Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Mortise technique

Posts

Re: Mortise technique

#51

Re: incannel gouges

Steve Voigt

I don't mind elaborating, but there is not that much more to say…still, here are few random thoughts.

The oldest written source I know of on planemaking, Armour's "Practical Planemaking" (from around 1900), mentions using a gouge to chop the initial mortise. The reason is that a firmer gouge is to a chisel what a jack plane is to a try plane or jointer. The analogy is not perfect because gouges have many other uses, but many people overlook the gouge's ability to hog off material. It's not so much that it can take a bigger cut; it's that it can take a similar cut with much less effort.

For roughing, you want a very stout gouge, not a delicate carver's gouge. You can use either incannel or out, but as I said before, incannel is faster. There are tons of old American socket gouges that will work.

Re: Mortise technique

#52

Re: furniture mortises vs plane mortises etc

Steve Voigt

Wiley, this pic, from my talk at Williamsburg a couple years ago, is the only one I have. I just moved and all my tools are still packed, so it will be a while before I can take any other pics. This one doesn't show a lot but it shows the basic posture at least.


Re: Mortise technique

#53

Re: incannel gouges

Mike In Los Angeles

That part makes complete sense. I can’t imagine holding a gouge plumb and malleting straight down with it, is that what you do?

Re: Mortise technique

#54

From Steve’s post just below:

Wiley Horne

https://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/1/md/read/id/494574/sbj/furniture-mortises-vs-plane-mortises-etc/

Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#55

guessing at efficiency..

David Weaver

...I hadn't really thought about it with gouges, but two things come to mind as far as removing material where end grain is present - unlike mortising, they don't have to push grain off of the sides of a cut. They sever it instead of wedging it off - in all parts of the cut.

And, a good part of the severing cut is not across the to of the grain, but rather slicing through the grain at some diagonal. That's also better.

Knowing why isn't that important, though. I've thought about the diagonal bit before, but not the fact that the wedging requires breaking side grain off.

Re: Mortise technique

#56

Re: guessing at efficiency..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have never thought to use a gouge for morticing. Interesting!

By coincidence - before reading any post here - I honed/buffed a couple of Japanese out-cannel gouges and then tried them out. Wow! They have never cut as well before.

Last evening I finished up preparing a Fujikawa mortice chisel. It needed a lot of work flattening the back - lots of work on diamond plates and diamond paste. Eventually I could get to waterstones. I prefer to hone and use this chisel (as I do all my Japanese chisels) in the traditional manner, this being a straight bevel. I did drop the primary bevel from 35- to 30 degrees. A lot of work went into getting this blade as perfect as possible. It was honed to 13000 and then I attempted to pare Tassie Oak end grain. It did this reasonably but not as well as a bench chisel with the same 30 degree bevel. I went over to the buffer and firstly did a 2-second buff at the angle of the bevel, then raised the chisel about 10 degrees and buffed about 2 seconds more. Back at the Tassie Oak, the chisel now peeled off end grain shavings.

So, one question I am answering is that it is possible to get sharper edges using a power buffer (no surprise there), and that this process is very quick. I tried for years to do this on a Tormek hard leather wheel, without success. This soft wheel produces a better result and so much faster.

Regards from Perth

Derek