M2
David Weaver
I suspect if brent beach's work is still relevant, the difference between V11 and what is probably M2 or similar here with the chinese steel would probably be made up for by the ASW iron, but that's not something that can be said for sure without actually testing it.
I'm not sure I'd want to test those two irons against each other - if they end up identical, One is about $50 and the ASW blades were on the order of $120. I'm not doing this testing for people to take recommendations, and I'd be through planing 3000-3500 feet for two irons.
What I can say after the maple and beech with much confidence is that the figures in this test are pretty representative. Clean wood without harsh flaws in it is necessary to achieve them.
What would they be in pine? I don't know. I'd hate to find out. All kinds of curiosities abound, but I'm glad to hear that kees had similar experience on his planing machine. There just isn't much to this test once we got all of the nits worked out so that most of the tooling was working on the same plane with the same fit on the same board and alternating so that variances were minimized.
The mechanism that's causing it, though? I have no idea. The carbon steel (my O1 iron, which I tempered so that it would still be hard for O1 but not fail at all by chipping) did what it should in both tests. No chipping. I don't like chipping and I'm pleased with it.
When someone tells me they're new to woodworking and what should they get, I just don't even know what to say any longer. If they'd been working long enough to tell me the way they sharpen, what they use, and how long it takes (if it was very fine abrasives and their sharpening cycle took them a long time), I'd tell them any of the top three in this test. I think A2 is relatively obsolete at this point, but not in a way that someone should replace it. Plus, if you really like LN's planes, then that's what's in them. I had a milled chinese iron (not tested here) in this LN smoother, which allowed me to have an almost new iron to test these on a comparable basis.
Once one can sharpen fast and use a double iron, not much of this stuff is a big deal, but I get that there's lots of folks who don't want to learn either of those.
But I am glad to see corroborating data. The way carbon steel fails is it just looks uniform and then it appears to run out of clearance, as the edge remains crisp without showing light at various depths (suggesting the very edge isn't that round) and then it just runs out of clearance. I expected as the V11 was cutting that it felt sweet (I'll have to define what that means, not sweet like a surfer would say, but sweet like the cutting characteristics) like carbon steel (despite not being sweet like it when it's on the stones) - and that somewhere around or shortly after A2, it would just run out of clearance. That would still be nice characteristics. It had that sweetness until right around when the 3V and chinese irons failed, and I expected that it might beat me up for a couple of hundred more strokes. I'm glad it didn't.
I could come up with all kinds of theories about it and 3V - the edges when you look at them are fine, but they're not otherwordly. Why do they appear to release parts of their edges in clumps on beech instead of in rows like the O1 does? Is something being pulled off of it when clearance is threatened? The fact that kees weighed it and only half the mass got pulled off suggests that's not it.
It's just something that is at this point in the conditions that this test were done under. I didn't really believe the marketing claim and also wanted to see how good a cheap chinese iron was against something known (LN and tsunesaburo). I wish the 3V could've been done in the same plane.
I've got a gaggle of other tests to do now, but this one blew up my last two weekends so maybe I'll do those off and on. I see that beach said he tested irons over years. I'll do it chicken and feathers style - it's not my nature to do tiny bits at a time of the same test. All or none. I'll do more limited tests now because I don't want to plane away all of my beech, but I would like to see how V11 will do across end grain (that should be a lot more brief) vs. the O1 iron. I"ve been using stanley plane irons and O1 for a while and have planed the ends of a lot of panels off, as well as drawer overlays and It's never occurred to me that I should have something tougher.
But testing feet planed in end grain to check if ratios stay the same would be nice, and testing a lower level of edge refinement with the two (if people using diamonds can manage a wire edge, a single cast plate with one diamond grit in the shop would make sharpening a whole lot more productive) and a 30 degree angle would be nice. If there's something taking lots of steps and being very particular about final bevel angle like I was here (piggybacking off of what I learned along the way with A2), it'll be nice to see what's worth faffing with and what's not.
Day to day, I don't faff with much. I'd still put a beginner on a stanley iron, a bare leather strop and a washita if they said they wanted to spend two weekends with me. The washita and the double iron both made me forget about chasing edge durability.