Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

Posts

Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#1

Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Chromium oxide is harder than silica so I can see that before the development of synthetic abrasives it would be a good choice, perhaps because of its hardness or because it was available as a fine particle.

By my recollection it was not used for polishing metal specimens when I used the polishing lab for polishing metal surfaces. We used a fine particle alumina slurry for the last step or two.

Today we have available alumina in graded fine particles, I suppose as fine as chromium oxide. Other than it comes in a handy stick form, is there any reason to prefer it to aluminum oxide of similar particle size on a leather strop?

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#2

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still releva

David Weaver

I prefer the chrome ox powder to al-ox for fine work, but the al-ox stick to the pure powder in the shop on the rare occasion that I'd use it (small knives, etc).

Only trouble with true graded chrome ox is that sometimes the suppliers who provide it for a reasonable price disappear.

I like what chrome ox pigment does to an edge (it's very smooth - gentle on razors ), and as much as I don't use it on my own razors, the market of buyers for razors seems to prefer that a seller make their razor shockingly sharp - so I do that.

I have gone to finishing my incannel gouges on a hard buff with 5 micron al-ox wax stick, though. It works well and is probably worth taking a microscope picture of - they are sharper off of that buff than they would be off of a trans slip. I keep them in shape almost entirely with a gray deburring wheel and the buff. The edge is drastically different (more refined) than it is when the wax is spread on a hard leather strop or MDF - the particle size is too large for that.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#3

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still releva

Wiley Horne

David,

Where do you find a hard buffing wheel, 6” with 1/2” arbor, i.e. a Baldor grinder? Do you have a link?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#4

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still releva

David Weaver

I just looked - it's a 10 stitch or so (the washers cover the center stitches) muslin wheel. If I said felt, that's because of my lack of attention to detail in most things :\ It's muslin.

Hard felt can be used with good effect, but it's really aggressive and can raise a big wire edge and round things over.

I looked under the scope off of the 5 micron wax polish and the edge is at least as fine as any shown in the test pictures with the edge durability testing. The compromise is a little bit of edge rounding due to the wheel softness, but this is an advantage on an incannel gouge because it prevents the edge failure from being a nick right at the edge (which usually means no edge failures).

I don't use it on the baldor (fear of a catch and ruining a tool slamming into some fixture on the grinder or stand), rather on a cheap harbor freight buffer.

The pair is dandy - gray scotchbrite wheels have to be one of my favorite modern tools. They leave a finish like a medium stone but cut fast, and in combination with the muslin wheel make a superb sharpening combination for incannel gouges and thin knives made out of files - things that need to be touched up often but where there's no clearance issue. The corners of the muslin wheel are soft and stay clean and a light pass through them takes off any of the remaining foil after the abrasive part of the buff is done.

The wax stick is the inexpensive al-ox stuff from mcmaster carr that's about $10 per kilogram. It's 10 lifetime's worth. Another combination that was chanced into by accident. I bought the felt wheels after seeing someone recommend them (and don't use them now), I can't remember how I got the muslin wheel, but it may have come in something cheap - as long as the last stitch is fairly close to the outside of the wheel, it should work well. I tried the compounds looking for something cheap and fast to use on MDF, but they raise a wire edge there, and the scotch brite wheel is just to clean rust off of dirty tools. I don't use any of them the way I intended, but it fits the spontaneous junk theory.

If you keep enough junk around, eventually it will organize itself into something useful (well, a tiny percentage of it will).

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#5

Visually similar *LINK*

David Weaver

113102460053

Ebay item:

( no experience with the seller or the wheel, it just looks like mine )


Muslin Wheel

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#7

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still releva

David Weaver

Yes - It needs something to hold it to a strop, though (like mineral oil or something similar). I use 0.5 that hand american used to sell (no longer), and it can't be ordered without finding out the grade (the pigment is often 3 or 5 micron if it's ungraded).

Not something I use much of on tools, but the 0.5 and 0.3 will work well without creating a foil.

Strangely enough, the formax compound sold by LV and others gets a lot of grief for having aluminum oxide particles in it, but those particles are the only things making it practical to use for woodworking vs. just as an add on for a strop (that is, if someone is using it as a follow-up to a fine but not-that-fine stone to finish honing rather than just minor refinement, the al-ox is appreciated).

A typical use for something like that powder is to lap a razor 50-100 times after the finish stone and then strop after. It's a little dainty and the sharpness is transient, but it's genuine sharpness. It can be enough on a razor to lift a hair while shaving and then cut not only the hair off, but catch the skin levered up by the hair and shave it off, too (that's simply razorburn).

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#8

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still releva

Steve Voigt

Thanks for the info, Dave.

My experience with the Formax, and with al-ox powder of similar grit (like Wood is Good honing powder), is that it is pretty aggressive--one could use it on mdf and effectively make a cheap fine stone that way. It will raise a burr and stropping with it will not remove all remnants of the burr, at least for me--it needs to be followed with a plain strop or some palm stropping.

My thought with the 0.3 stuff is that putting a bit (with oil, like you say) on a strop could speed the the removal of the remnants of wire edge, and do it thoroughly. Currently I go from a washita, to a trans ark, to a plain leather strop, and the stropping is the slowest part of the process.

In any case, for ten bucks it's worth an experiment.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#9

That is what I am going to experiment with

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I used 0.3 micron for polishing metal surfaces for testing. I suspect the use of chromium oxide is historical and perhaps no longer necessary with the availability of precisely sized alumina polishing material. I'll work some into leather with oil and see how it does.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#10

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still releva

William Duffield

That's what I use. Note that the url is a bit misleading. It is 0.3 micron.

As I said in the other thread, I mix it with mineral oil and stuff it in a Monoject 412 syringe (available through Lee Valley) and apply it to a horse butt strop from TFWW. That little tin is a lifetime supply if you are just using it for honing plane blades and chisels.

I think the Cr2O3 in the green stick from Lee Valley is 9 microns (30 times as coarse), and is mixed with Al2O3.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#11

to repeat the question....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

why not use alumina instead? 0.3 micron, in fact any micron, alumina is readily available. Is there an advantage to chromium oxide....not this who knows what micron size vs that branded stuff, but composition.....chromium oxide vs alumina?

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#12

Re: to repeat the question....

Steve Voigt

Bill, perhaps you can share some links or sources…I've not found al ox in the sizes mentioned here. I can get a tin of the chromium for $10 and as William said it will probably last a lifetime. Is the same true of al ox?

Assuming it is readily available, two possible issues are grading and aggressiveness. Like I said I haven't used the chromium yet, but it's reputed to be very uniform and doesn't cut aggressively. I don't know how the al ox compares on those fronts but it does cut pretty aggressively. That's undesirable for the application I proposed, but it might be desirable for others.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#13

Re: to repeat the question....

John in NM

0.3 micron alumina is commonly used as a lapidary polish. Google "linde A powder" to get a selection of sources.

Linde B is 1 micron I think, but I may be mis-remembering.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#14

sources

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

two markets use alumina abrasives in submicron sizes- rock polishing and metal polishing. Searching lapidary supplies will yield sources as will companies that supply material for polishing metal, and metal specimens for metallurgy examination(which is where I used this stuff). It will be available as dry powder and as a suspension. A pint will be about $15. The problem will be finding a small enough quantity as powder. May have to get a pound and sell 95% of it on Ebay!

for example: http://metallographic.com/Technical/Fine%20abrasives.htm

www.metallographic.com/Brochures/alumina2.pdf

It appears that in both applications diamond has replaced other abrasives in these applications. I could not find anyone supplying chromium oxide for metal polishing. Makes me think wood workers are using it for historical reasons rather than effectiveness.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#15

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The submicron alumina is prepared from a colloidal suspension. The size of the colloid can be controlled accurately and precisely resulting in an abrasive with narrow size range.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#16

Re: sources

Wiley Horne

We’re using the fine graded Cr oxide because we bought a 50-yr supply 25 years ago :) :) . I guess that qualifies as a historic reason.

Wiley

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#17

Historical methods

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It is shocking how many people refer to historical methods without a scrap of documentation. Do some research if you want to talk history. Plenty of us remember when this green compound fad started.

I have used a clean leather strop since 1965. I use the strop for the same reason woodworkers have used a strop for millennia. I use it because I am able to notice the improvement it provides.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#18

Re: to repeat the question....

Steve Voigt

Thanks John. I see that it's triple the price of the green powder. So for those who use it, what is the benefit?

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#19

Wiley you nailed it, I think

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am considering the possibility that your thoughts are spot on. The green stick is readily available, lasts for decades and works. Does it work better, as well or worse than just alumina or diamond.....?... so far we don't know. Most probably don't care. But I have a boundless curiosity and like to know about stuff I use, and can I make it better.

I am of the school, baring data to the contrary, that removing metal is simply removing metal, regardless of the means. Further I don't think that results from shaving has any relevance to sharpening a tool to cut wood, at least to my wood cutting standards. Not meaning to cast an unfavorable light on David's experience, but results of edge preparation for shaving with the response of blade to skin and hair seems a long way from driving a sharp edge into wood for the purpose of lifting up a slice of it so what remains is thinner.

Before someone advances the notion that this or than abrasive affects the remaining metal in some positive or negative way by how the metal atoms are arranged afterward, consider what is known about metal surface preparation for metallurgical examination. The idea in preparing these specimens is to reveal what the metal structure looks like, unaltered by surface preparation. Historically (decades ago, not 1827), this work was done with silicon carbide in the coarse grits and alumina in the final steps, at least in the lab I worked in occasionally. Now, as I understand it, diamond abrasive is used. Presumably the results are the same. The progression of grits is important; their composition is not.

Nothing is easier than ordering a green stick, and it works. The question is whether the combination of green and white is better than just white. Is the green there just because we have come to expect it? Do we need to be concerned that a green stick could be an abrasive mixture or that this stick has more green stuff than that, and hence is better?

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#20

Re: to repeat the question.... *LINK*

John in NM

Still not cheap, but here's another source that seems cheaper. I would imagine that metal polishing suppliers are cheaper still but that you have to buy a large quantity. I bet the green chrome is cheap due to being used more as a pigment than an abrasive - much bigger market for pigments.

I don't use it on strops, I used to use it polishing rocks. I don't recall CrOx being used much for that, perhaps it is less effective in that regard. I always suspected that a large part of polishing minerals was a chemical action between the polish and the crystal - that was particularly noticeable polishing quartz with Cerium oxide in the surface effects you could see. Alumina generally won't polish quartz either, in spite of being much harder.


https://kingsleynorth.com/alumina-powder-a.html

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#21

Diminishing returns

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Nothing is easier than ordering a green stick, and it works. The question is whether the combination of green and white is better than just white. Is the green there just because we have come to expect it? Do we need to be concerned that a green stick could be an abrasive mixture or that this stick has more green stuff than that, and hence is better?

At what point does one say "sharp enough"?

Well, Paul Sellers goes from his 1200 diamond stone and then spends 5 minutes stroking on green compound on soggy leather until the edge of his blade is shiny and sharp. To me this is crazy. Others seem to approve.

About a year or so ago there was a discussion on a forum about high purity chromium compound ... that the Veritas/Lee Valley crayon contained some grains larger than 0.5 microns. So the cool guys went off and purchased fine, pure and true 0.5 micron chrome powder. I think that they are still sharpening up their blades.

Meanwhile the rest of us scribble a little of the Veritas/Lee Valley impure stuff on hardwood or MDF, and stroke a blade three times following a 10K stone, and call it good.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#22

Re: Historical methods

david weaver

Hasluck's carving book (going from memory) mentions two benchstones (one - a washita type, for someone of limited means) and a strop with emery.

Chromium oxide is probably not mentioned in historical guides, but plenty of other emeries and flours are. The references that I have are for cutlers and razors (or perhaps that's the only place I remember reading them because I was looking at them to glean historical information about razors).

At any rate, there is some utility beyond the level that oilstones will take an edge, in my opinion, as long as it doesn't spoil geometry (but there are others who have opinions that differ - I recall randall rosenthal mentioning that he only used a charged buff to maintain gouges, and his work is supremely good).

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#23

Re: Wiley you nailed it, I think

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There are more variables to abrasives than just particle size. For instance, emery and tripoli, both historical polishing compounds and strop preparations, break down during use. The effect is that they cut more quickly initially, then break down into smaller and smaller particles as polishing proceeds. They also have more rounded particle shapes than harsh abrasives, so scratches are more shallow. Some sharpening stones have similar properties, allowing much finer polishing than their initial particle size would suggest.

The particle size model for abrasives is one dimensional, and rather clumsy.

It could well be that for the green bar, the Aluminum oxide does the work and the Chromium oxide does the marketing.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#24

The emphasis on speed...

david weaver

The comparison being made here is a small edge from a tool vs. polishing a large surface. The latter is an operation with an easily measurable economic component, but I don't think the increase in speed for very tiny abrasives is that relevant the way most people are using chrome ox on edge tools.

I've got abrasives down to .09 micron (iron oxide in that case), and have diamonds (which I've lost) down to 0.1 microns (I can't recall if I ever actually used those - I used the iron oxide on razors). Even fresh iron oxide will blacken quickly. The edge on a razor from the iron ox is noticeably improved very quickly, but it is in the stratosphere for sharpness and it will cut the hair and any skin raised behind the stem of the hair without noticing (that leaves nasty razorburn).

That aside, there is one advantage to chrome ox that wouldn't see me changing to alumina, well, two:

1) the only place I really use anything like that is razors. The gentleness is appreciated - I was probably need to go to smaller alumina to get the same feel and the speed difference would be negated

2) most importantly - the visual clue about how much compound is on a surface at any given time is always there with chrome ox because the compound isn't tinted leaving behind an ink, the color is the actual abrasive. That visual aspect is nice.

There's a supplier of lapidary products here in pittsburgh, but it's far enough away from me that making a drive it for one or two things would negate any savings. And, as you say, they generally have sample or giant. Not much in between. as i recall, they had alumina as small as .05 micron. If I buy a $12 pound sample of alumina, then I have it to deal with, I've lost the color reference, and tax and shipping are another $12. A drive to the place and back (which goes right through the middle of the city) would take an hour or an hour and a half, even though it's close. And it would solve a problem that I don't have (which is that the refinement of the edge should leave said edge ready for the next step. An oilstone edge that's completed properly is easily finished by chrome ox.)

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#25

Re: Historical methods

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think that if you maintained your plane irons with nothing but a "charged buff", you would soon figure out why sharpening with Arkansas stones is a better strategy for carving tools also. With a buff you have little control over sharpening angle; everything is rounded and sloppy.