Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

Posts

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#51

Re: Enlighten me

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, you suggested that workers were using Chromium oxide instead of Aluminum oxide for historical reasons. I asked you for documentation. If you have done no research, why talk about historic practices?

Chromium oxide occurs naturally, but it is very rare. It has been used for centuries as a pigment, and probably was historically too valuable as a pigment for use as an abrasive. Even when chromium oxide was synthesized in the 19th century, chrome was very expensive.

Aluminum oxide occurs naturally and is mined for abrasives. It was also synthesized in the 19th century and was marketed for India stones in the 1890s.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#52

Re: The wax thing...

david weaver

A paper edge like that is probably a drawn burr (of course). I'm guessing the wax gives the paper some conviction as well as smoothness and wear resistance, and probably heat removal.

Probably one step off of being able to give you a really fine and durable edge.

Wiley's bringing up of the Koch topic caused me to go watch a video. I was wrong about what it is (I thought it was specialty saturated wheels, and maybe they are, but they look more like charged hard buffs. probably not too much different from what you remember seeing).

I'm not going to be able to resist experimenting with this.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#53

A minerology lesson

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Dana lists no known mineral of composition- Cr2O3. From this fact it can be concluded that no natural source of chromium oxide was historically used as an abrasive.

It is easy to make "chromium oxide pigment" which is in fact a hydrated chromium oxide. Wrong crystal structure for the abrasive material. I don't know how the abrasive is made, but my guess would be by firing the pigment. As soon as it was discovered that chromium oxide could assume the crystal structure of corundum it would have been obvious to try it as an abrasive, if not before. I have no idea when this discovery happed, but likely historically relative to submicron alumina.

While crushing aluminum oxide to form an abrasive began centuries ago by crushing Corundum, and later synthetic aluminum oxide, the sub micron abrasive "alumina" is derived from another process. I doubt the fundamental knowledge to develop this process was known before about 1950's.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#54

Re: A minerology lesson

david weaver

1838 is listed as the start of commercial production of the hydrated form (on wikipedia). who knows how accurate that is. It also says the process was kept secret, which may have stunted availability (and there was probably also no real necessity for it given the huge selection of flours and crushed abrasives available dental production (porcelain teeth), razor polishing, cutlers, flatware polishing, optical polishing and on and on.

I checked the 1850 version of Holtzlappfel III this morning, and there is no mention of it there. There is an 1894 revised version that I also have, I'll dig out. I'm sure it's not mentioned there (well, not sure, but probably not mentioned there). I do recall that the 1894 version stated pretty much that the import of the washita stone had kind of wiped out a lot of the more popular (and varied) whetstones that were common to England and continental europe.

Also of interest in the original 1850 text is that there are mentions of products created at that time (synthetic sharpening stones and iron strop additive, etc) that were well regarded. In each case, developed for economic gain in use in a process (vs. economic gain by development of the product and sales to uneducated users).

No mention of carving tools on powered buffs, though.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#55

Marketing with the compounds...

david weaver

..the powder form of chrome ox, graded, sort of negates the need to explore the various sticks.

I got a $2 stick before I found that, from sears, and it's mostly aluminum oxide, fairly coarse.

I remember japan woodworker advertising *very* expensive green stick stuff from japan, and in the spirit of them as a source, it's probably double retail in japan. The big stick they advertised was Koyo-1. Woodcraft now owns JWW, of course.

https://www.woodcraft.com/products/green-rouge-polishing-compound-koyo-sha

$51.

The lack of accuracy in descriptions with JWW always bothered me. I think they just wrote what they wanted a product to be rather than what it was. That's my opinion, of course.

In this case, the narrative remains:

https://www.woodcraft.com/products/green-rouge-polishing-compound-koyo-sha

Quoted:

Our Koyo-Sha Green Rouge will give a finer polished edge than any other buffing compound and will put a razor like edge on your tools. The 19 ounce block will last for years.

In reading to find the actual composition (the ad copy says 0.5-1.5 micron particles), I was hoping to find an MSDS. This is difficult sometimes with japanese products because they're not written in type that google can search accurately.

What I did find was a list of koyo-sha compounds, no luck confirming whether or not there is alumina in the compound, and it's described as "#600" stainless steel finsih. Who knows what that is.

What I also found is that Koyo-Sha makes two finer green chrome compounds. How do you make a claim about a polish creating the finest edge when the manufacturer makes two other polishes that are finer on their own chart of products? Jeez.

JWW/Woodcraft has K-1. never heard of anyone using it. G-300 and G-546 are the two products from the same make that are described as finer, the latter the finest. I don't have trouble finding things in japan and getting them here thanks to translator/shipping services in japan, but may order a half kg stick out of curiosity. K-1 is available in 18 liter drums for really heavy users :b

Also listed with woodcraft is "Trend" green stick. the appearance of trend's diamond products on the razor boards put me off, because the wording was weasely. Not surprisingly, it looks almost the same or the same as the formax product, but woodcraft markets it for $18. The formax labeled stuff shows up in some retailers' price list as $7 or so. I just can't see the marketing of electroplate $130 chinese-origin diamond hones and $18 buffing sticks as being done in good faith.

and stuff like this:

https://www.woodcraft.com/products/trend-diamond-honing-polishing-kit

ugh.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#56

Re: A minerology lesson *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Dana lists no known mineral of composition- Cr2O3

Chromium oxide is rare in nature, as I mentioned before, but not unknown.

I am not sure that many woodworkers used Chromium oxide for sharpening much more than thirty years ago. Awaiting documentation.


Eskolaite

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#57

G-456--not that it's practical

david weaver

I ordered a stick of G-456 through buyee. We'll see what it is.

I'll post what i find. It comes in half KG sticks and I wouldn't call it cheap (because of the international shipping) but it's not going to be that expensive, either.

The original graded powder from hand american at $9 per four ounces of powder was hands down my favorite choice, but it's NLA last I looked. I sent half of my bag to stu tierney for him to play with and still have more left than I'll ever use.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#58

I stand corrected

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Dana compilation 1949. Disclosed in Am Min. Rec. 1958. Without reading the publication I don't know if the iron content is critical to the crystal structure or considered an impurity in a Cr3O3 crystal structure, that is to say, is the mineral Cr2O3, or a mineral that both Fe and Cr are essential to forming.

I have no idea when the green sticks began to be sold/used by woodworkers. I bought mine decades ago and used it on leather, and still do, for knives. All the carvers I know use it on carving tools. I needed a bit of "rice" carving and lacked the tool. Before it was loaned its owner, a Period Furniture maker, gave it a few strokes on leather/green stick.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#59

polishing stainless

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

for who knows what reason chromium oxide was historically used for stainless. So this stick may indeed by pure Cr2O3. I don't know if it has been replaced by alumina or diamond. If not it could mean Cr2O3 does something special.

Since XHP is a stainless steel we should be using Cr2O3 with it ;)

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#60

Or not...illegal to ship?

david weaver

I got a message from the proxy shipper that said that they can't ship the chromium oxide bar because it's illegal to ship overseas.

I'm going to assume that they're either fibbing and it's not actually available from a seller, or it has some kind of stabilized plant or animal oil in the compound that's not supposed to be shipped overseas.

Bill, I did get a pound of linde A .3 micron. I'll send you some, and then you can have it and not use it, just like me.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#61

Re: polishing stainless

David Weaver

Out of curiosity, I looked at the sds for a lot of compounds today for metals of various hardness and various types of polish level. Even the bulk of the well regarded soft metal polishes are alumina with some amount of something else, I'd speculate for identification more than utility.

Diamond may take over at some point, but other than some coarse silica bars, almost everything else is colored alumina with static acid or something else similar as a carrier. The k1 polish that woodcraft sells claims to be .5 to 1 5 micron chrome ox, but the sds would be in Japanese and only the microscope would tell the truth.

When my linde a shows up, I guess I'll mix it with iron oxide so I can see it. Funny that my whining about wanting to see a color on the strip is reinforced by an entry in holtzapffel that those making tin oxide are encouraged to add some iron oxide to the mix to be able to confirm the amount of paste in/on the polishing wheel.

It was a fun little diversion back into something I found interesting long ago.

It was also pretty easy to find inexpensive closely graded alumina in a stick at Rio Grande. Both in 3 and 0.5 micron size.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#62

Re: Enlighten me

John in NM

Pre-industrial revolution green pigments tended to be compounds of copper and sometimes copper-arsenic, and more rarely cobalt. Copper oxides and carbonates made for wonderful green pigments, but they were not always stable when mixed with other mineral pigments.

Chrome oxide's common use as a pigment started in the mid 1800's when chemistry advanced to the point that it became relatively easy to produce industrially. At that point I imagine someone noted the hardness and started using it as an abrasive polish as well.

The mineral you reference below was first described in 1958. Given the associated minerals listed, I doubt it could have been easily extracted from a skarn before the advent of industrial mining methods. There might be instances of it's pre-industrial use as a pigment, but they are likely to be even more rare than that exceedingly rare mineral.