Re: giving credit to others
George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA
>This thread has been remarkable. A lot of diverse opinions from knowlegeable craftspeople, without degenerating into something destructive.
That being said, my own two cents, as a beginner.
Everytime I turn on the lathe, I guess I am copying. Not plagarizing, but copying, because as soon as I create a shape, I have copied something done previously. As someone said earlier, there are no new shapes. IF I ever develop the skills that would allow me to copy EXACTLY what someone else had done, and tried to pass if off as my own, then I would be guilty, in the legal sense, of plagarism. It would also be idiotic as well as boring. When turning, I am trying to create a specific shape, be it bowl, vessel, hollowform (there's that $3.50 word!) or whatever. But I don't even find it interesting unless I can add something of my own to it.
Does that mean I cannot put leaves on the outside of a bowl or vessel, or use pyrography or texturing because someone else thought of it first? I think not. But I could certainly see the value and wisdom of giving credit for the inspiration, if the design came anywhere near close to someone else's.
I am sure that in the future, should I advance to that stage, that I will make and sell something that was influenced by someone, somewhere.
Some examples: Ford, Chevy, Dodge, etc...the idea originated with someone, but you don't see anything on the widow sticker saying
"Credit to ????? for the inspiration in manufacturing this vehicle."
The original pen turner? The original bowl turner?
I would never try to pass someone else's work off as my own, but my own work will always be influenced by something or someone, even as I add my own "originalities."
Best part of this site is that it really makes you think!!
Thanks to all!!
geofitz13
maker of fine sawdust