someone's opinion.
I don't care how long someone's been turning or what their level of machanical ability is- you can still make a butt ugly piece. Some people are blessed with a natural eye for form and some have to work at it. Some people have never turned a single thing- and guess what! They can still figure out ugly.
I think too many folks here suffer from ugly baby syndrome. If you have ever seen an ugly baby, you probably thought that saying it was a bad idea. If asked what you think, you'd lie like a politician before you say it. But woodworkers aren't asking for you to be so politically correct. They want the truth.
Steve
Father of 4 beautiful children and 14 out of 80 beautiful bowls...
Re: I am astonished that Robin ....
Russ Babbitt
>Spelling errors are probably keyboard problems. And yes we get what we pay for, but we all like something for nothing. If we had to pay for critiques or for the use of this forum, we probably would not be here. Hmmmm
Re: Why does this get debated to death?
keith tompkins
>Steve, It's true, we don't need a degree in music, or even know how to read music in order to know what music we like. We all drive cars, yet it's not necessary to be a mechanical engineer in order to select the model we like. You don't need a Master's degree to turn a nice bowl. The trick is to learn WHY we like what we do, and then apply the knowledge to our work. We ALL have some amount of artistic ability. Back to the topic.....consider almost every competition or exhibition bases their selections on IMAGES...slides or CD's. The judges can tell at least enough from these images to make their choices. Works for me.
Re: Time for the old gray guy
Allen Neighbors
>to step in, I suppose. :o)
"I is stupid, and I AIN'T afraid to use it." (No translation necessary, here.) I have no degree in art. I've never taken a course of study in art. In my opinion, I'm too danged old to enroll in one now. Besides, I'm too busy. :o) I'm not even a college graduate. But, I do use fairly decent grammer, I even try hard to use proper punctuation when I write, and I can spell words, so I'm going to do that, now. :o)
At this point in my retired life, I am a woodturner... probably not as well-experienced as most... but a woodturner, nevertheless. :o) I even sell a few pieces now and then for a little additional income.
I have posted numerous photographs of pieces I've turned, and asked for critiques. I have received some well done critiques. I have learned from them. Just looking at some of my earlier pieces confirms that last statement. :o)
For all of you who have critiqued my work, I thank you once again. I truly appreciate your taking the time to help me improve my hobby.
If I post a photo and ask for a critique, please, give me one... as well as you can, since you can't hold it in your hands. If you don't want to give me a critique, then please don't. It won't hurt my feelings. If you ask for a critique of one of your pieces, if I feel qualified, I will give you a critique as well as I know how. I will not allow pride in my personal accomplishments keep me from helping another. :o)
To say a critique is not a good critique, just because it's an online critique, is... in my most humble opinion... wrong.
Somebody, check his pulse... I believe this horse is dead. :o)
Re: Pay for the use of this forum?
Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)
>I'm paying for the use of this forum. There are expenses involved in keeping WC up and running, and I hope everyone will consider this and contribute something commensurate with the value you get from "being here". Al
I agree with your message 150%
Stephen Mushinski
>A couple of weeks ago on another board, someone asked for a hard critique. All posts were, oh my that is so wonderful. Stupid me looked at the turning and seen a balance problem. I wrote about how much I like the work, but with a tweak here and a tweak there, how a very nice piece turns into an outstanding piece IMHO. The response's were I do not see it, what are you talking about. Tried to explain what I meant. In person it would be easy but online it is much harder. I think the owner of the turning understood, but the response was one of I had no choice because of the piece of wood.
The key here, is it's only someones opinion. Maybe he/she/I do not have a clue about what they are talking about. I shy away from saying what I would do different to someone else work. Sometimes I forget that rule and offer up my thinking.
The very best learning experience I had with design and critique was in a demo by Jacques Vesery. Jacques took his own work over the years and talked about what worked and what did not. He talked about the thinking process of what he needed to change on each piece to make it more successful.
One other item I wish to touch on. It is so hard on a forum such as this for meaningful critiques as not everyone likes everything just as Keith as mentioned. I'll use Rap music as an example. I am sure most people on this board turn their noses up at Rap. Oh that is just crap most would say. Well that is just our opinion as we do not care for it. I doesn't mean that it is not great music. Same with the battle or banter if you wish, about pure classic turnings and turnings with paint, burnt marks and carvings. Maybe we just do not like what the person is doing therefore have a negative opinion to offer up.
The only person that matters is yourself and if you sell, the buyer. If you want a critique, you are the best person to do it. Look at your work and say to yourself, I really like this but what should I change to make it better. Set it aside for a week or two, raise it up high and look again and you will find the answers. You do not need an art degree to understand what you like and why you like it. You just need to ask yourself!
Re: Why does this get debated to death?
keith zimmerman, Normal, IL
>Remember Keith, there is a huge difference between looking at a two dimensional object (photograph, drawing, painting) and looking at a two dimensional representation of a three dimensional object (a photo of a sculpture, a bowl).
keithz
Re: IMHO
David Breth
>You struck a chord with me there. Family and friends like EVERYTHING. My wife gets upset with me as I am my own worst critic. Friends hold a piece then say "OK, go ahead, I know its killing you. Tell me what's wrong with it."
Last night I experimented, made a small box with a finial. My first finial, just wanted to appreciate some mechanics, etc., and used scrap wood to do it. put wax finish on it quickly just to get an idea of final look. Result looks like a round-topped trash can with a giant, terribly disporportionate giant evergreen tree growing out of its head. I mean, it is beyond awful, and I may post it for a humor-critique over the weekend. I showed it to my wife. "Its not bad. I like the shape of the box!"
I told my little girl she could have it for her doll if she wanted - I'll know later today. SHE'LL be BRUTALLY honest about whether she likes it or not!
Re: Why does this get debated to death?
Russ Fairfield
>Keith,
Yes, the jury and judges use a picture for selection, but they always reserve the to reject the piece when it doesn't live up to its "image".
Another reason that critiques are good:
Steve Antonucci
>There's an old adage for teachers: If one kid asked it, ten were thinking it. Some of us are "fearless" abot putting ourselves out there for the scrutiny of the masses. I sell for a living, and rejction and negativity are my middle name. Like water off of a ducks back, I roll with the tide. I don't take it personal, but I do listen to it. Hearing someone's else's point of view expands our own views.
If we become paralyzed by saying something nice to avoid hurting a turners feelings, we limit both of our abilities to grow. The turner will never get beyond a beginner because there is no one "brave" enough to voice their opinions. The reviewer will also suffer because of their self imposed censure.
If someone asks for help, I'm going to take them at their word that they actually WANT help. And for the other ten in the background who want help but won't ask, I hope you pick something up too...
Steve
Re: In other words, the only dumb....
Jamie Donaldson
>... question is the one you didn't ask!!!
Eggs Ackley
Steve Antonucci
>
Re: Critiques
Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.
>Hi Russ,
I did learn a lot on the chat critiques...I enjoyed the instant resposnes time wise on what people were saying, helped me to SEE better as it were.
I avoid a lot of posted critiques. If I have something to say I do it in an email where I feel the person recieveing it can also feel comfortable to respond. Despite what we feel about sharing, the internet is still a two dimentional process prone to mass mis-interpretations.
Take care,
Jim