Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

where is everybody?

Posts

where is everybody?

#1

justin ball

where is everybody?

justin ball

Umm...it's been a while since I visited, but there used to be hundreds of messages and threads in a few days. Where is everybody? Gone somewhere else?

Re: where is everybody?

#2

Re: where is everybody?

Mark Nowicki

Had a big fight about hide glue, of all things, a while back.

No point in looking for it, search doesnt work.

Re: where is everybody?

#3

justin ball

Re: where is everybody?

justin ball

you have to be joking.

Re: where is everybody?

#4

Re: where is everybody?

Mark Nowicki

A little.

The Search is broken, people get too exited about glue, sharpening or "Is it a chipbreaker or a double iron", but I think most are doing what you have done, gone on a walkabout.

Re: where is everybody?

#5

Re: where is everybody?

Jim Matthews

There's a limit most have in free time, resources and ambition devoted to making things. The pursuit tends to generate cyclic interest (and posts) as a new enthusiast finds a forum.

Most of us will make a dining table, maybe a rocking chair and gifts for family.

After that, the shop (and all its expensive trappings) gathers the wrong kind of dust.

Participation peaked when the major print rags had plenty of readers, and current articles became the point of discussion.

As mentioned above, there has been an inordinate amount of squabble over how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.

Re: where is everybody?

#6

Re: where is everybody?

Joe shelton

Clearly, that depends on whether it was a draw-bored pin.

Re: where is everybody?

#7

Re: where is everybody?

David Weaver

I can say from the few times I've posted things I've made, there just isn't much interest in things that are made, and people for the most part are done with arguments about sharpening stones, glue types and how much power tool use is acceptable.

I'm still making stuff at the same rate, but it's cabinets and guitars and not planes, and there's just no great reason to post much about it because it's not as germane to this forum as planes. Guitars, in my opinion, are really interesting to make in the same vein as tools - they're small, there's not much hassle in glue ups, and you don't have to figure out what you have room for (like cabinets or furniture) in the house. But there's so much out there on the internet (good stuff) about making guitars that it's not going to be interesting because other people on here aren't making them or (generally) using them.

I have to say the same thing on others' behalf. I've seen off and on, someone posts some interesting work, and either it's a two or three post response, or it's a two or three post response next to a 60 page fight about glue.

Re: where is everybody?

#8

Re: where is everybody?

Mark Nowicki

If you could point out a few of the good resources for guitar building, and plans, I would appreciate it.

Specifically, I want to make a soprano ukulele for a facebook friend.

We both lived in West Africa about four decades ago, and I have some quarter sawn sapele from that time and area I would like to use.

I am not looking for kits.

I know of Georgia Luthier Supply but i have read complaint about not responding to inquiries.

TIA.

Re: where is everybody?

#9

Re: where is everybody?

david weaver

I've actually bought plans pretty much from anyone and then bought a guitar to have in hand to use them. The same as with planes, it's just easier to build something when you have great pictures from all angles or an example in hand at least to base things on.

Stew mac has a video series on uke building that they posted on youtube, and though they probably have more expensive plans than anyone else, their stuff is generally thorough and good quality (can't speak to their kits other than that they're overpriced for guitar, but since you're not looking to build a kit, no problem).

Other than that, it doesn't look like there's a huge volume of books like there are for guitar (e.g., you can get a book written by benedetto describing the entire archtop making process in detail without hiding things from the reader).

Re: where is everybody?

#10

RE: Broken Search

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Use Google for WC Searches. Works great.

Enter your search criteria followed by site:woodcentral.com

Example:

pins or tails first site:woodcentral.com


Re: where is everybody?

#11

Re: good suggestion...

david weaver

I wonder if it could be made sticky.

As much as folks talk about fixing the search function, I use this style of search for everyones' site rather than the site search function. It just seems to work better, even when the site says "powered by google search".

There's so much valuable discussion on this forum in a more focused manner than most others because the difficult format scares away the tire kickers. I often end up in the archives via google even when I'm just searching the open internet.

Re: where is everybody?

#12

Re: good suggestion...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"There's so much valuable discussion on this forum"

That's an understatement. :)

The value of information I've gotten here over the years is large. It's why WC is the only WW'ing forum I've ever been a member of since Badger Pond closed. Well, I did join a FB group, but the depth of knowledge there is not nearly as much as here.

Using site: in Google searches is very handy.

site:stackoverflow.com has made me an expert programmer... :D not.

Re: where is everybody?

#13

--- PINS FIRST ---     

Re: where is everybody?

#14

Re: No, Technical Falls!!


Re: where is everybody?

#15

Obviously

Joe shelton

Because Frank said so...

Re: where is everybody?

#16

Re: Guitar

TomD

What kind of guitar would helpfully narrow it down.

I never use plans, the proportions are pretty easy to come up with as they relate to the string length which is not a fixed number, but there are some basic scale lengths. To develop the scale length itself, there is the utility Frets (or was). You just enter the length you want and it prints it out graphically and the numbers. That knocks out a really expensive and useless ruler I once bought. :)

So you might want a plan form for the box, the shape of the soundboard. You can find free plans online, and you can copy forms you see online, of say a concert SS guitar. Luth.org has some plans, often for kinda weird instruments.

I remember reading this article on how a luthier created an assembly line. He just made a workstation for every step in the process, then staffed them. The point being when you do a guitar, you have X processes. A lot of luthiers are not competent woodworkers, so there are probably 100 different, reasonably credible ways of doing every one of these steps, and the best place to find out about them is almost always on the internet. Another alternative for hand tool expert people is just to do them all with relatively available tools. So you can spend hundreds on a jig to cut fret slots, or make one, some of which are truly brilliant, or set up CNC. I cut mine with a small, cheap hacksaw.

It all comes down to a lot of steps, and then you just do them. It is actually pretty easy woodworking, getting the to the point where you have any control over the acoustics is possibly a myth, or the work of a lifetime, but there are plenty of 1rst time guitars that turn out great.

You can start out with something small like a strumstick, or Uke. Maybe a large Uke, like a Baratone.

There are Youtube vids that go through someone's whole process, I haven't watched any, but it is more a case of there being too much out there, not to little.

One nice thing about making acoustics is the wood tends to be extraordinary. So for hand tools it is a lot of fun.

------------------------------------------

Charles Fox, not the guy I was referring to above. He has for years been offering courses that deal with how to up your production so you can make 2 guitars a week. For a lot of luthiers, one is a push in a one person shop. I don't care about that, but it is interesting to look at the steps, and options available.

Fox also invented the bender, now a little obsolete, that really opened up lutherie to the masses, as it made it possible for anyone to bend sides. Silicon heaters are probably more common today, but he is a guy with a lot of ideas.

http://www.frets.com/FretsPages/Features/CFox/cfox01.html

Once one is familiar with the steps, one can start to look at the different ways one might deal with them.

If you look at what many of the people selling plans or templates are doing, mostly it is just selling the outline of the guitar. Some of the sets, and these get really expensive, are selling multiple template sets, but most of that info for things like body heights, or neck widths, is going to be online in manufacturer's websites, or many many other places.

Re: where is everybody?

#17

Re: where is everybody?

TomD

On Youtube probably.

I put up a lot of content on this site. Thousands of hours. And I hope it helped someone. Someone else putting that content effectively on youtube actually gets paid. And I revealed things here that are still not understood in the wider woodisphere. Mostly the dialectic is argumentative, when dealing with anything out of the mainstream, so it is a little unpleasant to do, if may be OK to read.

Eventually we got down to a granularity that seemed useless.

I have been active on other boards, and the drop off seems to be there also.

On the main page, you get 300 views on a big topic, most a lot less. I had crappy videos shot with me holding a camera with one hand, while sailing my boat with the other, that got 7000 views. And they essentially took less time to do for the whole process, than each of hundreds (I am sad to say, maybe 1000s) of posts I wrote and rewrote here.

I don't do Youtube myself. The standard is currently way higher than what Taunton press used to ask 40 dollars for back in the 80s. I just shot a few maybe 5-10 years ago.

Re: where is everybody?

#18

Free ukulele plans *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Mathias Wandel also has some videos to accompany the plans. I built one a couple years ago. It was a fun learning experience.


Mathias Wandel’s plans

Re: where is everybody?

#19

I had...

david weaver

put a lot of content on youtube where I thought I had something unique to share, but never turned ads on (and figure the total take in views so far would've been about $600, so why bother making people sit through ads?).

My editing of videos was limited to splitting them, so they're slow and poorly made to say the least.

But it's a good (or was) content sharing medium because an hour spent recording something and uploading it may reach 5000 or in some cases 50,000 viewers and a lot of them are going to take the information and run with it.

I get a troll once in a while, but you can ghost them easily on there. the diction of some of the trolls tells me they are certain forum members I've had spats with before (and others are originals) - too chicken to spat with their real names. They're not really looking for a debate, anyway, they're just miserable - btdt on a bad day seeing a ridiculous youtube video and leaving comments like "with instruction like that, you're going to get someone killed" on a felling video.

Just like forums, the platform changes, and I guess youtube is going for advertiser safe highly produced stuff and kind of burying the rest. Even a low quality content provider like me - if you put up a video with a unique premise, in a year, there will be a couple copying what you said and repeating it.

Still, it would be lovely if more experts would just set up a camera and do no editing (which in my mind is the difficult part that feels like work), just split out dead parts of the video - I guess that's some editing - and leave the decent stuff in. There are 10 well produced videos of crap for every 1 video of a professional working with little or no editing, and the latter is far more instructive.

Re: where is everybody?

#20

Re: Guitar are interesting

david weaver

because there are a lot of people who start trying to make them with the intention to sell from the start. They get interested in projects and jigs, and workstation work like you're saying (the world of production guitars is unskilled and semi-skilled labor - they can make a good guitar if not a great one, so you're not going to make a production type guitar as an individual and recover much for time).

I posted on a guitar forum for a little bit, but got banned because an older builder referred to someone else as a sissy in response to a criticism, and i questioned banning the older builder (who is a pro) and diluting comment!! Apparently, "sissy" is now homophobic -- :b It reminded me of sawmillcreek constantly threatening george because he draws fire from newbies when he insists that standards are important. Those types of forums are set up to make the owners money and keep individuals in place, not quality. Lots of parallels.

At any rate, there are a couple of former Gibson employees on those forums, and they are just kind of there. None of them could build a guitar. They can tell stories about what it was like to work at gibson, and how they have guitars made of unique parts that they snuck away from the factory, but I haven't seen or heard one talk about actually building a guitar. Just like the forums, the focus for them is on what it was like "in the old days" and now workplace politics.

I do (in four guitars so far) as you say, take the tools available, figure out what to do with them. Fret tangs are something like .023" (can't remember exactly). It's not hard to dig out a saw that will suffice based on plate or plate plus a little set. Mark them, and cut them, but there's very little of that kind of stuff on that forum. It's filled with 90% bad work and guys trying to set up routers and MDF to do something simple.

Cabinet factory work was obviously the same when I was in college. I may have hung the doors on 900 cabinets in a given day, maybe put drawer guides in them the next. But making work fast means that it isn't going to be meaningful.

I suspect I could sell my guitars for the cost of the parts ,and if i was dishonest (and talked them up to be more than they are - which seems to be de-rigeur for the market), probably a little bit more. I never intend to build anything for sale or sell for any reason other than making space, though, but guitars and tools are interesting in a way that making most pieces of furniture isn't.

The individual builders, I get the sense that a lot of them are temporary and are using partially made parts to speed up their work, too. I'm not going to bug you to post more of your work since it's a pain to find it and do it, but George is sort of in the same boat, and most of his work (for sale) was done in his younger days or bought by people who took it out of circulation. I located one of his one-off guitars last week from a prior sale:

https://reverb.com/item/1596063-wilson-pre-war-martin-d-28-brazilian-replica

...and gave him a call. He couldn't remember the guitar, but vaguely remembered it when he saw it. The listing is wrong, it's a gibson slope shoulder type acoustic, and it sold for more than George would've charged by a factor of two, but it's plain and neatly made. If I could manage to make a guitar of that quality in a couple of years, I'd bet I couldn't sell it in two decades for two thirds of that.

I see amp guys going through the same struggle when they think they'll make a business out of it - trying to sell hand made JTM 45 clones for 30% of what marshall does and probably clearing almost nothing. Much better as a hobby than a business!

Re: where is everybody?

#21

Modern production

david weaver

I posted this a few weeks ago, you probably saw it and may have responded to it:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cylr2aG6zAw&t=17s

But, in talking about how guitars are actually made. I bought a guitar from this factory, new. Pau ferro sides and back, baked sitka top, good quality hardware, and a case. $550. New, at retail. Actually a good guitar, and as good as an original early 2000s D-28 that I had years ago (a little stronger and just as neatly made).

No real economic sense peeing upstream against that. And there are still comments "$550 is too much" when you discuss something like the above.

I recall when I said I was going to delve into hobby making guitars, you sort of said something like "it really doesn't make sense to make them at this point - the market has figured out how to make them well and cheap". That is, of course, true.

Re: where is everybody?

#22

Re: Free ukulele plans

TomD

I watched that series on the Uke, and it was fun, but there is Uke Undersground, and a thousand builders with more reliable info out there.

Montolla's site is a good one, though he builds non-standard instruments, which is cool, just so long as people tripping into there don't think they are getting standard ideas.

Re: where is everybody?

#23

Re: I had...

TomD

"Still, it would be lovely if more experts would just set up a camera and do no editing (which in my mind is the difficult part that feels like work), just split out dead parts of the video - I guess that's some editing - and leave the decent stuff in. There are 10 well produced videos of crap for every 1 video of a professional working with little or no editing, and the latter is far more instructive."

Me too. Imagine if we had 100 hours of Krenov, Nakashima, Carpenter, etc... But from the beginning the folks who are all about production values were shaming people who didn't have professional production levels. I guess they were right, because over time the level is insanely high, and the content is ok also.

People watching this stuff mostly just want to be entertained; Directed to things they can purchase to be part of the lifestyle; and thirdly, maybe learn something. And in a distant last, actually develop the abilities. That is why you see people like Cosman, Sellers, and Mathias going to the personality blogs, you don't even have to come up with woodworking pretexts for the content. A lot of people dream of being Youtubers. My 12 year old tells me it is one of the stock answers to "what do you want to be when you grow up". So if you can just be seen to be living the life that will sustain the model.

Re: where is everybody?

#24

Re: Guitar are interesting

TomD

I got banned off guitar forums. Same with Bicycle frame forums, though I did eventually find a home. I find that those are hobbies where the main dream is to be a builder, no mater how horrible a living that is for most people who get there. And because the projects are expensive and relatively large, and the overhead is large, you really do need to think of how you will get rid of them. People want to do things the way pros do them, even when it makes no sense for an amateur. Bike building is possible on a small scale, but it is rather insanely expensive to gear up for as a pro. And has gotten a lot worse. Yet concrete ways of doing things on a reasonable scale get rejected with hostility, because were they accepted it would dash the dream. No problem, people want what they want.

They are also both crafts that require a lot of BS marketing. It is the case you can make a superior product and add a lot of value, but not measurable value. It is like a fine tailored suit. Jeans cover one's nakedness, and even have a style element that is comparable to the finest suit, if not in the same situation. But you don't have to apologize for the fact a suit can cost a fortune. Unfortunately with guitars and bikes, people have been lying about the products for so long, and they are so ill understood that you really aren't going to be able to sell them straight.

Re: where is everybody?

#25

Re: Modern production

TomD

"I recall when I said I was going to delve into hobby making guitars, you sort of said something like "it really doesn't make sense to make them at this point - the market has figured out how to make them well and cheap". That is, of coenurse, true."

True and not, I suppose. I got rid of all my guitars at one point, to clear the decks for the next one. And then I asked myself what I wanted to make, and nothing has since come to mind. So guitarless, first my daughter, and later I needed a guitar. I got her a Fender version of a Martin. It cost around 100 Canadian, and at least out of the box it was as good as a 800 dollar guitar I bought before I took up making them myself. When I took lessons, as a kid, like 45 years ago. I got this classical guitar, plywood everything, nut and bridge were plastic, no compensation. A good player could make it sound OK, but just a hideous instrument by any standard. But that Fender had bone, it was well set up, and it sounds great. They must have come up with a hit list of things to improve and just sweated it with cheap labour.

Later I bought a strat off Amazon, 95 dollars, free delivery and returns. There are problems with that one, and some that could show up later. But it is still highly playable, and no doubt Jack White could make a million selling single using it. Fine for noodling. I would guess an hour or two parking in NYC cost the equivalent of 95 dollars Canadian, at this point. With electrics, getting all the parts is not free, even the very cheapest parts.

----------------------------------------

But if you have basic skills in woodworking (when presented with a shape you need to create, you just make it happen), then you can make a 4K acoustic in a week, with mostly the tools and wood on hand. It will be a whole lot better than an Amazon guitar, but it may not be apparent to most as to why.