Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

Posts

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#51

Where I am going....

David Weaver

..the need for david and others to try to plane small pieces like that is because they cannot do it any other way accurately.

The trouble with things like sawing (something else that david can't do accurately, or at least as he describes that being the issue in his dovetail video) and planing is that if you don't have the experience doing the rougher work efficiently and accurately, you have to resort to things like you're talking about. Squatting down, getting really rigid.

I do the same thing konrad does with infills (albeit probably 1/100th or fewer as many). I do not squat down, and my standard of accuracy for an infill blank vs. a fitted gauge is one thousandth of an inch.

What's not being communicated here is that just because a bunch of people do things inefficiently now doesn't make the poorer technique and lack of experience the goal.

My technique on small pieces is no different except that I don't need to take a step. If I recall, david walks with the plane, but stays rigid on long boards. This is not good, but you do what you have to do. The more efficient thing to do is to get in a more relaxed position, learn where your errors may be, learn to see them more acutely with experience (so that you don't have to constantly check with a square until the last passes), and correct them.

The collection of all of these little problems is what leads people to not use hand tools. They are important to me because my approach isn't to just get a result, it's to get a result the best way possible and in a way that's comfortable. Comfort and efficiency lead to better results overall - even if hypothetically, but will work as well, only one will be tolerable and accurate for very long.

My point is that if someone is looking to hit a glass ceiling quickly, they can go with those instructors. If the ultimate goal is not to plane much, then it's not much of a glass ceiling. If one is looking to actually talk about the ergonomics of planes and efficiency, those guys are out. I have used both types of planes in context, and the low angle planes take a lot of feel and touch away from a user. I just tuned up the 62 after flattening it and i'm reminded pretty quickly of the assortment of issues that BU planes have. The feel is bad, the adjustment mechanism is bad (depth setting and lateral are both problematic), and there's no cap iron. I think with the right teacher, bettering them would occur with a new student in a matter of weeks.

I can't give any credibility to your planing mechanics thoughts and desire to change the designs of planes because they just won't come close to equaling more classical designs. The argument is attractive, but the more experience someone gets, the less attractive it will become.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#52

Re: Mini-ura on a new Veritas blade

Winston

I may try again another time to use a buffing wheel to make a shallow ura like this, but I think I'll need to use a much smaller wheel -- like Dremel sized -- and much, much coarser abrasive.

I saw that McMaster-Carr has "aggressive" buffing compounds, with particle sizes up to 173 microns (80 grit). I wish they came in sizes smaller than 3 lb bars, though. Let me know if you have any thoughts on what size grit to use.

https://www.mcmaster.com/buffing-compounds/buffing-and-polishing-compounds/

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#53

by the way...

David Weaver

..I can guarantee you that none of those folks that you showed would be able to work small pieces more accurately than I can, and most of them, probably not as accurately. I'd bet money that I can match konrad, but I've read posts on his blogs and the way he works when truing infill blanks is the same way I do. You use a plane you know ,and when you get close to a mark, you literally know by count how many thousandths 2, 3 or 5 shavings will take so that you can get close to the target quickly and then carefully do the last shavings.

I have one more handicap that konrad may not - I do my metal work by hand, so when I fit a blank, the front and back will need to be within about a thousandth to avoid a visual gap anywhere in the plane between metal and wood, but the front and back of one of my billets may be different in target width by a hundredth. I have to hit the target at both ends, and squareness can't be threatened, either (especially bottom narrower than the top) or the gap will show up in the bottom of the infill while the top is fit tight.

Despite all of that, what I advocate will be easier for a beginner pretty quickly vs. building the bad habits shown in those pictures. It's having the confidence to realize that you can try something, analyze what your personal biases is and then fix them rather than trying to create artificial or exhausting stances and getting ridgid like those pictures show. It leads people to migrate to using machines for more instead, and sometimes that's costly where it doesn't have to be, and sometimes it's detrimental (someone working entirely by hand will probably ruin stock or blow past a mark about 1/10th as often - you see it coming. If you are working relaxed and in rhythm as I do, then you free yourself from having to think about technique while you're working and you can observe the results that are occurring). Most instructors want beginners to get first time success, teaching method rather than results and approximate method. It's a bad way to go about things, but if you expect most of your students will never go much further than early classes or they'll move on to make rocking chairs with CNC machines and power sanders, and everything will be rounded off, maybe it doesn't matter there, either. It's a death knell for someone who wants to get better with hand tools, though.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#54

Visual difference at the back edge of..

David Weaver

..an iron or chisel.

This has come up a few times. Not talking about part of the back of a tool that's not getting abraded at all, rather when a stone seems flat (especially a waterstone with some loose grit or any stone with a slurry) and you just can't ever seem to get the edge to look like the center of the back.

I think what's happening is slurry dulling or abrading around the edge, or just in general without slurry. If you get a microscope and look at the edge and the stone is anything other than ultra fine, you'l see that the scratches at the edge are just a tiny bit deeper. If this occurs over 3 or so thousandths of an inch, it's visible to the naked eye as a slightly different finish. If the iron is sharp, don't worry about it. The only stones that seem to be immune from this are very fine stones or very fast stones where the particles are immobilized.

This was an iron sharpened with loose 1 micron diamonds. Notice in the middle of the iron, there are no discernible scratches except those left behind by prior steps. Take a look at the edge, then (this is from the planing test - the ruler trick edge is larger than the picture, so this facet is flat for the purpose of the picture).

Notice that you can make it a small area where the direction of the diamond scratches (perpendicular to the edge) become visible - but only right at the edge.

https://i.imgur.com/rmIEqnv.jpg

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#55

Re: Mini-ura on a new Veritas blade

David Weaver

Those are the "Greaseless" compounds, right? I'm assuming they are used to get bad surfaces ready for fine buffing.

I haven't tried them as I'm using a deburring wheel for that stuff instead. Deburring wheels are OK, but you'll need two hands to hold on to the item being deburred (which probably makes a buffer mandatory) and when they catch the edge of something (like a hard buff will, too, I guess), they'll go right around the edge and round a lot over.

Lots of heat deburring, too.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#56

Re: Visual difference at the back edge of..

Winston

I don't think that what's shown in the picture is due to slurry. Or, at least, it's not mostly due to slurry.

If the slight difference in reflection were cause mostly by the slurry, then I'd expect it to be consistent all the way across the blade.

But instead, the reflection is more pronounced in the middle of the blade. I think this is because the blade is cambered, and so more wood shavings pass over the middle of the blade, causing more abrasion there.

I'm not saying that the "slurry dulling" can't happen -- but at this point, the convexity on the blade's back due to wear has a greater effect than that. It's possible that over time, as I resharpen this blade with more pressure at the edge, the convexity at the edge will be reduced, and the phenomenon you're describing will become more apparent.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#57

Sorry, I should've been more precise...

David Weaver

...I kind of addressed something general (I thought I was posting a new post and didn't realize I was posting it here) that Steve mentioned but mistakenly put it after your post.

that made what I'm talking about misleading and unintentionally so. I agree with what you're talking about - the visual difference at the end of an iron will be uniform. Trying to get rid of it to match the center of an iron can drive someone bonkers.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#58

I risk offending a lot of people...

David Weaver

...when we get into this stuff, so I generally avoid it. If I say that I normally flatten/thickness to a mark (without calipers or overly thin shavings) somewhere in the range of half a hundredth (which is true), it's meaningless. If someone has a more accurate thickness planer, they'll wonder if that's OK. If they have a less accurate thickness planer, then they'll think that sounds fiddly.

I like david charlesworth. I doubt he appreciates me that much after some of the discussions about plane design and planing, but that's something you have to live with if you're going to try your best to make the accuracy of the discussion the top priority.

I think about this fairly often - I don't talk about BU planes much (usually) because they're inferior for anyone other than beginners and very occasional users (and probably for the latter, too). I haven't commented much on the COE discussion because all I can really tell you is that it doesn't pan out with experience, and since I deal with likelihood for a living, the part at the end of "perhaps everyone has had it wrong" hits the bone of being less likely than getting struck by lightning - for the same reason the double iron is clearly superior. There was economic interest in having the best design, both for the user and the seller. Uniformity occurred at some point once plane technology matured because in a sea of enormous numbers of makers and users, nobody could better what was available.

The draw (come up with a great design without learning about design -not talking about planes here, but in a more general sense. Design a new car without knowing how to design cars (brickman)). Those things just don't work out often. Seldom enough as to not be material.

Sometimes, truths that aren't causal are used as explanation for why. The LV and LN BU plane types weren't made in great numbers in the past because the gray cast didn't hold up. That sounds great. It's not true - there was no economic interest in the planes because they wouldn't appeal to an experienced user. Stanley made malleable iron tools during part of the time that they made the 62 and had there been enough interest, I'm sure they would've made them.

The toothed irons are offered now to work difficult woods. They work slower than just using the cap iron. Stanley offered them, too. They're rarely seen because there was no real economic interest in them.

What's far more likely that one has to be wary of (with anything) is finding with more experience that you'll be able to understand why things were made the way they were. Once in a great while, it's because a technique is antiquated or no longer relevant (we don't get tobacco enemas, etc), but quite often, learning why would teach us more than supposing that people may not have known what they were doing.

I can no longer get swept up in worrying about whether someone gets offended unless i'm just supposing something without credible experience (I try not to do that). I'm still fond of David C and appreciative that the first edge I ever sharpened was a good one, but not as swept up in feeling like i'm obligated to persuade him to like me just because I like him.