Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

giving credit to others

Posts

Re: giving credit to others

#26

Re: Woodturning has arrived.....

RussFairfield

>For the past 20 years, there has been a constant complaint among woodturners that their "art" wasn't being recognized as art buy the larger "art community".

We must have won that larger war, because we are now acting like a bunch of silly artists and fighting with each other.

Re: giving credit to others

#27

Keith Tompkins

Re: giving credit to others

Keith Tompkins

>George, the possibilities are unlimited. The only limit is the imagination of the turner. Welcome to the addiction!

Re: giving credit to others

#28

Keith Tompkins

Re: Woodturning has arrived.....

Keith Tompkins

>Russ, years ago, turners traded amongst themselves in a friendly environment. It seems money is the important issue now. Things are bound to change.

Re: giving credit to others

#29

Who Are You Angry At?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Mike,

I'll agree that the McMurray Article in the Spring Issue of the AW Journal was seriously flawed, but your comments seem to be directing a fair amount of anger at someone who now gives demonstrations and lessons (and makes DVD's and books, etc.) but then tries to prohibit the attendees, students, and buyers from using what was shown or taught. I've attended a bunch of demos by a number of turners, and not one of them, including Ellsworth, Jordan, Vesery, Wolf, Lancaster, Derry, to name a few, has ever, to my knowledge, expressed anything like what you're describing. If there's some self-rightuous prig-turner who's floating around pulling that BS, I'd really like to know who it is so I can avoid them, and let others know about them as well. In my view the craft has no use for such individuals, and some first-hand negative publicity is likely to assist them to change their ways or find something else to do.

You also seem to be forgetting that that "big name" turner who you refer to as now getting the "big bucks," worked long and hard with no "name" and even less money, but through innovation and dedication to their craft developed that "Name" just as they developed their skills and style. They get those prices NOW because over a significant amount of time, usually measured in decades, people with more money than you or I (and probably both together) have gradually become willing to pay those kinds of prices for their work. But don't kid yourself, I have yet to meet a turner who makes a living purely by selling their turnings. They teach, sell everything from wood to tools to lathes or even sandpaper, have regular jobs, and often travel days for demonstrations, all just to make a living. I don't begrudge them their success, and certainly hope you don't either.

Remember too, it's usually the collectors and dealers who make the real money in the Art World; almost never the actual artists. If anybody's threatened by copying a Name's work, and therefore most likely to raise a fuss over all of this, it's most likely THEM.

M

Re: giving credit to others

#30

A Rose?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Geez, Keith, howscum you had to "copy" an existing flower? Not creative enough to come up with a completely new flower shape, eh?

|;-}}}

[I'm sure you get my real point]

Re: giving credit to others

#31

Re: giving credit to others

Raymond Overman in SC

>You're welcome anytime Bill, just don't call me Ray ;-) and don't expect to find anything outstanding here. Even the knockoff pieces I try wouldn't be recognized as any approximation of the originals.

"What do you mean it doesn't look like a John Jordan? It's a hollow form and I touched it with a wire brush and it's oval shaped!"

Re: giving credit to others

#32

Re: giving credit to others

Kirk (KC) Constable

>Who was the original pen turner? I'll bet he's REALLY pissed. :-)

KC

Re: giving credit to others

#33

Re: Thank you, Kirk...

RussFairfield

>... for putting things into perspective.

Re: giving credit to others

#34

Re: giving credit to others

Curt Fuller

>Way back when some of us were very young, Guk saw Gronk slurbing his gruel from a wooden bowl and thought it was a lot better than drinking it from his dirty grimy hands. So he copied the idea and made a bowl of his own. A lot of ideas have come and gone and come again and gone again in the craft of making things from wood since the beginning. And if you've ever watched them eat a meal in the future, like in Star Trek, you've seen that they prepare their food in a 'replicator', just a new fangled copier. Seems to me that copying is here to stay, at least until the star date 2800's or so. What makes someone think that a shape can be owned or even the way to get that shape can be owned. We're all just links in the chain, passing the skills along with maybe our own little twist added at best.

Re: giving credit to others

#35

Re: Follow the money

RussFairfield

>Keith is right about it being about the money, and I read the AAW Magazine article on "plagiarism" as a bunch of guys who are PO'd because they are losing control of the cash flow.

There was a time when only a very few folks had it all their way. They were the artists, and they were the teachers. With the AAW membership now being over 10,000, and 10-times (my guess) that number who aren't members, they now have competition for our dollars, and it is hurting. I see all of the fresh new names and faces among both artist and teacher as being a good thing. Many of them are better at what they do than than old guard; and that too is a good thing.

Re: giving credit to others

#36

Re: Thank you, Kirk...

Kirk (KC) Constable

>How many people are building a Maloof look-alike rocker? Around here, you'll see two or three guys at every show of any significance with a chair that looks just like the other ones. And of course, they all want a ghastly amount of money for them...regardless of how well they've executed the joinery or what kind of '10 foot' finish they've slathered on.

Hal Taylor sells his plans, and professes to not care if you sell the chairs. I have his plans myself, but I bought them to make one for LOML and maybe the kids...I'll never carry one to a show. I'm certainly not above 'taking inspiration' from the Stickley catalog, but I try to not to make an 'absolute' copy...and there are little details I carry through all my Mission stuff that I think makes it 'mine'.

I only do a couple shows a year, and as a 'furniture guy', I've stayed away from pens...but I'm going to start taking some high-end ones with me because I don't see anybody else doing them at these shows. I won't take the inexpensive slimlines, not only because I don't like them, but because I'd feel like I was 'stepping on' somebody else's territory.

KC

Re: giving credit to others

#37

At the idea

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>Mark,

I'm not angry at any one individual. I'm not particulalry angry at all, I'm more tired and frustrated at the entire plagiarism garbage.

That article in the AAW is what initially got to me and then some threads here and at the AAW website. And, it does seem to me that many of those that you've mentioned have in fact weighed in on this plagiarism idea, giving the impression that they are the sole turners that are permitted certain designs. That they have some sort of ownership.

You're correct that it took many of the "big names" decades to get to where they are but, it sure doesn't give them sole possession of shapes, forms, methods and ideas.

What they do have ownership of is their name and signature. That's what people are buying and in most cases, nothing more.

Unless a turner or other, actually attempts forgery by way of a signature or otherwise misleading people into believing an object was made by someone else, I see nothing wrong with turning any darn thing one wants and can't see where pagiarism ever comes into play.

Re: giving credit to others

#38

Re: At the idea

John Lucas

>Mike I took the article in the AAW journal a little differently. I took it to mean that if we copy someone's work who teaches, and willingly shares their knowledge with us, then we may start to impact thier income by selling our work in thier market. If this were to happen then they would naturally stop teaching so as to keep other copy cats to a minimum. I think the author was simply trying to explain that we have a huge wonderful gift of artists sharing thier technique with us and we don't want to jeapardize this. Many years ago most artists jealously hid all of thier secrests to keep this from happening. As Mark said non of the turners are getting rich doing this they are simply looking for another source of income. When Binh Pho was down here we talked about doing workshops and he said he actually loses money doing them. He can make more money by staying home and working on pieces that do sell for quite a bit. He does it because he enjoys meeting the people and it helps keep his name in the public eye, sort of an advertising thing.

Re: giving credit to others

#39

Quality wins, always!

TD

>I just received an email from a customer who purchased one of my bowls last summer. She stated "I went to a lot of festivals in October and November and saw a lot of bowls, none compared to yours in quality". Now I am sure she saw plenty of bowls shaped like mine, and I am sure she saw some bowls with the same finish, and I am sure she saw some bowls from the same types of wood. So why does she feel mine is better? EXECUTION! Attention to detail, workmanship, skill, patience, EXPERIENCE. The serious buyers are not concerned about where the idea came from, they are looking at the quality of the piece. How does the piece feel in your hands? Is the bottom too thick? Are the sides uniform? Does the piece feel balanced? Are the proportions good? Are there sanding or tool marks? Do the lines flow? Is the finish good? All these things are generic but if you excel in them you have a piece that is recognizable as yours, not for the unique shape, but for the quality of the piece. I have customers who see one of my bowls somewhere and they are able to tell the owner that they know who made that bowl. Do I care if someone copies me? Heck no, that is why I teach bowlturning! If you get as good as me I'll get better! That is what it is all about. Share what you learn and keep growing. Stay ahead of others by getting better yourself, not by withdrawing.

TD

Re: giving credit to others

#40

Re: Follow the money

John Lucas

>I agree Russ. I'm hoping that the competition produces new markets and of course also increases the worth of turning in the art market as well as the craft market. I think it will.

Re: giving credit to others

#41

John, I agree on part of this

TD

>John, any good turner who teaches can make more by staying home and turning. Teaching at a symposium does not pay as much as staying home and turning; doing demos at other clubs pays poorly. Giving lessons at one's shop stops you from making objects that could sell for far more than what you can charge for the lesson. So why do it? As you noted, some do it because they like meeting people. Others do it for a change of pace. I think the most I get from teaching is what I learn myself. When I have to answer a question it makes me think about what I am doing or why I do it a certain way. Many times we make small changes over a long period of time to how we do things and we do not notice until someone asks us about why we do it that way. My super low handle position was like this; it evolved gradually but I really didn't know why until I started explaining to others why I like that method. When you take time to list the reasons for something you do, you learn also. AS far as the plagerism thingy, turning has been around for a long time, there are no new shapes. The only area that I can see subject to this thread is in enhancements. There are new ways to decorate that are unique and recognizable as a certain persons contribution to the craft. Should we give credit? Should we copy? Should we ask permission? Let your conscience be your guide.

TD

Re: giving credit to others

#42

Re: At the idea

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>I suppose that's the risk that one takes when one decides to teach and give demos in order to increase income.

But I still don't understand. Is Ellsworth the only turner who should be permitted to do big hollow forms with small openings, because if someone is also executing the same work that turner may surpass him and take a share of the market? I thought that's how it worked. Again, that's the risk that one takes, a risk I might ad, that is influenced by the risk-taker's desire to increase his income, not necessarily because he wants to simply help others and the craft.

So, what's the answer? Do turners attend these classes, demos, workshops, etc, attempt to improve their skills but not sell their work because it may compete with that of the "teacher" and therefor impact his/her income? Do the unwashed masses just do the work for the joy of it and either give it away or fill their homes with it?

As I said before, in the case of Molly Winton or Giles Gilson or Michael Hosaluk, I grant that it's unique and easily identifiable as being done by them. But while you may look at a piece by one of the Moulthrop's, Ellsworth and be able to guess that it's their creation, I still think that work by them and Stocksdale and Osolnik are simply forms and shapes. Beautifully executed and beyond my ability but shapes and forms nonetheless and how can that be plagiarism?

Re: giving credit to others

#43

That sounds like Capitalism

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Competition, free market?

What a radically idea!

How will the secret trade guilds survive?

Re: giving credit to others

#44

Re: Turning Anything

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Well Mike, you and I seem to have differing experiences. I've spent several weekends with Ellsworth, and he will happily try to teach you how to make his stuff if that's what you want to do. But he will do so in the hope that you'll take the techniques and come up with "new" and unique forms of your own. If you go to a show with his shapes and textures but your name on the pieces, it won't be David who's talking about whether you copied his stuff. It'll be the knowledgeable buyers and judges [the people who pay the $$ you mention] remarking about how you're obviously copying Ellsworth's stuff, about your lack of creativity, and about how "it's a shame that a turner with obvious technical skills can't use them to come up with something original." Ultimately it comes back to Ellsworth's comment in KC, joined in by all of the others in the panel, that copying another person's work really hurts the copier because it stunts their growth. Vesery doesn't have a patent (or trademark or lock or whatever) on carving feathers on a jar, just as Andi Wolf isn't the first person to carve leaf images into a bowl. Those same things have been done in wood, metal, ceramic, and stone for THOUSANDS of YEARS.

Just as copying the work of others stunts the individual craftsman/artist, so too does it stunt the growth and development of "T"urning as a Craft. In a situation where large numbers of people constantly replicate the work of a few, innovation and creativity are prevented, if not destroyed, the few become inordinately powerful and potentially corrupted by their false success and their ability to literally force their ideas on others. Envision a society where you ARE REQUIRED TO COPY, and your success will depend only upon how well you copy, but ALL INNOVATION AND CREATIVITY IS PROHIBITED. The result is a formalized good taste, and a dead artform. If, however, we, as turners, encourage others to innovate and create, and DISCOURAGE COPYING, turning will be and remain a dynamic and growing art participated in at many levels by an ever-expanding number of people. I deem that a good thing.

Oh, and, while we're at it, where did this $3.50 word "hollowform" come from? It's a freekin' J-A-R or B-O-T-T-L-E, boys & girls! Has been, and will always be just that. Oh, wait, because it's got this big-ass hole in the side and can't be used to store anything [you mean like it's busted?], now we need to call it something else? You want to ascribe artsy-fartsy titles to an ancient item so you can seem more esoteric and charge more for the object, don't complain when you get sucked into the "you're-only-as-good-as-your-last-show" scene.

|;-}}}

Re: giving credit to others

#45

Re: giving credit to others

John Lucas

>I want to thank everyone for this interesting discussion. I think it's really helpful to learn how others think. I like to see the other side of the argument and I'm so glad we can do it here without harsh words. I remember all to well the Rec.crafts newsgroup where you would get cussed out and even death threats just for posting an opposing point of view. This is a great group of knowledgeable folks.

Re: giving credit to others

#46

Speaking of Molly

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I love her stuff, but I didn't ask if she got permission from that caveman whose horse images she's obviously ripped off. |;-}}}} [Exit, the Geico-dude]

Actually, I remember Molly got a bit concerned in KC when Jordan made a comment in the Instant Gallery Critique about turners borrowing images from other cultures to decorate (enhance) their pieces. John was actually cautioning people in a few of his seminars to make sure that when you borrow and use an image, that you check to understand what it may mean so that you're not taking it out of context and possibly insulting the originators because it actually carries strong religeous meanings for them. Lets not be goring any sacred cows (or oxen, or buffaloes)!

M

Re: giving credit to others

#47

That's my point

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>I'm not attacking Ellsworth, I'm attacking the idea of plagiarism in woodturning. Yes, I was aware of Molly Winton's concerns regarding that and I understand that.

Re: giving credit to others

#48

Don Pencil

Exact replication?

Don Pencil

>Ladies and Gentlemen,

I would think that if one tried or did make an exact replication of anothers work and then attempted to pass it off as their own that person should have their head examined. To then take it to a gallery or turning competition would leave me to suspect that they had been sniffing to many of the liquids in the finishing cabinet.

On the other hand, as noted in previous posts, the turner learns by replicating, as best he or she can, the simple forms and techniques. Once these are mastered they then turn to the more advanced as they continue their growth. They read the books, buy the videos, take individual and group leesons, share things learned and experienced at club meetings and in their shops. They often make many simular works practicing the new found skills.

Think about it. If you have been working on a particular design/technique and have produced several nice pieces in the "signature style" of "ms. or mr. master woodturner", would you not sell them at the craft fair or out of your personal gallery or whatever.

If I could duplicate the Mona Lisa, and did, and then tried to pass it off as my original work that is one thing and it should not be. But were I to paint a different smiling female face in the style of the Di Vinci and call it the "Smiling Lulu" this would not be a problem in any art world.

If the signature piece is that important to the creator of the technique then they must not demo it, video it, or write about it in a book. Show it and keep raking in the dollars until someone else figures out what they have done. By then they will have moved on and the rest will be playing catchup.

Don Pencil

WWW.DONPENCIL

Re: giving credit to others

#49

My sentiments, exactly!

TD

>

Re: giving credit to others

#50

But "Sacred cows make the best hamburger"

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>