Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Apologies to David Chung :((

Posts

Apologies to David Chung :((

#1

Apologies to David Chung :((

Carole Valentine

>I can't believe I did this!!!! I had been meticulous about checking thickness with the calipers. I got a phone call, then went back to turning forgetting that I had removed wood since the last thickness check. Arrrgh! This was going to be a such a pretty little vessel. :(( It was a crotch piece of Koa that David sent me for Valentine's day. You can't see it in the pic but it had some fabulous figure. I am just sick. How many years of turning does it take to outgrow doing stupid stuff???


img

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#2

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Sorry about your loss... it's tough to loose a special piece of wood.

I don't know how you hollow such a small turning, it's amazing.

We're all human... if it was easy it wouldn't be fun.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#3

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

john lucas

>Carole must take longer than I've been turning because I still do stupid things. Bet my neighbors wonder what's going on when all the good language comes out of the shop.

You just get better at either saving damaged vessels or you tell yourself that your good enough to do a better piece. Of course you know that you can't because the wood is gone but it does make you feel better.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#4

Been there, done that...

David

>I am sure there is more where that piece came from. As I recall, there was another piece of wood in that flat rate box...I am sure you will do justice by that piece of wood, Carol--I have faith in you.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#5

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

Mac

>Carole, I think you went just a bit beyond the design opportunity stage with this one.......

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#6

I done it also!

Jake Niedling

>Carole - I did the same thing just a week ago with a nice piece of spalted maple. That last finishing cut on the inside, right thru the sidewall below the curve. If I could just eliminate that last finish cut. In this case it finished the turning as well.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#7

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>Now you know what happens when you violate the first rule of hollow forms: "keep the inside smaller than the outside". And then bro. Murphy gets into the act and sees that it happens to the nicest piece of wood in your shop........

That's why some of us less talented turners have resorted to the captured tool system with a laser to determine wall thickness.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#8

Steven Antonucci

Know that feeling all too well-

steve antonucci

>I spent the weekend at David Ellsworth's, and even he couldn't help me!

I cut through 4 or 5 vessels this weekend with a "mostly uniform wall thickness" of 1/8". The last one hurt the most...

Steve

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#9

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

George Van in WI

>We don't want to know how many years :-)

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#10

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>What a shame, indeed!

I found out yesterday what this is when I turned so thin near the base of my first natural edged ash bowl that light shone thru, its so thin I cant believe it held together. I blamed it on my glasses fogging up under my visor but in reality, I think I just got too aggresive and was too engrossed in "hogging out" the center.

At least now I am in good company?

Regards,

Wayne

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#11

Re: Been there done it too

OB OBrien In Pensacola

>Don't feel too bad Carole. I did it during my hollowing demo at the Gathering. Had a choice piece of wood I was going to pierce. Was just finishing up the inside. Got to talking to someone watching and went right through the bottom. It was real embarrassing, let alone during the demo.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#12

A Wise Man OnceTold Me..

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Carole,

I remember well once when I was a kid, I loved to build model cars. My father encouraged me a lot. I used to get frustrated sometimes, bad paint job, glue in the wrong places and so on (I know this does not apply to you in turning).

He sat me down and said to me that if I wanted to get better at what I was doing I had to appreciate the feelings of what it was like to Not Accomplish what I wanted so that when I indeed Did Accomplish the results I wanted the feelings would be that much sweeter�.and so were the lessons of that journey.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#13

4 or 5?????

Carole Valentine

>Steve!

You need help, man! LOL If I cut through 4 or 5 in one weekend, I think the next thing to be mounted on the lathe would be my head!;)

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#14

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

bob davis

>maybe after 100 years

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#15

Dick Hines

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

Dick Hines

>How you are learning how to turn hollow forms. Wait until you cut through the back while useing the laser. That reall makes you feel stupid.

Hollow turning is like they say about bonsai, "If you don't kill some you are not doing bonsai."

Good luck on the next piece.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#16

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ouch, sorry Carole....

I feel your pain :(

Jen

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#17

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

Raymond Overman in SC

>Carole,

I always find that this type of thing happens with the last cut I make on some of my hollow form. I've decided to stop one short of the last cut from now on. Hopefully this will solve my problem and might help you with yours.

It happens to the best, and not so best, of us Carole. Don't fret and hurry up and post the next block turned masterpiece from the pile.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#18

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

HarryB

>Carol,

I believe this is what Bill Grumbine calles "negative" wall thickness. Probably doesn't make you feel any better but we have all done this and most of us more than once. But the next one will be better.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#19

Steven Antonucci

It may have been 6...

steve antonucci

>I lost count to tell you the truth.

One of the other class participants was in the line of fire for a tall mulberry pot that hit him in the shoulder. Luckily, the 6" section of pot that hit him probably only weighed 2 ozs... He didn't even realize what happened.

I did turn a mini to completion just to make sure I finished one :-)

Steve

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#20

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

Ed Karch

>"Wait until you cut through the back while useing the laser. That reall makes you feel stupid." Yep did it last week.

Re: Apologies to David Chung :((

#21

Re: A Wise Man OnceTold Me..

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>You have learned well, Grasshopper!