Test 5
David Weaver
3v, v11 and m4. 1020 feet planed so far and no noticeable issues. All are noticeably more dull than at the start. V11 subjectively again slickest through the cut.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Test 5
David Weaver
3v, v11 and m4. 1020 feet planed so far and no noticeable issues. All are noticeably more dull than at the start. V11 subjectively again slickest through the cut.
Re: Test 5
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
3 x 1000'. You are amazing! If your wife thinks you have gone off your rocker, assure her at least two persons anxiously await your results.
Re: Test 5
E Phillip Smith
This is getting really interesting.
When you have time to comment I'm curious on the differences in sharpening of these very different steels.
Re: Test 5
David Weaver
Hard to tell much difference on diamonds between m4 and v11. 3v seems to have a more persistent wire edge, and be a little less fine feeling in the cut. Not sure why, I definitely eliminated the wire edge for sure this time. beech seems to grip the m4, but that feeling could be another factor.
Easy
David Weaver
I chose a slightly shorter piece of beech for this go-around, and the work was smooth.
3000 feet is just a figure, but all of the planing is very easy because the irons cut well for all of that. The pain in the rear is the point where the irons start coming in and out of the cut and you have to pay more attention to make sure you're not contributing to it.
It would be lovely if you could just plane until they come out of the cut once and stop, but that wouldn't be reliable.
Very idealized compared to dimensioning, though, where you do a lot of work just to get to a few continuous shavings and you're done.
Easy?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Maybe easy pushing the plane but not so easy planning a soundly executed experiment, assembling the materials, devoting boggling time to do the work, communicating the results, answering questions, defending the results, etc.
But in the end the edge life under realistic conditions of steels with widely differing properties will be located in dulling vs feet planed space, plus bonus information on sharpening, surface quality and maybe other information. As far as I know this will be the only data of this kind published.
The data set will enable one to determine what steel properties are significant contributors to edge life. The data will enable predictions to be made of the performance of steel not tested. Maybe there is a better steel out there waiting to be evaluated. The data set will enable quantitative comparisons to be made among possible blade steels for sale to guide new purchases. The data will challenge advertising claims. and more......
Re: Test 5 results
david weaver
3v - 1680 feet
v11 - 2295 feet
m4 - 2373 feet
v11 again seemingly slicker through the cut. m4 lasted, but more cut friction and harsher looking in the pictures.
Board with a few degrees of upward grain, beech. less dry and lighter heart than the last board. more favorable planing, for sure.
m4 and 3V both quit abruptly.
can't help but wonder if the grip of the m4 is something contributing to faster than expected wear. do carbides or groups of particles get pulled from the steel while planing, costing some of the wear potential?
distance
david weaver
1.2 miles from 3 planes.
thanks to phil and wiley for providing two of these irons.
Re: Test 5 results
Wiley Horne
Bravo, David! Great work.
One question: did you get a sense, while planing, about when you would have resharpened, had it not been a ‘plane to failure’ test?
Reason for asking: I have a bias to the effect that no steel has a 1/3 to 1/2 mile of quality strokes in it, though it may be held in the cut for that long.
Also: I don’t mind being informed I’m wrong about my biases
.
Again, wonderful work. I add my voice to Bill Tindall’s plaudits—he said it better than I could have.
Wiley
And another thing..
Wiley Horne
Lee Valley has certainly made a believer of me and I would think many others, in its PM V11 steel! Big congratulations to Rob Lee and his team! The combination of sharpenability and endurance seems to defy physics.
Wiley
Dang...
Jonathan Elliott
...and LV was already having trouble keeping their blades in stock, maybe you shouldn't publish these results...just keep it our little secret 
Re: Test 5 results
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
m4 and 3V both quit abruptly.
suggests to me that the shape of the wear is different than V11. This factor would be reflected in the vertical force vs distance curves in the K&K work. Will study these graphs and see what I can see. Well...I didn't see anything revealing. The longer wearing steels approached the transition from down force to up more slowly. But all the steel had approximately linear curves through the transition from down force to up force.
****Something interesting in the K&K paper translated. The slope of this curve is dramatically different with grain variation as a variable.(Figure 11) Blade lifted in just over half the distance with 7 degree up sloping grain than flat grain. This variable is critical in this experiment.
Will you elaborate
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"Reason for asking: I have a bias to the effect that no steel has a 1/3 to 1/2 mile of quality strokes in it, though it may be held in the cut for that long."
Caution: David's end point could be shortened significantly if the grain is laying in a favorable slope. K&K translation Figure11
I'm trying to get a picture of what people on this Forum do with a plane to get an idea of what demands are made of it and what the result is.
What exactly about planing as you do it, for what end result, would cause you to sharpen before David's end point, or believe you couldn't get 1000' from an O-1 edge? In practical terms if you were surfacing a 3 x 2' table would you expect to have to sharpen before completing the task, or whatever quantitative description comes to mind? What is your end point- looks, feel, fatigue? (I'm stabbing at questions because I don't know what to ask to learn what demands of the blade/plane are being judged)
Some "Supersurfacer" results were measured in km, presumably with results acceptable to whatever purpose this lumber goes to. The species often was Douglas Fir so I suppose house beams but I have no clue what quality surface house beams are planed to.
I think....
David Weaver
....the lack of blades from LV probably has more to do with ordering a specialty steel from a mill that there may be other customers for, and being able to get that one steel only from one mill (or company with several mills).
I read on one of the mill sites that they fast tracked the development of a steel for $20MM or something, so I would assume that LV picked a steel rather than having one developed (Rob mentioned costs of a quarter of a million dollars or something, half a million? not sure).
Hadn't really even thought about it until seeing that figure.
But it is *really* good, and I expected to prove that it was only a little more than A2. I obviously didn't bias my results to make them what I expected, and am surprised.
Re: Test 5 results
David Weaver
A couple of things. I would probably sharpen them when it occurred to me to and not in the last 10 strokes of something.
Just going by feel, I'd say I'd have sharpened the M4 and the 3V around 1000 strokes. The M4 has resistance in the cut. What is it? I don't know. It's not lack of sharpness, because it leaves a surface very bright like V11. Both hold on to that brightness for a similar amount of time.
Carbon steel holds on to this same brightness, but for a third as long, maybe. 3V seems to proportional to the length of wear vs. V11.
I'm sure I'd lean on the sticky LN bronze plane at some point and errantly blame it on the iron and sharpen it.
I guess if I had to make any guess as likely as any other, I'd say 1000 feet on the 3V and m4 and slightly longer with the V11, just because it's a little bit more slick in the cut.
I got an old ward ironed norris 2 out, sharpened it the same way as these, except on a japanese stone labeled "barber oil stone". It was about as dull as V11 was at 1200 feet at 350. That's not a typo. That iron has been only partially worked up, so it might have another 100 feet if it was fully done like the test irons, and the back was a little more perfect. The plane isn't quite as ideally made for the test, but it's clear that it was very dull at 500 feet or so. I still love those irons.
The interesting thing about this test is that the 3V iron felt good for a larger percentage of its cut. It looks better in pictures, too. It makes me wonder if it is the shape of the edge that makes it fail and not the amount of wear. After the first two pictures, I was sure the M4 wouldn't last, but it did. All the way along, the cut resistance made me think that it was wearing more - hard on the handle wrist, but it just kept going. ball park it at half of this total is where the plane not only stays in the cut but it just puts itself in the cut, slightly more than half for the 3V, though.
When I got about 800 feet out of O1 and warren said he figured that he'd be sharpening around 400 feet, I think that's pretty accurate.
Re: Test 5 results
David Weaver
Upward sloping means they're cutting with the grain? The feel of this wood (Whcih came in the same load from the same lumberman) is very different from the first piece of beech. That one felt more dry and was a little more dusty. This one has none of that, it's just more compliant, but the quality of the piece of wood isn't quite as good (the heart/sap divide isn't as stark, and it's not properly sawn quartered with pith centered. It would look quartered on the ends if that's all you saw, but that's it).
I should probably elaborate on one plane giving up vs. another. Early in the test, the planes operate like a well-set plow. A well set plow for the uninitiated will be dropped at the end of a row, it'll go right into the cut and will stay there. If it's marginally set, you can faff with it but it doesn't stay in the cut as well, and if it's not set properly at all (ignoring going too deep), it'll fight its way back out of a cut.
Once you're somewhere around 1200 feet in a test like this, you have to be more careful about staying directly behind the plane and not influencing it left or right, and it gradually gets worse until the plane somewhere around a couple of hundred feet before the distances shown bounces in and out of a cut and you have to be very deliberate (but it will still stay in). The test is over when the plane won't stay in no matter how careful you are, unless you add down pressure. So it's gradually getting worse the whole test, but what you perceive is the point where it flips over the line. 3V seems to be more simple at figuring that out whereas 3V and M4 hang around that line longer. It's not just proportional to total wear length. What is it that causes that right when you get to that point? I don't know. It's not a bad characteristic either way.
In the case of this test, I had different planes, so it's hard to say anything for certain, but I thought the 3V was going to last with the V11 until about 100 feet before it stopped. It must wear in a different shape.
First 500 feet or so with these planes, you point them toward wood and they drop into the cut and stay there, even if you're a little careless, but that goes away.
Re: Will you elaborate
Wiley Horne
Hi Bill and al,
Truth in advertising: I may have already made my last piece of furniture and that was a few years ago, so I don't want to give a wrong impression. However I will speak in the present tense below.
What I actually do....I think in terms of starting with a fresh iron, and doing a module of work. What’s a module of work? You mentioned 3’ x 2’ table top. So there are three boards. Suppose starting from 4/4 rough-sawn, suppose no twist and minimal bow or cup...crosscut somewhat over long...Strategy is to get them flat enough to edge join, join and glue up, then plane flat and no wind. Two-stage planing is to hold as much thickness as possible.
Module 1: With a foreplane, plane one side of each board flat enough to go thru a lunchbox planer, skin the other side in the planer. There are now 6 edges to be jointed. Using the same foreplane, knock the high spots off the six edges to get the edges ready for the try plane. That’s a module for the foreplane: 3 sides more or less flattened and 6 edges readied for try plane. The plane isn't dull, but I’m going to sharpen before I use it again. I want to hear a singing sound when I start anything new. Dunno how many feet were planed, but it isn’t anything near 1,000.
Module 2, 3...With try plane, joint the six edges, two by two by two. Glue up. Go back to resharpened fore plane.....well, yadda yadda yadda...suffice to say the foreplane and try plane will get the two sides of the top flat, no wind, ready to smooth one side. That’s a module for the try plane. Smoothing one side will be a module for the smoother. It’ll be resharpened before starting another task.
Bill, just trying to give the idea of when I resharpen.
If I haven’t used a plane in a while and pick it up to do something important, it gets fresh sharpening without testing whether it’s already sharp or not.
I think I would only be interested in duration planing if (1) I were fully dimensioning from rough with no machine aid, or (2) if I were woodworking for a living in the 1800’s.
My bias I mentioned is simply that I’ve noticed that the singing sound of a fresh iron, and the eager pulling into the cut, fades on O1, 3V or M2 while the plane is still doing respectable work. That gives me the notion that the very best strokes on any iron tend to be fleeting, but I never truly test it because of the ‘module’ approach mentioned.
Notwithstanding all this blarney, I still am avidly interested in David’s findings, and in the mysteries of carbon steel, alloyed or not.
Wiley
Six long-grain edges to be shot before glue-up.
It's really difficult...
David Weaver
...to make a parallel between this test and what I would do day to day in the shop. It's easy to lose focus, and after getting about 500 feet out of a wonderful norris 2 say "it's antiquated, it makes no sense to use it", but all things aside, the norris sticks to the board less than the LN, and despite having planed probably 20,000 feet so far in these tests, idealized planing like this doesn't really occur for me.
The bulk of the time is jack and try planing, and smoothing is fleeting.
The bulk of the time, I'm also using cherry and not beech, so the feet stretch out a little further, and i'm hoping to avoid putting the plane somewhere or getting something dirty on the wood so as to threaten the quality of the planing result.
So I will probably go back to using irons that I've made in stanleys 4, out of novelty and because they work well, and for the wooden planes, irons that are shaped right to fit.
But, boy was I wrong about how long these would last compared to a carbon steel iron. It's not a close contest.
Re: Test 5 results
Wiley Horne
Excellent description, David! I hope you include some qualitative ‘planing feel’ remarks like this in your formal report. It really grounds the whole thing and adds to the authenticity. An important complement to the distances because it tells the reader what the bare numbers really mean.
Wiley
good point
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
For those that did not follow this work from the beginning, in the final report there will be a credibility issue to deal with. It is details like this elaboration of end point detection that convinced me early on that these data were going to be useful.
Credibility
david weaver
When you're the person publishing the report, credibility doesn't seem like a problem, though I get the issue from the information consumer's side.
Thus the design of the test so that it can be easily repeated by someone else.
I expect a flurry of "no iron lasts that long" as well as "i planed three miles with a modern stanley iron".
From time to time, I get static about there being no way that I've purchased as many stones or chisels or planes, whatever it may be - as I talk about having used, but when you're actually sitting on more stuff that you've never talked about having, that's easy to laugh off.
The details of this test (the inconsequential lessening of clearance that takes place early, vs. the effect as it goes away and then the more abrupt effect when it gets to the point that a plane will skip in a cut and then decide that it can't enter the cut easily enough to correct it) - they're easy to talk about after 20k feet or so of planing. I'm a little more sure about what happens each time, vs some things that don't.
Re: Credibility
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
exactly why you were the person to do this testing and why the work is credible.
And why it is relevant.....l.
There are three worthy goals here.
1. When buying a new blade, what to buy.
2. If making a blade, what to make it from?
3. If searching for better steel, what properties to look for?
WOW what a data set
E Phillip Smith
Great work.
Last time I did any serious planning with the M4 iron I was around 2300 to 2500 lineal feet in cherry and yellow pine. That experience is in line the data that you have. It's great news that the V11 is so good. It's a lot easier to buy a good iron than to make them.
Now would be a good time to have an SEM of the surface. I suspect that what you are seeing is very different wear mechanism between M4 and V11. The M4 has a LOT of very small but very hard carbide particles that I suspect the wood does not wear or polish very well. I suspect the wood is wearing away the iron background and exposing the carbides, hence the surface at the micro scale will look rough and may have higher friction due to micro roughness.
The V11 does not have the very hard, Vanadium, Tungsten, or Molybdenum carbides but should have a ton of very small chromium carbides based on it's hardness. So the question is are the chromium carbides enough softer that they will wear (POLISH) with the wood. If so it will feel slicker in the wood.
Re: WOW what a data set
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
K&K papers have tons of SEM pictures of worn edges.
Want to know about carbides in these metals....
This site will keep one occupied for days.
https://knifesteelnerds.com/2019/06/03/the-history-of-3v-cru-wear-and-z-tuff-steel/
https://knifesteelnerds.com/2019/07/29/xhp-steel-history-and-properties/
Re: WOW what a data set
david weaver
Pretty much covers my guessing, though I'm professionally uncertain about things (I like to talk about what's likely or unlikely or just what generates results without having to explain exactly why unless I can get a perfect test).
In this case, the M4 is a spectacular planing steel. It tricks you into thinking that it's dulling quickly and then doesn't stop.
The V11 leaves you wandering in a forest of "how long have i been planing with this plane?" and then it eventually loses clearance and punishes you like any other steel if you're foolish enough (as I am by rule in this test) to try to find the point where it "stops cutting half of the length of the board".
I expected something better out of my ward iron in the curiosity test but it sort of went well for about 350 feet, then the next 150 were that same kind of torture.
I pat myself on the back for making the following statement: I learned a lot more about planing (especially with respect to from rough) from soft irons than I did hard. The amount of smoothing that I do is insignificant in the grand scheme of planing, the shavings on the try plane are thicker and the wood softer.
But I'm impressed by how far the M4 and V11 go. What is it about chromium that seems to get along so well with wood? Is it hard enough to do well in wood, but not hard enough to do well in other wear tests where M4 stands out? It's puzzling, but the steady difference in cut feel so far is something I wouldn't have noticed without running the same irons in the same plane one after another (and having used exactly the same sharpening method).