Here's my thoughts on the matter,
Doug Trembath
>for what it's worth, and as Adam Cherubini often says, it's worth exactly what you paid for it.
I've been following the plagiarism discussions within the AAW and without. As someone who makes a significant amount of my income turning, I work in a production mode, and the time I spend turning just for myself is rather limited. Experimentation is less important than repeating the shapes folks buy.
From the time I was a youngster, I have been fascinated by classic vessels, and the shapes the American Indians, Egyptians, Phoenicians, Greeks and Romans, among others, created and used seem to touch a place deep in my heart. The clean lines, along with tasteful, understated embellishment are pleasing to both the senses and the sensibilities. I started reading FWW at volume 3, and have followed the early efforts of Rude Osolnik, Dale Nish, David Ellsworth, John Jordan, the Lundquists, and many others with fascination and wonderment. I applaud the efforts these pioneers made in establishing the turning scene as it stands now.
Hollow vessels have a special attraction, and I have seen similar shapes, sizes, decoration, and grain orientation from each of these fellows. Do I copy them, or the ones I saw in the books and museums I have seen in my lifetime, that they obviously used as inspiration themselves?
When a craftsman establishes a distinctive, signature design, and sells many of them around the world, I think they deserve to be able to claim the credit and income derived from it. Take Mike Schwing's bugs, or Keith Tompkins' various Niche entries and award winners for example. Wonderful, innovative work.
On the other hand, if these two were to begin teaching these techniques and charging folks to learn them, do they actually expect that others won't make some? And if someone wanted to buy one, that it wouldn't be sold?
Take the patent and copyright laws as they stand now. Modify a single element, and it is no longer protected, right? If someone, after taking a class with Keith made a rose without thorns, is it still Keith's design?
Another example that comes to mind is Johannes Michelson, who became fascinated with the possibility of turning a cowboy hat from wood. He developed the techniques, and the tools, did the research and spent a long time refining them until he can make them quickly with high quality. I have seen them in Del Mano for thousands of dollars, and he can now turn one in a matter of a couple of hours.
Then he sees an opportunity to increase the payback by giving classes on turning hats, and charging money to do it. Again, should he be the only person in the world to be able to turn and sell a hat? Exactly what did the students pay for? It seems to me you give up the right to complain when you take money to teach the techniques to someone, provide written handouts describing the process, and give detailed plans for the subsequent clamps, turning aids, and related information.
Once the student becomes capable, does he then not have the right to teach others, give demonstrations for which he is paid, and sell his output on the market? He paid for the priviledge, in my opinion. Will his hats command the same prices? Obviously not. Will it affect Johannes' prices? Probably not. Besides, he has already accepted what, at the time, must have been considered acceptable compensation for teaching his craft.
Any wonder craft secrets were hoarded and kept secret through formal organizations and apprenticeships for so many centuries, even to the point that the techniques were lost to the world rather than allowed to become common knowledge?
Taking a basic turning class from a Master turner does not give you the right to duplicate their designs. Having them teach you to duplicate their designs, and accepting payment for such, does.
Again, my humble opinion, worth exactly what you paid for it.
Doug Trembath
Studio in the Woods