Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

Posts

The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#1

The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

david weaver

I wouldn't normally post about this, but since we talked about the aldi chisels a few weeks ago, I guess google ads feels like I want to see alibaba entries (the ones that involve getting hundreds of something, not the retail types).

This morning, they sent me a link from ningbo chisels, they're the aldi types (no guarantee that it's the same maker), $2 per set of 4 if I want to order them in blister packs with no logo. Only need to get at least 300 sets!!

What do you think these butt chisels might be?

https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/New-Items-High-Quality-Rose-Wood_60504599464.html?spm=a2700.7735675.2017115.200.ukbuOO

https://www.woodcraft.com/products/woodriver-4-piece-butt-chisel-set

(I've seen those before - actually, I'd say the chinese side is a little expensive and you run the risk of CITES issues, though I've gotten guitars from overseas that had madagascar rosewood in them and customs opened them for tax purposes and didn't care about the rosewood)

These aren't real narex, but they sure did their due diligence in copying the handles. I have to be honest, I like the blades on these better than the narex proportions.

https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/2018-Premium-Quality-7pcs-Wooden-Carving_60775492594.html?spm=a2700.galleryofferlist.normalList.32.21d248317nCQJD

Stanley 78 style plane? $7 with fixtures included.

https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/Ronix-Hand-Planes-Wood-Working-Rabbet_60775978766.html?spm=a2700.7724838.2017115.125.19a87312ZvdbWG

Chisel plane? Still don't know who uses them on a regular basis:

https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/Chisel-Plane-for-Woodworking_60687918589.html?spm=a2700.galleryofferlist.normalList.214.8e257312rRCYSa

(looks an awful lot like the one sold by woodcraft!! - low quantity requirement and relatively high price)

CBN wheels for $50? (yes, available in imperial measurements).

https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/Tool-sharpening-Diamond-CBN-Wheels_60758304774.html?spm=a2700.7724838.2017115.74.43eb6a643mPSQK&s=p

Two sided milled steel diamond hones? $13 if you order minimum quantity. About half if you order a lot of them. (I have two of these plates from this brand, with base, someone was selling them on ebay for $20 - the same base that sells in the US - originating from china, for $27 - except it was $20 for that and the hone...they're actually very good diamond hones).

https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/Hot-sale-diamond-knife-sharpening-stone_1994505425.html?spm=a2700.galleryofferlist.normalList.386.355f6c08qFzWpd

Not too much point to this other than that the first time I ever looked on here was when woodcraft was in the process of copying the LN planes (the first efforts were copies, and were posted on quangsheng tool companies websites - since then, some design elements in the frog, etc, as i understand, have been adjusted so that they don't look like LN's).

I remember the guy who had bridge city saying that he got an email offering $7.80 per grinder for the white wheel grinders that sell at woodworking suppliers for $90-$160, depending on their pricing strategy. That was the price with wheels delivered to the united states. I think costs in china have gone up, but I always ask when someone has a new brand "where is it made?"

When "trend" started selling a diamond plate "kit" for $150, this is just my opinion, but I thought it was a swindle. It was unclear what the origin was from any of the listings, but I gather that it's chinese origin (a couple of people confirmed that), and the flatness was quoted per inch. Several folks on the razor boards bought them and had flatness issues. Others bought them, and they were fine. But what remains as a question to me is what are you getting for your $150? The whole "kit" is probably available from china privately branded for $15.

When I first started woodworking, I visited rockler often. It's 2 miles from my house. I didn't know what i was looking for, but they had a little bit of stuff (two cherries, hock blades, etc). Slowly, anything of western origin disappeared. I don't blame them.

Woodcraft's pfeil chisels have to compete along side chisels that more or less look like knock offs of some of their tools (I have the rosewood butt chisels, but I think I got them somewhere for about $25, not $63. I'm sure they're fine, but like most folks who bought true butt chisels, I have no use for them. Cutting a shallow hinge mortise with chisels at hand takes less effort than digging them out).

These days, if I find anything that's within a significant fraction of the cost of a western good, I always buy the western good. I don't know that it makes much sense for me personally (I'm still paying more), but somehow, I feel like if the retailer had to pay a lot more for something, then I'm getting a better deal overall.

Some of the copy stuff coming out of china is obviously good. Some of it isn't copies, and some of the other less typical stuff (like high speed steel blades that sort of fit stanley planes - sometimes you have to adjust the slots- those are quite good, at least as good as an A2 iron, but $10 and thin like a stock stanley blade if you want that, or not, if you want something that looks more like LN proportion).

No real point, just pondering out loud.

I'll wait for the group buyer who wants to get 5000 diamond hones at $7 each and sell them for $20 :b

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#2

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

Philip Duffy

It would be wise to note that slave labor produced these items in a country that has no respect for intellectual properties and one which is a sworn enemy of capitalism, never mind all the other values we cherish and enjoy as Americans.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#3

Re: I know that comes up quite often..

david weaver

...but in my opinion, there is some reality that countries developing all go through this stage.

I'm not a fan of buying copied tools, copied guitars, etc, so I don't do it. I do have those butt chisels, but had no idea that they basically look like pfeil copies (because I saw the pfeil offerings well after buying the butt chisels).

The diamond hones, high speed steel blades, CBN wheels, etc, I think those are all fair game, though.

what I've noticed in the world of guitars (which is *ultra* competitive) is that China has been passed by for indonesia for a lot of current investment. The US and Japan produced a lot of guitars and in the 80s, korea became sort of the place to make guitars at lower cost for lower end guitars themselves or lower ranges for certain makes (guild brand went there, etc, for some guitar, then back here and back to korea again). Korean production went to china and then indonesia (some at the same time).

Long story short, over a ten or 12 year period, the average wage in china has increased 3 1/2 times - from $2,000 to about $7,500. I'm sure that it hasn't increased that amount for unskilled labor, but they're more or less working through the same growing pains we did, just in a slightly different environment. I think as consumers, we can pick the items that aren't copies and the result will be that their standard of living increases as their economy organizes (that's a principle that I support rather than keeping people on 1/6th of an acre near starvation - my parents visited rural china about a decade ago and there were still people growing food on a fraction of an acre, and eating basically garbage so that they could save the food they were growing to be sold). Labor conditions have improved in some cases (others not) and the video footage of a lot of the guitar factors are probably better conditions (air quality, lighting, etc) than the original heritage factory in kalamazoo, and they're definitely better than a tile factory that I worked in in the united states.

I have a much more dim view of retailers selling copies than individuals choosing what they think is their appropriate level of ethics.

An example of this came up with wood river planes a decade or so ago. It was apparent they were copied from LN planes in some aspects, and not from stanley planes. I never bought one, I don't like the idea of someone copying LN. But Todd Hughes and others on here were, in my opinion, correct, that LN's development in the first place was extremely limited and that the planes are in general, copies themselves. Copying the bronze lever cap, etc, and some trade-looking elements, that was in poor taste to me. Woodcraft and japan woodworker picked up some tools that weren't direct copies of LV's tools, but their style and elements were less than creative (black painted cast with bubinga handles and brass trim bits...). Not a fan.

But I think that kind of decision is up to each person to make. All the way up to guitars - I don't like outright fakes, but must admit, Gibson and Fender (who are probably faked the most) are protecting trade designs that were established almost 70 years ago. While I won't buy fakes, I'm not going to carry water for Gibson or Fender, who are both very litigious and have been historically, not always using their legal hammer for well-meaning purposes.

Very subjective, I think. My take is that I'll buy the non-copy goods, but not the copies. One feels fine to me, the other one -personally - doesn't.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#4

Chinese thievery .

Philip Duffy

Well, wake up world, the justification above just does not meet the "good neighbor check" that is for sure!

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#5

Re: Chinese thievery .

david weaver

I thought I'd edit this to make it more clear, and less argumentative, because that's not what I'm going for.

I've thought about it plenty, and don't need to "wake up". One of the local companies here basically sold their reactor design along with a few units and put themselves out of business. I'm aware of what thievery can do, agreed to or not.

But I started in my younger days buying only western made guitars. I'm "helping", right? Keep all of those people on 1/6th of an acre and don't let them have anything of ours.

To me, that isn't an ethical stance. There are plenty of individuals not caught up in any of it, and I choose to do business with those folks. Not the ones who steal things, but at the same time, i also have zero interest in telling other people what to do. It took me quite some time to get to the point where I realized that maybe my opinion about things isn't really the only one, and that the world will continue to turn, and the sun will continue to rise. I can avoid partaking in things that I see as unfit and not see everyone else as a threat or someone to battle against.

I hope that Chinese society continues its rise. So far, it's done well. Only affluence will bring them to a point where they are comfortable enough to innovate not only in technology, but in leisure and arts. The people on the ground certainly are not my enemy. I have been ripped off buying things directly from china.

Twice.

One of those two was an american living in china. The other was on a guitar that was NOT supposed to be counterfeit, but the the seller delivered me a counterfeit guitar with counterfeit markings on it. when it arrived, he made all kinds of promises to make it right. I threw the guitar away, told him that I recognized that he's a liar and moved on. the american mentioned first above buried himself in lies but was smart enough to know more about ebay rules than I did and managed to escape being held accountable. I could've squashed the second guy with dhgate's rules, but chose not to. I didn't get the sense that he had a grasp on what was a big deal to me, and squashing him with the rules probably would've cost him a week's wages. It cost me fairly little.

I've been stiffed more on items from japan - by far, and by domestic suppliers. It's not a boogeyman issue, it's a people issue.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#6

Re: Chinese thievery .

John in NM

What is the good neighbor check?

If one is very concerned about the standards of living in China, one may always boycott Chinese made products. Boycotts do not raise the standard of living anywhere, however. Looking at the ancient cars in Cuba, I think one could argue that the effect is to lower the standard of living over the long term.

To be honest, I have more distaste for attempts to shame those who do not boycott than sympathy for the boycotting route itself. This is just my opinion, however, and we all know the old sayings about what opinions are like or how much they are worth.

The typically libertarian suggestion on subjects like this is to go ahead and purchase these products and count on the Chinese culture to self correct as their country enjoys a trade surplus with the rest of the world.

Looking at the changes in China over my lifetime, I think that is probably what is happening there. I'm sure there is still a long way for them to go, but they seem to be on the right path and more importantly, more willing to change than other quasi-former authoritarian countries.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#7

American thievery

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is some thievery over here. We have people designing planes and chisels who barely know how to use these tools. Then they advertise them as the best available and charge gaudy prices.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#8

Re: American thievery

Jim Matthews

There's an element of complicity on the Seller's part - the makers don't hide the origin.

The makers want return business, and support their customers.

North Americans with their panties in a bunch should read the damn labels.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#9

A cost perspective - the +10% sale

david weaver

Years ago, before Hartville (I think it was Hartville) undertook a very expensive building project, they had a woodnet discount and would run a sale once per year that they charged +10% on everything.

If it was Holbren or I have the wrong retailer, I apologize, but I remember numbers, not names - failing of my life in general, not being able to remember verbal things, but spatial and numbers, no problem.

At any rate, you ordered everything you wanted from the store (not knowing what the price would be) and they calculated their cost and added 10%. That was the deal - you buy on faith.

I ordered several things from Norton that were US made at the time, and I took the opportunity to order some wall lumber rack systems. The norton stuff barely came down in price, and the lumber racks ended up being 35% of regular price. The racks were made in china or taiwan. I had lamented rockler slowly getting rid of everything that had any underlying cost in favor of melamine/plastic/anodized aluminum imported crap, but until then, I had no idea how big the difference was in retailer cost vs. retailer price. What sells now? Things that people can get a coupon offer on. A coupon offer on the norton products would probably have eliminated the retailer's profit. On the lumber racks, they'd be happy to sell a gaggle of them at 25% off and if some get returned, no problem.

I know Warren in this instance is talking about western made tools and the fact that they're being sold by people who don't know everything they should about all of the designs, or maybe act like they don't. They don't have an ire from me, though - they're selling to their market and it's pretty transparent as far as I can tell.

I have a less favorable opinion about a retailer who may do something like take a DMT or ezelap product off of the wall and put a trend diamond hone "kit" on the wall for more money than the DMT cost. They've just taken a bit out of both sides.

Seeing the difference in cost and the stupid gimmick garbage that a lot of retailers like to do now (tout "customer service" on low cost imported junk -stew mac comes to mind on the guitar side, they boast of customer service all the time, but retail common things from china that I can just get off of aliexpress for $2 for something more like $12. The tools that they used to have (they've always been expensive) that were made in japan slowly disappear for same looking imported versions of lower quality. They hope to capitalize on quotes from people about "service" and exchanging defective junk that never should've been swapped out. That's my opinion, of course. We see the same thing at retailers.

I trekked over to aliexpress yesterday to see what those $17 rosewood butt chisels sell for as an individual set - something on the alibaba side usually shows up on the express side as a single offering. The price on the aliexpress side? $1 more than woodcraft. Anyone think that's by chance? I don't. I think that kind of thing is by agreement - there are too many other sellers peddling $8 sets of chisels - I'm sure if one of them could get 500 sets of those rosewood chisels and sell them in the "express" retail side for double the $17, they'd do it quickly.

But, you're right. As far as the shell game goes with that stuff - it's up to the buyer to look around. It may be the case that in the age of amazon and ebay, the retailers who are left wouldn't be in business without that game. When I got lumber racks for 65% off, I knew there was no chance that we'd ever see good domestic supply goods for a reasonable price again. The "buy it and return it" mentality makes it impossible to sell that stuff. Norton's wares have gone to mexico for production since, at least a lot of them, I'm sure due to retailer demands that the wholesale cost needs to come down to support the coupon model and the fact that buyers return stuff just because they changed their mind.

I consider LN and LV to be some of the few bright spots less, even if I think I could plane everyone on their staff under the table without working very hard.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#10

Re: American thievery

John in NM

What you describe is not thievery, it is just ignorance.

Ignorance on the part of a manufacturer or vendor may not be admirable, granted, but it cannot be called thievery since that would require that they know better and ignore the knowledge out of malicious intent rather than an accurate gauging of their target market.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#11

Re: American thievery

Wiley Horne

Hi all,

I’m putting this here cause it has to be somewhere. Not arguing with Warren, who I have the highest respect for, but I have a different take on the small-production makers, sometimes disparagingly called boutique makers. As though they don’t get their hands dirty. They make planes, chisels, not many plate saws, marking gear, bench vises and accessories, fret saws....

I have a lot of respect for these folks, who are hardy enough to forego safe salaried work for the pure risk of owning their own time and betting they can compete in the market. Arithmetic itself requires high prices. And I doubt any of them are making much money, whatever they charge, because (1) they can’t produce enough to get any scale economy, and (2) they’re selling into a very small market, even if they could produce more.

To take this away from the US for a moment, a very famous Japanese maker of traditional saws died several years ago. He was third generation in a family of sawmakers. Untold hours and skill were required per saw. He could sell as many of them as he could produce for $1,500 each, less expenses and the agent’s cut. He died broke and without hot water in the house. He couldn’t beat the math because there weren’t enough hours in the day.

Perhaps the forces of family and tradition are not strong enough here in the US for the same thing to happen. But the business proposition is daunting and requires a strong constitution to face every day.

These folks are selling to amateurs. In Japan or America. We have all seen professionals at work, whether furnituremakers or plumbers or you name it—professionals do not generally use expensive tools. They use standard tools and have consummate skill in their use, if they’ve survived the market for long.

But having friends among the ‘small’ makers, and knowing something of their lives, I believe they should be respected for the risk they take, for the standards they impose on themselves, and for the hard work they do.

Wiley

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#12

Re: American (not) thievery

david weaver

I agree - my comments in general on the first part were just musings about chinese tools that in some cases are very inexpensive (as you said with the aldi chisels, who gets paid when someone sells a set for $7? Really, probably nobody).

I don't think any of the boutique makers in the US are making much, and even with my comments about the blue spruce chisels on the other side - it's not an accusation of someone trying to line their pockets and get fat, I just don't like the methods employed. But, you simply cannot make much per hour on tools, and as soon as you get big enough to need employees, a whole new level of costs and compliance comes in.

I'd consider anyone with up to several hundred employees to be a boutique maker.

On the japanese side, the distributors and dealers appear to do far better than the makers (in some cases, not all), but that's true in a lot of industries.

I never thought much about trying to make my wooden planes well enough to sell them. I thought that perhaps I could get to the point where if I only counted the making and procurement time (for materials), I could turn them into $30 an hour before taxes. That's not horrible, but most people complaining in the open market about tools (not members here, but the discussions I've seen elsewhere) would never work for that because it would quickly become $15 an hour after allocation of overhead and then incurring time to actually try to find buyers.

And deal with complaints, provide support, etc.

I do agree with warren that in some cases, the makers seem to be vexed by using their own tools as well as the parts they've copied design from would allow, but they're serving a market that doesn't care that much about that. how do we know for sure? If the market cared, they'd know it.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#13

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

Jim Matthews

"Sworn Enemy of Capitalism"

Only if Adam Smith wore Karl Marx trousers.

https://www.inkstonenews.com/china-translated/china-translated-china-socialist/article/2161467

Spare us the propaganda - plenty of places for that - elsewhere.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#14

Well said!


Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#16

Re: American thievery

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It is hard to give specific examples of these problems without upsetting people, but here is an example from England.

A fellow claimed he made the best planes that were ever made and he charged high prices. How good were they? Well, when he wanted make a piece of wood flat and smooth, he used a milling machine and sandpaper. It was obvious that he did not really know how to use a plane. So of course his planes were not very useful to a craftsman.

When someone with little experience and understanding in using hand tools is designing these tools, that is not so good. When they pretend to be experts and write that they make the finest tools, that is bad.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#17

I think it comes down to definitions...

John in NM

How does one define "finest"? Of new tools like you describe, marketed to hobbyist woodworkers and tool collectors, finest clearly has a strong component of aesthetics. In terms of making a piece of wood flat and smooth, ready to finish, the aesthetics of the tool used are completely irrelevant.

I think this is what you see in the plane maker's use of a mill and sandpaper - probably that is the faster way for him to cut the wood to his needed specifications. Presumably he is making infill parts rather than a furniture panel - that would be horribly slow with a milling machine. For making infill parts I would argue that he might have been doing it most efficiently with the mill and sandpaper - I've made wood parts that way myself.

So the question becomes whether we accept such relativism in defining the words that make up people's marketing claims. I tend to, but I can understand how you might not think it acceptable.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#18

You're right, John

Joe shelton

Or, as Sly sang, "...diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folks..."

Or as Bill Murray chanted, "It just doesn't matter."

Each of us may make good decisions for ourselves. None of us can make good decisions collectively for everyone else.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#19

Re: You're right, John

TomD

"None of us can make good decisions collectively for everyone else."

Now there is a comment that has ironic overtones for both sides of the Pacific.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#20

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

TomD

"Spare us the propaganda"

Propaganda is a rather intemperate characterization of an opinion.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#21

Leo Fender

david weaver

I'm assuming that's Karl Holtey as I haven't seen anyone else milling infills to a pattern (though I'm sure the older planes had them roughed before hand fitting as a matter of labor).

I've never had one of Karl's planes, it's out of my range more or less but probably nobody will chance in to one by accident.

Makers who can make good wares without knowing how to use them do come along sometimes, though. Leo Fender comes to mind. I don't think he ever learned to play guitar, but he's practically the Leonard Bailey of the electric guitar and bass. He sought constant feedback from professionals from what I recall, though.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#22

Re: American thievery

TomD

"When they pretend to be experts and write that they make the finest tools, that is bad."

If we are thinking of the same person, I think he was an expert, or at least a highly competent machinist, who saw the plane as a mechanism that he was uniquely qualified to produce the parts of. I don't think that makes one a bad person, probably just talking at cross purposes. On the general issue of whether a plane should be a 1000 dollar blade with a 20 dollar holder, or a 20 dollar blade with a 2000 dollar holder, I fall in the former camp, though woodwork is perfectly happy with a 10 dollar blade in a 10 dollar holder.

Clark and Williams used a milling machine for certain plane making tasks. The tool is just slightly over 200 years old. which takes it pretty far back through the antique plane forms, not to say is was available to workers back then, but it is pretty amazing how long these things have been around.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#23

Re: Leo Fender

TomD

Just curious, what is the evidence he didn't know how to use planes? If you dial this forum back to the level of knowledge it had when Hotley started, he might qualify as a super user.

I am not a fan of his planes, or of the overall concept, I think the Norris type was largely a misdirection anyway.

At one point I happened to write Leonard Lee when he was still in charge, and I mentioned that LV didn't at that point have a single chisel, plane or, saw that was capable of good professional work. It was a weird period when both Japanese chisels and planes had been dropped; German planes were out of the catalog, and the only goodish saw they had was a Japanese crosscut saw. He replied that they were on it, and not too long after that they certainly were. This was before the Independence saw was born, and FK said he bought several for himself, and one for each guy in his shop. Even so, it was probably 10 years or maybe 15 until LV brought out their saw. For a while around 2000 the best dovetail saw was a Japanese steel backed saw they sold for a very decent price.

FWW was creating demand in the 70s, it took at least 20 years before you could just buy a saw for dovetails. (well there were ones for astronomical prices from the Japanese sellers. I had a cheap one I bought around 1980, but I never saw a deal like that again, so I was scared to use it). It was bad back then.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#24

Re: I couldn't confirm it...

david weaver

...Just noting that Karl's work style appeared to be about control and known measurements with rough sizing by fly cutter.

I am also not a fan of all of the norris planes (especially not the later ones with an adjuster, but some of them are OK - the bigger the plane and the coarser the work, the easier the adjuster is to tolerate, plus you can get used to its nuance - that being that you have to set it for nearly no cut and use the lever cap for fine adjustment)....except the early planes are wonderful. Not sure of the context back when they were made, what caused people to buy them instead of a bailey type design - social pressure? Who knows, the early ones are wonderfully made...

..at any rate, Karl may have been a master with a plane, but most of his blog work didn't show much of it.

Konrad Sauer's blog, IIRC, showed a whole bunch of hand fitting.

I've never used a plane from either. Karl Holtey started using A2 steel earlier than most (but after George was feeding blades to coopers at williamsburg). I wonder if that was also about control (the stability of the blade), and not sure what further chasing he did with S53 and other such steels - they never appeared to hold up that well on smoothers. But, I don't think that's the point -I think Karl's planes are more like art, made to a level that I couldn't ever make a plane, and with a lot of hand finish work on them that is to a level of extreme perfection.

(though I've never looked for Karl's origin into planemaking before, his blog says that he was working as a cabinetmaker and that's how he got introduced to planes. I see from his web page that he's back to production again - maybe on a smaller scale, I don't know, but I couldn't imagine that he could've said he was going to retire and then follow through. Being a cabinet maker doesn't really answer how much he used planes, though. I have a lot of respect for Karl because he's chasing an extreme - I can only speculate that his methods have to do with getting the most precise result he can get - I can't imagine matching it - and he probably feels like he's obligated for each plane to be as perfect as he can get it. And no beginner is going to accidentally walk into an $8,000 plane).

I've seen you mention the 70s and 80s tool market before, and have heard the same from George about what was available. He's obviously a toolmaker (that was his job for something like 25 years at williamsburg), but he's also a tool hound. After making a couple of saw kits (something that wouldn't have been an option in the 70s), I bought a bunch of English from fine tool journal's web sales (man that was a steal for certain things for a little while - I still have a $26 groves 26" rip saw that is one of the best saws I've ever used) and some directly from England for probably $40 on average. They were very easy to get.

George mentioned that 20+ years prior, if you could find a good antique brass backed saw without damage at a flea market here in PA, they were $70-$80. Effectively four times the price I paid (or more, just eyeballing the impact of inflation) once there were modern makers and more ease in getting tools. I think the last 15 years have kind of been the golden era for hand tool woodworkers. Ebay's global shipping opened up supply, Japanese makers started catering to the West, and the domestic makers have popped up everywhere. It has a little bit of a temporary feel to me - certain vintage stuff is already much harder to find than it was 10 years ago, but in fairness, the shine of some things has worn off (10 years ago, infill planes were sort of an "it" tool. They are easier to get (used) for reasonable money now if you avoid larger dealers...to the detriment of folks who bought dozens or more of them 10 years ago when they cost two or three times as much.

Re: The interesting world of Chinese Tools..

#25

Not sure when the rough work...

david weaver

..became mechanized for plane making. the WPINCA book that was offered years ago (if i'm remembering the right total) talked about Chapin or predecessor (again, terrible with changing names over time) seeking water power to do the rough work on planes in the late 1700s or early 1800s.

I've seen on Larry's blog that over time, he's come up with a lot of fixtures (on machining tools) to do various parts of the side escapement production. At the time his video came out, he did one by hand, though, and did a nice job. I hoped for a couple of years that he'd make a bench plane video, and I'm sure he was harassed by plenty of other people to make the same video. Not sure how he'd have showed it, but it wasn't that hard to figure out a workable solution with double iron planes in hand and a bunch of tools courtesy of Larry's sharing what he used with LN. It probably would've been a lot harder to figure out in a vacuum.

Point being, I'm not sure if there was a time in the last 200 years that many tools were made by a process that wasn't separated from "pure" use and skill of a maker in favor of speeding up production.