Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

giving credit to others

Posts

Re: giving credit to others

#51

Re: Turning Anything

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Mark, it seems to me that you could fill a fairly large dictionary with new words coined in the past few years in this age of technology. When D. Ellsworth started turning his hollow forms in the 70's another new term was added to the rest. I believe that it's two words, not one. It is rather descriptive.

Wally

Re: giving credit to others

#52

Re: giving credit to others

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>This thread has been remarkable. A lot of diverse opinions from knowlegeable craftspeople, without degenerating into something destructive.

That being said, my own two cents, as a beginner.

Everytime I turn on the lathe, I guess I am copying. Not plagarizing, but copying, because as soon as I create a shape, I have copied something done previously. As someone said earlier, there are no new shapes. IF I ever develop the skills that would allow me to copy EXACTLY what someone else had done, and tried to pass if off as my own, then I would be guilty, in the legal sense, of plagarism. It would also be idiotic as well as boring. When turning, I am trying to create a specific shape, be it bowl, vessel, hollowform (there's that $3.50 word!) or whatever. But I don't even find it interesting unless I can add something of my own to it.

Does that mean I cannot put leaves on the outside of a bowl or vessel, or use pyrography or texturing because someone else thought of it first? I think not. But I could certainly see the value and wisdom of giving credit for the inspiration, if the design came anywhere near close to someone else's.

I am sure that in the future, should I advance to that stage, that I will make and sell something that was influenced by someone, somewhere.

Some examples: Ford, Chevy, Dodge, etc...the idea originated with someone, but you don't see anything on the widow sticker saying

"Credit to ????? for the inspiration in manufacturing this vehicle."

The original pen turner? The original bowl turner?

I would never try to pass someone else's work off as my own, but my own work will always be influenced by something or someone, even as I add my own "originalities."

Best part of this site is that it really makes you think!!

Thanks to all!!

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: giving credit to others

#53

Re: giving credit to others-Thanks agian

Lan Brady

>TO Everyone,

Thanks again to everyone that took time from their schedule to post a response. I hope beginners, (myself and others) have learned from this. To me this has been a great outpouring of wisdom. Many of us agree to disagree and it sure is great that no ones opinion is put out, but accepted as their point of view.

I feel challenged to use everyones teachings, but to create something that they themselves will want to copy someday.

Thanks to all my Woodcentral friends, Lan

Re: giving credit to others

#54

Re: giving credit to others

Ron in Drums PA

>I can answer who was the first...

Either Bill Grumbine or Russ Fairfield :D

Re: giving credit to others

#55

Re: giving credit to others

Ron in Drums PA

>John you are absolutely correct.

This has been one of the best threads I've read in a while

Re: giving credit to others

#56

I remember reading...

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>An article about how people in Japan were printing up T-shirts with one word or two in english on them and selling them to the public who had no idea what the words meant but felt they looked stylish on the shirts.Some of them were quite profane and would get you a black eye at least if not arrested if worn in parts of this country.

Mainely,Bob-Who once got arrested in Texas for the t-shirt I wore.At least I knew what it meant.

Re: giving credit to others

#57

Re: Words

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Of course it is descriptive, Wally, because, among other things, "jar" and "bottle" connote a certain, if not primary, function of "utility." I seriously doubt that anyone would consider actually using David's forms, or yours, to store stuff. Neither of you are making storage jars, nor are you seeking to compete with Tupperware[tm] and Zip-loc[tm] on Wal-Mart's shelves. But too often language can take on a life of its own [Keith, don't get me started on titles!], and ordinary people can loose the ability to relate to artists' products because they have become "Objects D'Art" and their creators, somehow, don't think they need vent fans in their bathrooms anymore.

So, if we're going to invent new terms for what we do, I suggest we remain considerate not of just of fellow turners, nor collectors nor art history types, but of the Great Hoi Polloi, and consider not just how the term will be undersood, but how it and we who use it will be regarded because we use it. Any art that raises a barrier, however low or thin, between it (and its artists) and the society in which it/they live will be destined to be marginalized or replaced by something more vibrant.

M

Re: giving credit to others

#58

forgery

JKJ in East TN

>>Unless a turner or other, actually attempts

>forgery by way of a signature or otherwise

>misleading people into believing an object

>was made by someone else...

How about mistaken identity? A turner friend of mine joked that all I'd have to do was put my own name on my turnings, keep my mouth shut, and I could make a fortune. Ha! (I didn't even know what he was talking about at the time.) I wonder how many woodturners in Tennessee are named John Jordan.

JKJ, the real John Jordan, but not that one

Re: giving credit to others

#59

Excellent summation

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>This is the same thing I hear from most of the "famous" folks up my way.

The idea is to get you to look at the lathe as a tool to help bring an idea to life.To expand the way you think about how turning and what comes after can be expanded for you.

Most folks who see what Jacques Vesery or Steve Gleasner do and how they do it go away thinking "Wow that`s a really involved and time consuming process" and they`re glad that folks like that are committed enough to go thru it because it opens up some doors for the rest of us to take a bit of thier hard won lessons off in another direction.

I have yet to hear of any nationally(or internationally) known turner complaining about how a student of thiers took what they learned from them to the next level.Art Liestman credits his time with Jacques with giving him the push he needed to become a well known turner.Funny,his work looks nothing like Jacques,well maybe the collars a little bit.;^)

Mike Hosaluk even encourages you to take some of the many things he comes up with and try them out with the intent to "Run with the idea" as he just has too much in his head to develope all of it.The post asking about the laminated box that led to Mike Schwing posting pics of a natural edge version of the same type of work by that maker set off a lightbulb for me as I immediately recognised it as a dirivative of Hans Wiesflog`s(sp) "Drunken boxs".Plagurism,hell no!an excellent example of taking a design basis and running with it.I believe Hans said something about being taught the basics for the boxes during his apprenticeship and that some of the masters were none too happy he was sharing it.I wonder why.

One of the down sides of having a "signature" line of pieces is that you may find it hard to break out of that style and still be able to sell your work.Everyone brings up Ellsworth`s name so I`ll use him as an example of someone who struggled to have work other that his sinature hollow forms accepted at first.

The point is that these well known folks go out of thier way to nurture the craft that has meant so much to them,many time at a loss to them both financially and time spent with thier families and friends.

Many of us don`t understand that the sharing that takes place in the turning world is absent in alot of other crafts.We take it for granted that it`s the same everywhere and I`m here to tell you that aint so.Even if you pay money to see the "secrets" of how a thing is done it doesn`t give you the right to abuse the gift you`ve generously been given and directly copy the objects for profit.

I`ve run on far longer than needed to say basicly what Keith said but I wanted you all to know this is important not only to the famous but also to the rest of us who may not be well known but love the craft.

Mainely,Bob

Re: giving credit to others

#60

You may be on to something

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Do you suppose the Shakers went into financial decline because everybody was ripping off thier stuff?

MB

Re: giving credit to others

#61

Keep "Running," Bob

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You're Doing just fine!

|;-}}

M

Re: giving credit to others

#62

Re: Quality wins, always!

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>On the other hand those who DON`T know quality mostly base thier purchases on the "pretty wood" factor.I think those of us who are committed to the craft need to educate folks on what is quality and what isn`t and most importantly how to recognise it.

It does none of us good to have someone show a less than quality product to a person savy about wood art and have that informed source tell them they were taken.

Mainely,Bob

Re: giving credit to others

#63

Caveat Emptor!

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>

Re: giving credit to others

#64

Keith Tompkins

Re: You may be on to something

Keith Tompkins

>Yes, added to the fact that they didn't replace workers as they passed away...unfortunately, no hanky-panky, no new workers. LOL

Re: giving credit to others

#65

Keith Tompkins

Re: A Rose?

Keith Tompkins

>I tried Mark, I tried. My stuff will never compare with the real thing! Yes, I think I know what you mean...I think!!O NO..I was copying the BIG GUY!! that's not good.......

Re: giving credit to others

#66

No ventilation fans in the bathroom eh?

TD

>Can I use that line? That is g-o-o-d....!

TD

Re: giving credit to others

#67

Re: Sure!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I haven't copywritten it

(yet)

|;-}}}}

Re: giving credit to others

#68

Asian Tattoos

Stuart Johnson

>"Some of them were quite profane and would get you a black eye at least if not arrested if worn in parts of this country."

I've often wondered about some of the tattoos one sees with the asian symbols. Do they mean "wonderful strong football player" or "I love wearing mommies pink tutu"?

Re: giving credit to others

#69

Re: Asian Tattoos

Jim Howe

>Beef & broccoli *NM*

Re: giving credit to others

#70

Beef & broccoli 

Jim Howe

>