Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Removing twist

Posts

Removing twist

#1

Removing twist

Jason in Denver

I am in my first attempts at dimensioning rough stock with hand planes, and I have one piece that I'm not sure is fixable. It is 14" wide by 37" long and just over an inch thick. It is twisted such that with three corners on the bench, the 4th corner is about a half inch off the bench. The finished piece is supposed to be 7/8 thick, but it would probably be ok down to about 3/4. From what I measured above it seems like the best I could get is around 1/2" thick. Would I have a thicker end result if I ripped the board in half, surfaced the halves and then re-glued? My Plan B is to make the part by gluing two bookmatched boards together, so there would be a glueline either way. I would prefer to salvage the first piece due to its figure, but I don't want to end up planing down to a piece of veneer. What say y'all?

Re: Removing twist

#2

Re: Removing twist

William Duffield

If you ripped it in two and flattened both pieces, you would still need to take a minimum of 1/4" off of each, which would put you too close to 3/4", probably under 3/4". If you ripped it in three pieces, you would probably achieve your minimum desired thickness. If it is flat sawn, the glued joints would probably show, but if rift or quarter sawn, they would be practically invisible, or at least unnoticeable to anyone but you.

Re: Removing twist

#3

Re: Removing twist

david weaver

Not seeing it, we don't know if it's mostly rise in a corner, or if the issue is over a broad area.

I think realistically, if it's not going to make what you need relatively easily, then I'd set it aside and get stock that will work more easily.

Re: Removing twist

#4

All twist doesn't have to be removed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I find woodworkers fretting over flatness more than necessary. I don't deny that working flat lumber is easier but in practical woodworking we deal with unflat lumber, or reject a lot of lumber that isn't perfect.

There are a few occasions that require dead flat, an unframed door for example. If it is not flat it won't align in the opening and there is no way of pulling it flat in the assembly. If your board is destined for this application choose another.

At the other extreme there are boards and panels that are constrained by more or less stout framing or joinery. Those that are disturbed by radical woodworking practices should read no further. This table provides an extreme example of dealing with a very not flat board.



By cross cutting it in the middle and folding it back on itself the board that made up this top yielded a stunning, near book match pattern, of curly walnut. I was highly motivated to utilize this board for the top. The problem was that one end curled up, a lot. I carefully prepared the glue joint, laid the two boards on some stout bar clamps and forced the curved end flat against the clamps with jacks forced between the panel and the shop ceiling. After the glue was cured the top was unclamped and the corner of one end curled up about 3/4".

The top was to be fastened to a frame that defined a flat plane. I fastened the not flat top to the frame with table top fasteners, leaving the curled up corner largely curled up. Over the course of a month I tightened the screws holding the top to the frame. Eventually it pulled flat against the frame. That was 10+ years ago. Over time the stress of pulling the corner flat dissipated.

The point of this tale is that in many applications a board cupped or twisted will be constrained by framing or joinery to become flat. Not flat makes doing dovetails more difficult but I deal with this problem often. Most every panel I ever put in a frame and panel assembly was more or less cupped before installing in the frame (which pulled it flat enough and kept it so) It is just part of learning to do practical woodworking. Again, it is easier to work flat lumber when you can, but learning to utilize unflat lumber should be part of gaining experience in building stuff.

So, what is this board to be used for, and can you deal with a bit of twist in this application?

Re: Removing twist

#5

What I would do, and do do

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If I determined I could live with a not flat result I would knock off the diagonal corners on one side with a scrub plane (hand too content!) as much as I could stand and still have the thickness needed. Then I would run it through my thickness planer. And if it was a panel for a case side or table top, or even a panel for a door, I might not entirely clean up one side in order to preserve thickness.

Re: Removing twist

#6

Re: Removing twist

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It is 14" wide by 37" long and just over an inch thick. It is twisted such that with three corners on the bench, the 4th corner is about a half inch off the bench. The finished piece is supposed to be 7/8 thick, but it would probably be ok down to about 3/4.

Jason, if you can determine roughly where the twist begins, I would rip away that section a little way in from that point. I would not rip at the halfway point.

This will afford you the maximum thickness for each section. The twisted section can be jointed to lie flat against the wide section. There should be minimal change in grain on the face side - essentially just a saw kerf and jointing removed (the other side may have lost a 1/4" - 1/2").

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Removing twist

#7

A tangent..

david weaver

....not suggesting this here by any means, but I remember watching a video of a japanese maker several years ago. The maker was putting together dressers and chests of drawers similar in style to american furniture.

At the beginning of the video, they showed either the maker or another workman putting lumber in a press (heated?) and flattening it.

Since then, I've bought stabilized lumber for guitar use (mostly maple, but some spruce). The stabilization looks to have originated when the supply of good structural lumber disappeared into unstable second growth wood (I could be wrong about that, but it's not new).

i have no idea how an average person would follow a process like this, but the wood that comes out of the thermal treatment is hard (more musical sounding) and it smells like a house fire (only mildly, though) because the volatiles have been baked out.

(with not much searching, I found another video showing the same thing, but the heat and pressure are separate)

https://youtu.be/P50VtDfQa1g

Still an advocate for using a different piece of wood, but a non-contact thermometer, a fire and some good welding gloves (along with something to secure the wood in) would make for an interesting experiment in a piece of wood that may not otherwise be used in the first place.

I didn't watch this whole video, but see my interpretation of "american style" furniture is large tansu, and I'm sure the makers would be offended by that, but their solid furniture looks a lot like the early manufactured veneer furniture made in the united states.

It also looks like theirs is paulownia, which can be rotten in terms of movement, and is usually low density and soft. Maybe it lends itself to this kind of game playing.

(all that said, I'd still start with a piece of wood that will allow you to work without making the simple dimensioning a complicated and potentially unsuccessful process).

Re: Removing twist

#8

mechanical flattening

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think that simply heating and mashing would do all sorts of bad things to a twisted piece of wood. For one, simply heating will crack the piece from moisture loss.

I expect you missed a step-steaming. Brought to 100 C with steam the wood is plasticized. It will move easily and when cool stay whatever shape it was mashed to.

I have taken bow (or is it crook) out of "priceless" boards with a steam iron and clamps.

Re: Removing twist

#9

Re: Removing twist

Wiley Horne

Hi Jason,

My first and last thought is ‘don’t fool with that board’. It’s going to be miles of bad road, ending in a piece too thin to carry out your intent. Use it for 3/8” drawer sides or a pair of housed panels instead.

But. If you absolutely mean to use the figure on that board, I suggest two steps: first, plane it flat in whatever way seems most feasible to you from the other suggestions here—ripped, flattened, and reglued, or not. Then you will end up with a flat board, say 5/8”+ thick with the figure on it. Then face glue this piece to a second board to bring the thickness to 1” or so. For the face gluing, use heavy cauls with wet towels underneath them (both sides) to offset movement while gluing—the wet towels are critical for any water-based glue—white, yellow, TB3 or hide. You could help yourself by using epoxy or other waterless glue, omitting the wet towels, and oversize by less. After face gluing, reflatten to 7/8”.

Wiley

Re: Removing twist

#10

Re: Removing twist

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This is a good example of a situation where an experienced hand tool woodworker can do much better than a machine woodworker.

First of all, if you try to make your new board parallel to the three corners that are flat on the bench, then yes, you might finish out at 1/2 or worse. We don't do that. If you rock the board back a little so that two opposite corners are equally off the bench, say 1/4, the picture brightens appreciably. And if you have not yet done anything to the board, it may be closer to 1 1/8. If it is a case side, you may be able to cheat somewhere, like a back corner where there is a rabbet on the inside.

If you watch the U tube experts, they first plane cross grain everywhere on the board, even planing places that are already low. Then they plane diagonally, every where, not just the diagonal that needs it, but also the diagonal that is already low. Judicious planing takes nothing from the low spots.

My hunch is that your board could be made to answer at 7/8, but that it would be hard for an inexperienced person could do it.

Re: Removing twist

#11

Re: mechanical flattening

david weaver

I'd guessed the same thing. The baking part (wood that I've purchased) is done with already straight wood to my knowledge. Even after that is finished, the wood is steamed again to prevent it from being too brittle (the kind of brittle that some very old wood gets to).

I hadn't seen nor heard of any of this the first time that I saw that japanese wood press and figured aside from the fact that it probably weighs 6 tons, I wouldn't mind having something around that could make every cupped or twisted board flat again.

These days, I think I'd rather just have more stable stock, though.

The older documents regarding stabilization of lower quality building lumber were fairly interesting, though, insofar as they hold some key values that someone like me would look for in paying even an extra penny for any guitar woods that have been "torrefied".

Re: Removing twist

#12

What an experienced machine woodworker would do

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Creating a plane is all the same no matter how the wood is removed. Some one experienced can do it by jointer or other machine means to achieve an equivalent result. Place flat on jointer bed, teeter until the high corners are equally high off the bed and run it across the knives.

Some would deal with the situation much the same way if the jointer was more narrow than the board. However, if one has an hour of scrub plane experience diagonal corners can be nipped off until the piece doesn't rock on the table saw top. Then run it through the planer. I find the latter approach best for me.

The cherry chest of drawers I recently built was made from lumber from a tree with emotional connection. For various reasons the lumber was cupped and twisted but I was motivated to use it. I did a lot of straightening as described above. There isn't an alternative to having flat drawer fronts and frame stock for framing panels.

Re: Removing twist

#13

Re: mechanical flattening

Joe shelton

I agree about the temperature and plastisizing, but my experience is that it does not always retain the new shape. For example, last night I bent a shotgun stock. It started with 1/4" cast off at the heel and about 5/16" cast off at the toe. Using the techniques in Bob Smalser's article here, I pulled it to 1/2" at the toe and 3/8" at the heel, cast on, then left the clamps on until it cooled to room temperature. That amount of displacement had me nervous as the proverbial harlot in chapel, so I quit. When I removed the clamps, springback reverted it to 1/4" cast on at both heel and toe.

Springback in this process is not unusual, but I'd not previously seen that degree of regression. Smalser says that you always can go back and add more displacement (in the same direction), and I may need to do that. But first, I'll shoot it some. If I don't really need the toe twisted out, I'll settle for what I got.

Re: Removing twist

#15

Re: What an experienced machine woodworker would d

Charlie

Yep, there's no reason a woodworker can't process such a board and obtain maximum thickness, regardless of what he or she is using to reduce the high corners.

Re: Removing twist

#16

Re: Allow me to take a hack at this...

Charlie

A tabletop only really needs one, flat side and that's the side that fits to the apron. Any twist can pull the undercarriage itself into twist when the top is mounted. If you've left enough trim room on the legs you can make the table sit flat, but it could mess up the fit for any drawers included in the design.

Unless the surface exposed to nothing but air is egregiously out, and of course it shouldn't be, nobody will ever notice. The only requirement for this surface is that is be attractive cosmetically --smooth, etc. it does not usually have to be a geometrically perfectly flat surface from end to end and across its width.

Re: Removing twist

#17

Hand work

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There are a lot of techniques available to the hand worker that would be awfully clumsy on a machine. I expect you know them, Charlie.

One such technique is planing corner to corner on a diagonal, with or without going the whole distance.

Re: Removing twist

#18

Re: Removing twist

Jason in Denver

Thanks for all the good advice. To add some detail, it will be a top for a bookcase (Stickley #700 bookcase), so it could be pulled down somewhat as Bill suggests. I'm working on planing twist out of one of the side pieces, and did make the mistake of flattening the cup first. The wood is QSWO.

Someone needs to build a steam-vaccuum-kiln-press to flatten boards. Sort of like a dry cleaner for woodworkers. I wonder if the neighbor's sauna would get hot enough...

Re: Removing twist

#19

Re: Removing twist

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First some background to put my advice in perspective. We sold lumber. It was common to get a piece or two in 1000bdft packs that was going to be hard to sell. It was this lumber I often worked for my projects. I was highly motivated, and became experienced, working stuff that others would avoid. Eventually it became a goal to turn sow's ears into silk purses. (Maybe millennial don't know these farm sayings) I don't worry much about how flat a top is; I will flatten it upon installation.

1. I looked up a 700 book case. I would not want to live with this furniture but I do enjoy looking at it. You need the specified thickness for the top or it is going to look not authentic. (and you need the perfect stain to look its best. Develop finish schedule on test pieces)

2. The bottom of the top is not going to show much or at all, so only one side needs to be perfect. Unfortunately the top's bottom front corners will show so they need to be almost perfect.

3. Before I planed on pulling it flat I would test to see how much force it took. Oak is sturdy but I think if you wind up with 1/8" twist it will pull out against the framing.

4. Spare no effort to get the stiles and rails flat and straight if it has a door.

Re: Removing twist

#20

Undeniable

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One such technique is planing corner to corner on a diagonal

The teetering on a jointer bed alternative to simulate this technique was abandoned as soon as I converted an old Stanley into a scrub plane.

Wrong Forum to advocate the following but these diagonals just have to be removed enough so the piece doesn't rock on a flat surface. With this surface down, run through the thickness planer and the top will become planer.

If I could conjure the patience I can see that flattening entirely by hand would be a rewarding accomplishment.

Re: Removing twist

#21

Farm sayings about stingy..

david weaver

..I'm sure there are hundreds, but my mother was always cheap, and would keep cutoffs from the local pole building place and eventually force my dad to cut them to shape (santa clauses or whatever) and she'd paint them and sell them.

When you grow up in a rural area, especially if it's a rural german area (way different than urban german), everyone accuses everyone else of being cheap, but most of the people who have two nickels to rub together are actually cheap (and tax sensitive).

My mother's common saying (and she'd point out that you were using junk wood and turn around and use it herself - thrift double standard, I guess) would be to accuse you of "being so cheap that you'd skin a fart for a nickel".

Re: Removing twist

#22

Re: Farm sayings about stingy..

Wiley Horne

The old folks kept their farm ways, even when they moved to town. But mine didn’t have the concept of being cheap as a value judgment. In their world, you were either lazy or thrifty.

My maternal grandmother kept a big ball of string. She’d take the string off the newspaper (they weren’t plastic wrapped in those days) and add it to the big ball o’ string. She sewed everything on her treadle Singer, which I don’t recall ever getting motorized, and all off cuts ended up being made into hook rugs, made with crochet tools, or quilts. Maybe it’s all still alive in farm country.

Wiley

Re: Removing twist

#23

Re: Farm sayings about stingy..

david weaver

I think the family farm has gone now (not totally, but it's disappearing fast). We still (we being my parents, not me - I wish) own our farm, but it has been rented for over 25 years now.

The renters used to be farmers, but now they're corporate business owners who farm as a hobby and the last two have signed the contract and then the people who show up in the fields are subcontracted.

I couldn't name anyone in my school who grew up on a farm and is still working on it (my school was rural).

The ball of string is familiar, rubber bands, strings, pencils. When I went to my grandparents' house as a kid in the late 1980s, it was a thrill to get the pencil box out because they had pencils that still needed to be made wet to write (we licked them - I have no clue about the backstory about them or what they were made of), and the rest of the writing instruments were promotional material. They wouldn't dream of throwing away the old pencils in favor of something easier to use.

Re: Removing twist

#24

no, no, no

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It's skinning a fart to save a s/cent. Better said than typed.

Re: Removing twist

#25

woodworking content

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Around the mill it was "tighter than the bark on a hickory tree"