Re: Great to hear from you, Kees!
Kees
Hi Wiley
Apart from lots of traveling, mountains and rock climbing, I have renovated my bathroom. Because there is some handtool content I will post some pictures when I am back home again.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Great to hear from you, Kees!
Kees
Hi Wiley
Apart from lots of traveling, mountains and rock climbing, I have renovated my bathroom. Because there is some handtool content I will post some pictures when I am back home again.
good points except for #4?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
.....I don't know 4 is a bad point I just don't understand it. What about David's results would suggest "white steel" would be a better choice than O1? The superior alloyed "blue" didn't last longer than O1 so what would lead one to think "white" would be better?
The steel property that dominated David's results was abrasion resistance and that is most affected by alloy constituents and to a lesser extent, probably, particle steel technology. Toughness was irrelevant within the bounds of the toughness tested. We can't rule out corrosion resistance as being a minor factor.
Which leads us to point 5. In spite of the LV claims you can't get higher edge life without making the stuff more resistant to sharpening media. Kee's data showed PMV11 abraded half as fast and David showed it planed twice as long. That sums it up. But one can overcome, if willing, the lost of sharpening speed with modern technology. But point 5 should be part of the warning label (along with CA Prop5) to not buy a longer life blade without buying a suitable sharpening media. (Has anyone ever got cancer from the chromium in a plane blade? )
Re: all PM not equal
david weaver
When I went out to look for bar stock to play with that tempers in a household oven range, particle stainless, I noticed "first second and third" generation PMs from various places.
Our typical adopted alloys for woodworking (from bit steels and diemaking steels) are pretty narrow. Going out and looking at carpenter and crucible spec sheets is dizzying.
I can tell that PM V11 isn't for 11% vanadium just the way the stones treat it- there's far less than 3V. The cap iron rusts, it doesn't, and the wire edge is very 440C like. There aren't that many spec sheets that meet those conditions and temper in regular tool steel range (as rob has warned, don't grind it with abandon) AND meet the hardness spec of V11 after tempering (assuming that tempering is required).
I had a 154CM blade - I know there's a powder metal version, but it gets to the spec (61-63) only without tempering and the wear resistance isn't in line with what we've seen. the S30Vs, etc, are out. too much vanadium and their resistance to sharpening stones is instantly apparent.
It would be interesting to know..
david weaver
..in relative terms, 3V is more resistant to stones than V11. As a ruse, when I sharpened wiley's 3V iron on the suita (which led to a powdery looking surface), I also sharpened the V11. It sharpened well on the suita, but the suita reaches past its constituent composition by having particles rolling around. I'm guessing the powdery looking surface on the iron was related more to things being abraded off of the steel rather than the abrasions running through all of the constituent parts (as they do with diamonds).
Which leads to the question, the "sharpening school lunch" (the impression that there's no free lunch available, but are some subsidized compared to others), are some carbides more suitable in terms of meeting their potential in a steel matrix in cutting wood, leather, whatever vs. resisting abrasion from particles harder than them. Or in short, have we found something where the wear of the steel to things softer than it is better relative to others than it is to things harder than it.
in slicing and planing, the answer appears to be yes, but in this case without my initial assumption (being that I could use edge uniformity as evidence that one steel didn't meet its potential because it was giving up bits and pieces in ugly losses off of the edge).
As far as wiley talking about white steel - he's in tune with my likes. I'm a speed sharpener. I like to pretty much step over to the stones and step back to my planes. A steel that leaves its wire edge behind without organizing any really noticeable new one early on in the process is really ideal for that. I'm still supposing that those types of steels (as seen with the O1 - itself fairly stringy compared to something like an old water hardening steel in a file) are the most compliant. There is a useful phase of sharpening with them - raising the wire edge to confirm that wear has been removed, but it's not participating at any material level once you move to the fine stones. It works itself off without any care at all.
Most people would say O1 has little wire edge, but it's not remotely similar to white steel in that regard, or even smashed files. I'm enamored with that property - I'm a surface gazer. I like an iron that cuts the same (even with a little adversity) from sharpness to right before it runs out of steam, and then is almost thoughtless to refresh properly. White steel at 63/64 is probably that. I'm going to shoot for 1095 at 62 in my next house made iron and see how it compares to the O1 iron that was tested here.
Last night, I cut apart some boxes. One of them had staples, and i hit one with one of my smash knives (small knife hammered flat out of a file or an end scrap piece of O1). I sharpened the damage off, and then did the usual for those knives - gray deburring wheel, hard buff with compound, ideal for cutting boxes. Twice, it showed little bits of wire edge hanging on, even after the buff. That's a pain, because it looks to the naked eye just like a damaged area of the blade - a tiny indeterminable bit of stuff that reflects light back. I strop it on my jeans a few times, and it's gone. I thought "this is a crappy file steel used in this file" and then noticed from the handle that it was made from an offcut of O1.
The knives made from files never do that. They are really sublime. (all are about the same hardness - far harder than a utility knife blade).
Pretty much..
david weaver
..hit the nail on the head. The path to less hating of sharpening is still paved by getting better and faster at it than it is by replacing old irons with new ones that may last 50% longer (v11 vs. A2). There will still be two sharpening cycles for each three previously. Cutting sharpening time in half and making sharpening enjoyable is ..to me, like learning to score from 75 yards in in golf vs. trying to get 20 more yards out of a driver so that you can hit two clubs less into the hole. The latter seems more practical, but the former takes more strokes off of the score and normalizes the game, making it more enjoyable and less ponderous about possible potential maybe future improvement.
I love the white steel ideal. I'd love to see it warm forged by hammer and then trimmed and ground, but i know that'll never happen. I can't imagine the cost.
I remember steve knight talking about buying japanese irons for his planes. The planes were $135, and the japanese iron was a $100 upcharge. He would talk on the phone for a while if you called to check up on a plane. I asked him about those irons, and he said he didn't really make anything on them and he had difficulty getting the smith to believe that he needed an iron so long and so flat. Something more along the lines that the smith told him he didn't need what he said he needed. Stan covington has a way of delivering one off things (I challenged him to have a pull saw made that could be tested against a western saw in western hardwood ripping, and low and behold, he delivered two saws that you or me would never dream would could break by how they felt...
....the cost for him to have them made was $750 each. They found homes. I had the option to buy one, but i'm too set in my ways with western saws and test ripping with the japanese saw was slower for me - the local carpenters tried both and they were faster with the japanese saw - and it made me hurt because I don't do the sawing motion that's required very often. Anyway, he delivered something for me to test and post about (with no obligation to buy) that I didn't think was available. I'm sure if he felt like it, he could come up with a good western plane iron in white 1 or white 2, but I can't imagine a cost (for anything other than prelaminated material just cut, heat treated and ground) being less than about $300-400. Man can dream that one day, something will be made by industrial process in dies and then trimmed for about $50!!
Test 3
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I tried planing beech with a 100 year old Stanley iron this morning. It is the iron I currently use for smoothing. I sharpened with Arkansas stones rather than diamonds. And I do not know the composition of the steel.
I planed 1380 feet. I might have been able to make 1500, I guess it was technically still passing, but it was getting to be no fun. I long felt like I was abusing the tool.
At 300 feet I was already beyond where I usually would sharpen an iron. At 400 feet I was still getting a surface that was better than anything I have seen at a Lie Nielsen event even when they have freshly sharpened. In other words their sharp is below my dull. I don't know if this is because of steel or sharpening media.
As a hand tool woodworker my instincts are to be gentle on my body. I guess some guys can overdo it and then take a couple of days off, but as a professional I never want to be in that position. So using a sharp tool often has a lot more benefit than just surface quality. That surface quality is also a symptom of how well the tool is cutting and how hard you are working.
Re: point 4
Wiley Horne
Bill and all,
White steel is different from O1, whose composition is typically 0.85 carbon, 0.5 chromium, 0.5 tungsten, and 0.3 vanadium. ‘Typically’, because there are numerous different standards and proprietary practices: here is a reference showing three different standards—US, Japan, Germany. There are about 30 of them altogether, plus individual maker tweaks.
http://www.astmsteel.com/product/astm-o1-tool-steel/
In comparison, white 1 is 1.2-1.4% carbon; nothing else. white 2 is 1.0-1.2%, and there are subdivisions within those ranges (the range is not just a fudge factor). Where does the extra carbon go? Into Fe3C carbides,. For performance, I call our attention to Derek’s PMV11 vs. white 1 chisel-off: it was a horse race. Now don’t beat me up about ‘a chisel ain’t a plane’—I’m saying the chisel torture test was plenty stern enough to reveal weaknesses in abrasion resistance and toughness. Hasten to add: white steel has made its reputation as a handforged steel, going through multiple heats to refine grain size and get good carbide distribution (not an urban legend—Prof. verhoeven has detailed in a chapter of his book how the multiple heats reduce grain size, in terms of grain-formation mechanics).
Would commercially produced white steel have the handforged characteristics? Would be interesting to know.
All of this may be immaterial to diamond sharpening, but could be of interest to Arkansas stoners and some water stoners.
Wiley
toughness vs wear resistance
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
All you say is certainly true about the properties of white steel. And we have good data that says these properties are the most significant for a chisel being stressed by wood penetration cross grain. Wear resistance has at best minor importance to a chisel that dulls in cm of use rather than m.
We also have David's data on various steels that show these properties are not the main drivers for edge wear in planing, its abrasion resistance.
And I have some data from Kato and Kawai who tested white steel against other alloys including M2. The comparison of White vs M2 shows M2 beats the socks off white in terms of wear and ability to pick up a shaving (Fig9 the Pv force positive means the blade is lifting instead of digging, loss of clearance)

Bottom line: no reasons to expect white to be any better than O1.
Re: Test 3
david weaver
Yes on the distances - and the conditions in the planing. The first test I did (years ago) of LN's iron yielded something like 1,800 feet in hard maple. It was still cutting. You can see the condition of the edge in my original test at 600 - it was coming apart, sharpening was overdue - especially if the surface was important. Imagine driving the same edge another 1,200 feet and what the results would look like. I did that because I thought there was a point that I couldn't lean on it and get it to continue cutting. I think I remember writing at the time that the point where I'd have resharpened the iron was somewhere around 500 or 600 feet.
The A2 irons are capable of at least some intervals of planing without defect, but I don't think most of the irons get resharpened to a level that removes them.
The 3V iron in this test was the hardest to sharpen (in terms of how slow it sharpened) and I'd bet that the average woodworker would not manage to completely sharpen the defects out of it, either.
I chose loss of clearance on this test because the point where you have to lean on the plane a little is pretty well defined. The point where you could lean on them and have them stop cutting, I wouldn't want to find. Kato and Kawai's machine had the benefit of near infinite stamina, but they pushed their irons kilometers or something, forcing them down and through the cut and examining the results. Once clearance is gone, the surface may be uniform, but it won't be bright.
Your points go toward people who are planing a lot, and want to be able to do it two more hours today, then whatever's necessary the rest of the week, next month, and next decade or three without needing surgery. I expect that the folks not in that camp will report to me with my study that they managed to plane 3000 feet with their V11 iron and it's still leaving a perfect surface.
(I will test later the difference between clearance angles, abrasive size and abrasive types - but using the same bogey. I expect the arkansas stone results to be the same as these diamond results for two reasons - the edges sustained no damage in these tests until wear pulled material from them, and a shaving bogey of about 2 1/2 thousandths really doesn't challenge sharpness that much - it just relies on clearance and moderate lack of bluntness in edge geometry. There is a short initial period from a method like this one where the brightness of finish is at an almost tasteless level, one that can't be sustained - it's very transient. Arkansas stones skip that. If some goof wanted to run one of these tests to find feet at half a thousandth or less, they'd find half micron diamonds or something to be the cutoff, but we're not testing that.
I do expect 3 and 5 micron diamonds as a finish to create some problems with the wire edge removal and result in shortened planing lengths.
A stanley iron of the best quality would last about like my O1 iron did in this test with the same failure conditions, regardless of sharpening media (idealized - meaning very fine waterstones, very good quality arkansas stones, wax compounds with micro abrasives, etc). The initial sharpening media, as far as edge life is concerned, needs to do a good enough job to not create any points where failure occurs for reasons other than wear. What point that may be is something interesting to find out. I don't know if we'll discover it. I have attempted to plane right off of the 2000 grit diamond hone with brisk bare leather stropping before, and the result was pretty nasty - I'm not going to go that far down the ladder if that's needed. that's something like 15 micron diamond. The ability of the wire edge to hold, and then probably damage the edge as it comes off is pretty spectacular there).
Re: toughness vs wear resistance
Wiley Horne
Hi Bill,
Very interesting data—looking forward to the translation. Is this the work that also shows that only kigami gave a fine surface?
I am especially interested in Fig. 9, as that one bears most intuitively on the planing experience. I note that the worst performing steel pulled itself into the work for about 400 feet, which corresponds interestingly to Warren’s ‘Test 3’ comment elsewhere on this page.
I’m not surprised that M2 and many other alloy steels will ‘beat the socks off’ plain high carbon steel, especially as prepared from sheet material for professor’s test purposes. And I would not argue that plain carbon steel will outlast O1 alloy in a planing durability test.
I am arguing something different, which is that each of us is having a different experience in the shop. And eventually we will all pass on beyond the shop, and so I argue that the shop experience is what counts. And that experience is TOTAL. There is a German word ‘gestalt’ which can be simplified to mean ‘the whole is a thing unto itself; it is not the sum of the parts. The whole is indivisible. Now you may not buy into this, but it is what I am arguing. Also, your gestalt is different from mine. Or from David’s, or Warren’s, or anyone else’s who reads this far. How does this apply to our subject? Warren would resharpen while his plane is still pulling itself into the work; he doesn’t view this as a drawback. Nor do I—in my amateurish way, I am feeling the downforce and listening to the tone the blade makes. Sharpening is also part of the whole experience, though I understand from your point of view, sharpening may be dead time, time taken away from production. Because you derive pleasure from production, and from the thought of your children enjoying that production decades from now. But that is not everyone’s gestalt.
Well, frankly I enjoy reading about data and durability testing, and love to pick through the arcana with you. But it never enters my mind while sharpening a blade that’s not even dull yet.
Wiley
Re: toughness vs wear resistance
Jonathan Elliott
Couldn't agree more or have said it better Wiley! Thanks for putting words to what I was feeling and introducing me to that German concept...I have lots of German in me 