Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Ron in Drums PA
>Suggestions would be appreciated
(prototype)

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Ron in Drums PA
>Suggestions would be appreciated
(prototype)

Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
david
>I like the relative simplicity of it (finial). Nothing wrong if a tall finial is what you are going for. Think it also would work with the long middle section of the finial removed, so that the top bulb element sits on the ogee curve of the beginning of the finial, making it essentially a short pick-up knob for the lid. Would like to try the 3-sided box bottom myself one day.
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
john lucas
>Pretty cool Ron. Ideally I'd like the base a little smaller so there,s more taper to the vessel and maybe a smaller detail on the top of the finial. It's just a litte too large for my taste. That's being picky however because I like it a lot.
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
tek-Brunswick, Ohio
>I think that the top shape of the finial should reflect the shape at the base of the finial. It should be more onion shaped with the curve flowing from convex to concave up to the point. Everything else I love. It is a beauty.
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
tek-Brunswick, Ohio
>I think that the top shape of the finial should reflect the shape at the base of the finial. It should be more onion shaped with the curve flowing from convex to concave up to the point. Everything else I love. It is a beauty.
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Frank of Mantua NJ
>That looks good as is. Try turnung a shorter plan top ?
Some times less is more.
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Mike Nelson
>Great looking box Ron!
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Bill Stehman
>Ron,
Beautiful box and a perfect fitting lid. The finial is perfect for an ornament but I can't put my finger on what is needed here... maybe shorter and more delicate ? Nice work.
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Brad Vietje
>Great looker, Ron ! I'm with John -- a little smaller diameter at the base might be even nicer. I like the finial as it is. Very nice design.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Ron in Drums PA
>Thanks for all the ideas
When this was still on the lathe it was a bit taller and the top was a bit wider. I kept on getting tear out on the three tips and I wanted a sharp edge. By the time I got it right the box looked to short with the base to heavy. But everyone is right, I need a smaller base.
My wife tells me I should have made a three sided, hersey hiss shaped finial. I haven't figured that one out yet. But it seems everyone so far are kind of saying the same thing.
Thanks again!
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Jorge Castaneda
>Ron,
To me the lower piece is just fine, the finial is too long.
Nice looking piece!
Jorge
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
john lucas
>Ron How about just a 3 sided reversed cone. The big end at the top. Then turn a small tenon on the bottom and glue it into the lower part of the finial.
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Ron in Drums PA
>I like that... back to the shop....
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
MIke from St. Clair Shores
>Ron,
Very nice triangle box. I like it alot. I have made about 30 of these type boxes, and I have found that my personal preference is to add a collar to the bow to elevate the finial. The picture I have posted should help clarify this.
Mike
Re: Still trying to figure this one one *Pic*
Bob Slocum
>I like it as-is! If I had to make a suggestion, I would add some type of transition element between the onion bulb shape in the bottom of the finial and the top of the finial.