WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

old vs new

Posts

old vs new

#1

old vs new

John Lucas

>I challenged my fellow turners to show an old piece vs one of thier new pieces. I'll start. The segmented vessel was one of my early turnings. I don't have a photo of my really early pieces. This was about 10 years ago. My woodworking skills were good so the joints are tight but the shape had a long way to do. Because the bowl had relatively straight sides and flat bottom I always had a really tough time turning and finishing the transition between sides and bottom.

Obviously my segmented work has taken a different turn. The pregnant goblet had inside-out turning- miniature turning-offcenter turning- steam bending and turning acrylic.


img

Re: old vs new

#2

Great idea John....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I hope to participate in this thread tomorrow when I get home from work.

Jennifer

Re: old vs new

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: old vs new

Keith Tompkins

>Hi John, I love the goblets! Here are two of my pieces.....the lamp is walnut, with a segmented cherry and walnut base. polyurathane finish...it is one of my older turnings.

The white piece is holly and ebony.....lacquer finish. The lamp is in my living room; the white piece was critiqued in Orlando, and is on permanent public display in Hong Kong!


img

Re: old vs new

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: old vs new

Keith Tompkins

>oops, here is the lamp


img

Re: old vs new

#5

Re: old vs new

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Hey! Your stuff is in Hong Kong already? US Postal still has mine in it's possession.

Your early work is damned nice, too. Wait till you see my first piece. Gimme a few minutes...

Re: old vs new

#6

my first turning

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Sits right next to me on my computer desk.


img

Re: old vs new

#7

at about 2 months

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Didn't realize how hard eggs were to turn till someone told me. Sometimes ignorance is bliss.


img

Re: old vs new

#8

15 months (now)

Mike Schwing from Md.

>On its way to permanent display somewhere in Hong Kong.


img

Re: old vs new

#9

Re: old vs new

John Lucas

>This is fun. Keep it up. When I get to Atlanta I'll take photos of some really old pieces. John

Re: old vs new

#10

Re: old vs new

John Lucas

>Here's another set. The ones on the right are my first hand mirrors. These were Christmas gifts and took forever to make. They were done completely with a router except for the stamped background which took about 1000 hits with a leather tool on each mirror.

The ones on the left were my latest batch of hand mirrors. Made almost entirely on the lathe except for some carving.


img

Re: old vs new

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: at about 2 months

Keith Tompkins

>I think I posted these before, my very first turnings, about 1970. I won " craftsman of the year" award that year in high school, also my first award.


img

Re: old vs new

#12

Re: 15 months (now)

Doug Trembath

>'Attaboy, Mike! Shows nicely.

Ah, progression...

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: old vs new

#13

First Bowl - 1989

DW

>Curly KOA... usd only a scraper and a lot of sandpaper. Didn't finish the bottom because I didn't know how.

Learn'n by do'n

DW

Re: old vs new

#14

PIC 

DW

>


img

Re: old vs new

#15

Bowl #10...

DW

>... about 9 months later... learned to use a gouge and shear cut. Also learned about what they called "power sanding" ... whis I knew about that 9 months earlir...

learn'n by do'n

DW


img

Re: old vs new

#16

Last Bowl - 1999

DW

>... only did 12 bowls between late 1989 and the latter part of 1990. Moved and never had time as a single dad with three small kids.

This Bowl is Japanese Zelkova. Hardest wood I have ever turned... like concrete. Did it in a friends unheated and unlighted shop where my lathe had been stored... December 1999 Christmas Eve for a gift. Had my number three son sitting on the lathe to keep it from walking out the door. Have not turned since.

Too old and sore to learn no more...

DW


img

Re: old vs new

#17

Spalted Wormy Myrtlewood

DW

>

Re: old vs new

#18

Re: old vs new

RonZ

>My last and only remaining project from highschool. Two pieces of teak glued together.






Re: old vs new

#19

Re: at about 2 months

John Lucas

>Keith

Rude would have been proud.

Re: old vs new

#20

My first pear bowl

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

John,

Good idea for a discussion!

This is my first "real" bowl turned from pear wood back in May of 2001. I actually use this bowl just about every day. It holds my keys and watch on my dresser (not good for much else!).

See ya around,

Dominic


img

Re: old vs new

#21

A newer one

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

Here's one I'd like to think of as one of my "best".

It's cherry, with maple and ebony segmented rings. I actually cut the bowl, then added the segmented inner ring and glued it back together (matching the grain pattern of the solid wood). Then I added the segmented ring up top.

See ya around,

Dominic


img

Re: old vs new

#22

Re: old vs new, PICS

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Interesting idea. Some of the old stuff I've seen people posting looks really, really good. This should help "bring down the average" a bit :)

This is my first bowl. It's more of a shallow plate really, but it got me hooked. It's about 6 inches across and made from a walnut cutoff:



This is not my most recent piece, but it is still one of my favorites. I've kept very few of my own pieces, but I did keep this one. It is a natural edged Lignum vitae piece. The brown sapwood has turned really dark in the year since I did this one:


I've turned one other piece with lignum vitae and really love it. I've got a hunk of log left that I've been hoarding until I come up with the right project for it.

Again, neat idea for a thread. I've done some hollow form stuff as well, but don't have any pics of that stuff.

Thanks for looking,

Mike

No lathe time in sight in Apex, NC...

Re: old vs new

#23

Errr, brown is the heartwood :)

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>

Re: old vs new

#24

a separate post to say

Mike Schwing from Md.

>That this is indeed a great idea.

I'm sitting here wishing I'd have seen this thread when I was facing my first few turnings. I think it would have made me feel much more at ease with my skill set at the time. Sometimes I think new turners (like me recently) come here and see folks' best work and think "oh my gosh, I can't possibly post my work here" or "I might as well give up, I stink compared to these folks".

This thread would have gone a long way towards encouraging me, had I needed it.

Re: old vs new

#25

Re: old vs new

Thomas Saunders

>Great Idea,

Don't know if I have posted this pic before...it represents 100 years of turning in my family.

The lamp was done by my Grandfather in 1902 or 03. The ashtray holder in the middle was done by me..my first ever turning..over forty years ago.

The bowl on the right was the first piece I did after my course this time last year. The segmented bowl was my first attempt at that last Christmas.

Since then there have been many "minis" Most of you have likely seen them in my "Mini" gloat in a previous posting.

My very latest bowl is in the next posting.

Tom in Red Deer


img

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.