Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

where is everybody?

Posts

Re: where is everybody?

#26

Your videos are excellent

Jim Matthews

Plenty worth watching in your vidyas, DW.

The primer on stones is particularly helpful.

I'm down to two stores, and a strop thanks.

Total outlay of funds, about 30 bucks.

I've got expensive stuff sitting in drawers what dinnae work as well.

Do what YOU think best, and your audience will find you.

Re: where is everybody?

#27

Re: I had...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, I like your unedited video material. It is the unrehearsed that tells so much more. Last year I followed your lead and placed such a video (of building a curved drawer for the apothecary chest) on YouTube. I think that it has received 10 hits, mostly from my mother. Even I fell asleep watching it :) This format is only for the die hard.

I have not posted here much of late. I generally only post when I believe I have something to add. If another posts what I would have, I move on. It seems that others do the same. The downside is that there are fewer posts on the Hand Tool forum than on the Messages forum. It gets disheartening to post, say a build, and not receive any replies or discussion. That often happens in regard to practical topics, such as builds. It suggests that there are a lot of armchair woodworkers on the Hand Tool forum (who feel more comfortable with theoretical topics). The Messages (power) forum is always busy and informative in regards to technique.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: where is everybody?

#28

Re: I had...

David Weaver

Derek - the detail and depth of your hand joinery work would draw a lot of viewers, and you'd need to do nothing other than video part of your actual work and then talk a little bit about why you do the things you do and more importantly, what standard of work you're looking for.

I like to watch pros work or very good amateurs because it gives me an idea of what I should expect for execution and speed.

Not to be too harsh, but youtube doesn't need more stealth marketing unskilled woodworkers who fail to mention free products and do things like build giant pole buildings and bandmills to demonstrate making picnic tables.

But, if you don't want to do it just because it ruins shop time, then no big deal. You're right about not for the faint of heart. Making unedited content sort of ensures a small group of people who are actually looking for the content, and you can ghost anyone who leaves a nasty comment - which happens less often than I'd have expected.

Re: where is everybody?

#29

Thanks, Jim..

David Weaver

Thanks, Jim - I'd probably turn the camera on if I was doing something unusual again, but I'm just making more cabinets to the mrs' spec right now and guitars (which are very well represented by skilled makers on youtube...well, and represented well by some unskilled makers, too!!).

I'm glad you found the sharpening stone stuff useful - after all of the years of this or that distributor talking about their stones being finer and faster and finer and faster, who'd have guessed that the fastest way to sharpen is often with the stones that are more about control and less about speed?

Re: where is everybody?

#30

Re: Thanks, Jim..

TomD

My problem with stones is that it seems as though every three months there is a new theory. They all work. I am less convinced progress is linear. Or that there is any real way to prove it.

And of course, if you want speed, you just move to power. I just stick with stones for some stuff, because I have these Japanese legacy tools where sharpening with power is like drinking a fine wine with a straw, or out of a Camelback.

Re: where is everybody?

#31

Re: Thanks, Jim..

David Weaver

100% agree, they all work.

I recall talking to george (george is half laid up and likes to tell stories now, but he still does some work) and he mentioned that as a kid, he made his first guitars with a block plane, a cheap combination stone and newspaper.

I have yet to find a type of stone or method that doesn't really work, but I have learned some things. Things like hard arkansas stones' fineness is 100% dependent on density, and not color (and that the density varies by company based on what their mine produces - dans' black and trans stones are identical in density. Everyone else has higher density in their trans stones, and the cheap black stones that float around from time to time are really junk. ). density at 2.65 specific gravity is about as high as you'll find (it's almost zero air in an ark stone). 2.6 is all it takes to get translucent stones that you can see pores on and they will raise a wire edge whereas a good quality trans won't. Can they still be used? Of course. Would you pay the same for both? I hope not. If you're sharpening a razor on one, the latter is marginal and should be avoided.

There's no shortage of blanket statements from people who haven't tried things, though. Old stones are better than new? What old, what new? Japanese? In general, yes, the older stones are far better per dollar - especially on the fine end. Black or trans ark stones? I've never seen anything better than what dan's is putting out right now, but the inexpensive black stones that show up for $60, they're no good. There was plenty of low cost junk in the old days, though, too.

Re: where is everybody?

#32

Re: I had...

Jim Matthews

"Rich rebuilds" is a YouTube channel devoted to repairs of salvage Tesla motors cars.

His enthusiasm, and inclusion of "Why did I do THAT?" errors makes his videos compelling, and engaging. He has slowed the pace of projects, posted videos and commentary online - as his young family grows and available time diminishes.

He has been forthright about the poor return this sort of effort provides.

It is my belief that in his discoveries, he felt a compulsion to spread the word.

*****

Those of us that share an interest should express, at least, gratitude to those among us that make an effort to publish.

Kudos to you and DC.

I only wish our Man from Williamsburg had carried a camera.

Re: where is everybody?

#33

Re: I had...

david weaver

>> george <<

You, and me too. It's hard to even find much of his work floating around. I posted a link to one of his more plain guitar commissions last week. I guess it wasn't a commission, rather a trade.

George is still bursting with ideas, and he still gets a little shop time. I have not met anyone who has more stiff about work quality and design and with more depth about why.

https://reverb.com/item/1596063-wilson-pre-war-martin-d-28-brazilian-replica

It is common for guitar makers to depart from martin or gibson copies, but rare for them to look as good as that one without being at all gaudy.

It would be fantastic if he were to ever undertake a few more projects and let people tape him and talk with him about what standard he's working to and why. Just his design sense (and ability to communicate why something is or isn't good design) itself is something that would help a lot of budding woodworkers to stay out of the rut of "design doesn't matter that much, I don't have enough experience to worry about it yet".

Re: where is everybody?

#34

Re: I had...

TomD

Actually don't like that guitar, but I am not the arbiter on such things. The head stock looks wrong to me (and possibly a little dangerous). It is funny that with all the drive on copyright how closely people rip off the Martin designs, so why bother with mixing and matching styles. Sitka is certainly a choice for SS guitars, but probably not the top choice of a prewar Martin guitar, which might be more red spruce territory. Making a really responsive, even fragile guitar on a D28 platform seems a little odd to me, but then it is also a look, and there is no combination of uses and shapes there isn't a customer for. Of course playability and tone are key, but probably people will buy anything Brazillian. The price says it all though.

It would be great to get some of his design experience out there. I thought about 20 years ago that people where going to take the next step and start designing they own stuff. There was a nexus of information and software, but I don't see that having happened really. Of course on old furniture the formal information exists, but I don't know anything about, and could use a little spoon feeding.

Re: where is everybody?

#35

Re: I had...

david weaver

I kind of like the peghead style, but it wouldn't be a guitar for a newbie or a kid - the corners of the peghead might come off. A closer look at the peghead sort of outs it as gibson proportions.

I talked to george about that listing after I found it and said "that doesn't look like a Martin to me, and it doesn't look prewar martin, or martin at all - it looks like a slope shouldered gibson early american style in some elements and with a gibson pip and hear at the end of the fingerboard"

He said the same, basically that it has nothing to do with martin, that it's mostly slope shouldered gibson, except 12 fret (I don't know what the J-45 is), and the style is turn of the century (I guessed older and wrong).

The brazilian is actually flatsawn because that's what he was able to get a hold of when he was in college in 1960s (it's from slices off of the outside of a log as the mill was truing the log itself).

I think george would've used red spruce on a martin copy, but he probably didn't make many as he doesn't like the way they look since they're not tapered much above and below the waist - I think he called the "square looking". It sounds like he made this guitar for himself or for another order and then traded it to this guy (I can't remember what he got in exchange) and I joked with him and said "I can't believe you stuck the guy for $8k on such a plain looking guitar" and he was certain that it was probably half of that back then.

So, it's more or less a 12 fret uniquely styled gibson jumbo.

You're right about people slavishly copying martins, but I think now that we have the internet that it's gotten even worse. People get used to D-28s and HD-28s and they want everything to look identical, even if the logo on the peghead is different, and martin seems to tolerate people copying their plain peghead whereas fender and Gibson don't tolerate it at all (or want to get paid in license fees). Not sure if george would've used red spruce on a martin copy, but the only guitars of his that I've seen (other than really odd custom stuff) are in the proportion of J-45s and SJ-200s.

I'd bet that 95% of the makers making martin type guitars would sell fewer guitars if they used their own peghead design, no matter how good the guitars were. Collings has carved out their own niche, but their pegheads are barely different than gibsons - they took the same general idea but call it a parted hair instead of an open book (and most of their martin style guitars still have the martin style slab square peghead).

I wouldn't want to be a maker now. The market gets younger each year, less educated in terms of what they're buying, and cheaper. 10 years ago, ukes were going to save the string instrument world, and this past year, fender and gibson started making it apparent that they're trying to push acoustic guitars to women as those two things are, I guess, the only part of the market growing. The buyers now want to be ed sheeran (i don't know the female equivalent) instead of chet atkins or carol kaye.

Re: where is everybody?

#36

Re: curious about design ...and the brazilian..

david weaver

George mentioned that he doesn't like using the brazilian, either. It's fragile and often cracks, and I'm sure the age of the stuff that he was able to get doesn't help (60+ years old by now). Maple is his favorite wood for backs and sides, and I guess it goes well with the gibson guitar designs that aren't so bright and chimey like a rosewood martin.

Curiosity with the design is that I've never seen it done computer wise other than sketchup furniture plan type stuff (which I'd not be the user of, and often it looks gawky), or design items for manufacture. I've asked george for design elements (advice on lines, etc) but never an entire section of anything, and nothing in a while, but when I asked him what his method is for designing something (wondering if there was sort of a rule book) he said "I draw designs freehand until I'm satisfied with them" or something of that sort.

I'm sure software can help, but I'm not sure I get how that is more than design by legos. Maybe it allows people without the coordination to draw map what they want to see or make revisions more easily, but it seems like every good carver or good maker (who makes more than one thing) is able to draw well. I cannot draw well, but I'm definitely not motivated to use software to design anything, either.

Re: where is everybody?

#37

Re: I had...

TomD

That makes more sense, a classic misnaming by the seller thing.

I don't think CAD makes it easier to design stuff like Queen Anne furniture, say. More stuff that is quite simple in it's geometry which includes a lot of guitar parts, or knives, but moreso things like boats, or airplanes. There are things there that CAD does with great rapidity that required a lot of understanding and endless calculation, before computers.

Re: where is everybody?

#38

Re: I had...

David Weaver

I wouldn't be surprised if the seller used a Martin model in the description just to draw views.

I've sold a bunch of guitars on reverb this year. I must admit that anything that says gibson or fender in the description will draw at least 10 times as many views (probably 40 times) as something less common like Dean or DeArmond.

A lot of the Dearmond listings use the Guild name somewhere in the description or title just to draw views.