Two things more common...
david weaver
for most people than a 33 or 35 degree final bevel (which is intended to preserve edge quality more than it is to plane the most feet) are:
1) a coarser final abrasive
2) a lower angle
I will be testing both of those. Angles below 30 don't really have a practical use except in softwood planing, bevel up or japanese planes, but we're not testing those, so I'm going to test V11 and O1 at:
* a final honed angle of 30 degrees
* with diamond abrasive in the 3 micron range on a hard surface (which is pretty brash, but will still provide a finished edge
* with an oilstone finish or a natural suita stone (both will provide a similar result - a less refined edge in absolute sharpness, but in the terms of how gentle they are on the steel - more gentle than diamonds). Probably oilstones.
I gather from reading over the years that:
* there are a lot of oilstone users who consider them to be gentle on an edge and provide better edge life or quality than diamonds (I am in that camp so far as I consider them safe options, but I have never tested the idea that anything other than micron or submicron diamonds are harsh and may cause failure - so I'll test it.)
* there are a lot of folks who get started with a sharpening regime who believe there's a significant gain in longevity if you follow to a very fine abrasive - in some cases all of the way to pigment only chromium oxide powders or pastes.
I'd like to see both how the irons perform on an absolute basis with those changes, and whether or not less refined edges than 1 micron diamonds on wood (which is beyond what will be achieved with a natural stone on a final angle so blunt - perhaps to a pointless level, which we'll test) narrow the gap between steels we're used to and V11.
Using only those two instead of the full set of irons because it takes a very long time to dull all six irons (about 6500 feet planed or some such amount). I suspect stainless alloy with some trickery (like 440C plus something) for V11, which I've mentioned many times. If that is the case, toughness of O1 is probably higher, wear resistance, we already showed. Basically, we'll see if the big performance gap happens only in ideal use.
The original testing method is useful because it takes those variables out and it's something people can do as a sharpening regime if they'd like - there's numbers and cheap guides that make it easy to duplicate (but, i don't like it).