Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Hold downs and augers

Posts

Re: Hold downs and augers

#26

Re: 80 grit

Raymond in Trenton NJ

Thanks Warren,

I forgot all about this, and I even saw his holdfasts. Much better solution (IMHO) than severe roughening of the shaft. All the old 'fast' I've seen whether at auctions or in living history sites had fairly smooth shafts. All showed wear and scratched, but not enough to look like a rat-tail file.

"Two lines" is 0.167"? Doubt I'll go that thin, but will take some meet off mine. In all likelihood it will probably be an iterative process.

Is The Great Zodo still active here?

Thanks again,

Raymond

who has his ginco bilbao somewhere . . . I just forget where.

Re: Hold downs and augers

#27

A tool review from Frank Klausz.......

roger lance

I watched the video of Frank Klausz where the Gramercy holdfast was slipping and then I watched the video that came up after that......it was of Frank in his new retirement shop and he was demonstrating making thru dovetails on his bench......he was setting the holdfast with a metal hammer......about mid video, he talks about his holdfast.....says that it is a Gramercy and that he "loves it".

There was no slipping in this second video.

Re: Hold downs and augers

#28

Re: A tool review from Frank Klausz.......

roger lance

This was a YouTube video called "Hand Cut Dovetails with Frank Klausz" by the channel Wood and Shop.....at about the 8:50 mark.

Re: Hold downs and augers

#29

Fantastic....still fantastic..

David Weaver

Roubo doesn't have anything about a stanley bailey plane, i'm sure, but they are a marvel.

I suppose this is what you're talking about?

https://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/that%E2%80%99s-not-a-holdfast/

Right now, I have a pair of smaller hold fasts that will hold as long as I want to work on something with one strike, and they'll release with one strike. They're made of something that wasn't economically available at the time that roubo wrote his article, and they fit in dog holes that I already have in my bench.

I have a tool box under my bench with all of my marking gauges, knives, regularly used files, etc. If I were to chase history, I'd have to drill more holes (no thanks), move my tool box (no thanks) and deal with a much heavier holdfast (no thanks) for a problem that I couldn't identify (the gramercy hold fasts are light enough and unintrusive enough to hold down glued together pencil stock, or to hold an 8 foot sticking board with a huge piece of wood in it, or a plane blank. The lower profile makes them easier to work with when you're planing something thin (like a door panel) that's moved and you're left to thickness it by holding it with a hold fast and planing center to end.

But it is true that a user should sand these inexpensive hold fasts. Frank wasn't given that chance on something that isn't his. As for everyone else, woodworking is really punitive to anyone who wants to purchase everything as-is and never do anything to make their tools function any better.

Re: Hold downs and augers

#31

not piling on...

David Weaver

That appears to match the text. it wouldn't solve any problems that I have but it would create more. If I were starting fresh, maybe I'd have a different outlook (the roubo apparently holds well in benches up to 8 inches - a problem I don't have). It apparently - at the size - will not gall the tops of the holes like some people complain about with the smaller holdfasts (those folks must have softwood benches -something I have no interest in).

I couldn't tell you who even makes a good forged version. You can always look to Chris Schwarz to sell the flavor of the minute in something else (it appears that he sells a casted version for the price of forged - it's straight shaft - would create the same problem, and I could also replace my stanley engineer's hammer with a $100 fancy "lump hammer" at the same time).

But, I'm not a re-enactor and would need to find a problem first. One whack in, one whack out isn't a problem.

Re: Hold downs and augers

#32

push them in sometimes...

David Weaver

I will push them in sometimes, but my relative largesse (210 pounds) is enough to hold light things. thing more like doing a body weight dip on them.

I don't avoid hitting because of long term damage, though - rather complete lack of toughness and oversensitivity to pain, as my dad would say :)

Re: Hold downs and augers

#33

Re: 80 grit

William Duffield

Warren, do you have a link to Zodo's post on his modification to the Gramercy holefast? I don't know why I didn't pay attention to it when he posted it. (Maybe I thought mine worked well enough. ;) ) I think Paul's idea is worth investigating, especially given the price and availability of the Gramercy holdfasts and the fact that I have several of them. Since they are made of spring steel wire, tapering the head to increase the springiness (technically, to decrease the spring rate) should not result in premature failure. The extrusion process should have effectively lined up most of the minerals to significantly increase the material's toughness and reduce brittleness Of course, traditional hold fasts made from either wrought or ductile iron, should have similar properties, at least compared to cheap Chinese cast iron.

Ray, If you find you need to apply the abrasive, you probably will find that you don't need to make it anywhere near as rough as your rat tail file. If you want a shaft that rough, you might look into the Veritas hold down.


The hobby users who have it don't report prematurely chewed up dog holes. Of course they haven't been using the same bench with one preferred dog hole for 40 years. If you ever wear out a dog hole, just drill a new one next to it. If the original one happens to already be in exactly the right spot, drill it out to a larger diameter, turn and glue in a harderwood plug, and drill a new dog hole through it. I would suggest using rock maple, persimmon, hornbeam or even ipe for the plug if you don't ever want to do it again.

Re: Hold downs and augers

#34

Re: 80 grit *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes, here is the link.

Earlier David Weaver talked about "the time when roubo wrote his article".

Andre Roubo wrote a three volume work on woodworking: 1300 pages of text and 380 plates jammed with illustrations.


Paul's Holdfast

Re: Hold downs and augers

#35

Re: 80 grit

David Weaver

poorly worded on my part, probably. Schwarz wrote an article from roubo's text. Schwarz then talked about a bees knees giganto holdfast from peter ross, then showed himself having trouble accommodating it in his bench, leading to giant tapered holes.

Then Schwarz talked about finding a big french holdfast in a barn that held better than anything else they tried, and it wasn't tapered.

Subsequently leading to very expensive cast holdfasts, and discussions about where to put extra dogholes for these things (with commenters asking where should they go?).

I'm not sure how people would make things at their bench and then want to know from someone else where their holdfast holes should go. My dog holes are generally in a different place than most - to make planes. If I listened to someone else about where to put dog holes, etc, I'd be drilling more dog holes.

At any rate, if I implied roubo was writing articles, I mean his text being quoted in blog articles or posts.

Re: Hold downs and augers

#36

Re: 80 grit

Raymond in Trenton NJ

No need for abrasives here Sir William. And no, I am definitely not looking for something that rough. They hold and release fine as is. Granted, sometimes it's a tap or two to set and/or release. But no issues or complaints. Can't even remember if I ever took off the coating, I remember you telling me about it. I figured I'd try them first, and they worked as is.

FWIW: I'm using them in 3" and 1 1/2" thick material. That correlates to Derek's experience with his bench thickness.

Warren thanks for the way back link.

Raymond

Re: Hold downs and augers

#37

Re: 80 grit

William Duffield

CRS Syndrome strikes again! :( Paul notes that it was I who encouraged him to write the article, but I have no recollection of the discussion or even of the technical improvement itself. At least, I should have filed Paul's WC post, but I didn't. I've corrected that now. Thank you, Warren and Zodo.

I gotta go out to the shop and try the mod, but there's no time tonight due to a n upcoming potential WC chat). The only issue I have is whether to use a file (no, I don't think so), or a grinder, or a belt sander. I don't think these are high chrome, carcinogenic stainless tool steel. :D

Re: Hold downs and augers

#38

Re: 80 grit

William Duffield

If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

If it's too loose, try one remedy. Pick one based on your best judgment of your situation. If you go too far, it may hold just fine, but you may need to whale on it to get it loose again. All benches are different, some differences are material to this discussion, but most are not. There may have even been production process differences over the life of the tool. If so, they are not documented, and there are no serial numbers stamped into the steel. Maybe, you just need a bigger hammer. Maybe mine lets go easier because my bench top is made from Ulmus rubra.

(To get the joke, you may have to look it up yourself. :D )

Re: Hold downs and augers

#39

In your bench....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

........if one hole didn't hold you could try another nearby.

To get the joke, you may have to look it up yourself. ;)

Re: Hold downs and augers

#40

Re: In your bench....

William Duffield

I have more than enough (more even than rabbit holes). I'll never wear them all out.

I have discovered another holdfast failure mode that occurs in rift sawn ring porous hardwoods like oak, ash and slippery elm, :D and is more likely to happen in thinner material and if the holdfast is oriented in the direction of the grain, and you have a row of dog holes spaced very close together. The force of hammering the holdfast can chip out a triangular prismatic section of wood between the dog hole you are using and the adjacent dog hole.

Re: Hold downs and augers

#41

Re: No hands

William Duffield

When you do a video, do you post a warning message at the bottom of the screen, "The head was removed for illustrative purposes only"? :D