Re: Inches
Bob Fawcett
>I certainly don't want to buy 30 sets of jaws :-).
Do what works.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Inches
Bob Fawcett
>I certainly don't want to buy 30 sets of jaws :-).
Do what works.
Re: Regardless of what diameter tenon you use,
Al Crandall (NE of Indy)
>Regardless of what diameter tenon you use, the profile jaws of a Oneway brand chuck will only hit the tenon in 8 places. Fully opened or fully closed, the 8 lobes machined in the jaws will be the only contact with the tenon diameter. Same grip any way you turn. Great holding power imho.
Re: Regardless of what diameter tenon you use,
David Breth
>Turned a small piece of sassafrass last night (thank you Mike Cunningham), using a tenon. Made the tenon about as big as I could,took note of many tips above. Result worked out ok, in spite of the tenon snapping as a result of a mild catch. The wood is very dry, and must have had a weak spot there, but enough of the tenon survived to sally forth.
Ultimately, the results were pretty good. I wasn't as interested in design/shape as I was in technique/method, and to that extent it was a definite success.
Thanks once again to all!
David B.
Re: Putting It To Good Use
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>It's always nice to get feedback that the advice given helped with the particular question or problem posed. Thanks for letting us know of your progress!
Re: Regardless of what diameter tenon you use,
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>I'll bet it smelled real nice in the shop too! I'm not much for turning sassafrass, but I love working with it for flat work.
Bill
Re: Inches --- Hmmmmm....
Brad Vietje
>Well, Mark makes some good points, and I thank him for the diagram, but I firmly believe the chuck jaws will actually have the best grip when the tenon diameter is just a bit larger than the smallest size the jaws will handle. Bob's right that they then have maximum contact with the wood. I have also been led to believe that the flat surface the tops of the jaws seat against is where a lot of the stability comes from.
However...
This depends on a few other things, too. Mark's certainly correct that too small a tenon might be insufficient for the mass of the bowl and the cutting forces involved. Thus, even if the tenon is held in the jaws as securely as possible, that does no good when the bowl has sheared off and flown across the shop. Those clever folks at Oneway thought about this when designing their profiled jaws, which are rounded on the corners, and shaped to have 8 wide areas of contact instead of 8 points. They can be opened well beyond their minimum diameter and still hold real well. They also hold square tenons better than many jaws. Pure dovetail jaws, like Oneway's "smooth jaws" only hold at 8 discrete points when opened too far beyond their minimum size, which I think gives pretty poor holding power. They work best at diameters nearest their least -- if that makes sense. Nova and Vicmarc jaws I've used are pretty similar (though the Nova 50mm jaws are only dovetailed at the tips, not all the way to the base). I'll also throw out there that problems caused by compression of the wood fibers are at their worst when the jaws are opened up to their maximum diameter, since those 8 points can really dig in (and not always evenly at that).
It also won't work to make a tenon close to the minimum size with fresh cut green wood if we intend to re-mount it after it dries; there just won't be enough wood to grip after the tenon is trued up.
SO, IMHO, there's basically a compromise to everything. I tend to use tenons that are about as small as I can for a given set of jaws, allowing for wood shrinkage and re-mounting later. For bigger bowls, I use bigger jaws, and thus a larger tenon (though changing jaws can be a pain). For really hard or tough woods, smaller tenons will hold, while for soft wood like Basswood, Cedar or Boxelder, a bigger tenon may be needed. I have three sizes of jaws for my Stronghold and for my Supernova, plus a few odd sets of more specialized jaws. I'm in no hurry to buy any others, so I also do like Mark suggests, and open 'em up when needed.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Regardless of what diameter tenon you use,
David Breth
>It has been two or three days and the basement still smells of it. Great scent. Puts me in mind of the spice trade in the 1400-1600's.