Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

A rising level ...... of indifference?

Posts

A rising level ...... of indifference?

#1

A rising level ...... of indifference?

Rick Davenport

>I've been posting on this forum for about 6 months now, but I still consider myself an outsider newbie.

From this vantage point I have made an observation.

For example:

John Vitosky posted some pics of his very first tries at woodturning.

There were 520 views and one comment (from me, and I hardly consider my opinion to be very valuable).

Jim King posted pics of some outstanding work. 310 views and no comments so far.

To say they didn't ask for comments is a cop out.

They wouldn't post if they didn't want recognition, encouragement or constructive criticism.

I've heard that the WOW website is a bit snobbish, but I have never been there.

Is WoodCentral now leaning in that direction too?

I hope not.

This site has provided me with lots of information and inspiration.

I hope it continues to do so for anyone and everyone who participates.

I'll get off my whiney soapbox now.

Rick

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#2

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Rick,

I think you have somewhat of a point. I feel that I am also a newbie and that this site has helped me immensely, often just by lurking and reading and trying to learn. I hope that the more I post the more I will feel accepted, but there is a breakthru period and there are about 20 members that always respond to each others postings because they have all been around so long and have gotten to know each other. Since summer is almost over, I'm looking forward to more post with pics than there have been for the last few months. I also know that when I have posted a pic I get few responses. I have patience and hope that as I post more I will in time become more recognized. I want to be a good WC contributor.

Mike

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Don't mean to lean

Ellis Walentine

>I hear your concern, Rick, and you're welcome to open that subject for discussion. Though I am an avid turner, I can't be in here every day, so I may not have my finger on the pulse of the turning forum to the extent that you do. I've observed over the years that discussions have a life of their own. The number of views reflects the willingness of visitors to share in someone's work and to respond if they feel inclined or particularly if they are invited by the poster to do so.

When someone like John posts a photo of a variety of small bowls, no doubt he is pleased with his output, and normally a lot of people would weigh in with words of encouragement. To an extent, whether you consider yourself to be a regular or a newbie here on the forum, it is fair to expect folks to say something when you post a picture. For whatever reason, though, it doesn't always happen. Sometimes, the photo is too small or of poor quality, so the pieces aren't displayed to advantage. It's hard to comment if you can't really see the form or the scale or the level of finish, so I suspect a lot of people chose the better part of valor, rather than praise the work for the sake of praising it.

Whether we like it or not, superior work always gets more comments (gotta watch that word "always":-), because it inspires people. We're naturally inclined to be thoughtful and spportive of those less experienced or less skilled than ourselves, but sometimes it's hard to come up with the kind of praise that person would like to have. With the high number of posts on this forum, it's natural for me to assume that people are picking and choosing their responses carefully.

I hope I'm right.

Cheers,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#4

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Bill Crommett

>Another thing : For a newbie to post a pic of his work, it takes a bit of a stretch and he needs to get some encouragement. So he is encouraged ! When Jim King post a pic of some of his beautiful exotic works, we all know that he has a long history of turning great woods and that part of his motivation (only a PART) has to do with the comercial aspects of his business. Those who follow this part of the forum know that I do not often have anything to say about the posted pics. This is because by the time I get to see the pics there have been ten to twenty replys already, and any more redundancy would be futile -- unless I was narcicistic enough to enjoy seeing my name in print .

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#5

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Rick, This is an interesting subject. I used to post pictures of some of my work on the WOW site and ask for them to be critiqued. I was disappointed in the number of responses that I got so I stopped posting pictures. However I am active on the site in regard to asking questions and responding to other post of pictures and or questions that I feel that I can answer. I am also active on this site regard same. There are lots of posts that I dont respond to simply because there are others that can give a better response. Some guys are on many sites posting lots of pictures and respond to many posts with their advice. They are very accomplished and expierenced turners and normally give excellent advice.

I dont know if my rambling has helped but sit back and relax. Turning and learning is what these sites are all about.

Good luck,

Norm

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#6

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

John Lucas

>Some days you look at work and feel like commenting. some days you just look at the work and enjoy it without commenting. Doesn't mean anything other than you simply may not have anything to say that day.

It's still fun to see someones work because we get to watch you grow in your skills. If you never post anything then we don't get to enjoy watching you grow.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#7

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Rick Davenport

>I want you all to know that I am not upset or angry.

I simply made an observation and decided to put it out there for all to see.

Occasionally, we all need to have our noses tweaked to get our attention.

Consider me a tweaker.

Speaking for myself - people can either love me or hate me, it's indifference that makes me crazy.

And one thing I will guarantee - you will always know where I stand.

Which is why I do not play poker for money.

Rick

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#8

Consider This...

Ron McKinley

>Rick: I felt the same as you until I reviewed my own reading habits. I always read the posts by the recognized experts first. I don't miss a post or response by John Lucas, Ken Grunke, Brad Vietje, Bill Grumbine and many others. If I feel I have anything to add to a thread I'll post but usually someone else already has it well covered so I just read, listen and learn........Ron

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#9

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Ron in Drums PA

>Rick, your message seems to pop up again now and again. I've been on WC for three years and I felt the same way when I first started turning. At first, I thought it was something about me folks on WC didn't like.

Later I realized most folks on this site are like myself, stealing time away from work to glance at what's going on in the turning world. Sometimes I have the time to comment, sometimes all I have time for is a quick peek.

WC is like sitting by the fire with a good book and someone you care about is sitting right next to you. The both of you enjoy each other's company and you don't always feel to converse.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#10

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I think John and Ellis have brought up some good points. They reflect a lot of my posting habits. Sometimes a post is just going to get overlooked. I never have felt that WOW or WoodCentral were snobbish.

It is a good subject to bring up and to discuss.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#11

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Jim Rutten

>Great analogy, Ron.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#12

Re: And I don't see any.....

JamieDonaldson

>.....relevance in counting responses like counting votes pro/con as an evaluation of your work? There is little to be gained by withdrawing from the posting parade- we like to see what everyone else is doing, but are not always going to post repetitive comments when the point has already been made. I don't sense any snobbery on WOW either- the level of some work there can be intimidating for some posters, but that should serve as a resource for self examination and improving your output, not as a put-down for beginners. You cannot strive for excellence if you don't know what it is!!??

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#13

What Jamie said!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Jamie said " You cannot strive for excellence if you don't know what it is!!?? "

Boy, that is the truth! I tried to make that point on another forum with limited success.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Rick, I think you have a valid concern. As moderator, I try to make it a point to make newbies feel welcome, especially if they are posting their first photos. I know how intimidating it can be!

Sometimes I cannot catch them all....my daughter is expecting any day now, and I am leaving for N.C. as I write this for a week.

The number of hits is a good indicator of interest that has been generated...500 hits is excellent, even without comments. Many, including myself at times, hesitate to comment on a newbie's pieces, as we dont know them yet, and don't want to upset them with a critique that's taken as negative.

I think you will find, overall, that most people here are more than willing to help!

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#15

Re: What Jamie said!

Ken Oakley- Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Some famous Dead Poet once said "A Man's reach should exceed his grasp, for what are the Heavens for?" ( I think it was Robert Browning)

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#16

Re: Don't mean to lean

bob davis

>i understand you ,rick..when i first discovered wood central i posted a few photos of what i thought would beinteresting pieces.no comments..it does seem yhose few are only interedted in each others work.wood central is a great site ,,i have received several goodieas and help.from others.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#17

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

bob davis

>you are correct there.. i am amazed at the volume of help offered. for instanc i am forever grateful to john lucas for his work to develop a slower speed for the jet mini

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#18

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

david

>Rick:

The last two lines of your post says it best for me: I log on to this site at least twice a day, and to me the benefit is the informaton and inspiration I get from the posts. To me, the pics are a bonus. If it interests me, fine. If I don't particularly care for the piece on display, I move on. No sense posting a negative, and no need to jump on any bandwagon if there are a lot of posts. If a comment solicited, I often ask myself: Is there something I can contribute? Can I answer the question and help someone to give back for all the times when a question was answered for me--just by my lurking. Often I just don't have anything relavent to contribute.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#19

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Carole Valentine

>If I particularly like a piece, I say so. Otherwise, I now "try" to keep my mouth shut. (Yeah, I know - it'll be a cold day...) I have recently learned the hard way that with some people, when they ask for comments, they really mean only positive comments - not a combination of positive and constructive comments. I have also been told (not on WC or WoW) that as someone who has been turning for such a short time, I am quick to "parrot" what I "have only heard or read elsewhere." Guess I'm too stupid to have my own opinion or my own sense of form. At any rate, unless I know the person, I will be doing more looking than commenting on pictures of other's work.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#20

JL

Re: One thing to consider - sheer volume..

JL

>as the posts slowly scroll down the screen. Depends on how you set your preferences.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#21

Self critique helps

Stuart Johnson

>A photo with a message that just says: "Some nice firewood.. what do you think?" might not get a lot of response. If you go on to talk about what aspects you think make it look good, what detracts and what you think could be done better and then ask for opinions you will probably have more comments.

I have never asked a question on this site without receiving many answers.

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#22

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Lan Brady

>Rick,

I cannot add anything contructive that you have not already seen. But I have a question for you Or anyone. How do you know how many times a post has been viewed?

Thanks, Lan

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#23

Steven Antonucci

Happens all the time...

steve antonucci

>And not just to new WC'ers or new turners.

I've decided that it's just how things are. Somedays, you'll hit a nerve or strike a chord that everyone jumps in on, and other days, you could be running down the street naked and no one would care.

If you decide that you want critique, be prepared for "ugly baby" syndrome. I still have some ugly babies from my early days layin' round to remind me that we all start this way. It's not personal, but it might just be true.

Post your picture again. Let's see who steps up.

Steve

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#24

Brad Vietje

Re: A rising level ...... sorry, a little long

Brad Vietje

>Great question... and a delicate one.

I read through a bunch of replies, and had a hard time deciding where to add my 2 cents. I agree with what Ellis, John and Barbara are expressing, and also what Jamie writes below (the way I see the posts). I have not seen any evidence of snobbery here, and I think what some people perceive as snobbery at WoW's is a high standard of quality in both the turned work and the photography.

I make quite a few encouraging replies, especially to posts from beginners, but sometimes I steal a quick peak at a few interesting posts when I'm waiting for a call back, or when I really should be doing something else ! I often find I'm running late, and figure I'll add a comment later -- and sometimes life prevents that "later" from coming true. Other days, I'll make 10 or 12 comments, and start to feel like I'm posting too much.

I also agree with Jamie Donaldson that the number of views is no measure of anything other than confirming a popular topic, or the three letters "pic", which always get quite a few looks. Unfortunately, some really provocative and excellent questions are asked, or points made, which don't get as many views because they don't have an attached picture, so it goes both ways.

I think its just the luck of timing, but bouncing off Keith's comment, I feel more comfortable commenting on a newbie post if they invite it, or if I have some sense of who they are and how open they are to constructive comments. I sometimes write "Atta go" or "nice job", but without a few more details, these can fall a bit flat, too. I think it could be perceived as snobbery or maybe patroniziation for me to just presume that a newbie wants or needs my advice and/or bias without being asked for it.

I think one approach would be to for WC veterans thank a newcomer to the forum for posting a photo, and asking a few questions of them to get some dialog going. I remember very well what my first bowl and first hollow form looked like (of course I kept them), and how much pride someone has in completing their first (or fifth) bowl, peppermill or chair leg, and compliment them on the work they've done and invite them to come back often.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

#25

Re: A rising level ...... of indifference?

Don Henthorn

>Look right after the title. Views means the number of lookers.