Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

Posts

Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#1

Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

Winston

I've noticed for a while that the backs of my plane blades never quite seem flat all the way to the edge. Right near the edge, it reflects light slightly differently, indicating that the blade is ever so slightly convex near the edge, and that the reflection sometimes isn't uniform all the way across even after sharpening, indicating some edge damage that wasn't removed.

I think this is because the slight convexity is preventing it from making good contact with the stone. I think the convexity is caused in part by abrasion from the wood shaving rubbing on the back of the blade in a bevel-down plane, and possibly also by the slurry on the sharpening stone .

The purpose of the ura on a Japanese plane blade is to help deal with this problem -- it reduces the amount of work needed for the back of the blade and still sharpen it right up to the edge.

This got me thinking: would it be possible and practical to use a buffing wheel to create a min-ura on a plane blade? By "mini", I mean that it would not be nearly as deep as the ura on a kanna blade. The mini-ura would only need to be deep enough to avoid touching the stone when working the back of the blade on a fine stone.

I don't know enough about using a buffing wheel for this purpose. Anyone with more experience with this: Does it sound feasible? I assume that a much coarser abrasive would be needed.

I have used a grinding wheel to help straighten out a chisel that was very concave, but using one to make a mini ura would require much more precision that I'm capable of. I figure that a buffing wheel would be much more forgiving in terms of technique, but also significantly slower.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#2

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

Steve Elliott

I've noticed the same thing when trying to achieve a very flat surface all the way to the edge of a blade. No matter what type of stone or abrasive on a substrate, there seems to be a little bit at the edge that doesn't reflect light like a flat mirror, more like a fun-house mirror but on a tiny scale.

The thin ura on a Japanese plane blade allows the effect of the finest stone or abrasive to be concentrated right at the edge. A back bevel on a Western plane blade achieves the same effect. For that matter, using a leather strop provides a little more pressure right at the edge and has a similar effect.

On chisel blades where the flat surface of the blade is sometimes used as a reference surface to guide the cutting action, a back bevel is not advisable. On plane blades it can be quite useful.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#3

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

Mike In Los Angeles

Whether you use a flap wheel, scotch brite wheel, or a buffer, i think it works better on a dremel or maybe a hand drill where you can see where you’re hitting the surface. I had one of those lame wet grinders and that’s about all I ever liked it for, but when you grind the tip it ruins your evening.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#4

finger pressure...

David Weaver

..I can't remember if this is why, but one of the things I noticed once microscope viewing became and on and off again thing is that you have to rely on bias and pressure to finish an edge (it can be done with small bevels, but in my iron testing, I attempted to expedite the process by using the ruler trick with the old steel ruler that charlesworth suggested in his original video - something like 1/2mm).

If a blade is used with the cap iron, it turns out to be easier to refresh a well worn blade without the back bevel - the bias is still needed due to curvature at the edge, in combination with bevel honing.

Once the back bevel starts to become significant, then it's a grab bag between determining how much you should actually do to the back of the iron (to get from https://i.imgur.com/Xv9vsRI.jpg to https://i.imgur.com/vn2UAFI.jpg generally took more ruler tricking than one would guess).

As the abrasive gets really fine, it's easy to come up with a process that takes a while and still doesn't remove all of the wear on the back side under the scope, exacerbated further as the back bevel grows.

With faster media on the back (even if followed by slower media) and finger pressure on places where you want the abrasion to occur, it's a lot easier to finish.

One of my sharpening stone omnibus objectives was to see not just whether or not media is suitably fine, but how fast it would do something like refresh all of the wear off of the back of an iron. If one type can do it in 20 seconds, and another takes 45, the former is likely to result in better edges.

Several times a year, I get tools from people, sometimes none in one year, and then several the next. I would secretly like to ask them to do their best sharpening job so that I can accurately diagnose what their tool issue may be (but secretly to take pictures under the microscope). That feels like invading someones' privacy, though.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#5

Something precise.

David Weaver

I think if you want to do this without buffing the corners off of a chisel, you'd rather have something like a deburring wheel and some fixture to concentrate the work in a certain spot, with the awareness that a deburring wheel will create heat.

Another option is a radius wheel with a sanding belt on it.

If you concentrate finger pressure at the very edge only with your finish stone, you'll remove all of the wear you're seeing and the problem will cease. no rolling the edge up or anything will be needed - just continue to sharpen using pressure at the edge from above.

Japanese chisels would be a pain without the ura because their hardness is well above anything silica based (the bulk of what's in a japanese natural stone, aside from 15-20% alumina), and on top of that, the hardness slows down the speed of the alumina a lot.

The key to getting something initially flat is using something fast enough to remove material so that you're not encouraged to bias pressure toward the edge in earlier steps. If edge refinement isn't perfect because of a few deeper scratches, they will eventually leave in subsequent resharpenings.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#6

Side sharpening

Wiley Horne

I like side sharpening more and more, despite the arguments against (weakens edge0 by scoring). These arguments may or may not be practical issues—I haven’t noticed a problem.

But getting down to the current matter.....side sharpening avoids running the edge directly into grit or slurry. Should work well for back flattening to the edge.

I like Winston’s original thought about something ura-like on western chisels. I suspect, like Mike, that Dremel or the like would provide a more focused and controllable cut.

Wiley

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#7

Re: Initially flat

Mike In Los Angeles

Everything I’ve gotten second hand has been bellied on it’s flat face, working out the blown corners takes forever. 80 grit psa on glass seems to be the best for flattening the belly without rolling on it, I saw a youtube video where the guy said “Dont roll on it” but didn’t say how not to. Seemed like a sharp guy.

It’s a big drag to work a back on the 80 grit and see a big belly when I go to the next stone, makes me wonder if I made it worse.

I have a foredom rotary tool for my square job and a ton of Little sanding drums, That’s what I’ve used for micro hollowing chisel backs and it has worked okay just going real light on it and taking the marks off with the India stone until the corners are worked out.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#8

Rotary tool?

Winston

Do you have any pictures of the result you get with the rotary tool? And how long do the sanding drums last?

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#9

Some context

Winston

The reason I'm interested in this for plane blades is because I've been trying to buff them (on the bevel side) just a minimal amount, to avoid possible clearance issues with bevel down planes.

However, I've noticed under the scope that sometimes the edges aren't quite uniform after buffing. I think this is because before I go to the buffer, the blade still has some burr hanging on, even after going back and forth a few times with the bevel and back on the Sigma 6000. I think that perhaps the reason that I still have some burr is because of the slight convexity on the back of the blade. An ura on the back of the blade would make it easier to sharpen on stones all the way to edge and get rid of any burr; then I could buff for a small amount of time.

With chisels, I haven't really had issues with this, because an edge that's not perfectly straight doesn't matter as much as it does for a plane, and because chisels can be buffed for longer (resulting in a straighter, more uniform edge) without any real drawbacks.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#10

Re: Some context

Mike In Los Angeles

Although I’m very tempted to lie, I’m going to admit that my chisel showed the blown edge on the back when I went to take photos for you. This is a beater Marples register chisel I chop with sometimes, I have really aggressive Lily White that I sharpen it on. I was surprised to see the back was so thrashed, it was just the one close at hand.

Still, this edge drama leads me to suspect I’m doing something in my sharpening that’s making it recur, I wonder if this is your case as well? I got the impression that it predates buffing for you? Turning over a blade to flip the burr and having it not flip is something that has driven me crazy, any insight is welcome.

Here’s what I’m using and what it looks like. That rubber block is for cleaning a loaded sanding wheel, I’m not sure what it’s called but that’s what I use.

55665-DF1-C122-417-F-9205-297-AC7616009

1148-CA2-E-72-BD-41-A3-8869-8-E210-D85430-F

796238-FE-4-C7-D-4020-844-A-1-F2-BB692-D62-C

869-DA400-EF4-B-4-C52-9474-2-EF228-CFD577

71-FC96-BD-1486-41-CC-8186-248950-E6-E640

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#11

A failed attempt

Winston

I tried using the yellow 5 micron JacksonLea compound (or, as David calls it, yellowcake), and it was a bust.

I used a modern Stanley block plane blade -- not fancy, and probably pretty soft. First I flattened it on a Shapton Pro 1000 and then Sigma Power 6000. (I made sure to dress the stones with a flat diamond plate first.)

Here's what it looked like. There's a visible line where the texture changes. I'm not sure what that is -- maybe where the heat treatment stopped? Interestingly, the side of the blade is darkened, but the dark part goes up another 3/4" or so. Maybe one line is where it was heated, and another was where it was quenched? I don't know.


I had a soft 3" buffing wheel that I charged with the yellow compound, and used it on the blade this way, for a total of probably around 1.5 to 2 minutes.


This is what the blade looked like after.


I apparently got too close to the edge, but it didn't really matter. When worked the blade on the stone again, I found that only a relatively small part of the center was raised enough to avoid the stone. This isn't enough to really improve sharpening time, and I think it would go away pretty quickly because it's quite shallow. This is what it looked like after hitting a Shapton 12k stone (note that the lighting makes the scratches look a lot deeper than they are).


So the 5 micron compound on the soft wheel didn't have enough cutting power to make much of a difference, and the soft wheel didn't let me control the positioning well enough to make a useful ura. Ideally I'd be able to prevent at least 80% of the blade from touching the stone, and hopefully more. This wasn't even close to that. For this to work, I'd need to use something far more aggressive.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#12

Re: Some context

Winston

Thanks for the pictures. I tell if there's any hollowing of the back, though. Did you do that to this chisel?

> Still, this edge drama leads me to suspect I’m doing something in my sharpening that’s making it recur, I wonder if this is your case as well? I got the impression that it predates buffing for you? Turning over a blade to flip the burr and having it not flip is something that has driven me crazy, any insight is welcome.

I never used a microscope before doing all this stuff with a buffing wheel, so I can't say for sure whether I had issues with a tiny remaining burr back then. (The stuff I can see with the microscope is much more detailed than what I was able to see previously, with a 30x loupe.) I previously used a bare leather strop after a Shapton Pro 12000 and that improved sharpness a bit (when I used a paper cutting test), which leads me to believe that I wasn't fully removing the burr before.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#13

Re: Side sharpening

Winston

> But getting down to the current matter.....side sharpening avoids running the edge directly into grit or slurry. Should work well for back flattening to the edge.

That may be the case... but I already use side-sharpening for the backs of blades, and I still get the little convex part near the edge. It's possible that it's caused mostly by abrasive wear from the wood shaving. Or, even with side-sharpening, there's still some slurry build-up right near the edge. If it's due to slurry, then oilstones would probably be better for avoiding the tiny convexity. (Of course, we know that a little convexity isn't bad in and of itself! The problem for me is that I think it's getting in the way of clean burr removal on the back side.)

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#14

Re: A failed attempt

David Weaver

220 grit psa roll with finger pressure right in the center of that raised area. Slow firm strokes (lots of pressure) all in the same direction (probably forward) to avoid rocking the iron.

Attack it with that until you get uniform scratches on a diagonal to the iron face, then rotate the iron slightly (20 degrees is enough and do a few strokes to ensure the pattern starts to switch across the entire face)

Then once it does, light figure 8s with finger pressure in the middle and you'll be able to go directly to a middle stone.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#15

Re: A failed attempt

Winston

I can imagine that working with the thin, soft Stanley blade. Do you think it would work with a thick blade as well?

(Even if this does work, it's questionable whether it will save any effort in the long run.)

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#16

this is a lie nielsen iron?

David Weaver

I can't remember which iron this is that we're talking about.

Any decent middle finishing stone will maintain the end of an iron unless the iron si bonkers hard....even then, I think the (back) edge of my chinese irons (bill tested one of the batch that I got somewhere around 65.5 hardness) is still maintained fine with a washita.

I think trouble comes at the edge with irons like this when the back work isn't done with finger pressure at the edge, because it's easier for the iron to somehow lift or roll or dub.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#17

Stanley iron

Winston

This particular blade is from a modern Stanley block plane. Thin and soft.

I'll try to take some pictures of the issue tomorrow. The problem is that, after minimal buffing of plane blades, the edge isn't quite straight and uniform (as viewed in the microscope), and this corresponds with a planed surface that isn't quite as good (but still very good!). I think the problem probably is caused by a bit of burr that's still hanging on when I go to the buffer. It's possible that improving my burr removal technique will make these problems go away.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#18

Re: Rotary tool?

Mike In Los Angeles

Winston, when you asked if I had a photo of the result I thought you meant after some hollowing and some lapping. Most of the hollowing is quickly removed on the coarse stone. When I hollow it out with the foredom, I’m hoping to just get rid of the belly and not leave a hollow that I’ll reach with future sharpening. So I hollow it real lightly, lap it until the hollow is gone or mostly gone, till I get the feeling I’ll be removing the last of my sanding marks when the edge clears up. Usually all the marks are gone by the time it’s honed. That chisel in the photos was one that still showed some hollowing marks and it wasn’t lapped very well.

I either didn’t get around to finishing it, or I’m reintroducing that back bevel somehow.

The process David describes is probably better, I’ve seen people use a magnet or a loop of frog tape to focus downward pressure on a belly. I’ve also seen people hit an iron with a hammer to work out a belly but that gave me a broken iron. If I didn’t have that foredom tool for my square job I wouldn’t get one. You could do it with sandpaper rubbed on the middle of the blade or a stone or anything.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#19

Re: Stanley iron

David Weaver

If the back is prepared without serrations going to the edge, the buffing serrations at the edge should be gone.

No need to do anything with the wire edge on the block plane, it'll just come off just like a chisel.

My 18 irons are made of cheese - they are *really* hard to get off of the irons hand honing just flipping an iron back and forth (which I am generally good at) because even the lightest honing of the bevel side on the washita cuts a little bit more of the edge and prolongs the burr.

It should be really quick to address if you can manage to find PSA roll and a surface to use it on. I've never been too sold on spray adhesive and paper, it never works as well as the psa roll, but have to admit that I can't find any inexpensive PSA roll on amazon right now (if you don't already have it - often there's sungold or some other off brand for about $11 or $12 for a roll, and it's something you'll find a use for sooner or later).

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#20

Re: Side sharpening

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Winston, this is the raison d'être for the Ruler Trick. Another alternative is a leather strop, since there is a minute amount of give.

I am trying to think why I do not have a problem with flat backs (there is an even polish across the back). I use either a flattened Sigma 13000 or an UF Spyderco followed by green compound on hardwood. The Sigmas get flattened frequently, while the Spyderco are checked a few times each year. I do lap the blades on the polishing stone after a wire is created, and this maintains the flat back.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#21

Re: Stanley iron

Mike In Los Angeles

Have you tried Supergrit for PSA?

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#22

Re: Stanley iron

David Weaver

It's about the same price ($16 for white, $21 for gold roll).

I've been there in person before :)

It's about 5 miles from my parents' house. I guess the reason I'm stingy is because amazon will sometimes have all of the typical stuff around $20 for a 4"x 10YD roll, and then something that's a deal for about half that or a little more.

(not easy to find anything there in person last I was there - it's a sea of stuff that makes my shop look pretty clean)

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#23

Re: Stanley iron

Robert Hazelwood

Are we just talking about the wear bevel here? That is technically a convexity right at the edge but not caused by stone technique, just by wear.

Honestly it's a pain to fully get rid of. The usual recommendation of only honing the back with a very fine finish stone is not going to get it done unless you are sharpening every few minutes and have no wear to remove. I have taken to using a slurried soft ark on most plane iron backs and it still takes longer than what David is describing in the Omnibus thread. I'm not really running the planes way beyond dull or anything, I use relatively thin shavings and resharpen whenever they don't stay in the cut perfectly.

You can also remove it by sharpening the bevel side more, but you have to sharpen it an awful lot more than is necessary and raise a huge burr.

Anyways if you don't get rid of the wear bevel you can't fully remove the burr using the conventional sharpening technique because on the back side the very edge will never touch the stone.

Practically speaking, I get as much of the burr off as I can on the arkansas stones and the strop seems to handle the rest, even if there is a little bit of wear bevel left.

So, if you need to remove the burr before buffing you might try stropping.

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#24

That pretty much covers it...

David Weaver

.if it takes a while longer than 20 seconds on a slurried arkansas stone, then it's probably a matter of how much pressure I'm using or how directed it is.

One of the things I wanted to make a point of (but have inconsistently) is how fast the methods are as faster leads to more likely being completed. But I'll admit I've never timed them before and have been a little bit surprised how much slower all of the waterstones are at removing the deep cap-iron induced wear in most irons than the washita is.

I've been using some of the irons shown in the pictures, so if the intervals would've come up short (i never sharpen until clearance problems are becoming evident), we'd see it in some of the pictures.

I believe the slurried translucent stone is about half as fast as the washita under a lot of pressure (lots of variables depending on what the iron is made of an how hard it is, but all of us will find tools that accommodate methods or methods that accommodate tools). I just finished all of the heavy planing that I'm likely to do in the next month and a half (work will be busy for a while), but will try to remember to address this the next time I have a dull iron - I'll count 10 seconds on the washita and we'll see what the result is.

10 on the washita would be at least 30 on an 8k stone, and seemingly more like a minute on something like the SP13k. 1 micron diamonds on cast (which are aggressive for their fineness) are also a lot slower than the washita. Half or a third as fast, and plane iron durability testing showed me that it took more time with them than expected to remove all visible signs of any wear).

Re: Creating a mini-ura with buffing wheel?

#25

Ruler trick

Winston

From what I've seen with the ruler trick, the little bevel on the back grows over time, which probably also means that it becomes less effective over time. And once you start, you can't stop unless you do a lot of work to get the back flat again. Those are my reservations about going the ruler trick route.