Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Yet another chisel edge test

Posts

Yet another chisel edge test

#1

Yet another chisel edge test

Winston

Many of my previous posts focused on pictures of what a chisel edge looks like with different treatments, but this time I did a controlled test of chopping, similar to what David has done. The short version is that the edge durability that I got was extremely impressive -- better than I thought I would get.

Note that I've put this information plus a lot more pictures at https://chisel-chop-test.netlify.app/. There are pictures of the edge as the test progressed, so you can see how the edge gradually gets damaged. Well, you can see how the flat-sharpened edge gets damaged. The buffed edge looks essentially unchanged throughout the test. Please bear in mind that the content there isn't permanent; it will change in the future as I test out more things, and the URL will change as well.

For these tests, I used a 3/4" Buck Brothers chisel from Home Depot. At $21 for a set of three, this is a cheap chisel. In the past when I've used it, I've been kind of surprised at how quickly the edge gives out. I don't think it's a bad chisel for the price; it's that just I've gotten used to my nice chisels.

I compared this chisel with two sharpening methods. For the first test, I used a flat 30-degree bevel, sharpened up to a 12000 grit Shapton Pro stone using a honing guide. For the next test, I sharpened it with a 30-degree bevel on a 1000 grit Shapton Pro, then I buffed the chisel for about 10 seconds using a drill with a 4" spiral-sewn buffing wheel and white rouge compound. I also ran the back of the chisel on the side/corner of the buffing wheel (avoiding the buffing compound) for about 1 second to remove any possible burr. (An aside: I find that I have to charge the buffing wheel fairly frequently, like every few sharpenings. Also, I don't claim that the white rouge is the ideal compound to use -- it's just the first compound I used, and the finest, so I've been sticking with it for now.)

I chopped a 1/2" wide, 3/4" thick piece of soft maple 20 times, taking off a 1/16" slice each time. Here's what the chopping test looks like:




The "edge" images below are taken looking straight at the edge, with the back of the chisel parallel to the axis of the lens. You can see the bevel in the images, but the reason you can't see scratches is because the depth of field with the microscope is so shallow, so they're blurred out. The edge-on images were taken using a 45-degree mirror under the scope, with a small light held in the same plane as the chisel back.


Here's what the flat-honed chisel looked like, with views of the bevel, back, and edge. It's not the best edge I've gotten off of the Shapton 12000, but it's probably representative of when I'm sharpening normally and not putting in the effort to get a perfect edge.


And this is what the buffed (AKA unicorn) chisel looked like:


This is the flat-honed chisel looked like after chopping off 20 pieces:


And the buffed edge after chopping off 20 pieces:


This is a huge, huge improvement over the flat-honed chisel. There is essentially no visible damage to the chisel, even with the microscope. I swear that I actually did all the same chopping for both test runs. I can tell by feel and by shaving that it's not quite as sharp as it was to start with, but we're talking going from extremely sharp (able to cut hairs without contacting skin), to just really sharp (able to shave hair just fine).

This is a picture of the profile of the chisel. There's a part that looks like it's hooked below the flat back of the chisel, but I think that's just an artifact of the lighting.


Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#2

This kind of confirmation is invaluable...

David Weaver

...I have no idea what ideas thrown out are just stupid or aren't as easy to communicate until they're replicated.

I found those buck brothers chisels really "Rubbery" feeling but when I had them, I rounded the edges over in a much longer roundover bevel (probably a sold 16th of an inch or more) and they then held up OK, but I didn't get the subtlety at that point of being able to do very little to get them to hold up (and they were tough business through softwood because of the wedging of the bigger roundover).

On the chisels traditionally having a bigger roundover at the tip, like the pigstickers, I think they were actually intended to be used bevel down and that roundover was ridden. The UK guys say they were production tools, and my use of them also suggests that a large full bevel makes a lot of friction that's not encountered in smaller tools. I thought that the roundover was for sharpening ease (afield) and to prevent damage only, but I think that's not correct - so when I imitated it to limit damage, the result was a chisel that acted like it had a big bevel (separate and aside, when the rounded bevel gets to the point that it's a 16th of an inch or more, it's not hard to ride it.

So, I see this type of bevel everywhere but would've guessed that it's been sussed into the lower effort like this only by some carvers who use buffers and will eventually get to it because it's just less work to use the tools with it, and while we don't like chipping, it's intolerable for carving unless you really love scraping and sanding things and adding a lot of time to the work.

I posted a video of unicorning a plane iron and one of the comments already is from someone who isn't happy about having just bought shapton stones to use and take much more time. With some talking and refreshing an iron that really was ready for a regrind, I think the total process was about a minute 5 or a minute and 10 seconds. When I sharpen with a washita only and strop, I think that's about a similar time expenditure but there's less chance of finding any unremoved nicks with the unicorn method since it pushes a small layer of metal off that would be unlikely to be addressed with stones.

Is the last picture of the bevel before or after chiseling? I found the rubbery steel on those buck brothers chisels relatively compliant to bending uniformly at the edge of the chisel without really sustaining too much damage. It could almost just be realigned.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#3

Re: This kind of confirmation is invaluable...

Winston

> Is the last picture of the bevel before or after chiseling? I found the rubbery steel on those buck brothers chisels relatively compliant to bending uniformly at the edge of the chisel without really sustaining too much damage. It could almost just be realigned.

It was from before chiseling. I'm quite sure the part that sticks down below the plane of the chisel back wasn't actually there, and that it's just something weird about the way I took the picture.

For this profile picture, I also used the 45-degree mirror and handheld the light. The exact positioning of the light makes a big difference in the appearance of the picture. I think that the plane of the chisel back may not have been quite parallel to the lens axis, and the part that looks like a hook may actually be the cutting edge receding into the distance, slightly askew. With the very shallow depth-of-field from the microscope, sometimes the pictures have artifacts that behave in ways that we're not used to seeing. I probably should have tried to take a better picture, rather than post one that's a bit off and then try to explain it.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#4

perfect pictures..

David Weaver

trying to get perfect pictures is torture. Good pictures with accommodating commentary to tell people what matters in the picture is all you need.

There's an aspect of visual lighting, then dimensional orientation (you can see how wide scratches are or damage, but then what if it's deeper in some spots than others), and then the software interpretation of what's shown.

I think your pictures tell the story great. face-on view is probably hard to get perfect without some software that takes various layers and puts them together or a really expensive high magnification scope with a deep field of view, and then I don't think most will interpret it. This test is idea for bevel and back side pictures as they show damage in from the end based on different light deflection or metal that's completely removed.

The pictures in the maple tell the story so clearly that I think most people will find the results hard to believe, especially if they've ever used stanley 60 or buck brothers chisels of that type with a flat bevel.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#5

Re: perfect pictures..

Winston

> The pictures in the maple tell the story so clearly that I think most people will find the results hard to believe, especially if they've ever used stanley 60 or buck brothers chisels of that type with a flat bevel.

I agree, I would find it hard to believe if I hadn't done the test myself! Hopefully the pictures tell a pretty convincing story, and hopefully others will try it out and find that yes, it really makes that much of a difference.

I think my next test will be a flat-honed PM-V11 chisel. I also want to compare a buffed PM-V11 chisel. I'd expect it to last longer than the buffed Buck Brothers chisel, but I don't think my test procedure could demonstrate that, since that chisel was essentially undamaged in the test.

I think I have been buffing these chisels more successfully than the first ones that I tried when I heard about this method. By "more successful", I mean that I'm getting chisels that are both sharper and significantly more durable than a flat-honed chisel. There's something I'm doing better with technique, though I'm not sure exactly what it is. Maybe it's that I'm using a lighter touch, or that I'm putting the blade closer to tangent to the wheel... I'm not sure exactly.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#6

Brilliant Photo Essay. Thanks NM


Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#7

Therein lies the problem

Jim Matthews

If operator "feel" is required for success, widespread adoption will come slowly.

"There's something I'm doing better with technique, though I'm not sure exactly what it is. "

The appeal of this technique is rapid mastery using inexpensive gear.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#8

Think of how long to master....

David Weaver

..for most things. I can't comment here as I don't learn well from other people and have walked into this, but I think it's something that anyone can do better than their underlying sharpening method within a week for about $60.

By better, I mean sharper and longer lasting chisel edges. What really goes on with planes remains to be seen until some yokel (me, I guess) A/Bs some plane edges.

The process, though, is very forgiving. If you can prepare an edge with a middle stone and raise a decent wire edge, for chisels, all you really have to do is put some abrasive on the wheel with a stick and then lean into the chisel to get to a little "backbone" in the wheel and then that's pretty much it.

The more you do it, the better your feel will be, but you can do a good job without it being perfect.

I suspect a good job in this case is far above what most people do as a "good job" when sharpening with stones.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#9

my experience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Once I knew what profile I needed to achieve I achieved it first try on flat "stones" and an abrasive loaded strop. Successfully produced 5 ash drawers with the edge with no damage. Was what I did optimum? Don't know. Did it work satisfactory, yes. End of story.

Then using a buff I had on hand and the yellow stick I ordered, I did it again on a steeper angled chisel. Again success. Winston did it with a drill and buff, successfully.

There you go- 3 for 3 for those willing to try it.

If you are not using a chisel and having edge damage that this technique will eliminate you are not a candidate for trying it. No benefit to be gained.

I have made something on the order of 100 dovetailed drawers the past few years and suffered chisel dulling by deformation on them all. You note how damn quick I tried it. And given the benefit I would have kept trying until I succeeded. I was driven by the benefit. All I needed to know to learn it was the reliable knowledge that it does work astonishingly well.

I told someone in the club about it and within an hour he had ordered a wheel and compound. This is the audience we want to reach. The unmotivated will be unmotivated to expend even the small effort it takes to employ this technique. These is no point convincing them to try.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#10

We added another

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Actually I told two people, people that make stuff, about this technique. The second just emailed that he found a buffing wheel and had some abrasive on hand and was going to do a chisel today.

Offer something that will solve a problem people know they have and they will figure out how to use it even if every detail has not been provided.

You are correct. The merely curious may never learn to use it or even try without step by step details.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#11

sort of...but..

David Weaver

>>If you are not using a chisel and having edge damage that this technique will eliminate you are not a candidate for trying it.<<

I'd imagine most folks will not tolerate an edge steep enough to avoid edge damage, and those who think they have, often have damage that shortens the sharpening interval.

What this does for paring chisels is wonderful - it is alone worth that. Low resistance paring without edge damage, even in hardwoods.

What it will do for already good chisels is improve the edge holding and drastically improve everything around the process (the work in hardwoods comes out in neat leaves, the force of the chisel pounding into halfblinds and across end grain is reduced).

It's obviously not necessary, but the biggest benefit (making marginal chisels work like really expensive chisels) is certainly there. There much more benefit than that, though, too. It's worthy of use on any chisel aside perhaps from a very steep beveled mortise chisel. Useful on gouges, too.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#12

Good vs. ideal

Winston

My first attempts may not have given ideal results, but they were very good, much better than a normal flat-honed chisel. Since then, I think I've gotten better at doing it and gotten even better results.

For some context, I'm in the middle of testing a very expensive PM-V11 chisel, and have made three chopping cuts with it so far. It is no longer able to shave hair. The Buck Bros chisel, which costs less than 10 dollars, made 20 chopping cuts, and is still capable of shaving hair. With that particular chisel, I think that buffing has allowed it to maintain a shaving-sharp edge at least 10 times longer than normal!

I know, this all sounds impossible. But I'd suggest that anyone who's curious should spend $10 on this buffing kit, and see what it does for them. This is what I got:

https://www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-Metal-Buffing-Kit-7-Piece-A10BK72/301848645

It's possible that some other equipment works even better, but that kit has worked pretty darn well for me.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#13

Needle moving testimony

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Anyone making dovetailed drawers and cases with an inexpensive chisel will be moved by this testimony. They will figure out how to make it work for them. The wide latitude where it seems to work assures some measure of success the first time.

A publication providing details is soon to follow.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#14

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

Joe shelton

I'm on the bandwagon. I just ordered some wheels for drills.

I do have a question about the compound, though. You describe addressing the corner of the wheel with a chisel back, without getting onto the rouge. How narrow a strip of compound do you apply?

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#15

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

Winston

I'm glad you're trying it out! I hope you'll report what you find. As David said, having confirmation from others is very helpful.

> I do have a question about the compound, though. You describe addressing the corner of the wheel with a chisel back, without getting onto the rouge. How narrow a strip of compound do you apply?

I hold the drill in my left hand, pointing right, and I hold the chisel in my right hand. With this orientation, I put compound on the left and middle of the wheel, avoiding the right-most edge. I hope that makes sense.

I've been buffing the chisel's bevel anywhere from 5 to 10 seconds, and then the back for maybe a second total, hitting the corner of the wheel without compound. The chisel seems marginally sharper after doing the back. (Also, I don't claim to really know what I'm doing -- this just seems to be working for me.)

I think the amount of compound in the buff has a strong effect on how quickly it cuts. But I wouldn't worry about details too much at first. I think it's simple and forgiving enough that an exact technique doesn't matter too much.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#16

what you are looking for

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Present tool to wheel with bevel tangent to the wheel surface and then push with enough pressure to deform/dent the spinning wheel. I think the shape of the "dent" in the wheel abrades the correct profile.

This technique seems similar to the "slack belt" the knife people used to abrade a similar but larger profile they call the convex edge. In this case the shape of the belt assumed by the edge pushing into the slack belt grinds the correct profile like the trailing edge of an airplane wing.

Success is a tiny shiny reflection across the edge, about the thickness of a piece of paper.

I think a convex edge is going to strengthen the tip to resist lateral deflection, while at the same time provide more lateral force on the wood fracturing to lessen the force on the tip.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#17

Please include the following...

Jim Matthews

Description of the buffing wheel and polishing compound.

Rough idea of the angle (I expect its tangential) of the steel relative to the center of the arbor.

How many passes, and how long a pass should take.

I'm finding a fine line between enough to bolster the edge and dubbing to dull.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#18

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

David Weaver

winston's way is fine. I just push the stick into the whole wheel. The cotton at the corner is really soft and has no structure at all. Even if it has compound on it, it can't drive it into the chisel at all (it doesn't round over the edge).

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#21

The full sharpening cycle

David Weaver

For anyone having trouble navigating my long drawn out video, the sharpening cycle starts here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Do7FdOh6S9s

you can ignore the safety discussion and bit about endorsement at the end. It occurred to me that I've had a couple of catches of knife tips in the buffer and while I think it's probably no more dangerous than a bench grinder, if this video gets a couple of thousand views in the end, I have no clue who might stick plane blade, chisel or knife in the top of the buffer wheel and shoot it across the shop or have it snapped into their hand.

This sharpening cycle is this exact picture (i fibbed about using one hand sharpening, i do it all the time if the media is fast cutting. The angle makes it look like i'm putting a healthy secondary on the chisel (steep), but it turns out this one was 23 degrees.

https://i.imgur.com/wyoqb4H.jpg

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#22

Thanks for posting!

David Weaver

Thanks for posting what you're doing, Winston. It eliminates a lot of guessing and wondering.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#23

thanks for video

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

sent video link to those locally that are trying it. Picture was worth more than a thousand of my words.

I dismissed that floppy wheel format as too floppy but the proof in in the pudding. It may be any wheel works.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#24

The rest of the story

Warren in Lancaster, PA

End of story?

Am I reading this right? For over a decade you have promoted innovations in sharpening and steels. Remember cpm 3v? Remember loose diamond sharpening? Remember pm v11? All these game changers. You have constantly belittled the efforts of those who use traditional methods.

In 2011 you told me I needed tougher chisels because of some imaginary problem which I have not had.

Now this:

I have made something on the order of 100 dovetailed drawers the past few years and suffered chisel dulling by deformation on them all.

What? All these innovations and you were still unable to perform routine work without damaging an edge?

I cannot diagnose a problem from 500 miles away, but something is very wrong here.

Re: Yet another chisel edge test

#25

What are traditional methods?

David Weaver

I'd imagine that what we're doing here wasn't that uncommon historically.

The trouble about arguing what's historical and what's not is trying to write off anything shown on a huge number of professionally used tools if those tools were used or made during a period where information was thin on the ground.

About five years ago, I received two different tools from different places:

1) a plane that had a very long primary and a neatly done secondary. It was rust free (no prior rust) and there was some patina on the sharpening job. I wrote it off as having been a site tool, maybe the user just wanted to be able to sharpen a lot of times before dealing with the full thickness of the blade.

I sharpened the plane as it was already set up and to my surprise, in heavy use, no damage to the edge occurred.

It was a curiosity but went back out of my mind.

2) a set of english tyzack chisels (probably early 1900s) from someone who appears to have worked doing lighter work. All of the chisels had a very long thin primary bevel and a neatly done secondary bevel.

I wrote it off as a curiosity again, but I'd imagine it was someone making drawers or doing some kind of repetitive operation.

Having the English market opened up to us initially (when ebay started to proxy packages from England) allowed me to get a whole bunch of tools that hadn't been abused since they were used professionally. Not similar to a lot of the beaters that had been sold by dealers here at higher prices, tools you'd find at flea markets or domestic tools used here where most were made after woodworking had already become a factory enterprise, one that went to changing process to lower the cost and skill of labor as fast as possible.

What we're doing here isn't likely to be very original. The performance of the chisels as set, though, is well above a flat bevel. Nothing is absolutely needed, but this is better just as micron diamonds create a better edge than any natural stone (more uniform, sharper and longer wearing).

Some of the things that I'd written off as anomalies (chisels that arrive neatly cared for with long bevels, etc) probably aren't really anomalies, and the idea that anything that doesn't show up in nicholson or roubo is just due to unskilled users is probably wouldn't stand up well in a world of more complete information.

Separately, I noticed today that a set of sash mortise sorby chisels (boxwood handles) came from the factory with the top rounded over. It's easy to tell on the set that's listed because again, some of the chisels are rounded over and have the same wheel or leather belt with loose grit (factory finish) from the tang to the bevel, while one of the chisels was more well used and the refreshed roundover is noticeably done on a hand stone.

It wasn't more than a couple of days ago that we heard that chisels weren't made this way from the factory.