Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Weaver chisel grind

Posts

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#26

it makes sense

David Weaver

that paul would emphasize stiff primary work every time (as a conscious thing) as what I've noticed with japanese tools is that people starting tend to chase them shallower (because the jigane sharpens faster than the higane), and full bevel sharpening on anything, people tend to chase steeper trying to get the edge finished.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#27

You nailed it

Jim Matthews

"We need to not loose sight of Weaver's discovery by getting distracted by technique. A 30 second addition to a chisel edge preparation turned a $10 chisel into one that performed as well as any I have on the bench, including a $70 LV."

This is one of those rare ideas that improves results while saving time and money.

Being accessible and cheap, it could be the "ruler trick" of this decade.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#28

the premise is different in this case

David Weaver

where I found the need for it was mortising cocobolo. You can be careful with technique and maybe save an edge set for mahogany and cherry or oak in cocobolo or purpleheart, but you'll punish yourself in work like that. if someone sets their tools for mahogany, let's say, they're not going to hold up even in ash unless they've unknowingly set them up a little strong for mahogany.

this got rekindled for me in lower quality chisels because of how sharp the patternmaker gouge gets and how strong the edge is in bulk work. It's beyond the level that any reasonable effort with oilstones will provide because of the fineness of the edge.

The cut resistance as it's set now for dovetail type work is less than what I would've typically done by hand.

It's true that it may save some of the trouble that folks have when they have bad technique, though, but it's too small of a replacement at the edge to tolerate prying and twisting. That'll just do as cliff stamp says for knives - push the failure up further past the point where the edge was adjusted.

The other reference here is when derek mentions dovetailing gidgee or something, macassar ebony comes to mind to me, too, with the purpleheart. People rarely work stuff like this, but when they do, they are led to believe by advertisements about hardness or toughness that they need to buy something. They don't need to - they can do this, have a temporary edge adjustment that's literally removable with the next hone. That part of it is nice.

It's also sharp enough to leave a waxy finish on incense cedar (but that's with the buffer, and it would take considerably longer to get an edge that fine hand stropping). When I cut all of half blinds on the last up and down case, I don't remember if I did it because it doesn't strike me as a situation where you'd need the help unless the chisel quality is low (and something like a sorby chisel is low enough that you can't get the edge to hold up just by making sure all strikes are straight in with a direct in line mallet blow and not flopping around, twisting or prying.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#29

How about making a video?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, it is time to make another video. This will help poor fools like myself understand what to do. I am prepared to nominate you for an Oscar if you do this in period costume.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#30

Rafael from PA

Re: How about making a video?

Rafael from PA

I second Derek's request.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#31

Trying things out

Winston

I agree, a video would be very helpful.

I went to the store and got a set of Ryobi drill-mounted buffing wheels which came with three kinds of compound. The wheels are cushion sewn, so they are soft. My drill is said to spin at 2000 rpm, which is slower than a bench buffer, and the wheel is smaller (4 inches), so this setup will work slower than a bench buffer. For my workshop setup, it's more convenient to use a drill for this than a bench buffer.

I tried the finest compound, white rouge, on a sharp chisel, which was hollow-ground and sharpened with a 30-degree bevel. I used it for maybe 8 seconds on the bevel side, and then I flipped the chisel over and worked the back for about 1 second. After all this, there is a tiny hairline at the edge, which looks similar to the one

My initial impression is that the chisel does not seem as sharp as it was before. It was previously sharpened on a 12000 grit Shapton Pro stone and shaved hair easily. After buffing, it will still shave hair, but it requires more effort. It can still pare pine end grain, but not as cleanly as before.

That said, a slight loss of sharpness is a small price to pay, if it buys greatly increased edge durability. I haven't yet used the chisel for anything (other than some test paring cuts) so I can't say whether the edge actually lasts longer.

Anyway, a video would be really helpful for those of us who are interested in trying this out. I can't speak for others, but I know nothing about buffing wheel types and compounds, so a little discussion about what kind of buffing wheel and compound to use would also help (I just used what was easily available and I have no idea how well it would work compared to something else).

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#32

Re: How about making a video?

David Weaver

Period costume for me is op shorts, high tops and striped tube socks.

Will do on the video.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#33

Re: Trying things out

David Weaver

This should greatly increase paring sharpness over a shapton cream, but I say that having failed a few times years ago to figure out how to get good repeatable sharpness off of anything powered.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#34

Marc Adams

David Gli

Many years ago I took an intro course with Marc Adams. His method for sharpening plane blades and chisels involved using a Workshop for the primary bevel and a fairly firm (cotton?) buffing wheel with just a smidge of green stuff on it to hone. It was super fast and as I recall yielded a great edge. I never used a buffer since then, so details escape me. Perhaps someone who has done one of his courses more recently can chime in.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#35

Period costume?

Jim Matthews

SpongeBob, Blinky Bill or Asterix?

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#36

On secrets, incantations and open source

Jim Matthews

"I'm sure it's been done zillions of times. No idea is really truly original, even when this is even at that, only a slight variation on others' ideas..."

The day after you post, some crank will come out of the woodwork to complain they thought of it first - even though they were stingy about proselytizing.

We follow what you're up to because it's out in the open; no secret decoder ring required.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#37

Re: Trying things out

Winston

> This should greatly increase paring sharpness over a shapton cream, but I say that having failed a few times years ago to figure out how to get good repeatable sharpness off of anything powered.

It's possible that after I buffed, the edge is "sharper", in the sense of being more uniform, but that the apex angle is significantly more obtuse, and that the overall result was that it was more difficult to shave with.

I'm not sure I'm understanding this part -- when you say that you failed to figure out how to get good repeatable sharpness of of anything powered, do you mean that you've now figured it out with your buffer?

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#38

This is hilarious

Frank D. in Montreal

The discovery of the decade is basically what many hacks were doing when buffing their chisels, all the while chided by sharpening gurus who claimed that you should never buff a chisel because it would not preserve the geometry of a perfect edge. I can't believe this is being passed off as the discovery of a decade. It is the rounding off of an edge.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#39

Re: How about making a video?

Jonathan Elliott

I think it would help too...the one you did on scrapers helped.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#40

Absolutely *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been stropping my tools on leather for 55 years. Woodworkers have been doing this for millennia. Why? Because it improves performance. We have dilettantes who suggest that this is poor practice because it "dubs the edge". What they are lacking is the ability to discern actual performance.

If this experience can be replicated by others it will be as significant as the rediscovery of the close set cap iron.

Rediscovery?


What is a double iron?

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#42

failed to figure things out...

David Weaver

...my first attempts were a long time ago - I heard various folks talking about leather wheels, etc, and tried to just hone with "moving things", hoping that I could find a wheel or disc combination that would work but I think I polished things really brightly and chased them all steeper.

This method is something that's kind of hard to just say "Do X" because I can mention the stones, the buffer and the abrasive but I have no way (or not enough experience?) to know if someone else is doing the same thing or even if you buy the same buffing wheel, if it's really the same thing (I doubt ryobi - which i where I think I got this buff - uses the same chinese supplier for their buffs. I'd bet they just order a run from the lowest acceptable bidder because that's what home depot does).

I still hone each time to about 25 degrees (wiley made measure) the secondary bevel and for some reason the combination just works. Something that gave me a lot of experience, touch is file knives. They're really thin, I use them to cut boxes and as marking knives now, so they can end up being abused and it's really handy to hone them flat once in a while and then strengthen the edge with a buffer. They slide through cardboard - the very very tip of the edge of whatever I've honed is probably more blunt, but it's small and backed by thin geometry.

gradually things have gotten better and the point where all of this clicked (the little knives are sharper than I can ever get them by hand. They'll catch damp humid paper away from the point of hold and cut it push in cross grain and with the grain, no problem) - anyway, this clicked when I started using the deburring wheel to maintain the bevel on incannel gouges. It's useful on things like that and the little knife, but I think it's still easy to do all of the pre-work with a stone on flat tools.

I haven't gotten anything useful with planes doing this - I'm sure it's possible, but planes don't chip the way chisels do (or fold) and the very edge is worn off so fast that I don't think this method can be used to better stones. I noticed with the time that I tried it that the plane left a very bright clear surface, but it had the feel of a plane where the clearance was reduced.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#43

Jim - here's your guy

David Weaver

Show me the post talking about this in context. Using poor quality chisels without the loss of sharpness (or added sharpness) and no extra resistance penetrating wood.

I haven't seen it and doubt at this point that you could spend 15 minutes and manage to do it, but it's easy being a keyboard jockey.

I've generally seen people use something like this on a paper wheel and bare leather, but folks are showing chisels brightly polished from end to end and with a blunt feel.

Certainly, the whole thing is nowhere near a new idea. For at least 75 years, systems have been provided for razors that require zero introduction of a razor to a stone. Dovo still sells a paste system.

And one of the things that egged me on with gouges is that randall rosenthal mentioned that he sharpens his gouges only with a buffer.

The trick is to make it better than not using it without doing something difficult or expensive.

In the case of razors, razors work better if they are stoned and stropped, but enough people historically couldn't figure it out or didn't want to, and the paste setup is still available. A razor is usable off of the pastes, but it's worse.

This is better.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#44

Moving the needle

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Dulling a struck chisel by micro folding or micro chipping has been discussed on the Forum for many years. As confirmed with a conversation this AM with a mechanical engineer these are the failure mechanisms for a rod(chisel) with sufficient force applied along the long axis, even a force as perfectly parallel as can be possibly achieved. No flaw of force application is necessary if the force is sufficient.

The date on my early microphotographs studying this kind of dulling is 2003. So, for something like 17 years this effect has been known on this Forum for someone to do something about.

Some years ago LV did something about it. They introduced a chisel made from a steel that could be taken to higher hardness while maintaining toughness. Simultaneously increasing both these steel properties resists this kind of dulling and many noted an improved chisel as a result.

There is no evidence presented to suggest that Warren's stropping or anyone else's preparation produces the physical properties of the edge Mr. Weaver described. If anyone can make that claim document it with a picture that shows equivalence to Mr. Weavers picture and description, and describe exactly how this edge was achieved so others could repeat it, and you get the early claim date on this "invention", not Mr. Weaver.

But even if person XX has been using this kind of edge for 40 years there is no credit to be offered until this person "moves someone else's needle". "Moving the Needle" is a phrase a colleague coined to describe an activity, or disclosure that caused something different to happen. Kees and Pan writing moved the needle on using the cap iron. Elliot moved the needle on sharpening abrasion resistant tool steel. Etc. If someone has a useful technique, do something to get others to adapt it. This Forum provides the opportunity. Those benefiting will reward you with "credit" for the information.

Mr. Weaver moves a lot of needles. How? He tries stuff. When he thinks that something he has tried is beneficial he makes a full disclosure of what he did, how he did it and what the result was. Others can then repeat the work to confirm the result. It sounds like Science, the activity that began in the Renaissance which has moved a lot of needles. The people that get credit are the ones that published work for others to learn from.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#45

I've made a video.....

David Weaver

it's long and three parts and it'll be until later today that I patch them together.

I need to describe what the problem is in the video, what the ideal solution is so far, and then prove that it works better than a typical flat bevel, show the damage to the steeper flat bevel that doesn't occur in the buffed edge, and then finally show how long it takes to sharpen off the tiny buffed part.

Brevity isn't my strong point.

And then I realized that I'd better add a point about safety at the end because if I put it on youtube and make it public, someone inexperienced could easily stuff their chisel into the top part of a buffer wheel and have it shot at them with great speed.

This is the first time I've a/b-ed two chisels and taken microscope pictures, and it makes for a half hour or more of videos to show all of it, but I get the drizziling ___ of finding something that actually works better and then getting a bunch of youtube comments and forum jockey junk that creates even more nuisance afterwards. The a/b test was better than I expected - the rounded edge chisel was intentionally chosen as the wider of the two sorby chisels and vs. a flat bevel, it went through the wood easier than the narrower chisel (not counting for any compensation for width - easier at greater width) and sustained far less damage:

20/28 degrees narrower chisel in beech (more strikes to get through the same wood):

https://i.imgur.com/N71EKxf.jpg

(same primary, honed -and then 1 micron diamond honed polished on the facet 28 degree secondary bevel, and hand stropped to remove any wire edge). This is as close as I can get to giving a typical microbevel the benefit of the doubt (to avoid the extra wedging that would occur with a full flat bevel)

20/25/buffed chisel in beech (fewer or same number of strikes - i probably ended up malleting it less hard in the video to come because it went through the cut a lot easier)

https://i.imgur.com/Oi9obaS.jpg

these are around 100-150 true optical, the back sides (sorry I don't get the rounded bevel side - it's just way too hard to take pictures of curved surfaces on a scope that has such a shallow field of view.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#46

Re: Moving the needle *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is what I wrote the last time you made spurious claims about chisel dulling. You pretended to know the condition of my chisels sight unseen.


chisel dulling

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#48

comments on the two pictures.....

David Weaver

looking at these pictures - the 28 degree bevel (flat) edge:


after a set of cuts in the video

And the rounded edge after cuts in the video (this edge looks unused, guessing that the tiny notches are after use.


since this is the flat side (back) of the two chisels after performing the same task (one where the rounded edge went through the wood more easily, despite being a wider chisel), it's probably worthwhile to ask how big the rounding is.

These pictures are about 2 hundredths of an inch tall. I would guess that the buffed area is between 5 thousandths and a hundredth (I can scope something at some point to check), but most of the rounding isn't that much steeper - just the very edge).

So, the damage that's shown in the edge is well inside the rounded over area. I already resharpened the wider chisel in the video so I don't know what would happen if you kept pushing the edges.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#49

Some quick tests (lots of pictures)

Winston

I did a little bit of testing with using a buffing wheel on chisels. Short version: like David and Bill, I have gotten greatly increased edge durability, but unlike them, my buffed blade takes a bit more effort for cutting (he had the reverse). It's likely that the difference is due to differences in equipment and technique.

For testing, I used a cheap Buck Brothers chisel I got from Home Depot ($21 for a set of three). Normally when I use this chisel, I'm surprised at how quickly the edge gets damaged and folds over, probably because I've gotten used to my nice chisels.

I got a drill-mounted buffing set made by Ryobi, which was only $10 from Home Depot. It came with three wheels and three different compounds. I used the largest wheel, which is 4 inches in diameter, and the finest compound, which is white rouge, and mounted to my drill, which supposedly goes up to 2000 RPM. The wheel is a cushion-sewn wheel, which is softer than the sisal wheel that I saw David use in his scraper video.


The Buck Brothers chisel was sharpened with a 30-degree bevel using a honing guide, with the final stone being a Shapton Pro 12000. Then I used the buffing wheel on it, for about five seconds on the bevel side, and then about half a second on the back.

For comparison, I used a Veritas PM-V11 chisel, also sharpened to 30 degrees with 12000 grit, but I didn't use the buffing wheel on it.

Both chisels were at the same level of sharpness before I took the Buck Bros chisel to the buffing wheel.

Here's what I've found. First, some of the initial observations:

- The buffed chisel had a hairline of reflection at the edge, similar to what David showed in his picture. More on this later.

- Just by feeling the edge with my finger, the buffed chisel did not feel as sharp as the unbuffed one.

- The unbuffed chisel easily shaves hair and can pop off hairs, the buffed chisel could only shave hair with some effort.

- With a push-cut across the grain of printer paper, the unbuffed chisel cuts easily and cleanly. The buffed chisel did not cut as cleanly, but it still could do it. Given the previous observations (about the edge feel and shaving ability), this was quite surprising to me. When I sharpen on just stones, if a blade can't easily shave hair, it won't be able to do this type of push cut. So this is one place where the behavior of a buffed chisel is quite different from a stone-sharpened one.

I then used each chisel to cut endgrain of a small piece of oak, and then chunk of pine. Here are my observations about that:

- The buffed chisel had more resistance in both the oak and pine. The unbuffed chisel cut more easily.

- Both chisels were able to cleanly pare oak end grain.

Paring oak end grain with buffed chisel:


Paring oak end grain with unbuffed chisel:


- However, with pine, the unbuffed chisel cut noticeably more cleanly.

Paring pine end grain with buffed chisel:

Paring pine end grain with unbuffed chisel


- After doing this work, the unbuffed chisel had some edge damage that was visible to the naked eye (this chisel is PM-V11). The buffed chisel looked exactly the same to the naked eye (this chisel is the cheap Buck Brothers chisel that normally folds over very easily).

- With the buffed chisel, I chopped through more of the pine, and it still looked exactly the same.

After doing this, I looked at the edges under a microscope. The appearance of the blade is very sensitive to the direction of the light, so I've included multiple pictures, with the light source in different positions.

- Here's what the unbuffed chisel looked like (after being used). This is the most damaged part of the edge.




- Here's what the buffed chisel looked like. In the second picture, I moved the light so that you can see the reflection off the buffed edge. This is even after the additional chopping through pine. As far as I'm able to see with the microscope, the edge still looks undamaged.




In terms of the angle, you can get an idea of the angle by looking at how light reflects off of it. The angle of the buffed edge in my case is at least 45 degrees, and I think slightly higher. To measure the angle, put the chisel down so its back is horizontal (you'll need to support it with a block because otherwise the handle will get in the way of it being horizontal). Then look straight down at the edge and shine a small handheld light at the edge. Move the light up and down and observe what position lets you see the reflection of the light.

The reason I know that the buffed edge was 45 degrees is because when I did this and held the light directly horizontal to the cutting edge, I could see a reflection. I was actually able to move the light a little lower and still see a reflection, but I didn't have things set up to measure the exact angle.

Edge reflections, with the light positioned horizontal to the edge:


A closer look at edge reflections. Visible edge damage to the unbuffed chisel:


I suspect that the very cutting edge is not just more obtuse, but actually rounded over from the buffing. That's exactly what I'd expect a soft buffing wheel to do to the edge, and it would also explain the increased durability. It makes sense that a uniformly rounded edge would be durable, since the forces from cutting would be spread more evenly. (This is different from an edge that is sharpened with a coarse grit, which would have a ragged edge with little peaks that can bend and break.)

I don't know if it makes more sense to describe the edge as being rounded over, or as having a more obtuse angle at the edge. Let's say the edge had a 1 micron-wide apex before buffing. I'm certain that after buffing, the apex would be much larger than 1 micron, and behind the edge, the blade would be convex.

From my small amount of testing, I agree with what David and Bill have observed, that the buffed edge will be much, much more durable than a regular one that comes off of stones. I suspect that something similar is achievable with a strop, but I don't know for sure.

For me, the edge was noticeably less sharp, but much more durable. I'd like to be able to do what David has done, which is achieve an edge that is both sharper and more durable. It's possible that a harder buffing wheel and/or different compound would work differently. Or maybe I just need to buff it for less time.

I'm guessing that if the soft Buck Brothers chisel can become so much more durable with buffing, a high-quality chisel can be even more durable with buffing. Or, one could buff the high-quality chisel for less time and have less edge rounding (or increase in edge angle), and therefore cuts more easily, and still end up with a very durable edge.

Here are some pictures of the microscope setup. It's a regular microscope, with a phone mount on it.




Re: Weaver chisel grind

#50

stitches.....

David Weaver

my wheel has about 8 stitches in it. I believe that it's probably got more backbone with the abrasive and should be able to be used at less angle increase....but I'm just guessing.

One of the first things I tried years ago was a pair of felt buffs (and they were stiffer in the other direction). I found them difficult to use because they had too much backbone and would really round an edge fast. Same with leather at high speed - just too capable of honing too fast.

It may be the case that a higher stitch wheel is a sweet spot, and it just may be getting used to mine.

I'd bet finding the middle isn't far off for you, and maybe with that wheel (I hate to advocate purchasing to experiment).

It's interesting just how fine the surface is on the buff, though (as you're showing) it's devoid of scratches big enough to be seen visibly.