Who Are You Angry At?
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Mike,
I'll agree that the McMurray Article in the Spring Issue of the AW Journal was seriously flawed, but your comments seem to be directing a fair amount of anger at someone who now gives demonstrations and lessons (and makes DVD's and books, etc.) but then tries to prohibit the attendees, students, and buyers from using what was shown or taught. I've attended a bunch of demos by a number of turners, and not one of them, including Ellsworth, Jordan, Vesery, Wolf, Lancaster, Derry, to name a few, has ever, to my knowledge, expressed anything like what you're describing. If there's some self-rightuous prig-turner who's floating around pulling that BS, I'd really like to know who it is so I can avoid them, and let others know about them as well. In my view the craft has no use for such individuals, and some first-hand negative publicity is likely to assist them to change their ways or find something else to do.
You also seem to be forgetting that that "big name" turner who you refer to as now getting the "big bucks," worked long and hard with no "name" and even less money, but through innovation and dedication to their craft developed that "Name" just as they developed their skills and style. They get those prices NOW because over a significant amount of time, usually measured in decades, people with more money than you or I (and probably both together) have gradually become willing to pay those kinds of prices for their work. But don't kid yourself, I have yet to meet a turner who makes a living purely by selling their turnings. They teach, sell everything from wood to tools to lathes or even sandpaper, have regular jobs, and often travel days for demonstrations, all just to make a living. I don't begrudge them their success, and certainly hope you don't either.
Remember too, it's usually the collectors and dealers who make the real money in the Art World; almost never the actual artists. If anybody's threatened by copying a Name's work, and therefore most likely to raise a fuss over all of this, it's most likely THEM.
M