Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

Posts

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#26

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still releva

david weaver

It is ideal for exactly what you're doing. a slightly softer surface with the green formax bar and a drop of oil would also be good (the edge would be improved and there wouldn't be much wire edge formation like there is on MDF or harder leather).

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#27

Extrapolation of scenarios

david weaver

I'm sure that there's someone somewhere trying to do that (maintain a plane iron with a buff), but it wouldn't be me. Clearance is important on a plane, so is straightness of the edge.

I applied that at first to my incannel gouges, too (not being able to maintain geometry), but with a deburring wheel and then a buff, I have to admit they are superior in daily use vs. sharpening with slips, at least how I'm using them (to widen control channels in guitars, or to clean up the sides of a plane mortise). What is the issue here? I guess it's an internet thing - I sharpen plane irons one way, incannel gouges another, outcannel gouges another, drill bits another. It's results and efforts based. I guess it doesn't lend itself well to generalized discussion because it's not "I do it this way" and most of these discussions attract imagination about what might be vs. what is.

The specific issue being addressed here as I can figure is if you sharpen a plane iron and you're going to strop, what happens if you charge the strop with chrome ox powder. Two things come to mind.

1) not much happens fast (and that's good)

2) if the strop is used properly, the edge will be sharper than it would've been without the charge and it will last at least as long (if I tested it, it would probably last longer)

Does it matter? I don't think so. I don't bother with it on chisels or plane irons, my strop is bare.

There is some usefulness of very fine and reasonably slow media, though, and that is to round over the tip of an edge with ideal geometry (on the bevel side). it pushes the failure of the edge further up into the bevel (which should never be an issue unless there is rough handling) and extends time in use (I'd prefer to use slow stones for that, like a settled in trans or black, or some other artificial oilstone that cuts that level of fineness).

Not something I would direct a beginner to do because they won't understand the difference between what level makes or an improvement and what level makes for a blunt edge.

I sharpen all of my bench chisels this way, including japanese. This rounding is subtle, not a blunt curl (more of a strong bias), and to me (not anyone else, I'm sure), it's important that the rounded area is very small so that there's no significant change in cut resistance.

Once in a great while, I've mentioned this with japanese chisels and a few users who are loud but to my understanding, not very accomplished, will rebut that it's unacceptable (loudly). I think they read too many books or websites and don't do enough work. I think they might imagine what I'm doing and imagine something that's not remotely close to what I'm doing, and then go on from that point with errant information. When I sell a tool, the only question I ever get is "what did you do to to the edge? It's sharper than I'm used to" (off of the stone, not with compound). To go further into detail would be pointless because I think it just creates a scenario where peoples imaginations run wild, that there'd be some compromise made such that they couldn't use my tools because of the adulteration to (or from) perfection and that would be far from the truth.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#28

Green and white vs. white

david weaver

The green stick that most people use is 70% alumina from what I recall. The chrome ox may have some polishing effect, or maybe the original stick was developed for something specific (probably sped up polishing on stainless steel).

it would be imperceptibly different from a white stick that was 100% alumina of the same size.

I have taken microscope pictures of edges off of green chrome as well as the formax bar, and the edge off of the formax bar is probably similar in sharpness to the 0.73 micron sigma power 13000 stone. It's not as even because the abrasive isn't as closely graded, but in subjective sharpness in use, it's about the same. You can find stray scratches in it, which caused an uproar in the razor community (despite the fact that it'll strop a razor into a nice level of sharpness when used properly, and the 6 micron particle here or there is on leather and never does actually cut that deep). Once the razor forums posted about it, a few LV trolls posted at length on woodworking boards about it and advocated green chrome paste or powder as a substitute (and the green chrome paste as a matter of doing anything other than cleaning up an already fine edge is a complete waste of time - it's too slow).

There's one handy byproduct of the green, though, in that bar - it's easy to see.

It was interesting to see at the time how many people used those bars, sparingly for razors, liked the result, and then suddenly did not because they read that they shouldn't.

The real issue with a white bar is that they're usually harder (the formax bar is soft, and scribbles off easily with a drop of oil) and the alumina often isn't that closely graded in them unless something very specific is bought. The yellow bars sold as "gold" by carving suppliers are expensive and less fine.

If you could find or make a very well done (closely graded) 1 micron alumina bar, the speed and practical result would probably be similar to the formax bar.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#29

Re: Diminishing returns

Steve Voigt

Derek, I understand your point in response to Bill, but I think you're oversimplifying. The purpose of the pure chrome ox (.5 or .3) is not to get a sharper edge than the formax stick, at least not in the way I intend to use it (and it sounds like Dave has used it this way too). The purpose is to knock off the bits of wire edge a little more easily/quickly than a bare leather strop would. I use a bare strop and it works fine, but I'm interested in an experiment, nothing more, to see if I could speed things up a tad.

This is probably only relevant to oil stone users anyway. A fine Ark will leave a wire edge that must be removed. With your water stones, the slurry beats up the burr enough that there's likely not much wire left after your 10K stone; in fact, I'm not sure I see the benefit of the green strop after a 10K stone, but I'm not a waterstone guy so I'll leave it alone.

Broadly speaking, there are two fundamentally different activities that get described as stropping (you've written about this before and we're in complete agreement). Stropping on plain leather is about removing the wire edge remnants after an oil stone, and done correctly will have no effect on the geometry established by the stone that preceded it.

On the other hand, scribbling green stick on mdf or leather and using it aggressively is really just adding a finer "stone" to one's repertoire, a "stone" that's more flexible than a real stone. Nothing wrong with that, but it's a different thing.

The 0.3 powder is interesting to me because it's potentially a liminal instance, abrasive enough to knock off that oilstone burr without being abrasive enough to establish a new geometry or raise a new, finer wire edge.

Personally, I could care less whether the fine powder is al ox or chrom ox. I suspect the chrome ox is less aggressive and would work better for me, but I don't really know that. I have no idea where Bill is going with this comparison, whether it's intended to solve an actual problem or is just theoretical speculation.

Side note on your Sellers comment: I think he spends 5 minutes on the "strop" for two reasons: (1) the diamond stones he uses are so harsh that he's got to at least ameliorate the deep scratches they leave; (2) his technique makes for pretty haphazard geometry (and I'm sure it's even worse for his acolytes), so he's got to make sure he actually "strops" all the way to the edge, through brute force and repetition.

OK, I'm done ranting.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#30

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still releva

Steve Voigt

Cool, I'm looking forward to trying it.

The problem for me with the formax is that I'm supplying irons for other people, and the scratches it leaves are pretty unsightly. I fully hear you when you say that these scratches don't affect performance, but I don't want to send ugly shit to my customers. That's not an issue for most people, but it's perhaps a reminder for those who need it that there are all sorts of ancillary issues besides ultimate sharpness: there's speed, repeatability, simplicity, ease of procuring the media, cost, and even appearance in some cases.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#31

Re: Good link, thanks.


Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#32

Re: Extrapolation of scenarios

Steve Voigt

When I sell a tool, the only question I ever get is "what did you do to to the edge?

Dave sent me one of his made-from-scratch chisels, and indeed it was really effin sharp, probably sharper than most people have ever experienced. The due knows (so don't pee on his carpet).

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#33

Re: Diminishing returns

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Steve, I totally agree with everything you wrote. What I was unsure about - either because this was not made clear, or (likely) I was being too dim to understand - why the need for such fine chrome powder. I recognised that it was really not going to add much to an edge.

In my own situation, I use Veritas green compound on hardwood as final step to ensure that there is no wire remaining. That is why I complete only 3 strokes. Unlike Sellers, I am not trying to smooth off a rough edge - although some may argue that a Sigma 10K and 13K, which I use, are not fine enough and would benefit from the green compound. Perhaps they do.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#34

Re: Extrapolation of scenarios

david weaver

That was definitely a stone edge (a white synthetic oilstone that I got from japan that leaves a very similar edge sharpness to a settled in black or trans stone), but with the bias that protects the edge a little bit (it's a really lazy way to sharpen things, I guess, but works really well, and as I learned from you, it probably covers up some sins of overhardness sometimes because it yields sharpness and good edge support).

Nothing special about the stone, though - it's just a slow cutting white alumina stone. A fast stone would be a bad choice for that. I love it, it was cheap, and I've not seen one again anywhere else.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#35

I hope brian doesn't show up...

david weaver

...the plane that I sent him years ago never saw anything but a fast washita :\

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#36

Appearance...

david weaver

....good point.

I've sold natural stone edges on razors before, but I always list them as such. I doubt anyone ever really appreciates what they do (they cut hair, but not skin).

when I use chrome ox, I make sure the bevel of a razor is totally bright and clear from end to end. People like to look at that before they shave and comment about it even though what's at the very edge is more important (and it takes a scope to see it).

I could put a letter in about the virtues of natural stone, linen and leather and an uneventful and comfortable shave, but people want a little bit of a fun house scare and they glow about the tastelessly sharp razors. "I have a tough beard, you know...I don't usually get a razor that's sharp enough for my taste".

(they're lumped in with the people who need heavier planes, bigger pickup trucks - despite living in an apartment tower, and golf clubs with 5x stiff shafts because they have "so much power")

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#37

Re: Diminishing returns

david weaver

I have pictures of a 13k sigma somewhere compared to the formax edge. It's interesting to look at them, but they're probably almost identical aside from a softer backing for the formax compound will make for a cleaner edge with no remnants.

The pure chrome powders leave a surface finish that looks visually perfect, as long as the backer is clean (as mentioned in a post above, my only use for them is setting up a razor for someone before I unload one - there's a large segment of the market of buyers who will open a razor and look for anything they can see naked eye and possibly with a loupe, and the chrome ox powder (0.5 or less) leaves absolutely nothing to be seen).

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#38

Re: I hope brian doesn't show up...

Steve Voigt

Brian brought a Japanese chisel when he and Warren visited last winter, and we compared it my favorite, freshly sharpened pre-war Marples. His was definitely a shade sharper.

I did the Hearne Hardwoods show this past weekend, and as always I heard a lot of comments like "wow that's sharp." So it's helpful for me to encounter edges that are slightly better; keeps me on my toes, tinkering a little. It's easy to get complacent and stagnant.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#39

Re: Appearance...

Steve Voigt

LOL, add in the 30 inch jointer planes, because, ya know, my plane is longer than yours.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#40

Re: Diminishing returns

William Duffield

I go from an extra fine diamond "stone" to the 0.3 chrome on horsebutt, glued down to a piece of plywood, and pull the bevel across it about 6 times. Usually, I also lay the back of the blade flat on the strop and pull it across a couple of times. Sometimes, when sharpeninig a blade that requires a slip stone, I go directly from a translucent Arkansas stone to the chrome strop.

I never set up any experiments. I don't even have a microscope to analyze scratch patterns or count carbide chipouts. Someone had recommended chrome on this forum a few years ago, and after I figured out that Crayola has replaced the chrome in their green crayons with some sort of dye, the green powder in the above link is what I found. It just seemed to make sense to mix it with mineral oil before wiping it on the strop. I tried it for a while and was satisfied with the results, so I didn't search any further. I was never expecting anyone to ask me to publish a peer reviewed scientific paper on my results. ;^) I just wanted to get back to work with sharp tools.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#41

What do I have?

Wiley Horne

Years ago, the good soul and carving instructor Nora Hall sold me some carving gouges, and along with the gouges, two German-marked buffing wheels and a block of sharpening paste. You smear the sharpening paste on the wheel.

The buffing wheels are 12mm arbor and ~4-3/4” diameter. The sharpening paste is curious: it is light green in color, and has the property that it is stiff at room temp, but liquifies as the blade/wheel surface heats up. And the liquification is not gradual—it occurs suddenly when the blade/wheel interface hits a particular temp, which ancient memory tells me is about 160F. Once this liquification happens, the cutting power of the paste is activated, and it puts a heck on an edge on carbon steel.

As I say, both the wheel and the paste are German made and marked.

Does anyone have experience with this liquifying paste? And what is it? And what is the cutting principle associated with the heat activation?

Wiley

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#42

Re: Is chromium oxide vs aluminum oxide +...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello All,

For what it's worth and because no has mentioned it yet, Wikipedia (and other sites) state that:

Chromium oxide has a Mohs hardness of 8-8.5

Aluminum oxide has a Mohs hardness of 9

Emery (corundite) - a naturally occurring mixture of various compounds so Mohs hardness between 6-9 depending on composition

Cubic Boron Nitride - Mohs hardness 9.9, Vickers hardness ~76

Diamond - Mohs hardness = 10 but more realistically is roughly 4x harder than Aluminum oxide using Vickers scale. Diamond ~115 GPa Vickers hardness

But, as Warren mentioned, these abrasives have different friability, particle sizes, grain shape and can react differently because of that.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#43

Something called the ‘Koch System’

Wiley Horne

Found the original marketing description:

https://www.norahall.com/tools_koch.shtml

I don’t recommend these tools and materials in the least. In fact, i ‘m a bit embarrassed. I only bring this method out here, because it’s so unique compared to all the other wheel abrasive offerings. Particularly the heat activation which I can’t fathom.

The fact is, it does yield a sharp sharp edge. However, I was not able to maintain geometry over multiple sharpenings. Would inevitably get rounding over and a steeper bevel. When what I always wanted was to maintain a long low bevel on gouges. So I gave it up for conventional methods. Nora liked it as a final hone, after getting the geometry and a reasonable hone by conventional means. I found that it worked great once, and then things kinda went down hill and I would soon have a major regrinding to do.

Wiley

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#44

Enlighten me

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I did make an undocumented assumption in referring to chromium oxide as a historical abrasive for metal abrasion relative to alumina. Small particle chromium oxide would be technologically easy to manufacture. No so with submicrom alumina. In referring to chromium oxide as "historical" relative to alumina I made the assumption that people figured out how to make and use chromium oxide as a metal abrasive before submicron alumina. If this assumption is in error enlighten me of the comparative dates for when these materials became used for polishing metal.

(submicron alumina abrasive is not made by simply crushing aluminum oxide and screening)

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#45

Historical yet again

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I suspect that much of what we consider for final edge refinement has been derived from historical metal polishing. I don't regard edge refinement(polishing the bevel) any different technologically than surface polishing a metal part. This assumption, I'll bet, is widespread. So a woodworker sees someone polishing a piece of metal and says, I could do that to "polish" a chisel bevel. And if it worked the rest is history. That's how I got into diamonds, which I found are now widely used for metal specimen preparation and metal polishing instead of historical abrasives.

If you go back in history I suspect you will find the method you found was developed for metal surface polishing.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#46

Two questions remain

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The original- does chromium oxide have a beneficial properly that proper selection of alumina doesn't match?

And a new one raised by Warren- will proper selection of particle size of the harder abrasives render irrelevant any friability, hardness, etc property of the softer ones. I accept that xx micron diamond will make deeper scratches than xx micron silica. That's why it removes metal vastly faster for equivalent effort. But can you achieve the effect of silica with a finer diamond abrasive? When it comes to visual appearance the answer is yes. Does a historical abrasive do anything beyond remove metal by scratching? No data revealed to suggest it does but one could make a case that it could.

BTW, add silica, hardness about 7, to your tabulation.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#47

Re: Something called the ‘Koch System’

david weaver

Last night, I recalled that system being marketed pretty heavily about a decade and a half ago when I first started woodworking. The melting point (I haven't read bill's post, he's light years ahead of me on this stuff) sounds like wax with a lot of paraffin in it, but who knows...

At any rate, I have tried a lot of things, but never got that one and I remember the wheels being colored, but I don't remember the separate paste. The process that you describe is great with a buff, especially if the edge doesn't need to be ideal.

I love to make skinny little knives out of files and use them to mark and cut things, cut out paper labels for packages (just so much nicer than scissors) and to cut cut down my boxes for recycling. They sharpen really well on a system like that on the gray scotch brite and the 5 micron buff, but once in a great while, they need to see an india stone to get the edge reset to perfect geometry.

I've never used this system for chisels, but I like the bias at the very edge described elsewhere. My early experimenting with a hard felt buff and a leather disc kind of let me know that I'd keep the straight blades on the stones, and then subsequent changes went toward slower and harder finish stones for the final bias. It's really lazy, and it prevents chipout.

As far as geometry goes, I'm sure with most larger gouges, it's possible to maintain pretty good geometry just with buffs and wheels, but I'm also sure it takes a long time to master.

(not advocating gray scotchbrite, just mentioning that i use it in the same way. I should've been brave enough to post that I thought you might be talking about the koch system, because I remember their discussion of the media liquifying instantly when coming in contact with a tool - it's also one of the few things I've never tried, despite my outsized fascination with sharpening as well and as fast as possible)

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#48

My opinion..

david weaver

...no practical difference between the two unless either is being asked to do more than it should.

What william and steve mentioned about chrome ox (william being far enough along to just say that it works and it's a settled issue for him) are about what you'd want to do with anything that small in particle size.

It wouldn't really make any difference if it was 0.25 micron diamonds, half micron chrome ox (or 0.3) or small alumina. In my opinion, the choice of the backer and how it's being used is more important than the media.

Chrome ox will be available because there is an economic subsidy from another hobby - shavers. Shavers will spend quite a bit experimenting with getting a good edge because it's an easy thing to do, but elusive for most beginners. Chrome ox has a nice quality and yields a good shave, making a difference that you can feel vs. something like 1/2 micron diamond.

The issue with all of it is learning to use it in context, and then sticking with the process and not mixing and matching different things without accounting for their differences (for example, people looking at grit charts and wanting to replace an 800 stone with an oilstone of "similar grit").

Iwasaki was selling razors that he finished with 1 micron diamonds, but after he used a good natural stone properly - the diamonds were used to "soften the edge" in his terms, and on an ultra soft backer. To put a razor on one micron diamonds as a final step on even soft leather would've been a no-no, but he used something like a soft felt cloth.

Long story short, no practical difference with any of it (except for me, the abrasives with the color as an integral part of the abrasive makes for a nice visual - you're never guessing at how much you have).

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#49

No clue about historical..

david weaver

....I'll yield to Warren for that. I read little, and it's usually just by chance that I refer to any older writing.

But I was surprised to find that some frenchman discovered chromium in 1797 and by 1838 it was being produced commercially as a pigment. I doubt it took too long before someone somewhere was using it on a strop or plate.

Re: Is chromium oxide honing compound still relevant

#50

The wax thing...

John in NM

I wonder if that was intended as a lubricant as much as a carrier for the polishing media?

I remember going to a gun show with my dad in the 1980's and there was a guy who would sharpen your knife for $2 - his last step was a compressed paper wheel charged with wax and no abrasive. Made for an incredibly sharp edge but it did not last well as I recall - basically just what Wiley described.