Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Mortise technique

Posts

Mortise technique

#1

Mortise technique

Wiley Horne—So. Cal.

Hi all,

We are enjoying a long thread on mortise chisel geometry elsewhere on this page.

I would like to take a step back, and ask what we know about mortising technique from the hand tool era. After all, the working methods of the artisans in any era would inform the geometry of the tools.

So, what early accounts do we have of mortising technique. Moxon (who was not a tradesman) describes a method quite opposite to riding the bevel. He says to start at one end of the mortise, and to start 1/8” from one end, then the other, with the bevel away from you and the handle slightly toward you, to make the strike. Start from the ends and work toward the middle. In Moxon’s account, the bevel is directly bearing on the chip, with the chisel face following behind. It seems odd, especially since the chisel would be relieved in depth, and so you want the face to be leading and severing the fibers.

Does Roubo go into mortise technique? Or Nicholson?

As a speculation, if the prevailing technique were to start in the middle and make a V to depth, and then widen the V to the ends, one could imagine that penetration would be paramount, and call for long acute bevels. If the typewriter method were more common, perhaps geometry would more favor chip ejection.

Anyway, what do the ancients say? Or do they say?

Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#2

How to tie shoes...

David Weaver

...the mortise discussion is one to be careful with!!

There's a little bit of passive aggressive stuff on the UK forum, but less than most places.

But a discussion of the fastest way to do mortises turned into outright war. It could've been turned into a folk song like the Alice's Restaurant.

There were drill bitters, bench chiselers, side parers, baby killers, father beaters.......and I told them that I like to use only the chisel and kill, kill, kill the wood...and they said "you're our boy".

....and now the earworm of the melody from Alice's Restaurant is stuck in my head for the rest of the day.

Re: Mortise technique

#3

Moxon

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Joseph Moxon wrote a series of articles on the trades which were later published as two volumes. The article on Joinery is unfortunately the weakest of the set. Carpentry, Smithing, and Turning are all more comprehensive; Printing, the trade that Moxon learned in his youth, is the longest.

In the middle of Joinery are two strange sections. The first is how to true up a piece of stuff. Instead of something like 1x3 or 1x16 or 2x2 two or three feet long, like we might expect for a joiner, he describes truing up a "quarter" which is 2x4 seven feet long. Quarter is a carpentry term. The next section is mortising where Moxon describes making a mortise , again in a quarter (2x4). The mortise is one inch wide and is made on the broad surface of the timber, so there is 1 1/4 or 1 1/1/2 inches on either side.

This is not the kind of mortise we usually see in joinery work; we would want to hear how they made a mortise for a table leg or a door stile. And Moxon himself describes a mortise chisel as narrow chisel that is thicker than it is wide, not something that is an inch wide.

I believe Moxon, realizing that his Joinery article was weak, took these two sections from Carpentry, where they would be a better fit, and used them to beef up the Joinery section. He made a lame excuse why he chose to put Joinery before Carpentry, then in the carpentry section says see joinery for mortising, not acknowledging there might be a difference in approach.

Re: Mortise technique

#4

Difference for Cabinetmaking

David Weaver

Seeing the older references for cabinetmaking and joinery where the oval bolstered types were labeled in some sales lists as "Best joiner and cabinet mortising chisels" was a little surprising.

There must have been some difference in technique for deep mortises vs. something more typical for cabinets and doors. If not in technique, equipment.

If I had been sold expensive oval bolstered mortise chisels in those days with the gradual primary shown in some older drawings, I would've been pretty unhappy about it. Cutting a mortise on a 2" door stile is difficult, let alone smaller things.

This is just my opinion, but on smaller mortises, neatness rules and early chisel rotation and a predictable smaller cross section (sash mortise, not bevel edge bench chisels) dominates. The cross section is a nice size on sash chisels to register well and not create too much friction, and the chisels rotate well without much depth. One back and forth (if someone starts at one end and always works bevel down) and the mortise is done without issues of getting to depth or working deep.

But once the mortise gets deeper than an inch and a half or two, the oval bolstered chisels work extremely well, and someone somewhere must've determined that a taller cross section works really well for deep rotation (rounded top or not). Riding the full bevel creates a lot of friction when it's that long, and the bevels in some drawings would never hold up in a mortise. It still needs to be relatively neat, but there's so much material removal that quick neatness is probably less important than reducing the friction on the bevel and getting good deep rotation (Which is easier to do with a longer bevel than it is a shorter steeper bevel).

Once mortises get wider than about 3/4ths of an inch, I have no experience, so I'd defer elsewhere, but the oval bolstered chisels seem better for joiners.

I'd bet there are a lot of RAy Iles mortise chisels that are bought and tried and then put aside for smaller mortise chisels. Why would I guess that? I ended up doing that, and then selling those chisels. I have the I sorby chisel set just because I adore them, but the occasion to cut mortises deep enough where they separate themselves from smaller chisels is pretty rare. And I'm not surprised to see sets of a lot of them with some showing the rounded bevel gone or mangled, and others showing factory finish full length, over the edge and only part of the bevel looking like it's ever been steepened - never enough to necessitate addressing the original primary.

Re: Mortise technique

#5

Re: Mortise technique

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am curious why anyone but a historian would be interested in how a factory in some way past time and place did hand tool woodworking. Given the multitude of variables that differ between this setting and the situation today I don't see these historical accounts of more than a curiosity, and certainly not a useful guide, even if they were accurate and depicted practices widely practiced at that time, both doubtful assumptions. What would be historically interesting would be equivalent documentation of a Colonial, British and German factory. I predict the differences in the details would be substantial.

What could be useful today would be for someone to describe what the Irion factory did. Here was a modern factory putting product out the door with a lot of hand tool work. Their techniques would have been efficient and reliable and in a setting and with tools more resembling our shops.

What would be practical for someone needing to make a mortise would be to ask any of the modern Period Furniture makers.

Re: Mortise technique

#6

Re: How to tie shoes...

Sgian Dubh

"There's a little bit of passive aggressive stuff on the UK forum, but less than most places.

But a discussion of the fastest way to do mortises turned into outright war."

That's interesting because I frequent that forum and didn't notice a morticing discussion turning "passive aggressive". Maybe I didn't look at the discussion at all, or if I did look, perhaps I simply skimmed through the thread and missed the nuanced aggression - I'm not the most avid reader and contributor to hand tool discussions.

Still, I do undertake hand morticing from time to time simply because it's sometimes quicker to simply bash out a mortice or two by hand in preference to setting up some sort of machine. Back in the 1960s and 70s I used to do a lot of hand morticing, as well as almost all other joinery, and that was when I was at school working in the school woodworking shop, and after that for the first few weeks and months of my training as a furniture maker.

Almost all the hand morticing I've ever undertaken has been for furniture and joinery items, in the latter case primarily items such as architectural doors and windows, so bashing holes in green 8X8 oak stuff and the like is outside my normal area of work. So, the following is a brief description of what I was taught as a method, and still use today, probably unchanged, when the need arises. I'm certainly not going to say it's the definitive and only 'right' method, but it works.

First, define the the width of the mortice using a mortice gauge set just a hair or two wider than the chisel, e.g., for a 12 mm chisel, set the gauge pins straddling the chisel a bit sloppily, maybe something like 12.25 or 12.5 mm. The length of the mortice is best marked with a knife rather than a pencil because it gives a crisp entry point for the chisel tip.

Set the part to be morticed above a bench leg if possible, and clamp it in place. With the bevel of the chisel facing towards the mortice's mid-length, set the cutting edge ~2 - 6 mm in from the knifed length of the mortice, and gently mallet the chisel to cut 2 - 3 mm deep. Repeat for the other end, then work along the mortice's length in a series of similar cross-grain chops back towards the first cut. Pick out the severed wood leaving behind a shallow groove that should have reasonably defined the mortice's width and length.

After that, with the the chisel about at the mortice's mid-length chop in vertically, but not too deep and lever out the waste using the chisel's bevel. Then maybe make two or three further chops, but now with the chisel leaning over towards the bevelled side and with each chop work towards the mortice end. Then turn the chisel around and chop along the other half of the mortice's length using the bevel to lever out as before. That's about it really. Keep chopping and levering out waste switching the chisel back and forth from time to time along the mortice length until the required depth is achieved. At some point, the chisel's bevelled side will want to start crushing the grain at the ends of the mortice as waste is levered out, but by this point the mortice should have been excavated to the necessary depth, or thereabouts, leaving a space for waste to be pushed into as vertical chops are taken with the flat side of the chisel working towards the mortice ends. There might, or might not be a bit of side wall paring required to get the mortice cut to the correct width.

Is this the 'correct' historical way to chop mortices by hand? I've no idea, but it works for me, and it seemed to work for the old farts that taught me the methodology forty or fifty+ years ago, and I guess they learnt it or adapted the method from old farts they were taught by forty or fifty years before that, and so on going back who knows how far. Slainte.

Re: Mortise technique

#7

Re: Moxon

Wiley Horne

Warren,

Thank you, very interesting history. Do you mind looking to see whether either Roubo or Nicholson discuss mortising?

Thank you, Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#8

Re: Mortise technique

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

Matter of fact, I am interested in history, because that can inform us how work was done by people whose daily bread depended on how efficiently they could do this work that we are now re-enacting. Plus, I like history in general—did I recommend to you Grant, by Jean Edward Smith, and Washington by Chernow?

Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#9

passive aggressive....

David Weaver

This is not an indictment of the UK forum, rather a mention that there's only "a little bit of this". As in, most topics don't create the "you have no idea what you're talking about and you've been doing it a stupid way your whole life" response.

There's less of that over there. I sometimes notice when users pick at each other and there are a few folks over there like that, but again, less than american forums.

There are also more folks over there who worked as apprentices at some point and were told how to mortise, and seemingly wouldn't have had the opportunity to try a bunch of things. With the benefit of lack of variety or trial comes clearer certainty that what you're doing is the best.

I follow laziness. sometimes laziness isn't the easiest for a given task, but sets up the next thing as easier to do - collective constructive laziness to a given standard.

Even this can be errant if discretion is wrong.

Re: Mortise technique

#10

George Wilson would approve...

David Weaver

..one of my first discussions with George was about his disdain for people who think they're great designers without having ever learned to copy good designs first to understand them.

I may have butchered that slightly, but one looking for the most likely solution would first look to a time when economic outcome was determined by the method applied.

Re: Mortise technique

#11

Re: Mortise technique - an observation...

John Aniano in central NJ

Wiley, et. al.,

Something I've been thinking about, what with all the mortise chisel discussions now. I can't quote any historical source, this is just an observation from cutting 16 mortises when making a joint stool...

If one assumes that the bevel is ridden downward into the mortise, if the edges of the chisel face are sharp, they would diagonally scrape/pare the sides of the resulting mortise as it cuts. If the chisel cross section is slightly trapezoidal, i.e., wider at the face than at the rear, this would facilitate this diagonal paring/scraping action.

Conversely, if the chisel is driven directly downward, there would be less or no paring as described above that would be possible because of the geometry. Again, if the cross section is trapezoidal, this side taper would preclude the paring/scraping action.

Just my two cents...

John

Re: Mortise technique

#12

What mattered to clients...

Jim Matthews

...may not be what mattered to the makers.

Builders of things always balance sales price against production costs.

Remaining examples of antique furnishings were the expensive pieces the sellers could justify expending more shop time (and finer materials), recouped in the sale.

I suppose mortising approaches were based on getting it done, not for aesthetics.

I admire honest joinery, built to tight tolerances.

Re: Mortise technique

#13

Re: passive aggressive....

Sgian Dubh

David, I forgot to mention that more often than not because I tend to work mostly on a lighter furniture scale, e.g., digging out a relatively small mortice for, let's say, a cabinet rail that's something like 60 mm wide X maybe 18 - 20 thick (with a tenon maybe 8 -9 mm thick X ~40 mm long, plus a square haunch going into a similarly fairly dainty female part, e.g., a leg maybe 40 - 60 mm square, I usually don't even use a mortice chisel morticing. Mortice chisels for small stuff tend to be a bit over-the-top I find, and cumbersome, with a tendency to bruise mortice ends too much, and I tend to choose in preference a plain old firmer chisel, and even a bevel edged chisel to do the job.

Bigger stuff, architectural door mortices, for example were generally attacked with mortice chisels. There was more mortice length and width (~12 mm typically) to play with, plus mortices went deeper, frequently right through material that is around 100- 115 mm wide. Incidentally, I can't recall how many decades ago it was I last hand chopped architectural door mortices, maybe as long ago as the mid 1970s - morticing machines are quicker, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Mortise technique

#14

Re: Mortise technique

Warren in Lancaster, PA

What could be useful today would be for someone to describe what the Irion factory did. Here was a modern factory putting product out the door with a lot of hand tool work. Their techniques would have been efficient and reliable and in a setting and with tools more resembling our shops.

I have been in the old Irion shop in Christiana. They had a large bench room with partitions for about 10 guys along the walls with a large central isle, and a large machine room in the back. I am sure they used machinery to make mortises, but I don't remember specifics. Their idea was to make something by machine and then go back and cover all their tracks with hand work. I know six guys who worked there; I have done turning and carving for two of them.

What would be practical for someone needing to make a mortise would be to

ask any of the modern Period Furniture makers.

Which is what you did on July 10 2012 when you emailed me about making mortises. I wrote back five paragraphs. You tried it and thanked me.

Re: Mortise technique

#15

Roubo

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Roubo did not bore out the waste, did not use a pilot hole, and did not use the V method.

Roubo used a fixed pin mortising gauge, so a different gauge for each chisel, which is most accurate. He started the mortise at the near end with the bevel away and chopped straight down. Then he gradually moved the chisel toward the far end riding the bevel. Then he turned the chisel around and gradually moved toward the near end, still riding the bevel. He occasionally used some sort of grease to lubricate the chisel.

This is just about the method Daniel O'Hagan taught me in 1978. He called it the "California Method"

Here is an engraving of Roubo's chisel and a fellow mortising. Note upright relaxed posture, short handled mallet, left hand on the chisel handle, left arm rather extended.


Re: Mortise technique

#16

Re: Roubo

David Weaver

This is the method that laziness has brought me to. It works well. Out and back riding the bevel. I'd bet roubo was greasing the bevel. I have also mortised with a width tapered firmer. They work far more easily but leave a slightly less clean mortise. I doubt it matters as plenty of beginners will rough up the sides of a mortise and never make one that actually fails

Re: Mortise technique

#17

Riding the bevel

Wiley Horne

Now I’m not sure I understand what ‘riding the bevel’ means. I had thought it meant (1) bevel somewhat down in the cut, (2) face of the chisel facing the chip, (3) at the strike, bevel being down forces the chisel face forward, shearing the side walls and creating the chip. Chisel being relieved in its depth eases the shearing action of the face of the chisel.

Is this right or exactly wrong?

Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#18

your observations are correct...

David Weaver

..it's harder to get a chisel driven straight down out of the cut, or pushed forward and back to free.

I have a champion socket mortise chisel - it's 1/4th wide, and already 3/8ths tall just at the tip - and then tapers thicker in height. It is almost a dandy cabinetmaker's mortise chisel for bevel riding except....

...the sides are parallel. It's horrid. I will fix it. (the other interesting thing about this american socket mortise chisel is that whoever had it before me decided that they should round over the top of the chisel. I'm supposing that this was done by a user based on bruising mortises or not liking the action deep in the cut. It could've come that way, but it's been used enough that such a thing can't be guessed at. Interesting, too, is the factory did chose to bevel the top corners of the chisels, similar to the round over for the law chisels on Joel's site. They must've thought it would help).

I also had a miyanaga mortise chisel (6mm, pretty much square in cross section) that didn't have enough taper and though I got it used, they are fairly expensive. I didn't have the heart to grind it back and potentially ruin the value of the set. In making face frames for my kitchen, I managed to break it at the lamination just in normal work. I sold the remainder of the set noting that they'd be better corrected. Someone still bought them.

Back to your original point. The chisels just seem to work better if ridden down on the bevel, and some of that is probably because they're scraping the sides as they travel.

Re: Mortise technique

#19

Re: passive aggressive....

David Weaver

Being no historical reader, my understanding is that the square sided English firmers are actually intended for that.

Re: Mortise technique

#20

Re: Riding the bevel

David Weaver

I think that's pretty much it.

Re: Mortise technique

#21

Re: Riding the bevel

Rafael E. Herrera

I also get lost when certain trade names are used. It'd be appreciated if plain descriptive terminology is used for those of us not so knowledgeable or whose first language is not English.

By the way, which UK forum?

Re: Mortise technique

#22

Re: Riding the bevel

David Weaver

uk workshop. It's a good forum, but the hand tool side is kind of dead for its size.

Little discussion of building things occurs there and the ongoing theme is the opposite of here (finding car boot tools for a few bucks rather than pondering which boutique tools to buy).

Think of riding the bevel as follows (I found it hard to figure out, and peoples' use of terms like "face into the cut" didn't help): you're striking the chisel so that it's traveling diagonally through the wood rather than straight in. The bevel of the chisel is against the side of the cut that's not yet been wasted out. It looks like you're attempting to hammer the bevel of the chisel through the not-yet-cut part, but it moves diagonally, of course, because following the sharp edge is easier.

Instead of going straight in, as it's moving through the depth of the wood diagonally, the sides of the chisel (Which are wider at the bottom in most cases) are also cleaning off the sides of the mortise.

Re: Mortise technique

#23

Making deep mortises and paying attention

David Weaver

I just cut four deep mortises in cherry 3 1/2 inches by 2 inches (Which is deep compared to what I'd normally do).

The oval bolstered chisels definitely separate themselves from everything else for two reasons:

* only a small part of the bevel is in contact with the uncut side of the wood, but the cross section is thick. It's just easier pull the chisel forward and then rotate the chips out in a nice neat stack. There's much less cleaning of anything else.

* with a tall cross section, you can get rougher with them and take more wood at once without having alignment issues. They will take an uncomfortable amount of wood at once and rotate it out

Cutting three mortises in a row makes the chisel warm. I also noticed that whatever is occurring at the tip causes some of the wood to "glue" itself to the bevel side of the chisel. There was a fair amount of mineral/pitch pocketing in the piece of wood that I mortised, so that may have skewed it.

This is done with one of the sorby chisels that I pictured. They are crisp along the bottom edge and leave a very clean mortise. They are only very slightly wider at the cutting edge than the bolster (A few hundredths of an inch, but deliberately made so).

Re: Mortise technique

#24

Re: Roubo

Wiley Horne

Warren,

Thank you very much! I appreciate your comments on the joiner’s mallet having a short handle, and especially noting the posture of the worker, relaxed and standing back where he can get a good sense of ‘vertical’. As an aside, I have noticed that sawing goes best when you’re relaxed and standing back a bit—the big picture is better than up close and straining.

Thanks again, Wiley

Re: Mortise technique

#25

Re: Terminology?

Steve Voigt

Wiley, I'm sure you're doing it right, but I can't tell because your terminology is confusing the heck out of me. I don't know what "bevel down" means when the chisel is vertical. I don't know what side of the chisel is the "face;" I've never heard that term before. I'm not even sure what direction "forward" is in this context. Not trying to be dense, just don't get it.

I think the way Warren explained it is super clear. If you start the mortise at the near end, the bevel faces away from you. If you start at the far end, the bevel faces towards you. That's riding the bevel. The bevel creates a 60°-ish ramp that the chisel slides down, like a kid on a playground slide.

I think anyone who mortises without pre-drilling will land on this method. Follansbee flips the chisel around, but he also holds it at around 60°, so he gets the same geometry by different means.

The technique itself is rather basic. More interesting is learning to master the lever-and-flick that pops the waste free.