Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Weaver chisel grind

Posts

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#51

Could've been felt...

David Weaver

..I'm sure someone has tinkered with many ways to do this. Any time you fall into something so easily without necessarily looking for it, you know it's been done elsewhere (maybe in isolation, maybe in classes)

I haven't gotten it to work well with plane irons (in a way that doesn't expedite clearance issues), but what's missing is initiative to do that since they usually wear well from the start (vs. the small failure at the edge that plagues chisels).

Thanks for posting that you've seen something similar before. It's good confirmation that at least someone else with experience thought that it was not just workable, but workable enough to use over other things.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#52

Thanks for the memories

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I am reminded at the time I was preparing to make the large M&T panels for this 7 drawer chest of drawers. In time I made a total of 3 of these large chests of drawers, plus a shorter 5 drawer chest of drawers, all with M&T paneled sides. By some combination of technique, steel and edge profile the mortises went well, frame squared up and the chisel edge remained sharp.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#53

bevel width

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The Weaver Bevel I created on the Narex was by eye something on the order of 0.005-0.010" as estimated from the bright reflection at the edge.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#54

Nice piece of work

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You do good experiments and write them up exceptionally well. Thank you.

I have had the aid of an industrial microscopy lab to make my pictures using scopes and lighting costing north of 5 figures. I must say your pictures are outstanding.

I think the benefit of the Weaver Bevel is for a chisel that is to be struck. It is striking a chisel that applies a large force to the tip, a force that can overcome the strength of steel at some ground bevel angle. Some increase in cut resistance is tolerable because it can be compensated for with a slight increase in bashing force.

I know my bevel was a maximum of between 40 and 35 degrees from the way I created it, (closer to 40 if not 40).

The problem with this discovery is how does one optimize the edge preparation for the variables it will face ? It is reminding me of the task of telling someone how far back to set a cap iron. It will be similarly challenging to teach. People are going to have to believe in it and try it enough to find what works best.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#55

video...not for the meek...

David Weaver

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Do7FdOh6S9s&feature=youtu.be

If you're not interested in watching 40 minutes discussing the why, how, and other things, don't bother to watch.

The two short sessions of actual sharpening are noted in the top of the video text (those two will take about 1 1/2 minutes to watch and may tell you all you need to know).

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#56

Another test

Winston

I decided to test the buffing again, primarily to see what would happen with less buffing.

Instead of testing a Buck Brothers chisel against a Veritas, I compared two Buck Brothers chisels. For the unbuffed chisel, I sharpened at 30 degrees, up to the Shapton 12000. For the buffed chisel, I sharpened on stones to 4000 grit (bevel side only), then I buffed it on the wheel for about 4 seconds, using a lighter touch than I did the previous time, then I deburred by touching the back of the blade to the side of the buffing wheel for about a second, which had no compound on it. (Incidentally, my buffing wheel is really wavy on the side, so the chisel was bouncing quite a bit while doing this. Not a great feeling when holding a really sharp tool!)

The buffed blade this time had a smaller microbevel at the edge. It was also subjectively much sharper than last time -- I was able to easily shave hair with it, and easily push cut across the grain in printer paper. The unbuffed blade was very slightly less sharp in these subjective tests. This is a reversal from my previous tests.

Here are microscope pictures of the bevel side after sharpening.

The buffed blade (with the light in two different positions):




The unbuffed blade:


Then I made about 20 paring end-grain cuts into pine with each chisel. With the buffed blade, it cut cleanly at first, but degraded a little bit toward the end. With the unbuffed blade, it degraded even more. At the end, I was able to shave hair with the buffed blade with a little more effort than when freshly sharpened. With the unbuffed blade, I wasn't able to shave anymore.

Here are pictures of the bevel after doing the cuts:

The buffed blade:


The unbuffed blade:


This time, the 4k stone and then buffing wheel was an improvement in all ways over the 12K Shapton: with the buffed blade, sharpening was faster, the initial edge was sharper, and the edge held better than the unbuffed blade. But the edge durability for the buffed blade wasn't as good as it was the first time around.

My takeaway from this is that, the first time around, I did too much buffing, resulting in a duller, but very, very durable edge; but this time, I didn't buff it quite enough: the edge was sharper and more durable than an unbuffed blade, but it didn't hold the edge as long as I had hoped (although perhaps my expectations for durability were set too high from that first test.)

I think that the buffed blade in test this held its edge approximately as well as the unbuffed PM-V11 chisel in my first test. I don't want to make a strong claim about this, but that's what it seems like to me.

In the future, I'll try to buff the blade a little more and see if I can get an edge that is both very sharp and very durable.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#57

Re: Nice piece of work

Winston

Glad you like it! I've gotten decently good at taking pictures of blades, and I figure that doing a test and writing it up is valuable for others out there.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#58

Re: Another test

David Weaver

Your efforts to see what you can make of this are much appreciated. Thanks!

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#59

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your efforts to see what you can make of this are much appreciated.

same here. I am impressed by the photomicrographs. They are as good as we got from a Nikon before I had access to the metallurgical scope and lighting. Lighting metal is difficult as I am sure you have discovered.

The morphology of the dulling is what we have observed in our work. Nice to see confirmation.

For a chisel that is too hard you will see microchips instead of the rounding profiles.

What kind of pine are you chopping?

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#60

Those pictures..

David Weaver

...are so much more life-like than the ones that come out of my metallurgical scope and for something like a chisel that's too big for my scopes bed, it's a real pain to get a picture of anything. If any part of the scope or chisel (including the tail part that's not on the bed) moves in a way that's not relative to everything else, the picture is lost and fine focus needs to be redone.

If I'd have known that phones could do as well, the need to spend $425 on an entry level metallurgical scope wouldn't have been there.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#61

Well that escalated quickly.

Jim Matthews

Try to be a little kind.

Hockey season was cancelled.

"Being accessible and cheap, it *could be* the "ruler trick" of this decade.

Emphasis added to illustrate the qualifier.

DC was also derided, at first. The best ideas are only obvious in retrospect.

To be fair, I haven't managed to work this out using my redneck buffing rig.

I probably need a tool rest to get it right.

This could be invaluable as my hands only tolerate so much in a day.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#62

Re: question

Winston

The microscope is one that I got for my kids. I've been really impressed with it -- for $80, it's a real microscope with a metal body and three objectives. It's fun to have around just to look at stuff that you're curious about (I've spent way more time looking through it than my kids have). The phone mount was $15, I think, and the light is an LED camping lantern, which is good for photos because it's more diffuse than a flashlight.

The pictures I've shared were taken with the lowest-magnification objective. Because I've been taking pictures of the bevel side, the shallow depth-of-field with the higher magnifications makes it hard to make out anything.

People say that using a 30x loupe will teach you a lot about sharpening. Using this microscope in the last couple of days has taught me at least as much.

Regarding chipping vs rolling: Yesterday I buffed a plane blade to see how well it would work. I buffed it less than the chisels, to avoid possible clearance issues since it's a bevel-down plane. The resulting wood surface was incredibly smooth. I'm able to achieve that level of tactile smoothness with just stones, but the buffer made it much easier to get there. (Burr removal on the side of the buffer wheel is a bad idea when the blade is wider than the exposed radius of the wheel, by the way. After a scary incident trying that, I used a plain strop on the blade's back to do the deburring.) As I was planing, I wondered if I would experience the clearance issues that David mentioned, but before I got there, I noticed tracks in the wood. There was a nick in the blade that I could just make out with the naked eye. With the blade under the scope, it looked like a huge triangle was removed from the blade -- very different from the worn chisel images I've shared so far.

As for the wood, I wasn't chopping this time around, just paring. I don't know the exact kind of pine it is. It's a just a scrap chunk of a 2x4 that has been sitting around for over a year, so it's has time to dry out and is harder to cut than a fresh 2x4 would be. I'd say it's middle-of-the-road in terms of density for construction lumber.


Re: Weaver chisel grind

#63

Re: question

Winston

Oh weird, it's showing Steve Voigt's picture of a plane instead of the one I tried to include. Anyway, it was just a picture of the piece of pine with some end-grain shavings next to it.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#64

It's a very funny video

Jim Matthews

I think your excitement is justified.

30 seconds is fast, regardless of methods used.

I also think "constructive laziness" is catchy.

Kudos

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#65

could be a database issue...

David Weaver

..we know we have them on the forum, especially with unsearchable bits ,etc.

Not sure if you can post a reference of the image from elsewhere.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#66

Light source?

Jim Matthews

What light source in the photos?

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#67

It's the scale that escapes me

Jim Matthews

We're down to VERY minute distances, here.

I suspect this inquiry will reveal paradoxical behavior in steel.

Something weird is happening, while buffing if the scratch pattern left by Alumina is finer than 1 Um diamond paste.

The resultant edge on the steel is something we can infer from the finish left in the wood that was cut.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#68

Re: It's the scale that escapes me

David Weaver

the surface left behind by this edge is one that looks like it was waxed, but it doesn't look burnished, just very clean.

I haven't yet had a decent chisel or knife that wasn't amenable to this, but I do have an underhardened piece of junk O1 marking knife that i made a while ago that really likes to draw a wire edge off of the buffer.

Harder chisels buff more slowly - it's kind of a do it until you get the result you're looking for sort of thing, and if that's getting to be a pain, it can be explored - you just sort of get the feel for it and as long as the second stone can hone it off, no big deal if it takes a few whacks.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#69

Re: Light source?

Winston

It's a small LED camping lantern: it's a Moji, made by Black Diamond. For the pictures, I hold it in my hand and spend a fair bit of time moving it around until it shows things in the best light.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#70

Second try for picture

Winston

Here's a second attempt to post the picture of the pine I was paring end grain from.


Re: Weaver chisel grind

#71

Some chisel pictures

Winston

Just for kicks, I decided to look at a few different chisels under the microscope, comparing a buffed chisel to an unbuffed one of the same type. No edge durability test here; just some pictures of buffed and unbuffed chisels. The buffed chisels were sharpened to 4000 grit and then buffed; the unbuffed chisels ended on a Shapton Pro 12000.

Just from looking at the pictures, you can tell that the Shapton Pro 12000 won't create an edge that is as uniform as the buffed edge. I think the buffing changes the edge in three ways: it makes the edge more uniform, it increases the angle, and it rounds off the apex. I wonder how important each of these factors is for edge durability.

Previously, I showed a buffed and unbuffed Buck Brothers chisel. Here's the unbuffed Buck Brothers chisel:


And two shots of the buffed chisel with different lighting:




*****

I also did the same with a Veritas PM-V11 chisel. Unbuffed:


Buffed:


The results are pretty similar, but the buffing didn't smooth it out as much. I don't know for sure, but it's probably because the metal is more resistant to buffing, and because I didn't buff it for as long.

*****

I also tried it out on some Japanese HSS chisels. I believe these chisels were billed as semi-HSS chisels by Stu at Tools From Japan, when his store was still open. The unbuffed chisel looks pretty similar to the other ones we've seen.


The buffed chisel has these little dots in it.


Looking at it with a higher magnification, you can see that they're bumps that stick out of the rest of the metal. I'm guessing they're carbides that remained in place while the surrounding steel was worn away. Pretty cool that they can be seen with the microscope!


Re: Weaver chisel grind

#72

excellent pictures!

David Weaver

I found the same, even with a compound that isn't that fine, the scratches appear to be smaller than the wavelength of light and there aren't stray bits and pieces anywhere.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#75

Re: Some chisel pictures

Wiley Horne

Hi Winston,

Outstanding photos! Thank you.

What is the approximate magnification?

Wiley