Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Test 5

Posts

Re: Test 5

#51

When I was younger, I hunted..

david weaver

...it took me a long time to figure out that the articles were pretty formulaic.

A lot of the woodworking magazines are, too:

* this rifle is a real workhorse in the field

* this plane is a real workhorse in the shop

* illuminated reticles (sp?) are a game changer that every hunter should have

* modern steel and fast abrasives are a game changer that every woodworker should add to their rotation

(and that's ignoring the domino and the gaggle of devices for people who like that stuff)

I admire people who can write articles without getting real far into them.

without looking back, IIRC, Charlie said Becksvoort reported experience in teak. V11 shouldn't last much longer than anything else in teak that has a lot of silica in it. metals that have much harder carbides should...except they don't last much longer in wood that doesn't have a lot of silica. I was careful testing wood that's not likely to accelerate a test, and at the same time, that should be relatively uniform within each test board. I was hoping for that in maple, but it didn't prove to be true.

If I had an article due, I couldn't justify all of the faffing. I leave accelerating things to the car magazines or CA Glue Fancy.

I'm pleased with this test so far, but I'm dreading the writing a little bit, even though I can sometimes do it well if I have a reviewer.

(I do think the woodworking magazines are a bit less beholden to selling what they're printing or making fancy claims, or something equivalent to taking a very unethical shot at a running animal from 550 yards away.

that's youtube videos now. I left a couple of nasty comments on a video from someone called stumpy nubs. No clue why youtube recommended that guy's videos to me, but it recommended that I watch one with hone rite gold and a bunch of amazon sales links in it. I should be above leaving a comment, but I couldn't help myself. It included comments like:

" WD 40 is too thick to use on a diamond hone and will suspend your stone away from the stone. You need something like this that's thinner than water "(paraphrased)"

"I never want to have oil around tools in my shop" (paraphrased - not going to watch it again. I have no idea what anyone would be afraid of - not having tools rust without buying a magic potion for water?)

And it had the $150 Chinese diamond hone in it (trend?) which I am diametrically opposed to because it represents the entire problem that's taken over woodworking in the last 20 years - how to get the lowest production cost item in place so that a maximum amount can be spent on marketing, partner links, coupons, etc.

I couldn't ever write anything connected by one or two degrees of separation from an advertiser.

Re: Test 5

#52

Re: That's true...

Kees

A little late in replying to this, but this catched my eye:

I expected to find with this test that LV's tales were a little tall. I'm not above proving myself wrong, though.

The little tall story was that LV suggested in their sales literature that PMV-11 sharpens about twice as slow as O1, but wears 9 times as slow in wood. That was kind of hard to believe. (http://www.pm-v11.com/TestingIntroduction.aspx)

Your test though suggests that PMV-11 wears twice as long as O1 while I found that it sharpens twice as slow indeed. So there is no magic after all.

Re: Test 5

#53

Re: That's true...

Rob Lee

Kees,

You mis-state the case here. The chart we show has no units. It reflects test scores of performance, on a scale of 1-10.

Our data was developed for more than 20 steels, and many different tests.

That O1 scores a 1 and PM-V11 scores a 9 only indicates relative performance in our test group.

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Test 5

#54

There's a little magic...

david weaver

The steel that you posted a link to has a very strong reputation in the world of knife users, and it appears that there are supply issues for it.

They are used to very high vanadium steels, especially in the stainless types. M4 (non-stainless), M390, Elmax, S35V, S90, S110 etc, are all commonly found in knives, and I'm sure they all wear reasonably well, but can be a bear to sharpen.

The key, as I see it, is finding a steel high in chromium carbides, but with enough other alloying elements to get hard enough to be in the sweet spot for planes (60-62 or so). And then, with little enough vanadium because vanadium seems to be a good very wear resistant carbide, even in wood, but it doesn't seem to reach what you'd think its numerical potential would be against something like V11. Whether the carbides are pulled out of the matrix or come out when the material around them erodes, I don't know, but the others wear more slowly without lasting longer and aren't as slick in the cut.

It's novel, I'm enamored with it, and as rob said, I can have a really cynical view sometimes! (that's not exactly what he said, he just mentioned that my view that I could be banned as a buyer was cynical).

I'm fast approaching 30,000 feet planed, and it's just nicer to use than anything else. I hate to say it (partially because like rob, I'm going back to O1 and other stuff like it, anyway - at least most likely), but it's nicer in the cut than O1 and the finish is the brightest I've seen.

I looked up XHP and bought a bar. It's expensive. If that's what it is and it's that good in plane irons, I'm going to foil wrap it and see if I can heat treat it and make some knives out of it.

I would assume that the market is limited because in more metal to metal contact type operations, or more abrasive operations, I'm sure the vanadium carbides would stand out. They do some in wood, but not proportionally, it seems.

At the cost of the bar that I purchased ($135 or something for 36 inches of .094" and 2" wide), I can't believe there's much financial incentive for LV to offer it compared to A2 and O1, though I'm not working in production. I have had some O-1 irons warp. The one I made for this test was a little more squirrely than expected. No big deal. I flattened it. That's probably problematic in a production environment.

But, I'll admit, I'm still fascinated with it and other stuff of its composition seems to be uncommon. Everything either is more like 440C or CPM154-CM where there's some potential, but the high hardness isn't there, or the high hardness comes along with lots of vanadium, which presents sharpening issues - easily solved by diamonds, but not much else.

There is only one fault of V11 that I can think of. Rob mentioned heat tolerance similar to other common tool steels that we use. It doesn't spark much on a grinder, and tools that spark less build more heat from what i can tell. One has to be careful grinding it.

One last test I almost forgot about after the angle and abrasive test in O1 - V11 vs. O1 in end grain. I have to fabricate a big fake endgrain board long enough to plane. At least that test should be faster.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f2WU-vUpfXc

Re: Test 5

#55

Re: That's true...

Kees

Okay. Then that's the magic of sales literature. This wasn't mentioned on the summary page I linked to, but when you read further you can indeed find a more detailed description of the scale. The problem with that test is that it hasn't much in common with the daily practice of planing wood. Planing MDF and then looking at the scratches is not so meaningfull, not like David's testing here.

I think I'm going to get a blade for my endgrain plane (Stanley #6), because that is the only area where the original Stanley iron is lacking in my experience.

Re: Test 5

#56

I'll be testing endgrain soon

david weaver

That'll give us an idea of toughness comes more into play. If it does, then you should just get a harder tough iron.

I am guessing (though I have no proof yet) that the gap will narrow some on end grain.

Stanley plane irons last well in long grain, but rubber to road, they're probably in my tests somewhere about 40% as long wearing as the V11. Of course, that's solvable with good sharpening technique without any issue.

The ad copy drove me bonkers, too, and is one of the reasons that I ran the test. So far, I've bought an iron and a stick of XHP that I didn't need, total of about $200.

End grain speeds the wear on something like a stanley plane, but I can't say I've ever really minded it. In panel ends trimmed, etc, after sawing, or trimmed to the mark, it's still several ends before needing to stop to resharpen for 2 minutes and then back to it.

I am fighting two problems that would keep me from just flopping V11 in the test bed used for most of my numbers.

1) I've made my own irons, and I like them

2) the Lie Nielsen plane is great for a testing bed. it's heavy and stable. But the bronze is monstrously sticky and needs to be waxed constantly, and the problem is multiplied by the fact that it's machined so perfectly. In my experience with prior planes, this is amplified on end grain. Something with a little sloppiness or uneven wear tends to be much less onerous to use on end grain

Back to the ad copy, though. it drove me bonkers. I want to see actual numbers, but I realize why that may not be a great idea to post - it can make you a target to post actual data, both from armchair critics as well as potentially legally, and it gives other competitors something to grab on to and claim against.

Re: Test 5

#57

The bug bit me too

Wiley Horne

Last week, it bit me while I was regrinding the W1 iron that came with my LN 4. Went to LV site and got in line for a V11 iron for my LN4. They were backordered. I like to sharpen, but grinding gets old.

No. 6 is a great size IMO.

Wiley

Re: Test 5

#58

If it takes too long...

david weaver

to get them back in stock, I'll send you mine in another week or two.

Since kees mentioned the suspected alloy and I've ordered a piece of bar stock, I'm going to try to make one using stainless foil. if I don't have the good one in hand, I won't know how bad my efforts are.

Re: Test 5

#59

Question for Wiley re Stanley Bedrock 5 1/2

E Phillip Smith

If I remember correctly one of your favorite planes is a 5 1/2. Do you have a bedrock 5 1/2 and if so what is the blade width. I have a Stanley 5 1/2 bedrock and the blade measures 2 1/4" wide. Lee Valley does not sell a 2 1/4" wide blade and my 3V, and M4 irons are 2 3/8" wide. Looks like I will need to custom grind a blade to width.

Re: Test 5

#60

Re: Question for Wiley re Stanley Bedrock 5

Wiley Horne

Hi Phil,

Great question! And a good drive by in re your 2-1/4 Bedrock. I do think a 5-1/2 is a plane for all seasons, course I think that same thing about a lot of planes. The modern 5-1/2’s (mine is an LN) are all 2-3/8” I believe.

I truly think 2-1/4” is a more handy width, and if I’m not mistaken, the 2-1/4” models are quite old vintage planes—perhaps someone can straighten me out on that point. They have some cachet among the old tools crowd, and rightly so. It makes sense they’re real old, cause otherwise you could find 2-1/4” irons commercially.

Here’s an option: Konrad Sauer took one of our 3V irons—fully hardened with the Elliott logo on it—and had a local machine shop there in Canada slice a 1/8” strip longways off each side. Using a waterjet machine. I needed the iron cut down so as to fit a 2” infill smooth plane that Konrad had made. He sent me the offcut strips along with the plane and blade! Never got around to making awls out of them, but I think I could still find them.

Anyway, I couldn’t believe it when I saw those,offcuts. Water jet?? But it was cut slick as you please. So you might bear in mind that you can take a 2-3/8 hardened iron and make a 2-1/4 out of it. Obviously, check around locally to make sure there’s someone with the right machine.

Wiley

Re: Test 5

#61

Re: Question for Wiley re Stanley Bedrock 5 1/2

Wiley Horne

Phil,

A little follow-up.....Stanley Bedrock 605-1/2 was made from 1898-1935, so they’re all prewar (the big one). All of them had the 2-1/4” iron, which some measure to be a skosh less than 2-1/4.

You’ve likely already checked, but here is Bob Kaune’s Bedrock type study, in case you want to pin down the manufacturing date:

https://www.antique-used-tools.com/brtypes.htm

BTW, waterjet cutting does not alter the temper in any way.

Wiley