Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Test 5

Posts

Re: Test 5

#26

Re: WOW what a data set

Wiley Horne

“What is it about chromium that seems to get along so well with wood?”

I like Phil’s hypothesis, namely, that the M4 is tending toward an exposed aggregate finish at the nano level; while the V11 chromium carbides are wearing with the matrix, with the edge remaining compact. I also like his solution: SEM photos to actually see what has happened, although the V11 may have been taken 100 feet too far to reveal why it was slick in the wood.

Wiley

Re: Test 5

#27

Don't forget about Derek

Jonathan Elliott

Not that anyone is but I thought he deserved mention for all the similar work he has done and the years of advocating the benefits of PM-V11 through real world use in abrasive woods despite much leeriness and push back. The results should not be a surprise as much as further confirmation and more excellent data.

This particular test with its unique and highly controlled parameters and the questions it is seeking to shed light on is very interesting and to be highly praised in its own right. I look forward to the results of the additional things David is looking to experiment with. It's fun and I'm glad David is up for it and doing so much heavy lifting!

Thank you too David and everyone else who is supporting this effort!

Re: Test 5

#28

Re: Credibility

Winston

Another thing I'm curious to know: Is it worth it to spend extra time going to super-fine stones and working a perfect edge? That is, does a more perfect edge result in an edge that lasts significantly longer? I realize the answer may be different depending on if one is interested in creating a perfect surface vs. removing material.

Re: Test 5

#29

That's coming...

david weaver

...next. Edge duration at 30 degrees vs. 35 and with different levels of final polish will be the last two sets of tests.

I'm debating doing those two tests with O1 and A2 since the V11 will be a pain to use. In order to test those accurately, I need to run one at control and the other with whatever adjustment is being made.

It's kind of a nuisance because I'd like to flip flop them (if I make modifications only to O1, then someone is going to ask whether or not they'd hold with V11, and I don't know the answer to that). Ideally, O1 and V11 would provide end points, so I may use them instead of O1 and A2. In an ideal world, also, I'd like to test edge life with the different abrasive finishes at both 35 and 30 degrees, but I think I'll run out of steam before doing that.

I'll do something meaningful, and as I'm typing this, I guess that means O1 and V11 and slogging through as much of it as I can with one test iron and one control iron for each iteration. There will be pictures for those, too, but fewer as initial sharpening, something part of the way through the test and a final edge picture should be enough.

Re: Test 5

#30

End grain...

david weaver

...almost forgot end grain. will do that, too, but not with the full set of plane irons.

Re: Test 5

#31

Re: WOW what a data set

Steve Elliott

It's great news that the V11 is so good. It's a lot easier to buy a good iron than to make them.

My feelings also. Despite finding 3V a big improvement over the other blades I tried in my infill planes (back before V11 was available) the trouble of making a blade was considerable. I'd rather be doing woodworking.

This morning I dug out a couple of V11 blades I got from Konrad Sauer, 3/16 x 2-1/4" which I thought would fit two infills I own. It turns out they're a few thousandths too thick to fit either plane. I can modify the planes or take a little off the blades now that I know it's worth it.

David, thanks for all your careful work. One of the benefits of doing a test is learning things you didn't expect. Your results raise a number of questions that intrigue me, for instance how the abrasion resistance of an alloy can vary depending on whether it is being abaded by a sharpening stone vs. wood. The "sharpens easily but retains its edge longer" idea seems to hold water. That's great!

I'll be looking forward to your future results.

Re: Test 5

#32

bill and I may differ..

david weaver

I didn't necessarily believe the sharpening thing, but I guess I did to some extent. I expected carbon steel to perform better optimized, but better has to be defined. It isn't as abrasion resistant, but it does retain its title in this testing - it goes to failure quickly but surface consistency is better.

But when it came to the alloyed stuff, I allowed the contradiction to what I thought determine that I should run this test. That the really tough to sharpen steels should do well in this what I'd consider a typical other than final pass smoother shaving. Instead, it looks like I'm backwards.

I don't have the ability to analyze V11 like bill, but it's clear that it's not got a lot of vandium in it (or at least I think it is), and its feel on the stones is like hard 440C. and it doesn't rust. Bill's pictures earlier about chromium carbides being small and evenly dispersed, and some other literature that i read discussing how chromium carbides can get out of hand and basically turn into big blobs at 900-1400F if you're careless....well, maybe it's a case of some property of chromium carbides in terms of wear resistance on wood that is more than just their hardness.

I swear I can feel the friction on M4, though, and it makes me think the wear mechanism on wood is akin to running soft steel over a diamond plate - the diamonds are far harder than the soft steel or iron, but it'll still pull them out.

And the 3V blade that wiley sent me *is* a very good blade. It's clear from toughness charts that it's extremely tough. I wouldn't be surprised if there was some circumstances where it fared better, but I'm limited to beech and maple in this test because I don't want to search for that circumstance.

The fact that it's a few hundred feet behind M4 in this test, and V11 doesn't describe that most of the extra feet that v11 and M4 had were pretty tough going. The 3V ran right with them for a long time and I was (to be honest), kind of happy that it gave up relatively quickly. That was a nice property to me. The wire edge is persistent, though!!

Whatever the case, as I remember off of the top of my head, 3V is 30-40% longer lasting than A2 in general, and it doesn't have the bad habit that A2 does where A2 seems to shed its edge as it's getting dull. The pictures show that - it's almost as if it molts its shiny part.

While I can't say that V11 will always do what it does in these tests, I expect that if someone tells me they're planing beech and they don't make the same thing happen, they're dishonest. That's the reality of testing - being precise gives you a few certain things and then a lot of other maybes, but life is less to me a bunch of definites, and a whole lot of learning what you can and putting the odds in your favor with it.

Re: Test 5

#33

Re: bill and I may differ..

Steve Elliott

Carbon steel did well in the test in terms of edge uniformity, an important attribute for some types of work. What I especially like about your test is that it allows users to choose which blade qualities they want and find a blade that will deliver them.

Re: Test 5

#35

Also, a question about strops

Winston

I know you already have a large list of things to test, but I'm also very curious about the role that stropping can play in edge longevity.

Some of the discussion about electron micrographs reminded of the images on the scienceofsharp blog. https://scienceofsharp.wordpress.com/

Looking at some of the posts there, it appears that stropping (with an abrasive-loaded strop) can improve edge quality without making the edge too convex. The pictures from the blog suggest that stropping can create a more refined edge, and also add a micro-convexity, which may increase edge longevity.

The blog is mostly about straight razors, which have a different stropping technique from that used with woodworking tools, but I wonder if woodworking tools can similarly benefit from stropping. If so, then it would be good to know, especially for people like me, who can do a decent job sharpening, but aren't experts at sharpening technique.

I know there are a lot of potential variables with stropping, and I don't think it's worth it (yet) to try a bunch of different ways. But if it turns out that a simple stropping technique leads to good results (without creating long-term issues like a heavily-rounded edge), that's a valuable piece of knowledge to have, because it can be put to immediate use, and because it could also lead to more exploration about different techniques.

In short: Does stropping improve edge longevity? And can a loaded strop serve as a substitute for a fancy finishing stone?

I think the work you've been doing is really valuable. There have been endless debates about sharpening and steels; if 1% of that energy were spent on objective, repeatable testing, like the kind you're doing, then 99% of the debates would be irrelevant. The thing is, dropping into a sharpening debate and arguing is easy; doing science and communicating it is hard work, and in this case, at least, it's falling on one person's shoulders.

Re: Test 5

#36

Re: Test 5 results

Wiley Horne

David,

Thank you for that very specific answer. Which is that you would sharpen roughly halfway through the published run lengths

It’s interesting that you still like the Ward iron, despite the runs that are short compared to the alloy irons. It makes me wonder whether the blocks of work that you actually do in real life do not require great longevity, since you would be using three planes typically—jack, try, and smoother. Maybe the ordinary rhythm of the work, sharpening after a block of work is done, would have you sharpening at 300 or so anyway, just in the normal rhythm.

I am curious whether the V11 iron can be sharpened to your usual standard on your usual Arkansas stones. Not right off the grinder, but say after 2-3 prior sharpenings.

Wiley

Re: Test 5

#37

Re: Also, a question about strops

david weaver

the level of sharpness that we're using in this test is something that won't be improved by stropping. Stropping is a complicated thing, though it doesn't have to be made so in process - but as far as where you gain from it.

* softer steels

* natural stones that create a long but delicate wire edge

* lack of edge refinement otherwise

Strop honing can take the place of a finish stone, but I think most people will come to prefer a finish stone.

Brent beach has something about stropping on his page, but it's simplistic and he's comparing low quality abrasives to a sub micron honing film. Honing films are very precise, but they're a complete pain unless you do only the simplest and cleanest sharpening operations (e.g., a brand new woodworker who just sharpens smoothing plane blades and chisels with a pull stroke in a guide).

There is such an unbelievably large world of purpose made and adapted abrasives (pigments, combination abrasive sticks with wax, pastes), etc, that everything needs to be well defined. The green formax stick that claims to be chrome ox is actually quite practical for a shop. Green chrome ox graded half micron powder is much finer, but the practicality over bare leather is little on tools and much on razors if a finish stone comes up short (it's not necessary with a good finish stone and a good true linen and good hanging shell strop).

The topic can get complicated because it depends on the use.

As far as longevity for planing, i don't think stropping adds any. The pictures under the scope show that the edge is removed very quickly due to wear, no matter what the steel is. The exception is if refinement isn't good or if there is wire edge remaining, I'd imagine you can shorten an edge nominally by allowing it to get damaged for the first few strokes.

My pictures and surface judging on this round of testing suggest that good blades that sustain very small damage at the outset will "heal" themselves if the wood is agreeable. Of course, nothing heals, but the defected area if it's not a narrow and deep groove will wear into some uniformity. The edge won't be perfectly straight, but it will become smooth enough so as not to leave a mark on the wood surface.

On a vintage western razor, stropping is essential. Even on a japanese razor. I've seen people mention that stropping dulls an edge, but severing hairs on every razor that I've sharpened is always improved by proper stropping and the ease across the face is greater with stropping. The only exception that I would mention is .09 micron iron oxide. It might be fine enough to leave a very clean edge, but the shave is harsh to me. even 0.5 chromium oxide is improved quite a bit by the strop in hanging hair tests. Whether it's straightening of the edge or what, I don't know. Sometimes the uniformity of an edge will actually look better straight off of the stone under the microscope, but whatever the strop does is an improvement. Some of the straight looking parts of the edge may not be in line with the rest or they may be part foil and weak.

(I'll admit that I never read too much of the blog with the SEM pictures because I'd already been viewing edges under a metallurgical microscope for a while, and grading stones to sell so as to support my own hobby. even a good metallurgical scope won't show you nearly as much, but sometimes the SEM pictures can be so in your face that it's hard to tell what actual effect they have on shaving)

In my opinion, for razoring, having a good linen and leather (real linen, real shell strop that's not too old, or at least broken in butt strip from horse) is an absolute necessity before making any judgments about edge quality. The edges are so acute that substandard leather can damage them, as can substandard harsh linens. Some of the felt and cotton sold to substitute for linen will actually leave visible scratches in an edge and dull it noticeably.

Re: Test 5

#38

I'll sharpen the V11 freehand tonight..

david weaver

straight off the grinder then from india, to mid ark fineness stone and then using an old japanese man made oilstone that just says "barber oilstone" on it.

I've never seen another one like it, but it's dandy and probably cost $5. I hate to say it, but I like it better than a trans ark stone, but woe be to the person who would ever have to flatten one (it's much like a spyderco in feel, but with a little more cutting power and instead of being a thin wafer, it's 8x3x1 or slightly bigger).

That is definitely a less fine regimen, and it won't be nearly as precise. It also requires stropping with bare leather.

There's enough of the last beech test piece left for several thousand strokes, and it's a poorly sawn piece of wood that doesn't really need to be kept for anything.

I expect some less longevity. I'm sure that my freehand sharpening angle is something like 32/33 because the 35 degree angle seems very steep by feel, and I sharpened the ward iron to 30 degrees last night and it felt very shallow to freehand hone. The result of that was an extra 50 feet with the ward iron (at 30 degrees) vs. the "charlesworth" process, but that's little different and I may have just done a better job sharpening, so I wouldn't count it as proving anything.

At any rate, we can see just how deficient my normal sharpening routine may be. If I continue to use the V11 iron in a smoother, it is the way it will be sharpened, anyway, whether it's freehand on cast or freehand on stones, the coarse work will not be done by diamond plates.

Re: Test 5

#39

The ward, by the way..

david weaver

..after honing it at 30 degrees last night and going for more feet, I noticed that it did collect a defect mid test that it didn't at a slightly steeper angle. One time, can't really conclude much from it.

As far as using it when it's posting numbers like 500-550 off of my oilstone regimen, 350 of that being "pure" where the plane stays well in the cut itself, I guess it's a matter of quickly realizing once I go back to dimensioning something that the smoothing is fleeting because the try plane's set the surface up to a near finish level.

The try plane itself is working at a thicker shaving, so I don't know how much ground it can cover, but it's a lot and i'm ready to sharpen it when it's ready to be sharpened.

I just estimated what in my sharpening process 350 feet finish planes, and I'm guessing it's about 8-10 square feet of finished surface (assuming four smoothing passes). That's a lot when dimensioning by hand, and the sharpening process does more than just keep the iron sharp, it keeps it free of defects that may occur due to contamination and keeps the geometry appropriate in regard to both smoothing without leaving tracks and in mating to the cap iron.

Re: Test 5

#40

Derek's efforts...

david weaver

...some might discount because of his relationship with LV, but I don't because of that.

I generally want to get a separate look because most of what Derek works with is harder or more abrasive than what we work with. I recall Derek mentioning that clifton's O1 blades (which are not the longest wearing of the O1 irons, but a lot of people like them) last few passes in a lot of the wood there. In cherry here, they'd last a lot.

One of the things I wanted to test in terms of longevity was a "normal" good-natured wood that we'd use in the united states. In good-natured stuff, it may be that my observations are even better.

When the inclusions or whatever they were (pockets of silica? who knows) showed up in the maple, the carbon steel blade took a fraction of the damage that the other irons did (tsunesaburo) - is there a need to have more polite wood? I don't know. The stainless powder knife tests that bill linked to show stainless PM steels as being relatively low toughness, but we've figured out here that if surface quality isn't a concern, low toughness really isn't a problem. If the wood is agreeable, I barely saw anything other than very minor defects in the beech tests (maple tends to show a little more in terms of edge defects - both tests - where carbon steel will work fine without showing any and all of the alloyed irons left some very small lines).

At any rate, I don't discard anything from anyone who has experience, though I do stuff some of derek's observations off to the side if they're done in really tough woods because we don't often use those types over here.

I had a very soft dwight and french iron in a try plane. I would bet you could gently roll a burr on it (if not, almost) if you needed to. I was sure that when I went to use the plane (which I bought while testing various try planes before building), the iron just wouldn't do. But I used it, anyway, and to my surprise in try planing, it lasted fine. Enough for me to get tired. It had visible bright wear on the bevel when I resharpened it, but it worked just fine.

I stepped it up and (can't remember which) tried to put it to a stick of hard maple or heart beech, and it was nothing but a fight. What derek usually works is a level up from there, and while I like the stanley irons in beech and cherry, stepping up to something like jarrah would probably make cut resistance more noticeable.

From a variable standpoint, it's important to me for all of these tests that even if derek has done some testing, rather than just requesting to stuff it in with the results of mine, I want to generate all of the results in the same plane with the same cap iron (if able - I had to use a different cap iron for M4 because modifying the original LN cap iron meant that it would no longer work with an iron thicker than stock LN).

Even swapping over to the norris plane to test the ward iron, I can tell the plane design is not quite as well suited to provide natural downforce in regular cutting vs. an LN bronze 4 - that could very well account for 100 feet of planing distance. I just don't want that variable. Doesn't mean that the norris is a worse plane, it's just going to be less tolerant of using a dulling iron. Contrary to some older literature that suggests infill planes excel at working longer into a dulling cycle. If that's true, it's not true compared to the bronze 4.

Re: Test 5

#41

Re: Derek's efforts...

Jonathan Elliott

Agree, it's nice to get another perspective and even among the different North American woods (hard maple, beech, cherry). I've particularly enjoyed Derek's stuff over the years since I'm in Hawaii and have the opportunity to play with more tropical stuff. It's still not Australian iron but leans more that way than cherry.

I'm glad you are doing what you are doing and glad Derek does what he does. Nothing beats personal experience but sometimes we can't play and experiment with everything :b

Re: Test 5

#42

That's true...

david weaver

I'd be better off in making things if I experimented with less. But I've not got a great deal of interest in furniture, so I'd have more tools and more guitars. I don't really need those, either.

One thing that I do like - regardless of the wood - if I find something and Derek finds something, and we both find the same thing in different woods, it makes me feel good about it.

I expected to find with this test that LV's tales were a little tall. I'm not above proving myself wrong, though. I can hardly wait for the folks who wonder if I'm on their payroll. I think after spouting off about LV not doing what I wish they'd do (offering some kind of primo carbon steel - which I'll admit for most of the market of tool users would be lost on the masses - I'm probably excommunicated. At least they didn't shut down my V11 blade order!!!).

If I'd have found something unfavorable and posted it anyway and they really did cut me off (still doubt they'd do that - Charlie says he has tried V11 stuff, and I'd figure at this point, he'd need a straw purchaser to get anything from LV), then that'd just be that. The consequence of getting the right answer or trying our best to. (I can make my own tools at this point, anyway).

Nothing unfavorable happened at this point, though. We found something unexpected. Bill did more digging and found that there's data in the knife world in slicing tests to support the same thing - that the high chromium PM steels seem to outdo their alloy when it comes to slicing. Derek's data agrees. And my supposition was wrong. I'm glad to be wrong, though, once I have some proof.

Re: Test 5

#43

I doubt that..

david weaver

...first, the internal people at LV probably have no idea who I am.

But some of the others probably don't like my scorched earth campaign with the cap iron, and that's OK. I guess I could still find my way on to the no-buy list. Just not intentionally. A bull in a China shop often breaks things, but he can't help that he's a bull in a China shop.

Re: Test 5

#44

That's what I appreciate...

Jonathan Elliott

...so much about people like you and Derek sharing their experiences with this attitude:

"I expected to find with this test that LV's tales were a little tall. I'm not above proving myself wrong, though."

"I'm glad to be wrong, though, once I have some proof."

Makes whatever you find and whatever conclusions you come to much more trustworthy compared to someone's personal agenda/preference.

As Steve mentioned in an earlier post

"What I especially like about your test is that it allows users to choose which blade qualities they want and find a blade that will deliver them."

I find this incredibly valuable. Rather than just share your preference, you share the particular qualities and let the reader apply them to his or her particular situation and desires. I find this throughout Derek's evaluations as well, especially during the heated BU/BD days.

It's particularly useful when talking about sharpening as well. All the systems work, more or less, but of course preferences abound!

Re: Test 5

#45

Re: That's true...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek's data agrees.

David, I suppose that I should be relieved to hear this.

I have always said over the years, in response to those who seem to believe that I have fudged my results, that sooner or later the testing I did would be replicated. Why would I fudge results only to be caught out in time?

Reassured but not surprised by the results ...

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Test 5

#46

Re: I doubt that..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

..first, the internal people at LV probably have no idea who I am.

But some of the others probably don't like my scorched earth campaign with the cap iron, and that's OK. I guess I could still find my way on to the no-buy list. Just not intentionally. A bull in a China shop often breaks things, but he can't help that he's a bull in a China shop.

David, I believe that you and Wood Central have had a significant part to play in the design of Veritas planes. I am very much on the periphery of what goes on there, but can put 2 + 2 together. Here is an example that Lee Valley listen and learn ...

I visited the factory in 2013, at which time the Custom bench planes were being designed and in the first stages of development. At that time we were discussing the chip breaker ad nauseam here (and elsewhere). At that time as well, bevel up planes were a dominant method for carrying a high cutting angle. Single-iron planes with high cutting angles ruled (HNT Gordon and Old Street, and I certainly built many of my own). The plane I saw and used at Lee Valley was a single iron plane. It was going to offer a range of different angle frogs. Yet by the time the Custom plane reached the market, it had developed into a double iron plane, with a chip breaker that could be used in the desired manner (I have demonstrated that many times). This design change was influenced, I strongly believe, by the discussions at Wood Central.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Test 5

#47

I don't know...

david weaver

...if the average person buying a custom plane would use the cap iron, but the plane with a normal frog and a cap iron is 4 times the plane with a different frog and without the cap iron. I'm glad they changed their mind on that one.

As far as the other tests. I never believed you falsified tests - I am obsessed with how things work and bias, etc, what skews results intentionally or unintentionally. It makes no sense to me that at professionally accomplished psychologist would skew results for *the profit* of getting tools to test that he may not even have a use for.

It's an obligation to test tools for someone. At least that's what it seems like to me. I have tested a few tools and stones from various places, but haven't accepted anything since a custom plane from LV. That ultimately sat on my shelf, got a couple of dots of rust and I sold it and gave the money away. There was nothing wrong with the plane, but it sat with others that someone else would probably love to use, too - I have what i use.

It's just not that much of an incentive.

The real issue is the wood. If someone tested sorby's chisels in white pine and low density mahogany, they would love them. Maple or even beech and they need extra help in final angle to hold up. What I like is probably somewhere in the middle, and is wonderful to use, but if you tested it on jarrah or especially used it every day in it, you'd be aggravated. I'm curious as to how stuff works in the wood we have over here, and whether or not the relative differences hold up. Accelerated testing and difficult woods are sometimes necessary to be able to get a certain amount of study work done without drawing it out like my test has drawn out, but it leaves me with a nagging question.

Charlie mentioned Chris Becksvoort doing a test with teak. It's a worthless test in my opinion. Teak has varying amounts of silica in it, and if it's significant and creates accelerated wear, there's no guarantee that the results will be proportional to walnut, cherry, mahogany, soft maple, etc.....I get the desire to accelerate the test for those folks, especially if they're getting paid to write an article and just want to slog through it, but it's not useful information to anyone except teak planers.

In your case, you just have natural accelerated wear woods all around. We do in some cases, but most of what's here domestically that has silica in it has other use (locust for fences, etc) and fortunately we're blessed with a lot of easy working woods that grow all around us.

Re: Test 5

#48

Re: That's true...

Rob Lee

David -

My goodness that's cynical.... :D - we'd never do that.

We spent hundreds of thousands of dollars researching and testing steels - looking for exactly what we chose - a steel that works well for woodworking, will fit into most peoples sharpening regimes, and will manufacture and heat treat well.

We are confident in our choice. That will not automatically mean it's the best choice for everyone.

The marketing dept would have kittens at me writing this - but the majority of my planes have O1 blades. I only have one PM-V11 plane blade - and that's in Sauer and Steiner K13 (drive by). I am a big fan of using O1 personally: with my manufacturing hat on - not so much. Too much movement when heat treating.

I do have PM-V11 chisels ..... but still like my old Mifer CR-V chisels too...

Anyhow -have been following the thread with interest!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Test 5

#49

An opportunity presents itself...

Jim Matthews

Packaging a given steel type with a range of sharpening media (minimum/convenient/extravagant) and a copy of "The complete guide to sharpening"

might be popular.

I said at the onset of this ambitious slog that curating an affordable "pairing" of effective stones with irons is an obvious outcome of the research.

The genius of sintered metallurgy is it's predictable qualities.

Figuring out what makes a workable vintage iron desirable is cloaked in forgotten lore.

Re: Test 5

#50

Gotta write about something...

Jim Matthews

"Charlie mentioned Chris Becksvoort doing a test with teak."

Was the material chosen because it was just lying around?

Given that most of CB's excellent FWW articles are Shaker pieces in Cherry I wonder if the test material was chosen because it's well known to be hard on tools and/or it was available at little cost?

I marvel at the output of some frequent contributors to the rags.