Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

test 2 numbers

Posts

Re: test 2 numbers

#26

PM-V11 and A2 on end grain

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I would like to see how V11 will do across end grain (that should be a lot more brief) vs. the O1 iron.

I did this here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/LVShootingPlane.html

and here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/MoreAboutShootingPlanesandTheirBlades.html

My tests included BU and BD configurations as well.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: test 2 numbers

#27

Re: M2

David Weaver

I wouldn't be surprised to see woods like teak produce different results due to silica.

With this data set, the plane may have had an effect for or against 3v since it's different, but I'd not expect a much different result for the rest unless something was changed (cut depth..I have a feeling from actual planning that thinner shavings like these may separate various irons more than thicker).

I wouldn't like to run this test with hundredth shavings.

The maple test shows that something nasty in the wood will stop them all at the same point. In order to get these numbers, the wood and the planing need to be ideal. How realistic is that on a day to day basis? I don't know.

Re: test 2 numbers

#28

Thanks, Derek...

david weaver

I want to do this in a bench plane in a situation similar to what someone would do trimming the ends of hand sawn panels and include it as another test. Maybe I'm wrong about anyone doing this with consistency other than hand tool only people (planing to a line on end grain)

I don't have any reason to believe my results will differ from yours, but they'll be whatever they are, and doing them will allow me to make more comments and do a write up consistent with the duration testing. Same irons, same plane, etc.

There are maybe half a dozen other things I'd like to test and include in the same paper or small set of papers (effect of angle on a subset of the irons, effect of edge finish routine, effect of sharpening on less than optimal media). I'd figured 3V would win the first test and it would be a test with 3V and O1, but I guess it will be V11 and O1. Which is good since they'll both work in the same plane.

Re: test 2 numbers

#29

Re: Thanks, Derek...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, if I wasn't so pressed for time, I could add M2, and V3 in the Veritas Shooting Plane to the existing data with A2 and PM-V11. Later perhaps, if there is still any interest.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: test 2 numbers

#30

The more an expert knows, the greater the unknowns

Jim Matthews

"When someone tells me they're new to woodworking and what should they get, I just don't even know what to say any longer."

This illustrates the difference between expertise and presumptive ignorance.

In any line of inquiry, real experts (such as you have become) realize the scope of such problems may defy simple explanations.

It's a slog, up a steep slope - particularly when you're losing questions few ask.

Those expressing frustration over this inquiry likely doubt a practical outcome, have an established approach that they won't change or grace the rest of us mere mortals with their presence.

For one; I think that if you've never built your own tools, made furniture for a living or lifted a finger to help out a newbie (such as myself) you should consider a demonstration of prowess before chucking darts.

Kudos on seeing this through, the data will speak for itself.

Re: test 2 numbers

#31

Re: The more an expert knows, the greater the unkn

Charlie

If you think about it, woodworking itself is quite impossible. As a thought exercise, one couldn't list all the variables even in two lifetimes, yet beautiful furniture and other items made in wood have existed for thousands of years.

Time for a reboot if tool steel has become that much of a muddle.

Re: test 2 numbers

#32

That data changed my thinking

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

At best the mean shavings to failure was short relative to edge long grain planing. I have a PMV11 in a LV shooting plane which I have been using with reckless abandon and it has been getting dull alarmingly fast. I see from your data that result is to be expected. I need to be mindful of technique and not shoot unless essential. Thanks...

Re: test 2 numbers

#33

Re: test 2 numbers

Brian Holcombe

David,

How's the back prepped on the Tsunesaburo?

Brian

Re: test 2 numbers

#34

It was....

david weaver

...flat on a natural stone, and then for this test, the last little bit was diamond prepped the same as the others. It's done and out for the duration, I think (unless something interesting happens with end grain tests - it would probably do well in that).

I can grind off the back beveled part and reflatten it on natural stones and see if it dribbles out the clumps like it did in this test.

Am I right in my fortune telling with where you're going here?

I have the expectation that if it had been white 2 rikizai driven to 65, those lines wouldn't have been there. I don't know that white 2 would last more feet, but it would provide the uniformity that we're used to. This iron produced good uniformity, but not the brightness you and I would expect. It also proved tougher than others over the bark inclusion, at least so much as one iteration would show. Not tough enough to continue cutting through it, though.

Re: test 2 numbers

#35

Re: It was....

Brian Holcombe

:D Pretty much exactly where I was going. This iron didn't start to behave for me until I tapped it out and used it like a normal Japanese iron. Now it's great, I think it just never likes having a bit swath of steel to sharpen.

Re: test 2 numbers

#36

Re: It was....

david weaver

It takes a pressure bias and a reasonably fast stone to remove the wear without putting a hollow in it. In this case, I cheated around that with the diamond back bevel (there's a fair bit of honed area on it), but it may not like diamonds. Whether or not that's an issue should be easy to check.

At the hardness (it's clearly harder than anything else in this test - not more abrasive resistant, but just straight up hardness), it feels like it has a lot of potential, and if this same behavior doesn't occur on other woods, it wouldn't really matter that it does in this test.

if there was a forged version in white 1 hardened to 64, it would be a lot more interesting, and the steel would be too plain to have those globs being pulled out.

Re: test 2 numbers

#37

Re: It was....

Brian Holcombe

There are smith's making them, but it's a been a while since I've seen one. Joshua Villages had access to them when he was in Japan, so he may still have access currently.

Re: test 2 numbers

#38

Re: It was....

David Weaver

Making white 1 stanley style/fitting irons?

Re: test 2 numbers

#39

Re: It was....

Brian Holcombe

Yeah, he was working for one of the dai makers at the time and they toured a shop of someone making stanley replacements in white steel, actually I don't remember if it was white 1 or 2 but either would be nice. I wish I had more info.

Re: test 2 numbers

#40

White 2 would be lovely

david weaver

and probably more likely to be consistent without having a price on the moon.

If I could get prelaminated white 2 in some reasonable thickness, I would warm forge (like I did with the file chisel) some of it and then trim an iron out of it and heat it in oil. It would attain high hardness if the iron was an eighth or less.

If I can manage to make a good hard and reliable iron in 1095, I'll send you one. It'll be close to white 2 and natural stone friendly.

Re: test 2 numbers

#41

Re: test 2 numbers

Robert Hazelwood

David, thanks for doing all this. Very sound and practical methodology.

I wonder how it would effect the results if, instead of each iron having the same 33 degree edge, you optimized the edge angle for each steel. 33 degrees is a good compromise if you are trying to keep everything the same, but the high carbon blades can go down to at least 30 degrees, and that should allow for some additional planing before loss of clearance. It might equalize the results to some extent. Then again, maybe one of the carbide irons is actually optimized at 35 degrees and does even better at that angle.

Re: test 2 numbers

#42

Two things more common...

david weaver

for most people than a 33 or 35 degree final bevel (which is intended to preserve edge quality more than it is to plane the most feet) are:

1) a coarser final abrasive

2) a lower angle

I will be testing both of those. Angles below 30 don't really have a practical use except in softwood planing, bevel up or japanese planes, but we're not testing those, so I'm going to test V11 and O1 at:

* a final honed angle of 30 degrees

* with diamond abrasive in the 3 micron range on a hard surface (which is pretty brash, but will still provide a finished edge

* with an oilstone finish or a natural suita stone (both will provide a similar result - a less refined edge in absolute sharpness, but in the terms of how gentle they are on the steel - more gentle than diamonds). Probably oilstones.

I gather from reading over the years that:

* there are a lot of oilstone users who consider them to be gentle on an edge and provide better edge life or quality than diamonds (I am in that camp so far as I consider them safe options, but I have never tested the idea that anything other than micron or submicron diamonds are harsh and may cause failure - so I'll test it.)

* there are a lot of folks who get started with a sharpening regime who believe there's a significant gain in longevity if you follow to a very fine abrasive - in some cases all of the way to pigment only chromium oxide powders or pastes.

I'd like to see both how the irons perform on an absolute basis with those changes, and whether or not less refined edges than 1 micron diamonds on wood (which is beyond what will be achieved with a natural stone on a final angle so blunt - perhaps to a pointless level, which we'll test) narrow the gap between steels we're used to and V11.

Using only those two instead of the full set of irons because it takes a very long time to dull all six irons (about 6500 feet planed or some such amount). I suspect stainless alloy with some trickery (like 440C plus something) for V11, which I've mentioned many times. If that is the case, toughness of O1 is probably higher, wear resistance, we already showed. Basically, we'll see if the big performance gap happens only in ideal use.

The original testing method is useful because it takes those variables out and it's something people can do as a sharpening regime if they'd like - there's numbers and cheap guides that make it easy to duplicate (but, i don't like it).

Re: test 2 numbers

#43

Re: Two things more common...

Jonathan Elliott

Looking forward to those next test objectives very much whenever the time is right! That will be really interesting.

Thanks again!

Re: test 2 numbers

#44

Re: test 2 numbers

Kees

There was a lot to read on my little phonescreen while on hollidays. Great work. You are exactly the right guy to do this. Plenty of experience with planes and handplaning, extreme sharpening experience and the motivation to go through all this work. Well done.

A couple of years ago I did a little bit of work but got quickly disheartened about the complexity of the subject. But I did found that PV11 is twice as abrasion resistant on sharpening media as O1. So it doesn’t come as a surprise that PV11 lasts twice as long in beech too. It’s mOre a surprise that CV3 and M2 are ‘t doing better because they are even more abrasion resistant. I think that would be because they are not very tough.

Pardon me for getting all the steel names wrong. It’s hard enough typing with two thumbs on an iphone.

Re: test 2 numbers

#45

incorrect statements

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It’s mOre a surprise that CV3 and M2 are ‘t doing better because they are even more abrasion resistant. I think that would be because they are not very tough.

I am not surprised you didn't find data I reported somewhere in the blizzard of posts. From the literature data I found the ranking of M2, 3V and PMV11 (as what we think it is) correlates well with the reported abrasion resistance of these metals. It is reported that M2 and 3V are similar and PMV11 is a bit better, exactly what David found in edge life.

3V is outstandingly tough. the toughness ranking from the literature would be 3V>PMV11>M2. What the data show is that toughness is not an important factor for planing, unlike in chisels. Beyond abrasion resistance, the powder metal technology may be the next most important variable, but I haven't cracked that coconut yet.

Re: test 2 numbers

#46

Re: incorrect statements

Kees

Aha, indeed wrong assumption on my part.

Remarkable feature for pm steels is the small grain size. That is atributed to all kinds of positive effects in steel.

Re: test 2 numbers

#47

all PM not equal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

During literature searching I just got a hint of the fact that later generation particle steels tease more favorable properties from the basic composition. I don't know the "invention" dates for Crucible vs Carpenter or whether the benefits from PM might be different between them. My metallurgist friend retired and moved away so I have no handy person to consult. I am tracking someone new down who I am told has XRF for analyzing David's Chinese blade.

Re: test 2 numbers

#48

Great to hear from you, Kees!

Wiley Horne

What are you working on these days, other than days at the mountains or beach?!

Wiley

Re: test 2 numbers

#49

Re: test 2 numbers

David Weaver

Sorry you had to read all of that!! One of the things that's curious to me, and has been is that even in the crappy irons, there are some that are harder to sharpen but don't hold up as well, anyway, and whether or not there's not necessarily a free lunch, but through quality of the edge (uniformity) in one thing vs another, a subsidized lunch.

I'm glad to hear that you found some data about abrasives and provided it to Bill, and it's nice that it lines up. But I'm assuming that you found (just subjectively from what I did, too, sharpening) that 3V probably loses about half of the mass to diamonds that V11 does if V11 does to O1.

It's a pain to do the actual planing, but done honestly, it's almost impossible to manipulate. Which means it's also easy to do accurately because of that.

Re: test 2 numbers

#50

Re: test 2 numbers

Wiley Horne

Looking at the final results of test 2, a few random thoughts....

1. Kudos to Lee Valley for bringing a PM steel to market that is good enough to surprise the experts here! [what are ‘kudos’ anyway?]

2. O1 can certainly hold its head up, and if I were standardized on Arkansas stones, I wouldn’t be tempted to switch systems based on these numbers. And that’s irrespective of the dollar cost to switch—I just wouldn’t be tempted to change the shop rhythm.

3. Despite the unloved status of A2 on this forum, it did well. For me, the choice between buying an LN plane versus an LV plane would come down to the plane, not to PMVii vs A2. That’s on temperate zone wood; for the various aussie ironwoods, or tropicals, the iron would make a big difference.

4. I’d love to see a line of white 1 or white 2 irons come to market, for western planes. Maybe David can form a company.

5. The choice of sharpening system is dominant; the choice of blades follows. Meaning, if someone doesn’t like diamond sharpening, or waterstone sharpening, a longer-wearing blade won’t overcome that dislike. And if someone likes their Arkansas stones, O1 or straight high-carbon will do just fine, again talking temperate zone woods.

6. Great work, David! You’re on a rolll.

Wiley