Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

A case FOR "plagiarism"

Posts

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#26

Re: That Log

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Quick, Mike,

If it's that heavy, it may still be good to turn! Get the chainsaw gassed and get some blanks cut!

If my ramblings helped you, it's taken Me a while to figure out how to phrase what I wanted to say, and Russ's original post was, perhaps, the right catalyst that helped me get there. I've seen way too many discussions on this topic where people of good will have become quite angry and polarized over what I suspect were mere semantic misunderstandings.

Peace

M

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#27

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Scott Hogsten

>Russ I like the way you said this. I think it's great that we can have these discussions without them degrading into flame wars, kudos to everyone.

I would like to toss out a few thoughts

-I feel that "wood art" is on the cusp of really taking off. Many people out there are laying some solid foundations for the future.

-I think some of the current pieces being seen as "Art" may be looked at historically as perfecting the "Craft"

-Artists need to realize that they can't be stagnant they must continue to advance their "Art"

-Artists must realize that it's more their name and the process of creating the art that they produce that define them and their value to the community. The piece of Art in and of itself is less important than the process and it's inputs (for example influences, interpretation, etc).

-Folks need to worry less about plagiarism and copying and start worrying more about creating art

-Question: If an "Artist" does not grow and continues to make the same excatly pieces does it become craft ?

-Have we begun to explore design because we are starting to reach and explore the boundaries of the craft of woodturning ?

Scott Hogsten

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#28

Re: Tail Lights?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>More like "Eat My Dust" (with the mold and fungi spores mixed in).

I don't know you better, I'm just handy for reminding you that you know yourself better than you let on.

|;-}}}

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#29

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Earl Eyre

>Russ, you said it all. Thanks. Just for the record, the Miriam-Webster dictionary says that to plagiarize is to "present as new and original an idea or product derived from an existing source." The way I interpret that is that if I see an Andi leaf bowl, reproduce the same thing, the same way and say "look at this. I just invented this process." That's plagiarism. If I take her idea and produce my own leaves and make no claims to it being an original idea, that's not plagiarism. Maybe my work isn't original, but there is nothing wrong with doing it.

Earl

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#30

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Fog Tanner

>Last year, about this time, my daughter and I went to the Dead Sea Scrolls exhibit. In one of the display cases, there were some examples of the items from that area, a number of pottery bowls and several turned wooden bowls. The bowls were dark from age, but well preserved. They were probably used by the same people that worked on the scrolls. The shapes were ones which can be found at any woodturning club meeting, and similar to the pottery that was in the case. The Egyptians had wood lathes 2000 years before that, so the shapes were not new at that time. Wonder if they had discussions on who "owned" the shape or who was claiming it as their own.

As noted, there are no new shapes, and there were undoubtably carved, painted, and inlaid wooden pieces that date back to that time. Any shape that could be explored was, the good the bad and the ugly. How else do you know what is good unless you make the ugly. And given that shapes originally came from pottery, that pushes the original shapes back five thousand years or more. And if one looks at the shapes we find pleasing today, they will also be found in the Ancient Egyptian designs. And when you study the Egyptian paintings, the lines that are thought to be pleasing to the eye are reflected in their portrail of the human form. The same pleasing curves flowing to the foot of a bowl can be found in various parts of the anatomy. So the original inspiration for those classic lines most likely came from an artisan observing and Egyptian pricess strolling along the Nile, and "borrowed" her lines, same as we do today- except its Galveston beach instead of the Nile. Gives a new meaning to the search for the perfect bowl, but makes one remember where it all began and no one on this rock can lay claim to the human form.

I think a lot of the "art" of wood turning is lost in the obsession of the end result. The true art lies in getting to the end. In painting, the "old masters" are praised as much for thier brush work and use of lighting and colors as they are for the finished work, in some cases more. Any painter can paint the same scene, but what seperates them is the use of the brush, subtile changes in color and light. For some it was the journey that was the true quest, DaVinci never finished the Mona Lisa and it was still a work in progress at his death.

A true musician works on a piece a note at a time, concentrating on the moment and not the past. It is that collection that makes the song, but how they are executed that makes the art. So too in woodturning, a number of steps or cuts to arrive at a given shape. A shape which may be five thousand years old and been made countless times, but the true art was in the making. Anyone can rough piece of wood into a shape and sand it into submission, but how many can create the form without the aid of the 80 grit gouge. While Raffan had some pieces in galleires, his true art form came in watching him made the piece. The speed and skill with which he used the tools tended to render the final shape of little rememberance, the real art was getting there.

In the late 60's and during the 70's there was a term "the Art of data processing", whcih referred to programming. There were a number of us "starving artists", although it was a small number back then. We created programs and traded them, there was exchange of knowledge technique that is now gone. The art was in the creating of the program, not such much the end result. A number of programs had no tangelable results, manpulating control blocks in the operating system. No one claimed a program as his own, as they were really collective efforts based on a broadbase of knowledge. And what one person started would become a communal work over time. The pride was being the first or making some significant change. What you would create or discover would be passed on to later caretakers, whilke you went on to the next thing. Today, its called intellectual property and owned by some company and you can't use it for fear of suits unless you pay a fee. Today, there are still the same number of artist as there were back in 1970, but we are not starving anymore. I have seen a number of wannabes over the years, and always find it amusing. We both have the same computer time and the same collection of ones and zeros, but who can have the best journey that keeps the mind active and in sense keeps one young. The money aspect is meaningless and really doesn't enter in to, those that do will never last nor produce anything of value. I look at woodturning the same, we all have the same wood available, its who has the best journey not who is the current caretaker of that five thousnad year old Egyptian shape....

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#31

The art is in the wood.....

T Daniel

>We can give a piece of wood a shape or form but unless we go the route of carving, piercing, painting, etc. to have a piece that is interesting we must first find the piece of wood that has the character needed and then manipulate that piece to display the character in the best way. To me this is the true art of woodturning. A craftsman can make any form; an artist can make a form come to life. If the wood has the art in it and the turner reads that art and displays it properly it will be a lasting piece rather than a piece from an "era"; timeless art rather than a fad. I wonder how many of the "enhancements" being used today will be considered a fad 20 years from now? If the art is in the wood then how can anyone copy that?

TD

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#32

How Do You Spell "Duh"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My reference to "Johannson" actually should have been "Johannes" as connected to "Michelson". Sorry, Johannes, if I'm gonna "use" your name I should, at least, spell it correctly.

|;-{

M

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#33

Are we missing the point again?

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>As has been stated before,being the first to be recognized for a particular piece is an accomplishment in itself.This is not to say that the same piece hasn`t been done in exactly the same material somewhere in history.There may even be a hobbiest who has taken on and mastered the same challenge in the here and now but because he doesn`t seek recognition it doesn`t become his "signature piece".If you get to the press before he does does that mean he has to stop making them?

All this to-do about copying and then selling a recognized piece or series misses one important point.The person ripping off the pieces has the TECHNIQUE down or they wouldn`t be able to copy the work.They just don`t understand enough about design to come up with an original idea that works.What these folks need is a better understanding of design and a good dose of creativity to take them to the next level.

Sure,there are always afew out there who will buy plans(or attend demo`s) and then produce copies with the only intent being the cash,are we going to let those few occupy a large part of our time with debate they will never read nevermind heed?

More and more I hear people say "It sold,so it must be OK".If that`s the case then we have in fact reached the point where the "Bottom line is the dollar sign" and that is not art folks,it`s commercialism.From what I`ve seen commercialism is one of the killers of growth and progress in real artists.

Mainely,Bob

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#34

Re: How Do You Spell "Duh"

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>I believe there are two Hs in Duhh.;^)

MB

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#35

Re: The art is in the wood.....

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Are you saying the wood "speaks to you"? Or that it must "Reveal it`s true intentions" before you can "Realize the wood`s one true purpose"?

I will add "The art is in the wood" to the list and try to remember to bring it out when you least expect it TD.

If I forget I`m sure Mac will remind me.:^)

MB

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#36

Re: Why is No One copying My Work?

Jim King

>I think someone should immediatly get a note out to all tire makers advising them to stop production until we find and get the OK from the inventor of the wheel. God forbid he didnt make it on a lathe, it could then really get complicated..

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#37

motivation?

T Daniel

>The price a piece brings usually says something about the quality, the originality, or the salesmanship of the person doing the selling; many times it is the latter.

TD

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#38

listen carefully.....

T Daniel

>My hearing is not too good.....I have never heard a piece of wood say a darn thing but I keep listening. Being able to see what is in a piece of wood and bring the best out of it is the mark of an artist; it is what separates an artist from a craftsman. I think 2 pieces of nearly identical wood could be given to two turners, one a craftsman and one an artist, and allow them to turn it and the results would prove who was the artist. Not enough credit is given to the artists that excel in reading the wood and making beautiful pieces without adding a lot of enhancements. I don't think we are listening to the buyers. I see a lot of imbalance in what the AAW mag is pushing us toward. From the mag you would think that there is no market for well turned pieces without enhancements. I do not find that to be the case. Tell Mac I said so :)

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#39

Re: Rude said..."the bowl....

JamieDonaldson

>....is in the tree, all you do is set it free!" I don't think the AAW and Journal can be said to be "pushing" anything- the term "leading" is a better fit.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#40

Jamie, by example......

T Daniel

>If we go to the AAW mag for inspiration what do we see? Have you seen any emphasis on pieces that excel without enhancements? Perhaps I missed them.

TD

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#41

Re: Talk About Rip-Offs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The statement about the finished piece already being in the block of material was first attributed to a guy by the name of Buonarroti who did most of his breathing during the first half of the 16th century. It has been "adopted" as their original thought (with a few word or syntax changes) by any number of artists in the intervening 500 years. The gent was an Italian stone cutter who worked in Florence and Rome, and said that all he was doing was removing the waste stone from around the piece that was already sitting inside the block.

Of course, some here may know him better as

MICHELANGELO

Now, I think we were talking about using other peoples' ideas, and words, without giving them the proper recognition . . . .

|;-}}

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#42

Re: Example.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Winter issue: page 51, Bill Luce's "Naked Ash"; page 52, Bob Stocksdale's "Mesquite Burl Bowl"

Fall issue: Jim Rind's article "Mission Accomplished"

Maybe even Lancaster's article on burl bowls even though he put beads on the outside?

Your right, though, Terry, in that the Journal doesn't make bowl-turning one of it's major focuses. Question is, in as multi-faceted activity (or art-form) as is woodturning, should it make any area a primary focus or is that, perhaps, better handled in small focus groups with discussion leaders [read Local Chapters with Terry Daniels doing demos]?

|;-}}

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#43

Re: Example.

John Lucas

>How boring would the magazine be with nothing but bowls. In fact Woodturning Design is following a similar course to American Woodturner in that there are a lot of enhaned pieces. It's quite simple. That's what everyone wants to see. If you go to a Symposium a demo on plain bowl turning will not have as many people as the bowl class with enhancements. Don't get me wrong I love a good bowl. I just turned one of the best ones I ever made. it didn't have any enhancements, the shape is great. However if you lay it next to a nicely done piece that has some sort of enhancement 9 out of 10 people will like the second one. Not necessarily to eat salad out of but just watch them pick them up and you will see.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#44

and here I thought that...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>... that thought was first expressed by a pre-historic shaman to explain the origin of his/her (history is a bit fuzzy here so it's probably best to be politcally correct) latest fertility figurine. Loosely translated:

"The great mother spirit Mommygoo created it, all I did was wash the mud off."

BTW, great discussion.

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#45

Re: Shaman

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Brian,

Sometime I'll get to tell you about how the Rain Dance was discovered, oh so many many moons ago.

|;-}}}}

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#46

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

Scott Hogsten

>Keith you said something very important in your response. A lot of what art is in my opinion is not what it is or looks like but how it got there. When an artists puts a piece of his or herself into a piece it comes through and it is there for all to see. Sometimes this difference is easy to spot sometimes it's a subtle combination of factors but I think most all succesful art has this. The piece get's some emotion or soul incorporated into it. Recently I looked at some pieces that a very good turner though not well known was making as production pieces and this person also had a couple of signature pieces. Even though the work was similar the signature pieces definitely had something the production pieces did not. Perhaps is was the care put into the piece, maybe a little extra sanding, maybe the carving was crisper, but it was there.

Scott Hogsten

Re: A case FOR "plagiarism"

#47

Keith Tompkins

Re: The art is in the wood.....

Keith Tompkins

>AHA! I worked as both a craftsman and an artist..as a craftsman, I would search for the perfect piece of wood...no knots, defects or weaknesses. As an artist, quite the opposite.I would look for and accentuate the same defects.

Like Terry said, give thirty turners the same piece of wood...the results would be drastically different. On average, most would be mediocre pieces. Only one or two would show an understanding of form or would use the character of the wood to their advantage.

I don't think it's a big mystery....some turners understand how to bring out the best in a piece of wood. In artsy language, it's called emphasis...WHERE to locate that special characteristic to really make a piece POP.

Why few plain turned bowls in the aaw mag? I think part of the problem is there are not that many well turned bowls out there. I see Bill Luce's work everywhere, and they are about as unadorned as turnings can get. He has the ability to nail the for consistantly. I met Bill in Providence, where David Ellsworth highly praised his work....I also suspect that many great turners fail to capitalize on the opportunity to promote their work.

I know when I see a wonderful "pure" form, say at a symposium, I am drawn to it....I would love to see them in print. Do you turn great pure forms? When was the last time you sent images to the AAW for publication? Why not? It takes some publicity work to get your work published. There are several here who produce pieces worthy of publication....many of whom have never been heard of....yet