Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

A case FOR "plagiarism"

Posts

A case FOR "plagiarism"

#1

A case FOR "plagiarism"

RussFairfield

>I just read through all of the recent discussion on "plagiarism" on this forum and a similar thread on the WOW site. Besides noticing that half of those commenting about it didn't know how to spell the word, I also discovered that I have a contrary view of this topic.

This my argument from the "other side" of the plagiarism issue.

My first problem is that we are telling everybody that it is OK to copy the classical forms of ceramics, glass, and other mediums. This is telling everybody to look at the same forms that I did, but don't copy them into wood, because I got there first.

This is also telling them that we have to go to the other media because there are no "classical" forms in woodturning. I think this is a very myopic view of woodturning as an art form. It ignores that there are such things as the Ellsworth vase, the Jordan pot, the Osolnik candlestick, the Michaelsen hat, and the list goes on. We have been looking at these forms for almost 20 years (that I know of) in the AAW and other magazines, and in galleries, and they are always presented to us as being the ultimate in the art of woodturning. Haven't these forms transcended the individual who originally made them and haven't they become the "classical" forms of woodturning? It seems to me that they are. As such, it follows that anyone who aspires to being a woodturner would want to copy them, just as we are telling them to copy the classical forms of other media. It seems to me that these forms have risen to a level that is above ownership by an individual. Those whose name is associated with them should be honored that this has happened. Yet, all they are doing is complaining about it. Is their complaint not that this has happened, but that they didn't get paid for it?

It all gets down to what this AAW stuff, the classes, the teaching, and the Symposiums is all about. Is it about people having fun at woodturning; or is it all about selling stuff??

If it is about having fun at turning things from wood, then there is nothing wrong with someone copying a "classic" turned wood form, just as there is nothing wrong with copying similar forms from other media. Everyone likes to achieve some level of acclaim among their peers, and we can't all be another famous woodturner in the making. The closest that many of us will ever get to fame is having someone at our woodturning club refer to ours as an "(fill in the name) form". I see nothing wrong with that. When that happens, I take it as compliment that I have done something.

If this is all about selling stuff, then it is all about the money, and we have all suffered the loss for it having come down to that.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#2

Both

T Daniel

>It is about money and it is about good forms, no matter where the form came from. I said earlier and I say it again: There are no forms that have not been made before. It gets down to how an artist works the particular piece of wood in hand. Aligning the grain, choosing the right finish, sanding to perfection, even wall thickness, good flowing curves, shadow lines when appropriate, balance, etc. All these are the makings of a famous turner, not just the shape. We get hung up on shape; craftsmanship is being ignored. The AAW mag is a good example; when have you seen skill emphasized instead of enhancements? How many of us know what a fair curve is? How many of us know when and how to use shadow lines? My opinion is the only thing that might be plagerized is enhancements. I don't worry if my bowl has the same shape as someone else's bowl, nor do I worry if someone else's bowl has the shape of mine.

TD

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#3

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Gary Ljostad

>Russ I agree with everything you said. All forms should be fair game. The problem comes when the copying goes beyond form. When someone turns a beautiful hollow form then adds puzzle piece outlines, that getting too close to Art Listman's signature style, or carved and prismacoloring a maple leaf design on a plate or bowl, ala Andi Wolfe, ect. There are many world class turners that have devoloped a signature style, John Jordon, J Paul Fennell, Pam Reilly Stephen Hatcher, ect..... and that style should be respected. Nothing wrong with a newbe learning by coping, but these pieces should not be passed of as there own designs. I don't think any one can take credit for inventing a form, it's what is done to that form that makes it there own. Just my two cents.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#4

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Ron in Drums PA

>As always, you are right.

Could not have said it better myself.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#5

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

RussFairfield

>I think that everything I have said about forms will equally apply to enhancement styles. Is the "Wolfe leaf" or the "Vessery feather", or any other technique so "original" that it is taboo to everyone else?? Some of these enhancements may be new to woodturning, but they are not "new". Woodcarvers have been using them for years. If we are going to copy techniques from other art forms, do we have to worry about who got there first to copy them?? I am not taking anything away from the folks who make these thing. But, I am wondering if some of these enhancements haven't also risen to above being proprietary to any individual??

I am also wondering where all of this is going to end. I saw a segmented bowl at the museum at Sauder Village in Ohio last year. It was made in 1923, and it looks just like almost everything that I see as segmented art today. Does that mean I should stop making them? Or should I be required to give credit to the original author? Or, is it only the living that I have to worry about because I am getting into the income??

How far back do we have to go?? Every time I have posted a photo on this forum, there is somebody who points out that this nothing new because they saw the same thing in a 1937 issue of some magazine.

Does all of this mean that I have to sit on my hands and do nothing (something that I do very well) for fear that I might be copying something that somebody else has done??? Or, does that only mean that I shouldn't be showing it anybody?? Is there a clearinghouse somewhere where I can check that something I want to do hasn't been done before?

In the end, this is much ado about nothing. It doesn't really matter. I sell the segmented bowls at what I think is a good price, and the folks with the money didn't bother to ask whose idea it was. The fact that I made it was good enough for them.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#6

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Gary Ljostad

>Points well taken. As always you gave me much to think about. Thanks

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#7

So Very Well Said!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#8

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>I have stayed out of this argument up until now. Haven't even read most of it. But reading Russ's post made me want to say "YES!"

Everything we do has been done before, in one way or another. If we are never to copy anyone else, then we might as well sell our lathes and get out of turning.

Thank you Russ, for saying what I have felt on this subject!

Scott.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#9

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Dick Anderson

>I recently saw a hollowform in a craft fair that looked like it had been made by Wally Dickerman. I had to turn it over to see the signiture to be sure it wasn't one of Wally's. Is that fair to Wally?

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#10

Thanks Russ

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>I agree 100%. A few weeks ago I tried to make the same point, your version is much more articulate.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#11

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Rick Allen

>See a vase you like

Chance a copy of that vase?

Make shavings and smile!

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#12

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Don Tewell

>After reading more than one thread on this subject, I'm not sure I should take up something else as a hobby. Since I'm fairly new at turning (February 2005) does this mean that I can't make a bowl or hollow form or candle stick that doesn't look like someones else's? I don't think that's possible. Being in photography we are concerned about copywrite issues. The main issue being you can't take credit for something I did. However, you can take the style or technique I use and make it your own. I think the plagiarism issue here is, I can't take something someone else made and claim it as mine, but I should be able to use the techniques (if you will share them with me) and style that you have perfected and start from there on my own. I will have to admit with this web site (as in photography) that most of use are more than willing to share our knowledge and expertise with others. Sorry for the rambling but after I got started I had trouble stopping. Just my $.02 worth.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Keith Tompkins

>HI Russ, and all, Thumbing through the latest American Craft mag, I see pottery forms strangely familiar to what are being produced by some big name turners. Leaves and feathers, whatever. We all try to mimic things that are familiar and comforting to us. Nothing wrong with that.

I've done lots of demos showing how to turn suspended pieces...pieces where the "bowl" doesn't touch the ground, and the piece is suspended by four legs. I started making those in "protest" to what was considered good form for a turned bowl....size of the foot and all that. One of them even made it into "500 wood Bowls".

Now I see these things popping up everywhere, in fact; I was asked to critique a whole roomful of them after a previous demo. Was I the first turner to produce one of these forms? NO, I don't think so. I was, however; making those before I realized others were doing the same thing. Vic Wood from Australia did similar pieces, but not hollow forms or lidded boxes like mine.

Do I feel people are copying me..No, not at all. In fact, my demo included ideas about form and design, and I encouraged people to give these things a try. I like to think I may have inspired a few people to think a bit differently.

I never considered these my "signature" work, so I didn't get emotionally attached to them. Now, the hard part. I spent many years trying to figure out some of my pieces, such as the rose. Lots of trial and error, pieces I finished that never saw the light of day. Destroyed, and then start over. Much of that time arguably, could have been better spent with my wife and family. There were no plans, demos, videos, etc., to show how to make one of these. I worked on technique and form until I felt I got it right....not to mention the thirty years experience that I relied on.

Now, I had put a bit of myself into these pieces. Looking at the rose pieces, you might get the idea that I was a gardener...you might have an image of me cutting a beautiful bouquet for my wife. You would be right on both counts. Roses from my garden decorated many evening dinners and my daughter's wedding as well. A few special rose bushes are from my sister's garden.

I have a piece I made after the death of my sister....I won't tell you which one. I didn't deal too well with her passing, and still cannot bring myself to think about it. The piece I produced shows the way I really feel inside,and speaks of something I cannot express in words.

Someone can copy one of these pieces, but they cannot hope to capture the meaning or feeling behind them. They mean something to me personally. It's funny, many people seeing these pieces say they have an emotional quality to them......would I be upset to see someone copying these and then attempting to sell them? Yeah, I probably would. I am only human, after all.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#14

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Amen Brother Russ! Preach it! While I think that people are deserving of the recognition they get for their level of skill and artistic ability, to claim ownership of shapes, etc, is over the line. As a wise man once said, there is nothing new under the sun.

Bill

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#15

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Keith, you make some very good observations. There is an emotional component to all of this, of course, and we do what we do for a whole list of reasons. Others may try to copy what we have done, but they will never put the same feeling or perspective into it. We are all different.

My attitude is that if people don't want it copied, there is not a lot they can do about it, beyond refusing to share techniques and processes. Back in the old days when I was making pens and boxes, I became fairly well known for both in some circles. I had people from all over the country wanting me to either make boxes to sell to them (at competitive prices with the Chinese imports) or show them my entire process for turning them out quickly and with good quality. I refused on both counts. They were mine, and while I knew that others could copy them with just a little bit of work, I was not going to hand them to anyone, because they were part of my bread and butter. I would offer to sell them one or two at retail, and let them have at it, but I did not divulge the things I had learned about the manufacturing process.

I think the same thing holds true for anything else in the turning world. If someone doesn't want their work copied, at the very least they should not be taking money for books, videos, demos, and classes. I think Russ is dead on on this one, and he has summed up things very nicely.

Bill

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#16

Re: It's More Than Spelling, Russ

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>People don't seem to understand the basic concept.

I can make as many "Wolf style" leaves or "Vesery feathers" or "Ellsworth inverse necks" or wooden cowboy hats as I want. I can even sell'em for whatever I can get, so long as I don't try to pass them off as Ellsworth, Wolf, Vesery, or Johannson pieces, and so long as I give some acknowledgement to the artist I'm emulating/copying/[ripping off] (including Mr. Stetson?), just as I might reference John Lennon for the phrase "love is all you need" or Professor Hart for "Virile Virgin." Plagiarising is not counterfeiting, it is using a portion of another's work as part of your own without giving due credit to the originator. It is the primary capitol crime of the academic world that prides itself on original contributions to knowledge.

Now, if Andi could patent the "process" she uses to make her leaf carvings, she could sue me for infringement of her proprietary rights if I duplicated not just the leaves, but also how she makes them. Since people have been carving and painting multicolored leaves on stuff for many thousands of years, she will get nowhere trying to restrict others from doing so. Likewise, if I made exact duplicates of Jacque's items, feathers and gilding and all, and tried to sell them as original Vesery pieces, he'd be well within his rights to come after me with his chainsaw, figuratively speaking, for stealing his copyrighted designs AND for FRAUD for using his name. He cannot, however, prevent me from carving feathers on a bowl, and I'm sure he wouldn't bother to even try. David informed me in one of his classes that he quit doing craft shows years ago because he got tired of seeing everyone trying to sell copies of his stuff.

While all of these examples involve copying the other person's work product, the only thing they have in common with plagiarism is that they are basically DISHONEST. What's the punishment for plagiarism? Expulsion from school, naturally.

Will those who continually make copies of Ellsworth spheres and pots be able to sell them? Maybe, some. For David's prices? Ah, Mr. Barnum's rule notwithstanding, No. Will they gain stature and professional acceptance in the worlds of Woodturning or Art? Never.

What, if anything will those "unmitigated copiers" ever get? They will get to be very good technical turners or carvers; they'd have to be to be able to make the copies. But they will also place themselves in neat little dead-end boxes wrapped in plain brown paper with tags that read "No Talent", "No Originality", and "Little or No Integrity". Why? Because they advertise to one and all that all they will ever be able to do is try to play catch-up.

The clear message that came out in the KC Panel discussion was "Copy all you want to learn how to turn and carve and burn and paint. Then go out and create something new with what you learned."

Why anyone should get upset about that is way beyond me.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: It's More Than Spelling, Russ

Keith Tompkins

>Mark, you mention people copying David's work. Maybe we should put ourselves in the place of those who are being copied...

What would YOU (hypothetical) do if you created a masterpiece design...a stroke of genius, once in a lifetime.... and somebody copied it? Claimed it as their own design, and attempted to market it as such? I bet many of those who feel it's ok to plagiarize would change their tune if it happened to them.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#18

Re: It's More Than Spelling, Russ

John in Kerrville TX

>Whenever I see these kind of discussions I think of Sam Maloof. Look at the number of people who have copied his signature rocker. Several even sell kits or plans and virtually none of them even bother to give him credit. Some even take to calling it the "_____" rocker inserting their own name.

Sam has been very gracious about it, but also has been quoted as saying he does wonder why they sell plans and add their name to it.

john

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#19

Re: It's More Than Spelling, Russ

John Lucas

>Mark You stated what I've been trying to say clearer than I ever could. I don't mind copying work. You learn a great deal by copying work. make what you want and give it away. It does bother me when you copy work and then try to sell it. Now I'm not talking about just making a hollow vessel that happens to look like someone elses. I'm talking about making a vessel that exactly matches that person's style and then trying to pass it off as your own. I think this hurts everyone. Make all the bowls vessels, jars, boxes,whatever but make them your own. Add your touch, your emotions, and your technique. That's what makes a piece special.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#20

Remember, Highlander,

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"There can be only one." (Screen writer unknown)

That, or course, would be the first one. The Progenitor. The Thompkins Original. Do you doubt that any number of people will attempt to copy your Niche Award piece? And if they make bunches of them, are they doing anything more (or less) than arguing for, even confirming their own lack of talent and ability? How many exact copies of that piece have You made? I'm betting not one. I'm also betting that you've taken your creativity and ability and moved on. That piece is done, that challenge met. Why would you do it over and over, like so many end tables, when there are so many permutations and developments waiting to be discovered and done? [like working on that base |;-}} ]

Keith, you don't think you're the first to combine counter-rotating spiral forms in a composition, do you? Looked at much Chinese Art lately? Look up the gold work of the Scythians (3000 to about 100 BC).

I could be wrong, but I don't think you're going to attempt to block others from making roses in the material of their choice. If you try, you're gonna get into a real fight with the silk flower folks, not to mention the porcelain artists.

Personally, I've seen what you've done, but the real excitement lays in what you're going to do next.

|;-}}

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#21

Why is No One copying My Work?

Barry Irby

>Maybe it won't be worthy until I stop copying the Masters. All of my best ideas were stolen by the Ancients.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#22

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Russ,

I like the way you said it.

I used to teach photography in Continuing Ed programs in Toronto. The same issue came up in that medium, but it was back in the 1910-20's when it had it's hay day of intial growth. In keeping with your comments many people made influencing photographs/works and were "copied". People today still try to copy the greats like Weston and Adams...but that does not diminish the works or the past or those of the present day, they all are wonderful in their own way. In "copying" a style or work you as the artisan/craftsman also add your own emotional interpretation as Keith said...and that can not be copied by my understanding.

I believe what ever the meduim of expression the art or function of the work is best expressed by the viewer and the response the craftman recieves back in comments.

But...no one makes pens like mine eh Russ (wink, smile)!!

;-)

Well said..

take care,

Jim

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#23

Steven Antonucci

Those Ancients and their darn time travel!

steve antonucci

>I know the feeling- I had an idea for eBay in 1983 and Google in 1984... just never got the press.

Steve

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: Remember, Highlander,

Keith Tompkins

>Dammittall, Mark! Why do you understand me better than I understand myself!?

No, I haven't made any copies....but..I have some neat things in the works. After all, why copy something I've already done, when I have a book full of sketches that are even better? I hope I can pull just a few of them off.

Spirals? Chinese, you say? Oh. My bad! :)

I realize people will copy my work....it's already happening.I spoke with David at length about it; your post pretty much covered it. All I can do is keep far enough ahead that they can't see my taillights...hope I don't run out of fuel.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#25

Re: Remember, Highlander,

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Mark,

I really admire the way you are able to articulate your thoughts in your two previous post. You have somehow delved into my mind and transformed my deepest introspectives on this ongoing diatribe into the words that I have not been able to pen. Thank You.

I feel as if a great log has been lifted.

Mike