Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Weaver chisel grind

Posts

Weaver chisel grind

#1

Weaver chisel grind

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Over on the Lathe Forum they speak of this named grind and that to describe profiles on the end of their cutting tools. Why not here.


David introduced us to the idea of a tiny convex bevel at the end of a chisel. This idea settled in fertile ground because I had already heard of the merits of this profile to enhance the durability of knives.

The chisel is a Narex, available unhandled for less than$10. The Narex handles are crap but can be readily made nice by chucking in the lathe. The shaft is useless for dovetails but can be made useful on a grinder. The steel comes with a story about nitrogen that sounds like marketing. It is not. A metallurgist told me the process makes very good steel. Used as I typically prepared a chisel I found the edge to be as good as Two Cherries and way better than Sorby. But it gets better!

I sharpened this chisel at 30 degrees, and added a tiny convex bevel at the tip. This chisel has chopped out the waste for 5 drawers and it is as good as when I started. I am not accustomed to this edge life for this task, especially on an inexpensive chisel. I did not notice a loss of penetration ease.

I have concluded this convex edge idea has merit for a chisel used this way.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#2

Re: Weaver chisel grind

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I wonder if that type of edge is what Adam Cherubini calls a “knife edge?”

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#3

making peculiar names

David Weaver

some of the details of this may have been missed from prior discussions.

Convex and flat edges are often discussed, but when you start examining where failure occurs and how much wedging force there is with a convex or blunt angle chisel, if you're lazy (I am) you start trying to go back the other way and look for a free lunch.

There's no arbitrage in chiseling, but I think this edge is probably on the efficient frontier of what's available.

Cliff stamp was talking about this with knives, as he'd done a bunch of testing and found that the most "capable" steels (as determined by gurus, not necessarily objectively the most capable) are often provided in super fat knife profiles and the performance of them for actually doing things is terrible compared to a cheap simple steel thin bladed stamped knife.

He started commenting on keeping the grind of a knife fine, and then working the very edge of the knife to a given profile as a single bevel would leave the failure point at the edge of the knife, and removing that failure point via modification would push eventual failure further into the bevel. The idea being doing only enough to eliminate both.

So I've found over time (Without knowing it) that my general purpose chisels have crept toward a 20 degree primary angle and a small secondary angle around 25 and then a roll. Some terrible chisels still didn't tolerate this (r. sorby chisels are really lovely except they are really soft), so I rounded over the edge of a couple (just the very edge) with a buffer and found they did well.

I just mortised a plane with one.

So, more or less, it's a knife edge, as you say. But since one of my favorite chess channels calls a knight move a knight move ("knife F4"), I'm going to steel knight.

And call it a knight edge.

So that nobody has a clue what we're talking about.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#4

Weaver grind—how is convexity added?

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill, David, and all,

David has explained that he creates the convexity by brief use of a buffing wheel. How did you do yours? I am interested in whether this convexity needs to be done with real intent, or whether you can strop it on using green on leather.

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#5

Re: Weaver grind—how is convexity added?

David Weaver

The result must be more important than the method. I did this for years on a fine stone and over time (with the benefit of trying so many stones) got to using a very slow finish stone from japan that says "barber's oilstone" on it.

The first effort was to stop chisels from chipping in mortising (including japanese chisels).

The buffer isn't and can't be essential as I didn't chance across it despite doing this for a while) until recently. I'd prefer a very slow fine stone otherwise, but leather stropping would work fine. If it's too slow, a slightly coarser polish would do it (like autosol instead of green chrome, etc) - autosol on leather is as fine as a 1 micron stone despite the alumina being something like 3 microns - it has much less conviction with the leather backing.

This picture from our prior discussion is the amount of shine (the last tiny white line) on a sorby chisel (almost worst possible case) that achieves the result of making the easy and early edge failure go away.

https://i.imgur.com/tN4PfxO.jpg

follow up sharpening becomes removing wear (warren just said something about that recently, too) rather than damage.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#6

Re: Weaver grind—how is convexity added?

Wiley Horne

Thank you, David. Very useful. The picture especially—I understand the bevel overall is very acute except for the tip.

Wiley

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#7

solving a problem, not creating one...

David Weaver

fortunately, we don't have that many newbies here. I don't know that such a thing is fortunate, but in this case, it is.

This is one of those kind of free solutions that works - and faster than going and buying something else, and I have a soft spot for those.

But the trouble with discussing something like this is that inevitably the resolution/connection that it was being used to solve a problem is lost and it becomes a "Guru's new method that everyone should change to". Next thing you know, someone will go out and buy 300 sharpening stones chasing that kind of nonsense :| :| :|

I didn't think of it as that, but rather rounding edges over and then seeing the justification from cliff stamp, it became something that solves a problem faster than buying and waiting for anything else. Free in cost is one thing, but getting on with something that's not a real drawback (such as making an entire bevel steep - there's a big cost to that in resistance and then in softwoods, the same chisel blows out the end between pins or in sockets), that's really great. If the results sucked, it would've gone into the trashheap of ideas like adding teflon to cap irons.

This doesn't seem to have any real compromises (if we can control ourselves and not make the initial edge too big or too step). And after buying and waiting for a tataki nomi so that I could move up a level and mortise planes faster, this (the roll early on vs the buffer) turned out to make an inexpensive easy sharpening chisel that worked better (the tataki nomi's corners chipped off in heavy work - I never bothered to try tempering it back, just sold it...it had a giant cross section of jigane that wasn't really that soft and it was very slow to resharpen because of it)

I cleanly pared the end of a pencil when i first tried the buffer and came back with the excited result here. If bill hadn't been fighting dovetailing something stringy, it would've disappeared into the ether. I pondered not posting about it (As with most of my crackpot ideas at this point - I usually post them, anyway) because it's goofy.

(but So yamashita does it, too....secretly... and I'd bet some of his earlier-in-the-curve customers wonder why their chisels hold their edges so well and then never do as well again when they resharpen them).

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#8

BTW

Bruce, a MN Galoot

A good friend of mine, a gifted wood carver, used a similar method on his carving chisels, honing until sharp, then a few seconds on a green compound charged, hard felt wheel on his grinder. They were always spectacularly sharp, but he didn’t care at all if the back of the chisel wasn’t flat.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#9

how I achieved the Weaver Bever

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

note I coined a better term...

David estimated the "Weaver Bevel" to span 0 to a max of about 5-10 degrees. The picture showed it to be tiny, just a glint of light.

I removed the dead edge with ex fine fixed diamond plate, followed by 1 micron diamond on cast iron. After a few rubs to be rid of the wire edge, as I drug the chisel across the plate I rolled the chisel up what I estimated to be about 5-10 degrees for about 5 strokes. Then I rubbed on leather at + 5-10 degrees for a few strokes. I observed a thin bright line at the edge.

The idea is to be making a convex edge. I imagined in my mind what sort of a roll of the wrist would achieve the profile I was after.

For edge longevity of a chisel that is bashed to remove wood from a mortise or dovetail the Weaver Bevel seems to be a game changer. I am simply astonished that after bashing out 5 drawers the chisel looks like it did to begin with.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#10

Weaver Bevel

Wiley Horne

Good, Bill. Weaver Bevel is a good term for the tiny convexity. As I understand it, David also uses a very acute grind above the convexity, like 20-25 degrees, in order to keep wedging tamed down.

Wiley

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#11

The world is upside down

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Let me see if I have this correct, because the promise of doing it right brings a rueful smile to my face.

David, you have created a micro rounded bevel by presenting the chisel (and plane blade, no doubt) to a softer wheel, one that acts to buff rather than grind. In so doing, it dubs the bevel and gives it a rounded upper edge (it cannot be rounded completely as then it would end up dull).

If this is so, the other way to achieve this is via stropping on leather (with some give). For some years I had moved to stropping on hardwood (using green compound), which is technically not stropping but sharpening. The hardwood is just another "stone". However, the hardwood was chosen to prevent the possibility of dubbing - rounding over the edge.

Years ago I used horse butt leather for strops, and I still have these round. Now I need to return to them for a comparison of edge holding. They should be the quick and easier way to the micro rounding. Yes? No?

The other issue is what this rounding is actually doing? One thing appears obvious to me (but I may be misunderstanding all this in the first place), is that the rounding increases the angle at the edge. To be effective, a higher cutting angle does not require size, just a higher angle. Another example of this may be the leading edge of a chipbreaker ... just enough angle to re-direct the chip.

The last issue is how this compares with the rounded bevels popularised by Paul Sellers? His bevel are wider/longer (however you wish to define them), but they may be doing the same thing - increasing the cutting angle somewhat (which has been a criticism by many of us of his sharpening method). While I have not been a support of PS's sharpening methods generally, I have used the rounded bevel on my Western mortice chisels (not on Japanese edges) and also when sharpening tiny marking knife bevels.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#12

Further defining the Weaver Bevel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is important to deemphasize the primary bevel from the description.

The essence of the Weaver Bevel is to add edge durability to whatever primary bevel one is currently satisfied with. If someone is using a bevel of about 30 degrees, or a bit less, and getting chipping or folding at the very edge (maybe only seen under some magnification) the Weaver Bevel will lessen or eliminate these unfavorable dulling mechanisms.

In the case at hand I wanted to create a chisel just for chopping dovetail waste, thereby preserving my collection of bench chisels for jobs where extra sharp was required. This approach was not a novel idea I conjured, and hence to be easily dismissed. When I watched Will Neptune, my woodworking idol, do dovetails he did the chopping with a Stanley butt chisel ground at a more acute angle than his bench chisels.

Round 1 was preparing the Narex at 30 degrees and building drawers for two bed side chests of drawers(6total). One corner of the chisel chipped off and the edge was folded before the drawers were completed. Not a good start to my plane to prepare a chisel just for dovetails.

Round 2, inspired by David's description of the Weaver Bevel, I restored the 30 degree bevel which I was satisfied with for penetration, and added the Weaver Bevel to the tip. The result was simply astonishing. 6 drawers with ash, not mellow cherry fronts, and the chisel looks like it did when I started.

Anyone wanting to try it should understand that what is important is the shape of the first 0.010", or less, of the tip and not what the primary bevel is. It follows that if one whats to try it add the Weaver Bevel to whatever you do now. Later, if easier penetration is desired, experiment with the primary bevel which we will continue to call the "primary bevel".

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#13

thoughts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This idea is so new here I think it safe to say that the optimization of this bevel has not been explored, nor ways to achieve it. Some thoughts:

If dulling through micro chipping or folding is not a problem with whatever one is currently doing the concept of the Weaver Bevel should be ignored.

David and I have discussed this concept off line for a while and like anyone else the question is how to achieve it. I wondered about achieving it with a leather strop only. David thought just the strop would be slow, but then we don't know if 0.005" is good enough or 0.020" is necessary, or that the answer may depend on a lot else.

David convinced me to at least begin the bevel with the last "stone" I used for sharpening, in my case 1 micron diamond on cast iron. I added some passes on the strop for good measure. This is the first and only preparation I have tried.

At this point this is not a technique ready to advertise to novices. It needs to be fleshed out by people annoyed by chisel dulling as a result of folding and chipping at the chisel tip as illustrated in this picture of a Sorby edge after a dovetail job.


Re: Weaver chisel grind

#14

variations on the already done...

David Weaver

..there's nothing really new about this other than the use of the buffer, but I"m sure that that's only new to me.

But as you point out, it's kind of the same thing as other things other than the bits where it's not. Why the buffer? I couldn't tell you exactly- for some reason, the ease with the buffer is better, and the sharpness is higher than doing it by hand. I think the lack of conviction in the abrasive on the buffer just does a finer job in a few seconds than I can do much longer on a strop and there's never an issue with contamination. That's a productive laziness thing for me. Debatable (I wouldn't take the pro side) that it's really significantly different than just rolling the very edge by hand.

As to how it's different than a tiny flat microbevel, I haven't experimented with trying to dial in numerical little flat facets, but figuring out what's what probably wouldn't be hard.

Vs sellers? There's less primary and secondary angle behind the edge so the wedging is less. You're also working only a tiny part of the bevel by hand (the secondary and then the tiny line) and can chase it off with a regrind. I think most people will tend to make a fairly blunt bit of steel behind the edge with sellers' method (a large amount of it) though that's the fault of the method and not the user. I guess you could more or less point this out to be the same thing if you just drew a profile of the edge, picked an arbitrary spot and then drew a secant line eliminating any of the rounding not needed.

Knives may have brought me to this - I do the same thing (But by hand) with japanese knives - very thin bevel profile, enough strength at the edge so that they don't chip.

It's a little bit embarrassing to have my name stuck to it as I'm sure there are a lot of carvers who have done something similar over the years.

But the kicker (other than just rolling the very tip) that made me bring this up was using an incannel gouge and sorby chisel that were both sharper off of the buffer in a couple of seconds than I can ever get them by hand, and the cutting resistance seems less than an ideal single bevel that would hold up as well.

no good for planes, though.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#15

perception of penetration?

David Weaver

Only wiley's prodding a few months ago forced me to measure my primary bevel (grinder rest being set at 90 degrees, and then freehanding from there, I have no clue and have just come to the shallower primary out of laziness).

The edge holds up better on my chisels than 28 or 30 degrees flat primary did, but with a very shallow primary, there is less resistance from the cut. Enough less that it's easy to take something like a harbor freight chisel and do the same cut that will neptune showed with his very long primary chisel.

I cut all of the shoulders to the line (I have always done them previously malleting) and none were chased appreciably low (as you're aware, if you use a more blunt edge, even paring with a narrow chisel, the marked line will get chased back and perhaps unevenly. not a lot, but it's annoying).

The harbor freight chisels are the same thing that aldi markets. They're tolerable. They are probably in the ballpark of robt. sorby chisels, but not nearly as pretty.

Somewhere in the past, I did something similar on one of the newer buck chisels that I ground the corners off of to go straight in to the end on half blinds, and then liked that chisel, too, better than the purpose made skews that I had, so I sold those.

...forgetting the main question here, though. I never noticed a significant increase in resistance other than the first trials, like mortising cocobolo in the smoother I've showed pictures of. I made a stanley fairly blunt and it held up well. When you're mortising a plane, the bevel gets to a cutoff point in cocobolo where it gets steep enough that it will shoot the chips out of the mortise instead of laying them over. I don't usually do that. Other than that instance, never noticed the extra resistance. The fact that the edge stays ideal through work would suggest less average resistance, anyway, even if initial was a tiny bit more.

What did you notice in terms of cut resistance?

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#16

rolling over edges....

David Weaver

..the first few times I used buffers or powered leather wheels, I rolled edges over and concluded that I don't get it or it wasn't for me.

I use an incannel gouge a lot on guitars (for bulk work) and now lots of other things where removing bulk. I got stuck using it twice on the cabinet that I posted because I had in-situ waste that needed removing and for whatever reason, an incannel gouge goes through waste a lot easier than a chisel.

But using them heavily means sharpening them regularly and somehow the deburring wheel and buff turned out to be great.

Your mention of a carver makes a lot of sense - you can keep the tools relatively shallow if you like that geometry and then just buzz the tip subtly and it will hold up well.

I'm sure it's been done zillions of times. No idea is really truly original, even when this is even at that, only a slight variation on others' ideas (you could say that it's much like the three bevel system that charlesworth advocates, because other than the incannel gouge, I'm refershing a secondary bevel each time and then a tertiary bit of edge (rounding instead of a bevel) and when the secondary bevel gets large, you chase the tertiary.

I'll be using this method on more carving chisels now (than just the incannel gouges, but it's nice to use those. I have some already, but then a benefit auction on here generously offered by wiley has made me very patternmaker gouge rich).

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#19

More on the Weaver Bevel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When we studied dulling there appeared to be three mechanisms.

Abrasion- this kind of wear removes metal. It is the kind of wear a plane bade receives. It will not be lessened by the Weaver Bevel.

Chipping- If a blade is too hard for the stress it endures it will micro chip at the tip. M2 can suffer this fate when fashioned into a chisel.

Folding- If a blade is not sufficiently hard the tip will deform under stress, as shown in the example of the Sorby chisel in one of my other posts here.

The Weave bevel will strengthen the tip of the primary bevel. Hence, if either chipping or folding is experienced this bevel may lessen or eliminate the dulling by these mechanisms. It would seem to offer the best benefit to a chisel stuck by a mallet where the impact deforms or chips the edge.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#20

narex and their hardening....

David Weaver

...as i recall, those chisels are hardened by austempering rather than the typical critical heat and fast quench. I don't know exactly how austempering works and am being too lazy to go reread it other than to find that it cuts steps and leaves a final product at about 59 hardness. The idea of pushing to 61 or 62 (which is probably ideal for chisels and where most of the chisels that warren prefers are) isn't attainable.

That leaves them in striking distance of being nice work chisels. The benefit of this method as a problem solver (not as an obligation) is it takes a chisel that's kind of frustrating to work with and makes it a winner.

I have a rosier view than others will because the sharpening cycle time on a 2000 grit diamond stone and then a buffing wheel is something like 30 seconds, and then on top of it, the edge lasts many times longer. It's a cheater's way to get to warren's edge care efficiency. If I had a force recording scale, I would probably give in to doing a test to prove cut efficiency (resistance), but it's better just observed when you find something like you did - a test where you're seeing edge failure -the kind that was often advised to be solved by purchasing and waiting.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#21

I took a nine day Sellers course

Jim Matthews

The sharpening method focused on a full convex bevel for both plane irons and chisels.

The upshot of this approach was that it was easy to remember, could be done freehand and left a polished surface gor shavings to glide over.

No mention of cutting angles, probably because there was so much ground to cover.

The only admonition was to start each session from the coarsest grit, lest the cutting angle become too steep. It was mentioned in passing that stropping could refresh a "tired" edge but if you had the iron in hand it was only a few minutes to run through all the stones.

I think DW's observation that a cotton buff can do much of this in seconds is remarkable.

I'm experimenting with a ddburting wheel and buff, to mixed results.

More often, I still need two stones and a strop to get good results.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#22

Re: solving a problem, not creating one...

Jim Matthews

"(As with most of my crackpot ideas at this point - I usually post them, anyway) because it's goofy."

That's where innovation happens; the ragged intersection of disaster and discovery.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#23

Re: More on the Weaver Bevel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

On a rainy Sunday in May I watched four or five U-tube videos of guys making half blinds. They all started out saying a very sharp chisel was essential; they all abused the chisel so much in the first minute that it was no longer sharp.

Chisels that are struck cleanly wear with abrasive wear. Chipping and rolling come from shear and bending forces: prying, twisting, scraping, digging. A lot of guys will hit the chisel in then flick out the waste, not realizing they are scraping the edge. Or they will hold the chisel near the bevel, not realizing that when the handle flops around with the chisel in the cut there are bending forces on the edge. Or they will get the chisel stuck and yank it out rather roughly. Few intentionally abuse the chisel, but sloppiness inadvertently causes edge damage. It can be pretty subtle.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#24

I don't agree with limitation of your premise

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Chipping and rolling come from shear and bending forces: prying, twisting, scraping, digging.

These dulling mechanisms certainly could result from the forces you enumerate but they also result from impact on an acute edge that is not sufficiently tough or hard enough to resist these forces. For any given steel just start lowering the bevel angle and at some point you are going to see dulling by either chipping or folding at the very tip no matter how perfect the striking force. Or alternatively, bash the chisel with ever increasing force and get the same result.

I will not deny that technique can influence the longevity of a chisel tip but the steel and its heat treatment also has a profound effect on what bevel angle the chisel performs satisfactorily. Now Weaver has shown that the edge profile may be as significant a variable as the steel properties.

We need to not loose sight of Weaver's discovery by getting distracted by technique. A 30 second addition to a chisel edge preparation turned a $10 chisel into one that performed as well as any I have on the bench, including a $70 LV. If this experience can be replicated by others it will be as significant as the rediscovery of the close set cap iron. Our role should be to encourage others to try it to see how broadly the benefit applies.

The goal is longer edge life. If someone gets it with sloppy technique and a more expensive steel it is the same result as getting longer edge life with better technique. Now we have a new variable to explore to reach this goal.

Re: Weaver chisel grind

#25

Re: I took a nine day Sellers course

David Weaver

The deburring wheel is a bit strong unless it's needed to maintain a bevel out of laziness -

e.g., the incannel gouge, I carefully keep the bevel in shape with a deburring wheel and then finish it with the buff.

On chisels, just a shallow primary, a small secondary bevel on something like a 2000 diamond stone (ezlap 1200 if you use the setup that paul recommends - those stones settle in finer than their grit number) and about 3 or 4 seconds on the buffer.

No need to tend to wire edges or anything like that. Just a few seconds to refresh the secondary bevel on the 1200 diamond stone and then 3 or 4 seconds with a stiff hand into the buff.

If you're using a coarser stone for the primary, you can add 15 or 20 seconds of primary work each time you refresh the secondary bevel and just keep the secondary a constant size. Since the buffed part is tiny, you can remove it easily with the secondary honing.

There's something about the buffer that makes this super lazy and the sharpness is beyond anything I've done freehand in any reasonable period of time.

Deburring wheels are *really* fast and can change geometry quickly. The principle on an incannel gouge is a different (tending toward preventing any edge damage) because it's such a pain to remove chips, so a little more care on the deburring wheel is OK.