Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

It was funny at first, but now

Posts

It was funny at first, but now

#1

It was funny at first, but now

David Breth

>It just ticks me off.

Say I mount a blank to the face place, turn it to the desired shape, leave a tenon or a recess, sand it, flip it to mount on a chuck (in my caes a Oneway Talon).

At this point, something bad frequently happens. I'm very careful to place the tenon/recess squarely in the chuck, but more often than not, when I get the lathe turned back on, I'm no longer spinning round. Sometimes I get a little wobble, sometimes a lot.

I'm assuming the problem is sourced from one or more of the following:

1) The end grain/side grain are being compressed at different rates by the chuck, and therefore I get a little wobble.

2) I'm using a soft wood - yeah, sometimes, but last night it was hard maple, and it was pretty hard and the same thing happened.

3) I'm using a tenon or recess that is a little small for the piece (or the chuck).

4) Sometimes it might not be wobble, but could be that the side grain sanded more than the end grain when I was mounted to the faceplate, and it gives the appearance of wobble. That's more a question than a statement.

I'm also assuming I'm not the only turner in the world who was ever frustrated by this (after all, you go to all that trouble to make it round and smooth and everything nice, and then....). I'm hoping somebody can help me understand the cause of this problem, and can suggest ways to overcome it.

Thanks -

David B.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#2

Re: It was funny at first, but now

Walt Drummond - Middlesex, NJ

>Are you turning wet wood? If so, just the heat of sanding can give it a little warp.

When turning a tenon, is the shoulder flat and is the tenon short enough that it doesn't bottom out in the jaws? The shoulder should sit on the tips of the jaws, and the end of the tenon should not sit on the bottom. I usually use a tenon length of less than half an inch. The all important part is the point where the piece ends and the tenon starts. This should be square and flat.

If using a recess, be sure that it is undercut. I usually undercut it about 15 degrees.

If the piece is large, try to mount the chuck before you put it on the lathe. Hard to hold a heavy piece with one hand and tighten the chuck with the other.

Sometimes I'll mount the wood and just tighten the chuck until it's snug, then try spinning it by hand. If there's some wobble, I can loosen and try reseating it without having deep jaw marks to overcome.

One thing else to look at. Be sure that the chuck spins onto the lathe until it is seated against the shoulder of the head stock. Might try a FLAT washer if not.

Hope this helps.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#3

I've had that problem too...

KurtK in Indy

>What I do now is rough turn that blank on the faceplate and immediately get a tenon. I then turn that thing around and turn it on the tenon and get the final shape and sand. The problem often times is that the piece is not perfectly flat on the face plate, but when you turn it, the thing spins into round on an uneven surface. When you flip it around, since the faceplate didn't have a true flat face, the tenon will be true to the face plate but not necessarily to the center of the piece....does that make sense??

All I know is that I never finish turn on the faceplate if using a chuck. And I always need to true it back up after making the turn around. Sounds crazy and confusing (I don't know how to technically explain it) but if you try that, I think you'll have much more success.

My .02

Kurt

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#4

Re: It was funny at first, but now

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>David,

I usually never flip a bowl around and have no sign of wobble. Very rarely is it dead on. So I've learned to not sand through my finishing grits when it's in the faceplate position. Then when I turn it around, I take a very light finishing cut to true it up again. Start from rim down to as far as you can go towards the chuck. Sometimes all it takes is a shearing cut to get it back to running true. Then I hollow the bowl and go through all my sanding grits on both the inside and out. When I'm finished here, I then flip it around again using a jam chuck to clean up and finish up the foot and any area I couldn't get to while it was in the chuck.

Jennifer

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#5

SOP

Ron in Drums PA

>Almost always you will have to true up the outside when fliping a bowl around.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#6

Re: SOP

David Breth

>Thanks very much for all of these responses. I appreciate that help a great deal. Probably won't get in the shop to try them out tonight, since I'll be walking the neighborhood with little ones while my wife gives out cheap insurance to the other kids, but these suggestions will be next to me on the bench next bowl.

Thanks -

David B.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#7

Had the same problem w/ profiled/serrated Jaws

Devon Palmer

>So, I went to the smooth/dovetail jaws on my oneway. I give the center a coupla light raps with a deadblow as I'm tightening to seat the Jaws and TAA DAA - zero wobble, even with my stronghold and an 18inch bowl. (I DO wish the face of the dove jaws were a bit wider tho for more support.)

I've heard other turners with similar complaints on remounting w/ profiled/serrated jaws. Still love my profiled jaws tho, I think they hold a "little" better when roughing out green wood - plus the tenon size isn't as critical as it is with the dovetails.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#8

Oh, and.....

Devon Palmer

>If you happen to be using a nylon washer between your chuck and spindle, throw that sucker out - those things are evil and will cause vibration. Ask me how I know :)

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#9

Re: It was funny at first, but now

adrien

>One thing to add to Walt's excellent dissertation: you might, instead of making the shoulder 90� to the spigot, make that angle a little more acute, so that the EDGE of the shoulder seats against the chuck jaws and not the entire shoulder. I use an angled scraper to do that.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#10

Re: Oh, and.....

David Breth

>I do have a metal washer that at some point I ceased using with the chuck - my memory tells me I had a problem even earlier on in my illustrious turning career, when I would stop the lathe and the chuck would unscrew itself from the lathe (rather rapidly). And in retrospect, I'll bet this is at least a contributing factor.

Still - I've printed out all the tips, and will shovel a hole clear on my workbench to put them.

David B.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#11

Re: It was funny at first, but now *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>Oneway makes an adapter for their live center to allow you to mount your chuck. You can then attach the chuck to your work while it is still mounted to the spindle and use the tailstock to help align everything.

I have neve used one, but it may help. Maybe you could buy one and try then tell me if its worth the investment. :-)

Here is a link


Live center adapter

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#12

Re: I've had that problem too...

Fog Tanner

>The tenon is going to be true to the axis of the headstock, regardless of the angle of the faceplate. I use eccentric chucks where I intentionally put the piece offcenter from and at an angle to the axis. The foot/tenon is still square to the axis, while the rest of the piece may not be. The outside of the bowl will be concentric with the foot as with any bowl. When reversed on the tenion it is now concentric with the line that it establishes.

For a normal bowl, the tenon will still be concentric with the outside regardless of the angle its mounted on the faceplate. The rim may be uneven but gets trued when you reverse it.

A bigger problem is not uing the correct size jaws for the tenon being turned. The normal #2 jaws an a large tennon provieds a smaller amount of contact and the wood is more prone to crushing and allowing movement. It really doesn't take a lot of force to chuck some pieces. Enough to hold it but not enough to crush the wood. If you watch Raffin using is stepped jaws, he is only chucking into jaws which are 3/16" deep.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#13

Re: It was funny at first, but now

Bill Howatt

>It might help but the real advantage to mounting the chuck on the live center is for positioning the work onto a vacuum or donut chuck. I also would not want to rely on something that could be causing the blank not to be held against the shoulder of the jaws all the way around the chuck.

I use the standard serrated jaws on my Stronghold and Talon chuck all the time and I don't consider the wobble to be significant at all. Sometimes it looks perfect and sometimes it certainly is detectable but nothing that I would consider the least bit troublesome.

Bill

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#14

Have tried the tailstock adapter

david

>on some pieces where I use the adapter to mount a chuck so that I have a chuck and tenon on both ends of the piece. If spinning, the speed should be very slow just to determine if any eccentricity exists. That being said, I have on occasion turned the piece around to mount on the headstock only, and it was still not true. Sometimes you just can't win...

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#15

Re: To tight.

Duane C.Leach

>Some turners I have seen useing a scrol chuck will crank the jaws down to hard. Some have tightened so much they broke the tennon off. That much of a bite is not needed.

Try this experiment. Rough out a bowl and when mounting it in a scrool chuck just barly ttighten the jaws. See just how little pressure on the jaws will hold the blank secure.

Happy turning

Duane

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#16

Re: It was funny at first, but now

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Well, this is a good news, bad news discussion for me. Good news is I thought my having a similar problem was due to something I was doing all wrong. Nice to find out others share a similar plight at times and the suggestions were some of the things I've been doing. Bad news is I was figuring it might be a good enough reason to start hinting a new lathe was a reasonable solution to the problem. Oh well.

Bob Way

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#17

Re: It was funny at first, but now

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>I almost never use a faceplate.

Try starting between centers. It is easier, faster and allows movement of the work piece to allow for better grain allignment.

I use the large 4 prong drive. Be sure to keep the work tight and lock the tail live center.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#18

Brad Vietje

Re: Had the same problem w/ profiled/serrated Jaws

Brad Vietje

>I found this to be true also. Dovetailed jaws will hold very well IF the tenon is properly shaped, and there are fewer problems with the bowl being out of true when reversed.

I also agree with Jen and Dominic that it's pretty standard, and Duane's comment about it possibly being too tight, especially with softer woods.

Here are three more ideas:

1. When you are roughing the outside profile, look at the balance of the figure -- the symmetry of the pattern of growth rings. Generally, more symmetry leads to better balance, and the jaws are more likely to compress the wood fibers roughly the same. Beware of one or two jaws gripping sapwood, while the others grip heartwood -- see above -- recipe for wobble.

2. Spalting or degrade: keep in mind that any degrade of the wood will soften it, sometimes in a patchy way. Last night I reversed a partly spalted White Ash bowl, and had the same problem with uneven compression, as two jaws were gripping spalted wood, while two gripped harder wood. I fussed with it a bit, and trued up the outside as Jen suggested, before hollowing the inside; this will be a lesser problem after the wood is dry and I finish turn it.

3 Be sure your tenon isn't too long -- don't allow the jaws to bottom out, but make sure the TOPS of the jaws are firmly seated against a FLAT shoulder around your tenon.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#19

Re: It was funny at first, but now

robo hippy

>One of the best feelings in turning is seeing a long ribbon of shavings come off a piece that you are turning. Next to that is reverse mounting a bowl, and having it be true, with little or no runout. I don't know that I have ever taken something out of the chuck and remounted it so that it runs perfectly true. I have gotten a lot better than I was. Perhaps the biggest step I took to improve here was when cutting the recess, the plunge cut with a dedicated dove tail scraper, isn't made by plunging straight in, and then cutting sideways to make the dovetail. You plunge in at the angle of the dovetail. I also will let the tool stay at the bottom of the cut with almost no pressure removing micro shavings. This helps to take out some of the bump that comes from cutting across the grains. When remounting , I like the jaws of the chuck to straddle the end grain (the gap in the jaws lines up with the long grain). I don't have the curved part of the jaw on the long grain. Some times you can rotate the blank 90 or 180 degrees and get it to center better, but most of the time not. The tinyiest piece of dust or shavings in the recess, can make a big difference also.

robo hippy

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#20

Re: Just for laughs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>To illustrate Brad's comment see the attached.

The example on the left, long tenon, bottomed out in the jaws, will just about guaranty wobble. The example on the right will (almost) never wobble when reversed unless the tenon is poorly cut. Note too that on the right the flat rims of the jaws, are firmly set on the bottom of the blank to get proper registration, and then the clamping surface of the jaws (serrated or dovetail) merely hold the piece in place, thus preserving that registration. This way you can use much less clamping pressure (as suggested) to hold the piece. If, however you don't cut that registration flat for the rim of the jaws to be true tto the tenon, it's nearly impossible (and pure luck) to reset the piece and not have to recut the outside profile after reversing.

Second point not mentioned is to use as wide a tenon as your chuck will grip. Trying to hold an 8" dia. bowl on a 1-1/2" tenon is gonna get you all kinds of wobble and vibration if not a split tenon and launched bowl. Beginners trying to use every bit of the wood will skimp on the tenon. If you don't want to "lose" part of your blank to the tenon, glue on a waste block that you can part off later. Remember, it's only wood; it does grow on trees.


img

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#21

Re: Just for laughs

Bob Fawcett

>I was told that picture on the right is correct way.

I was also told to use a tenon about 1/3 the largest diameter of the bowl if possible.

I was also told to use a tenon sized to fit the jaws. Most jaws are turned to some diameter, then cut into 4 peices. The tenon should match the turned diameter of the jaws as close as possible since this is the "most round" setting for those jaws. You may be able to open 2" jaws to 4", but the jaws will only grip at 8 points.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#22

Re: Just for laughs

David Breth

>Thanks for the continued suggestions. Every time I think I've heard all there is on the topic, somebody else chips in with some great nuances.

Hoping to get into the shop tonight, and will be implementing new (to me) methods for sure.

David B.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#23

Re: Inches

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Bob,

A 1/3 dia tenon is usually fine for solid wood. If, however, you're working with spalted or stock with voids, cracks, or other infirmaties, bigger (wider) is better.

I may be misunderstanding your comment, but if the tenon were to match the diameter of the jaws as you describe, there will be next to no grip on the tenon. If, say, the jaws, when fully closed, form a 2" circle on their inside diameter, you will need a tenon with a larger diameter for them to grip at all. So, regardless of whether the tenon is 2-1/4" or 4-3/4", the jaws' points will always be the primary griping points. This is part of the reason that what I called the "registration flat" is so important to properly hold the blank for hollowing the reversed bowl. This is also why Oneway's No. 2 jaws have those internal serrations which act to contact and grip the tenon before the end-points make contact; a good design feature.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#24

Re: Inches

Bob Fawcett

>Mark,

When manufacturing a set of jaws, they are turned as one solid piece that is some diameter, lets say 2". They are then cut apart with a cutting tool of some type. Lets say it was a saw and the kerf was 1/8". There is now a 1/8" gap between the jaws when they reform that 2" circle, so they are not fully closed yet. If your tenon is 2" the jaws will reform that 2" circle and grip the tenon best.

This may be impractical in application.

Re: It was funny at first, but now

#25

Re: Inches

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I certainly understand the concept, Bob.

I just went into the shop and mic'd my large Vic jaws when fully closed and when opened by about 1/8". They form a precise inside diameter of 4.150" at all points when tightly closed. Opened to a 1/8" gap between the jaw plates, the middle of the jaws' arcs were right at 4.25", but the 8 points were each a smidge less than 4.21" apart. From that I must conclude that the only time they make a precise circle is when they're fully closed. Maybe Vicmarc makes their jaws differently.

Your point on practicality is right on. Who in his right mind would have 20 different chucks/jaw sets sitting around just so he could use tenons of different sizes, and why make the chucks that scroll out so much of they shouldn't be used that way?

Peace |;-}}