Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Mortise technique

Posts

Re: Mortise technique

#26

Re: Riding the bevel

Rafael E. Herrera

Hmmm, I'd call the one guy a little patronizing... come on Dave, just use your chisels :-).

In Cecil Pierce's book, Fifty years a planemaker and user, he noted that in the beginning he preferred certain Sheffield makers, over time he came to regard all of them equally well.

Re: Mortise technique

#27

Folsanbee central ‘V’

Tony Wilkins

There’s a YouTube video (on lie-Nielsen site) of Follansbee using the central ‘v’ method. I assume that’s his usual method, yes? That, to me, creates a whole different dynamic. He’s constantly flipping the chisel to create the v shape and the angle he’s using for the bevel to the wood becomes more steep (more up and down) as he moves towards the ends of the mortise.

Hopefully this doesn’t muddle the conversation but thought it might be helpful to poin5 out the difference in method.

Re: Mortise technique

#28

Re: Terminology?

Rafael

The one term I learned recently was that the face of the cutting tool opposite to the bevel is the "front" or "face" of the tool.

Re: Mortise technique

#29

Re: Factory?

Steve Voigt

Bill, I don't know what you mean by "factory." Until the 1820s here, and WWII England, joiners and cabinetmakers mostly worked in small shops, not factories. Furniture and millwork made in factories is made by machine, and not relevant to Wiley's question.

Wiley gave a good answer to your question; I'll just reiterate and extend. We study old methods, as in Roubo or Nicholson, because it provides clues to how things were done when everything had to be done by hand, and a mortising machine was simply not an option.Twentieth century texts on hand tool work are rife with misinformation because they were often written by people who didn't actually work by hand much. So if one wants to work by hand, it's better to go back to sources from before the machine tool era.

Re: Mortise technique

#30

The flip...

David Weaver

.not that you need to know it, but for anyone wondering...

If the bevel is being ridden and the sides of the mortise are clear, handle pushed toward waste side a little (which sounds pointless, but it helps the next), chisel lifted from the cut a tiny bit, then handle pushed back toward the uncut waste and pulled up.

The art of this is pushing the chisel toward the waste side enough to loosen things just a little, but not enough to break the shaving and have it topple down into the mortise.

If a chisel is inaccurately made, all of this stuff doesn't happen that easily. Even when it does work well, from a bunch of cutting of deep mortises today, the chisel gets pretty warm. Not hot, but interestingly warm.

Re: Mortise technique

#31

Re: same geometry, different approach

Steve Voigt

What Folansbee is doing is not that different from what most of us are describing. He turns the chisel the other way (bevel faces toward him when he's working toward the far side of the mortise), but he also angles it at about 60°, so he's accomplishing the same geometry by different means. He even says in his video that the bevel should be plumb...so he's riding the back instead of the bevel. He's still sliding down a 60-ish ramp.

It's true he changes direction more often, but that is the least important part of the process in my opinion. It's just a preference, one that doesn't have much impact on how long the mortise will take.

Re: Mortise technique

#32

Re: Terminology?

Wiley Horne

Hi Steve,

Word pictures are tough sometimes. So here is my understanding of how ‘riding the bevel’ gets started:

1. Vertical strikes about 1/8” from the ends, with the chisel face (the back) toward the end of the mortise (whichever end you’re starting from):


2. The vertical strike makes a stopping point. Now work back from the vertical strike, maybe in 3/16” steps, making successive strikes with the chisel angled say 60 degrees from horizontal, the bevel down, the strike toward the waste, the face of the chisel also toward the waste:


That’s my interpretation. All corrections appreciated!

Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#33

P. S. With appreciation to Winston Chang

Wiley Horne

for programming a photo resizer for us!

Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#34

Photo resizer app

Winston

I'm glad you're putting it to good use!

For those that may have missed it, it's a web app for easily resizing photos to a file size where they can be uploaded to these forums.

https://winston.shinyapps.io/image_resizer/

Re: Mortise technique

#35

Re: Terminology?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We continue to hold the chisel vertical. The bevel is what causes the chisel to ramp down a 60 degree slope; we don't need to angle the entire chisel.

Incidentally, I had commented some years ago about Roubo's worker standing somewhat away from the chisel, but I did not realize until today that Roubo also makes this point in his commentary. Hovering over the chisel is tiring and does not help the results.

Re: Mortise technique

#36

Re: Terminology?

Wiley Horne

Thanks Warren. That’s a big help. Vertical is going to get there faster.

Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#37

Re: Mortise technique

Don Stephan

Got to be a new world record for the number of posts in one thread in just over 14 hours.

Re: Mortise technique

#38

Re: same geometry, different approach

John Aniano in central NJ

Steve,

I looked at both of Peter Follansbee's two books (the joint stool book and his newest Joiners Work) and he describes his mortising method pretty much as it was described above. And the method obviously works. However...

If one is riding the chisel's flat face down on the ~60 degree slope, the diagonal side shearing/paring won't occur as well as if riding the bevel down, as I described further down in this thread. Especially if the chisel cross section is tapered. If the cross section is parallel, the shearing could occur, if the construction of the tool is not laminated. Most of my mortise chisels are laminated, so the high quality steel is along the flat face.

Does it matter? That remains to be seen. I think that the bevel riding method might produce a cleaner side to the resulting mortise. In my opinion (and experience) when working with a tool, any tool, on a skewed diagonal, there are benefits in terms of producing a more flat surface. Not always, but often.

John

Re: Mortise technique

#39

Another nifty behavior from pigstickers

David Weaver

The tall cross section chisels have another nifty trick at the ends of mortises. They can take a mortise end to vertical in almost one pass by driving the chisel in, rocking it up a little bit, and then rotating. A huge amount of material can be removed at once in one progressive pass.

Re: Mortise technique

#40

Agree with John

Wiley Horne

Peter Follansbee is a master craftsman, deserving of all respect, so his procedures certainly work for him.

i do the central V by riding the bevel—the bevel is driving the face, rather than the face driving the bevel. You keep the shearing action of the chisel face, rather than giving it up. This is so fundamental.

However. In my hands, the central V makes it more difficult to start and keep the mortise plumb and dead straight, than if I do the Roubo method described by Warren, and remove the waste in, say, 3 lifts or courses.

You can ride the bevel in either technique, so that is not what differentiates the methods. But I find that going full depth in the middle before getting the mortise framed in, as you do with the Roubo method, it is very very easy for 1 or 2 cuts in that big V to get slightly out of line. Then when you true it up, you’ve slightly wallowed out the mortise. Whereas, I find it just easier to keep control and avoid errant strikes with the Roubo method.

Intuitively, I’m drawn to the V, because it seems like it should be faster. But the Roubo approach—in my hands!—makes for a tighter mortise.

Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#41

Re: Making deep mortises and paying attention

Alan S

Do we need 27 8x10 colored photographs with circles and arrows, and a paragraph on the back of each one explaining how you're mortising?

Re: Mortise technique

#43

Re: furniture mortises vs plane mortises etc

Steve Voigt

John and Wiley,

I understand what you're saying, but in practice, levering the chisel to clear chips will accomplish the same thing. I know if I'm cutting a furniture mortise, every speck of mortise wall gets scraped more than once during the process.

For me, the main reason to keep the chisel vertical is that it makes it easier to avoid tilting the chisel right or left and screwing up the width. Again, that's for a furniture mortise.

One advantage of Follansbee's approach is that you can deliver more power when the mallet strike is in line with the direction the chisel moves. So this is my approach when the walls are going to be pared and perpendicularity is not as essential…for example, in planemaking.

I started out mortising bench planes with a chisel, bevel down (like I'd do a furniture mortise). I later switched to roughing out with an outcannel gouge; that was a modest improvement. Finally I switched to an incannel gouge, used the way Follansbee uses a chisel, and that was better still. It's just faster. So, different approaches suit different situations.

Re: Mortise technique

#44

Re: Making deep mortises and paying attention

david charlesworth

Enjoyed Alan's reference to Alice's restaurant......

David

Re: Mortise technique

#45

Re: furniture mortises vs plane mortises etc

Mike In Los Angeles

I started out mortising bench planes with a chisel, bevel down (like I'd do a furniture mortise). I later switched to roughing out with an outcannel gouge; that was a modest improvement. Finally I switched to an incannel gouge, used the way Follansbee uses a chisel, and that was better still. It's just faster. So, different approaches suit different situations.

I’m really interested in learning more about what you’re saying, if you’re inclined to elaborate. Might need it’s own thread or might not? I don’t make furniture or planes, but the kind of mortising I do seems to be more like what you are describing in a plane mouth.

Is this something you’d be interested to describe more?

Re: Mortise technique

#46

incannel gouges

David Weaver

When I had to trim end grain on the last case, I found an incannel gouge miles easier through end grain. I have no idea why they are like that. The whole unicorn thing came out of trying to find a way to keep the gouge in shape with supreme sharpness without much effort.

For anyone who hasn't cut across end grain with an incannel gouge, you can literally take a crank neck gouge and just push it across hardwood end grain. A chisel of any width, not even close.

Re: Mortise technique

#47

Re: incannel gouges

Mike In Los Angeles

I have been really enamored with the ones I have, and started the process of switching some outcannel gouges that were doubles to incannel. I agree about paring endgrain, it’s also nice to have some with the wings ground back a little and some ground as square as I can make them.

I hadn’t thought about mortising with them, that’s why I was asking Steve to flesh out the idea.

Re: Mortise technique

#48

Re: furniture mortises vs plane mortises etc

Wiley Horne

Steve,

I don’t question a result somebody got to the hard way. Especially if you and Follansbee arrived at the same place.

Can you show photo of the application?

Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#49

Re: incannel gouges

David Weaver

Neither have I, and I think Steve mentioned to me previously how useful they are for inside work in planes.

I'm slow.

IT is useful inside a plane, though, to have something almost flat that wouldn't scratch one side of the cut or another.

Re: Mortise technique

#50

Re: incannel gouges

Mike In Los Angeles

IT is useful inside a plane, though, to have something almost flat that wouldn't scratch one side of the cut or another.

Blunt gouge?