Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

giving credit to others

Posts

giving credit to others

#1

giving credit to others

Lan Brady

>Today, on another website, I read a thread where several people were critcal of an artists work. The piece was great. Everyone was upset because the artist had not given credit to the person whose work they had reproduced.

What are the rules/proper edicate? Every cut that I make, I owe soemone credit for knowing how to execute the move. When do I need to acknowledge another?

I have always thought that when I produced something without using a written plan that it was my work. I do not think everyone feels the same though.

I will never be a threat to anyones income, but I don't want to plegerize either.

Lan

Re: giving credit to others

#2

Re: giving credit to others

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>There is a big "issue" now in woodturning concerning plagerism or copying others work. Some feel that if you duplicate but do not sell that is ok. Others say do not copy at all. It is dificult when you watch a video or demonstration or take a class not to want to copy what you have learned. Many demonstrators feel that they teach and share ideas, it is up to individual turners to take those ideas and create their own techniques and style. I find it very difficult to come up with something original that has not been done before. For myself I try to combine all that I have learned in what I do. If I do come close to copying someones work I try to give credit to whoever inspired me. Bottom line is what do you feel is right.

Re: giving credit to others

#3

There's always going to be someone

DougJ in Crawfordsville, IN

>Don't sweat the little things,,, turn for the enjoyment.

Let the small minded people do all the worrying.

Re: giving credit to others

#4

Re: giving credit to others

John Lucas

>I try to give credit when I show a piece that has an obvious style of someone I learned from. They are right it is almost impossible in this day and time to make something that is purely original. Most of us have elements from some other work, be it ceramics, glass, or woodturning that mimick something we've seen. So don't worry about copying work.

Where I draw the line is selling work. If I copy the work of some other craft artist and then go out and selling it then I think that is wrong. This artist has worked to find his style and niche in the market place and for me to just come up and try to steal that away from them is wrong I believe. I know there are those out there that say If I can make the same product faster and cheaper and sell it then so be it.

Now when it comes to commonly recognizeable objects like bowls, vases, christmas ornaments, wine stoppers etc I think these objects and their basic forms have been around so long that is difficult to say this bowl is my style alone so you have to leave it alone.

This changes however when a person takes a bowl and adds something to it to make it thier own. I'll take Molly Winton as an example because we all know her here. Her vessel shapes aren't new and certainly drawings that resemble cave drawings aren't new but burning them into wood in the style that she does is her own and is a very recognizeable style.

So to answer one of your questions, if I made a vessel like Molly's using those techniques I would give her credit for teaching me how to do it.

Not putting anyone down but I have never understood why someone would want to copy work. With the exception of a bread box I made from the very first issue of Woodsmith magazine I have never exactly copied a piece of work that I saw in a magazine. I always change something. I want the work to say John Lucas made this, not John Lucas made a copy of this. That's just me and I fully understand that others do this hobby in an entirely different state of mind and thank god for the difference.

Re: giving credit to others

#5

Here's my thoughts on the matter,

Doug Trembath

>for what it's worth, and as Adam Cherubini often says, it's worth exactly what you paid for it.

I've been following the plagiarism discussions within the AAW and without. As someone who makes a significant amount of my income turning, I work in a production mode, and the time I spend turning just for myself is rather limited. Experimentation is less important than repeating the shapes folks buy.

From the time I was a youngster, I have been fascinated by classic vessels, and the shapes the American Indians, Egyptians, Phoenicians, Greeks and Romans, among others, created and used seem to touch a place deep in my heart. The clean lines, along with tasteful, understated embellishment are pleasing to both the senses and the sensibilities. I started reading FWW at volume 3, and have followed the early efforts of Rude Osolnik, Dale Nish, David Ellsworth, John Jordan, the Lundquists, and many others with fascination and wonderment. I applaud the efforts these pioneers made in establishing the turning scene as it stands now.

Hollow vessels have a special attraction, and I have seen similar shapes, sizes, decoration, and grain orientation from each of these fellows. Do I copy them, or the ones I saw in the books and museums I have seen in my lifetime, that they obviously used as inspiration themselves?

When a craftsman establishes a distinctive, signature design, and sells many of them around the world, I think they deserve to be able to claim the credit and income derived from it. Take Mike Schwing's bugs, or Keith Tompkins' various Niche entries and award winners for example. Wonderful, innovative work.

On the other hand, if these two were to begin teaching these techniques and charging folks to learn them, do they actually expect that others won't make some? And if someone wanted to buy one, that it wouldn't be sold?

Take the patent and copyright laws as they stand now. Modify a single element, and it is no longer protected, right? If someone, after taking a class with Keith made a rose without thorns, is it still Keith's design?

Another example that comes to mind is Johannes Michelson, who became fascinated with the possibility of turning a cowboy hat from wood. He developed the techniques, and the tools, did the research and spent a long time refining them until he can make them quickly with high quality. I have seen them in Del Mano for thousands of dollars, and he can now turn one in a matter of a couple of hours.

Then he sees an opportunity to increase the payback by giving classes on turning hats, and charging money to do it. Again, should he be the only person in the world to be able to turn and sell a hat? Exactly what did the students pay for? It seems to me you give up the right to complain when you take money to teach the techniques to someone, provide written handouts describing the process, and give detailed plans for the subsequent clamps, turning aids, and related information.

Once the student becomes capable, does he then not have the right to teach others, give demonstrations for which he is paid, and sell his output on the market? He paid for the priviledge, in my opinion. Will his hats command the same prices? Obviously not. Will it affect Johannes' prices? Probably not. Besides, he has already accepted what, at the time, must have been considered acceptable compensation for teaching his craft.

Any wonder craft secrets were hoarded and kept secret through formal organizations and apprenticeships for so many centuries, even to the point that the techniques were lost to the world rather than allowed to become common knowledge?

Taking a basic turning class from a Master turner does not give you the right to duplicate their designs. Having them teach you to duplicate their designs, and accepting payment for such, does.

Again, my humble opinion, worth exactly what you paid for it.

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: giving credit to others

#6

Where does it stop?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I totally agree with what Doug and John said and would like to add my own slant.

For the sake of discussion I'm going to use an example. Without giving names, I saw a turning recently that was inspired by a well-know turner, and that inspiration was credited. I happened to see the orginal turning first and when I looked at it I saw a standard shape - seen that a thousand times before - and a patch-work coloring pattern that looked exactly like a pattern that was popular in leather a number of years ago, but was by no means original there. Looking a little further afield, that shape and coloring style also exist in ceramics and I've even seen something very close to it in glass.

Here's another slant on the issue. There's a recent thread about import knock-offs of the Milwaukee/Souix drill. How is that different from plagiarism?

And another - I've got a turning that I did 9 years ago that looks very similar to a well-know turner's current work. My skill/craft wasn't as good (still isn't as good) but other than that... So who plagiarized who? Or did we both develop it independently? (I believe that we did.)

On the other hand, Forgery is a very different issue.

Re: giving credit to others

#7

Re: giving credit to others

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Doug summed up my thoughts pretty succinctly.

I have no problems with someone trying to duplicate another's work, if the goal is learning a technique. It is how I learned to turn hollow forms, by trying to copy some of Wally's work. No one would confuse mine for his up close and handheld, but it was close enough that people did say that at first glance it was a Wally. I believe I always gave Wally credit for the inspiration and I believe it is required of an honest turner to do the same. I never sold any of them, and I don't turn hollow forms anymore. Taught me valuable skills I use in hollowing out my bugs' heads. I learned to develop a bit of an eye for classical bowl shapes by using Bill Neddow's bowls as examples. About the only thing I didn't copy were my bugs and eyepods, but I'm sure they too were influenced by others' work somewhere along the line. The only time I think this is really done with malice is when someone makes a form and passes it off as someone else's. Me? Shoot, I can barely copy my own work much less someone else's.

Johannes Michelson has even stated that he's surprised Stetson doesn't come after him, after all he makes nearly perfect Stetson hats in a different medium. He says he's probably the biggest copier out there!

Still, when someone learns a technique based on another's work, I think credit should be given to that person. Impossible to do if the person is thousands of years dead - as in ancient pottery design. But when someone copies, say, the whales tails, they should give credit for the design and inspiration where due. Its simply courtesy.

When a turner begins to reach the point where collectors and the top name turners become familiar with his/her work, they see just how important it is to not copy someone else's work. It may not make much difference at the hobby level, but at the serious collector level, it can break your reputation. Wood artists in the upper echelon seem to go to great levels to avoid even the appearance of copying someone else's work.

I agree there's something disengenious about a turner teaching demos of how to make their signature work and then getting upset when someone cobbles together a reasonable copy. I also think there's something less than honest about a turner learning that technique and then continuing to make copies of that work without trying to apply it in a fresh and unique way. I also think its a shame to not reach outside of the box with those new skills.

I'm learning to use pyrography tools, like most everyone else. I have a wonderful hollow form of Molly's sitting on my dresser. I see it every morning and every evening. It is tempting to try to copy her work as a learning technique, but I wouldn't dare, even though she may not mind. I just wouldn't do it. Plenty of other ways to learn those techniques.

Re: giving credit to others

#8

Copying - Changing - Learning

Raymond Overman in SC

>I had a chance to meet Michelson at the American Craft Council's show in Charlotte, NC. He's an extremely nice guy and does amazing work. We briefly discussed how many people were turning hats and that his were the original. He was none too happy that he was being copied.

The interesting thing is, once we had moved on into looking at the hats and seeing what he did, he mentioned that he sold a video that described his technique. It's a double edged sword.

If I invest in a video, a class, or tool that someone else has made, I expect a return on my investment. There is a fine line on copying a work and having something inspire your own work. Though I admire everyone's work, I can't say that I'm not going to turn and sell a hollow form because someone has done that before. I can't say I'm not going to sell a salad bowl because I used techniques that Bill Grumbine uses to make his. Am I to credit a Roman for an ogee shaped bowl or Euclid for the mathematics around the measurements? We all use spalted wood or wood with voids in it. Are we to credit Melvin Lindquist for popularizing the material on every bowl we turn.

What I can say is that I won't turn and sell a hollow form that looks exactly like someone elses. I will give the credit for the technique or form where it's due and note that I learned the technique from some master craftsman. The thing is, my hollow form will not be an Ellsworth hollow form no matter what I do. The minute that I claim it is, that's when I've stepped over the line.

Re: giving credit to others

#9

Re: giving credit to others

Barry Turner

>As woodturners, most of us see a lot of demos by a lot of famous/semi famous turners whose work is widely known and respected. I don't think we have to apologize for using the skills we learn along the way or the collective influences of other turners on our own work. Now if we get really good and start signing their name on our work and selling it for half price..........then we have a problem.

As for me, if I tried to copy or emulate a famous turner's work, JJ, for instance, I would probably only get a few chuckles, frowns and a tsk, tsk or two. No matter how hard I tried to copy, it would still be my work, not theirs.

I doubt anything I would ever do could ever be good enough to be considered plagarism. Sort of like the hisses and boo's I would get if I tried to sing an Alan Jackson song anywhere except the shower.

Re: giving credit to others

#10

Re: Copying - Changing - Learning

Barry Turner

>When a well-known turner has a specialty.........hats or whatever, and holds workshops, produces DVD's and writes books to teach other turners how to do this specialty for a hefty fee, then I think that person gives up the right to complain about others who then go out and copy his work.

Re: giving credit to others

#11

Re: Copying - Changing - Learning

John Lucas

>Barry This comes up constantly and I guess I don't see it like everyone else. When I watch a turner turn his or her specialty what I'm looking at is their technique not the project itself. I don't think the turner is giving you the right to copy thier work for sale. I think this is true of video's, DVD's and books as well. They are showing you how to make a hat for example and I'm sure they wouldn't mind if you made a hat or two for gifts but I really don't think they intend for you to turn around and sell these. Now if you were to use this technique to make a viking helmet that would not be copying Johanne as I don't think he's made one of those yet. I have but that's a different story. They are doing a demo on tool usage and technique and use thier specialty because they are very comfortable turning this item and they also know you want to see that item turned. After all you don't book John Jordan for a demo and ask him to turn a hat. Ideally you take that technique and come up with something of your own using that technique.

Now again I think we are talking about selling the work not just making the work as a hobby. I have made a John Jordan poor copy and a Binh Pho poor copy etc, you get the point. These were given as gifts. I won't sell one of those. I did take the techniques I learned from these gentleman and applied them to another object.

When I learned Christmas ornaments from Bob Rosand it turned a few just like his. Then I started selling them so I purposely redesigned my ornaments so they didn't look like his. The same is true with the Larry Hasiak and Bobby Clemons style ornaments. I try to make mine different so they are my style.

Re: giving credit to others

#12

Re: Copying - Changing - Learning

Raymond Overman in SC

>Johannes video title is "Joahnnes Michelson Turns a Range Rider". His marketing says "These popular hats have been shown in over 40 galleries worldwide, including the Smithsonian Renwick Gallery in Washington DC. Johannes Michelsen has made a over 1,400 full sized, wearable hats and over 2,000 mini hats in the past 11 years, making him the most qualified person on the planet to be your instructor.� He is taking the role of instructor, or master as a master/apprentice relationship would be termed and teaching you to copy his work. If he expects you not to use that knowledge then he should be defined as the demonstrator.

That being said, I've heard his feelings on the subject and he'd rather be the demonstrator than instructor and I won't turn and sell one of his style hats.

Re: giving credit to others

#13

Limits

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Lan,

If you've got some time, cull through the two threads on the AAW forum at

http://www.woodturner.org/vbforum/showthread.php?t=245

and

http://www.woodturner.org/vbforum/showthread.php?t=549

Also compare/contrast the articles in the Spring and Fall American Woodturner of this year.

There was a PACKED (SRO!) room at the AAW KC Symposium and I thought David Ellsworth's comment summed it all up rather well. If you spend your time and effort copying the work of others, most of what you're doing is limiting yourself and stunting your own growth as a turner.

There was a great quote from Bob Stocksdale to the effect that the chinese had been copying "his" shapes for at least several hundred years.

Johannes Michaelson also commented that there probably wasn't a turner he knew of that "copied" more than he did. He also seemed almost a bit surprized that the Stetson Company hadn't knocked on his door.

Mark

Re: giving credit to others

#14

Re: giving credit to others

Andy Blackwell

>Mostly, this issue evolves around items sold in galleries. Suppose someone has items displayed in a small gallery, and for all practical purposes, their works resemble works of noted artists. Even if it is signed with their name, it presents a problem. If you have items that are going in a gallery for sale make sure it's your creation and not a knock-off.

Relative to artists teaching MHO is that it is done so that they have a predictable revenue stream. Gallery sales are almost totally unpredictable. This weeks darling is next weeks has-been. On the other hand, if I have four students every weekend for fifty weeks of each year and the tuition is $500. or $600. a student then I have a very predictable revenue stream. The question then becomes: Is the student an apprentice to a master or one paying to be taught a skill?

Re: giving credit to others

#15

Re: giving credit to others-THANKS

Lan Brady

>Thanks to everyone for helping me understnad my concerns a little better. It is better to stretch your own mind than try to capitalize on the latest fad!

I wll practice, practice , pracice!!!!

Lan

Re: giving credit to others

#16

Lan, my take....

TD

>Lan, I think that if I give a class on anything regarding turning that whatever I teach in that class is fair game. If I have a style or technique that I don't want copied I should not teach it. If I do a class on bowls and I show how I make my mounting ring why would I be offended if one of the students actually used my mounting ring? This is what the student came to learn. He paid his money, he studied under me, he went out and applied what he had learned...so why should I be upset? I should be honored. The challenge for me is to always keep improving so that when someone else copies my style I have already moved on to something more advanced. But, some things though are much more individual. Art's puzzle pieces, Andi's leaves, Mollies burned images, these are all very individual styles and should not be copied. These are not skills, they are unique designs. Skills should be copied, designs should not be. I am not saying shapes, I am saying designs. Shapes have been around forever; burning leaves onto a piece has not. But, if you take a class from the originator of a design and they teach you how to do it then why not? If they don't specify in the class that their design is not to be copied then why should they be offended?

TD

Re: giving credit to others

#17

Steven Antonucci

Copying vs. derivative work (long for a Saturday)

steve antonucci

>First, copying with the intent of defrauding folks into believing your $49.95 Ellsworth is a steal should be punishable...

However, without being a "lawyer" (lawyers chime in here...), I don't believe that you can copyright a shape or a style (If you can, than I claim all rounded wooden hollow forms and anything red...). Anything that a particular artisan is capable of producing with his or her skills makes that object uniquely his or her STYLE.

We all spend time composing wood grain orientation, sanding and finishing, and cutting wood fibers in some unique pattern that results in a finished form. If I happen to be influenced by Ellsworth or Jordan or Drozda, so be it. Over time, outside influences will form different objects, based upon personal likes and dislikes, exposure to other forms, and which way the wind blows.

Mankind has evolved from copying others work. Vast portions of our history are likely miscredited based upon who won, and who was around to record it. We live in an age where nearly every object can be immediately duplicated by a factory in China and mass produced with little reprocussion. Should one human gain the appropriate skill to be compared with another master turner, we should applaud them for their diligence.

Steve

Re: giving credit to others

#18

Re: giving credit to others

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Ultimately, it all depends on whose ox has been gored. I got into it big time with a big time turner a few years ago because I said the same thing that is being said here. If someone is going to sell books and videos and teach classes on how to do something, then that person should not be surprised when he or she sees copies of his or her work surfacing in various places. There are a lot of people who are very happy to copy, but if they are copied...

About the art end of it. I am going to be brutally frank here, although it should not really come as a surprise to anyone (my being brutally frank as well as what I am about to write). The art pieces which bring in the big money do NOT bring in the big money because they are well done, original, cutting edge, or whatever other adjective one cares to assign to it. They bring in the big money because of the NAME on the piece. Raymond mentioned me in his post, do I will use my humble self as an example. Lots of people write me privately for advice on what to charge for a bowl they made. I tell them what I charge, and then go on to say that a big part of that is because it is my name on it. If it is their name on it, they probably won't get as much because it is their name and not mine, the same way that I won't get as much for my bowl because it is my name and not David Lancaster's or Mike Mahoney's. It is that simple. The bowls may be of the same quality, but it is the name people are paying for.

Another thing. Artist types like to talk about their students finding their own voice, style, or whatever, and that is all well and good. BUT, I think we all need to stay ahead of the curve, so to speak. That includes the aforementioned artists. If someone starts making a thing, and keeps on making that thing for the next 10 years, who is the one not growing?!?

By the way, Ray, I am going to have to come to your house now to see if you have copied my bowl style. ;-)

Bill

Re: giving credit to others

#19

Re: giving credit to others

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>Bravo.............

Re: giving credit to others

#20

Re: giving credit to others

Barry Turner

>Don't we all want to be recognized for our own work and not how well we can turn out a reasonable approximation of the work of someone more famous than we are? Why would I, seriously, want to turn out a hollow vessel that looks like one by JJ or Ellsworth or some other big-name turner? Heck yes, I would like to master the skills, but I would want to be complimented on my own designs (if they truly ever deserve compliments) rather than the designs of others. The masters exist to teach the rest of us and provide us with standard to strive for. For this, they deserve our utmost respect and admiration.

Re: giving credit to others

#21

Re: giving credit to others

George (Oxford, NC)

>I just bought my first lathe and will be taking my first 'Turning 101' class in Jan. You bet your booty that I will be 'copying'. With all that I will be copying, I'll bet big bucks that anyone of you looking at it would not be able to tell that I copied something other than something in someone's throw-away pile. I believe that it will take many many copies before I can turn out something that evel generally reswmbles what I am copying, and many many more turnings before I can produce something unique.

Some one said in one of the posts that it is 'intent'. I agree. I intend to learn by trying to do some piece that generally resembles the piece I am trying to copy. I do not intend to try to pass it off as other than a learning piece.

Then there is one last thought. How many shapes can an acorn take?, how many shapes are there for a basic goblet?, how may shapes are there for a bench mallet? etc etc etc?

Going to start copying AND learning next month

George

Re: giving credit to others

#22

Re: giving credit to others

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>What exactly is your "own design"? A hollow form?, a natural edge bowl?, a salad bowl, a polychromatic turning? With the exception of turnings such as those produced by Molly Winton, which are obviously her design, how can you say that someone is stealing or copying another tuner's designs when he/she turns for instance hollow forms? Is Ellsworth the only person permitted hollow forms? Where did he get the idea/inspiration? These shapes and forms have been around for thousands of years. Unless a turner is actually committing forgery, I think all of the talk of late regarding plagerism is a bunch of BS.

I agree with Bill, a turner elects to conduct classes, demos, produce DVD's all about how to turn a particular form and all geared to his/her making money and then wants to yell plagerism....give me a break.

I know plenty of very talented turners whose work rivals that of the big names but they don't get the same buck. Why?...name recognition and that's all and those with the name recognition want to protect their income and one way of doing it is to warn everyone else off by screaming plagerism.

I admire their work but that doesn't necessarily mean that I respect them nor do I see where they have ownership of a particular form, shape.

The article in the AAW journal a few issues back made me sick. The auther said something to the effect "We must respect the work of these people and not copy it or they will shut off this valuable source of knowledge"....PLEASE!

Re: giving credit to others

#23

Oh good grief

JKJ in East TN

>Some people must not have anything better to do.

To credit to every influence we would have to list a chain of predecessors dating back to the 16th century. This is an ancient craft and there is very little new. Unless he grew up on a deserted island and invented his lathe, even the big name "artist" with his famous signature piece was influenced by others.

The recent thread where someone laminated a diagonal slice through a bowl reminded me of this - if I do one tomorrow I should credit them, right? The thing is I read an article on that technique (with some interesting variations) in a 1978 FWW magazine. I see this all the time in "old" books and magazines with turnings, furniture, sculpture, etc.

I agree with the advice to have fun and make what ever you feel like. Life is too short to spend it walking on eggs. If you made it and want to exhibit it or try to sell it, go ahead, even if it looks much like something you saw in a gallery. Maybe yours is BETTER than the piece in the gallery and everyone will be copying IT next year.

If the big name "artist" doesn't want anyone to be influenced by his work, he should keep it in a closet. Just my opinion.

JKJ

Re: giving credit to others

#24

Good copy

The Wood Spinner / Bill Hale

>Thank goodness for some copy work.

THE WHEEL

All copy is not bad if you revise it not as a copy but as an idea!

Bill in Casa Grande,AZ.

Re: giving credit to others

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: giving credit to others LONG

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Lan, This is a very good topic, which has some relevance to me.

The situation we are in as wood turners is unique in the art or craft world. As a professional cabinet maker and furniture designer, I was forced to sign non-disclosure statements; I would not divulge my employer's designs or techniques. Furthermore, any ideas I came up with while at this place of employment became company property...I have many utility and design patents that were assigned to the company I worked for. These things help ensure a company remains competitive in the marketplace.

The concept of sharing technique and design concepts is fairly unique to wood turning. I personally know several well known artists who guard their secrets and share absolutely NOTHING. Their belief is( and probably correctly so)that if they produce a successful design that is unique to them, they ensure their viability in the marketplace also. If the market was flooded with knock-offs it would devalue the price of their original work as well....I think the hat situation is an example...wood hats are now EVERYWHERE. Not everyone can afford the original, so the knockoffs are a great, affordable substitute.

Here is how the topic affects me personally....I have created some designs that have gained national and international attention, and I have been invited to participate in several outstanding exhibitions. I also teach to supplement my income, and have demonstrated on the national level. (I cannot expect to survive on sales alone).

I will be doing demos in Louisville this summer..one topic is turning the rose. WHY? Why risk showing turners my techniques so they can possibly copy my work? I think demo'ing at the national level gives a turner a certain amount of credibility, and helps create name recognition. Name recognition is critical in this field, as it is in most others.....when we thumb through the pages of the turning magazines, the same names seem to pop up on a regular basis...it's because these people understand the importance of publicity. Therefore, I must weigh the benefits of publicity against the risk of people copying my work.

The rose pieces I produce make an excellent subject for a demo. My rose demo is designed to show people the REASONING and the THOUGHT PROCESS behind my work. To the casual observer, my rose pieces involve very little turning and extensive carving. The cube I use for the base is obviously NOT turned. Of course, that's not possible. So..when an audience watches me turn a cube on the lathe their idea of what can or cannot be done on the lathe is altered. Same with the stem...multi-axis turning is a bit of a novelty; I didn't invent the process, but I am using it to help create finished pieces that do not appear to be turned at all. Finally the rose blossom shows a whole new approach to "segmented" turning. I hope the result of demos such as this help people expand their own perception of the lathe, and will encourage them to think "outside the box" and apply my techniques to THEIR work. The rose is simply used as an example of what can be done with my techniques..it doesn't mean the rose is now fair game for all. After all, if I teach you how to drive that doesn't give you the right to steal my car.

Is it possible that some people will attend my demo and start to produce similar items anyway? I would be ignorant to think otherwise. It's going to happen, if I show the technique or not..there are lots of clever folks out there. BUT, if someone attends my demos and only copy what they see, they are missing the whole point. They are abusing my trust and shortchanging themselves as well. We all lose.

Hopefully, if someone "borrows heavily" from my ideas, I will already be far ahead of the curve, with new and better ideas...which I may no longer be willing to share.