Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Planing perfect dados

Posts

Planing perfect dados

Edited #1

Planing perfect dados
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have begun to put together a series of articles based on the new Veritas Combination Plane. This is not intended as a review, but rather as a how to set it up for use. The methods used should be transferable to other similar planes.

In this article I focus on planing the perfect dado. For contrast, I have included the HNT Gordon dado plane as well as the Stanley #46 ...

35a.jpg

The article is too long to post here. Link to my website: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasCombinationPlane-dados.html

Regards from Perth
Derek

Re: Planing perfect dados

#2

Re: Planing perfect dados

david weaver

Nice article.

Two things come to mind (but don't matter much).

I've taken to modifying old dado planes to oddball sizes when necessary. There are a lot of common sizes, and sometimes for about $40 with a good depth adjuster and about an hour of tuning needed.

The supply in australia may not be quite so nice.

they do have the double nicker (two or three drags back and the entry is clean).

the other thing is that it's easier to leave a board a tad wide and cut the dados and then rip the boards to final width than it is to ensure a perfect backside to the cut.

if I missed that in your article, pardon!!

Deliberate work, and attention to detail on plane setup can't be understated (I guess people were using the dado planes I've acquired when they put them away, but the nickers are usually in rough shape if they haven't gotten rusted), neither can tuning the underside of the shelf going into the dado for the final tweak vs. fidgeting with the dado itself.

Most of the dado planes in the states were made in the throes of cheap planemaking and poor wood selection, which results in a skate/sole that's not parallel, but after tweaking, they're most pleasant to use (and we have the favorable situation of keeping planes in our shops and knowing what humidity and temp they're subjected to).

Re: Planing perfect dados

#3

Re: Planing perfect dados

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks David.

the other thing is that it's easier to leave a board a tad wide and cut the dados and then rip the boards to final width than it is to ensure a perfect backside to the cut.

Yes, one can do this. However, what I have demonstrated is that with three chisels strokes spelching is a thing of the past.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planing perfect dados

#4

Re: Planing perfect dados

david weaver

Perhaps in pine, but an errant stroke of the plane can still catch the edges. At least that's my experience - maybe attributable to not being deliberate enough sometimes.

It'd be interesting to know what old texts prescribe.

Maybe warren can advise if nicholson or roubo had planes of this type in shop made orientation.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#5

Re: Planing perfect dados

Paul in NJ

When I plane dados for a book shelf or carcass, I like to do both the left and right sides at the same time. I tightly butt the front show faces together so that when you plane, only the back side is in danger of spelching. This also ensures alignment for both sides eliminating one set of marking or measuring. Normally there is a rabbet for the back planed after the dados which would clean up any breakout. Sometimes I will make small angled saw cuts to the ends similar to what Derek showed with the chisel.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Planing perfect dados

#6

Re: Planing perfect dados

david weaver

>> small angled saw cuts <<

Me, too (i've done that in the past to try to mitigate horrible lateral splitouts), if the pieces are already ripped to width. I try to rip last, though. Rebate last is also a good idea.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#7

Re: Planing perfect dados

TMStock

Thanks, Derek - interesting reading. Had thought of replacing the army of #39's with something more flexible when I was still doing casework on a routine basis, but having things already set seemed handier. In looking at the last time I got any use out of those 39's, it seems like the LV plane might be a reasonable replacement.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#8

Re: Planing perfect dados

Steve Voigt

David, that's a good idea (modifying an odd-sized plane), especially since it easy to find too-large dado planes in the wild, the smaller ones having mostly been used up. As you know,the main problem with vintage dado planes is warping, partly due to their design, but probably due, as you say, to years of sub-optimal storage. You should do a post or one of your videos on this--it's something that could be very useful to people who want to make unplugged joints.

Derek, I strongly suspect such a plane, or just a vintage dado plane in good shape, would outperform the Gordon (and the others). At least the Gordon is skewed, but it is bedded at 60°, which seems totally unnecessary. Most traditional dado planes will be bedded at 47.5 or 50, thus will cut much more easily.

For folks who only want to own one plane, or are unwilling to learn wooden planes, I agree that the Stanley or Veritas are viable choices, though I think the slow setup time is not to be underestimated.

One small criticism of your otherwise excellent discussion: you don't discuss ergonomics. I am sure that the Gordon, and any vintage plane, would crush the metal planes on this score. It may not have been noticeable when making only one joint with each, but when making a case full of dados, it's surely an issue. In my view, ergonomics is the biggest reason to prefer a traditional dado plane, though ease of setup, as you note, is also an important factor.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#9

Re: Planing perfect dados

david weaver

Gordon's marketing material discusses "cranky" grain and the use of the 60 degree bed. I'd assume that he's angling toward cutting grooves against a batten as well as dados, and marketing to people mostly in australia.

His plane is $440 AUD, which doesn't seem at all unreasonable given he's making a living making them, but I got most of my dado planes for $10 (I recognize that's not a reasonable estimate, I just got a bunch of dilapidated planes that have all of their parts and need correction) about 10 years ago.

At any rate, they can be found for $50 relatively easily if you set up a search on ebay and let it bring them to you. They only need to be complete with a working depth stop (even that's not really needed, of course, and perhaps for neat/fine work marked ends and no depth stop is better because there's no foot burnishing the area next to the dado).

I guess it depends on the market. If two attorneys came to me and said they want to work dados by hand, I'd probably try to find them an expensive plane that works right away. Then they'll feel good about having it when they don't use it.

if someone getting deep into hand tools was looking for something, the combination planes just leave a negative thought in my mind (where there's one dado to cut, there's often 10 or 20 feet worth of them to cut in succession), and the refurbished american planes will be better working for bulk work than Terry's plane, and at current exchange rates, you could probably come into seven of them for the same price.

It's unfortunate that I was too dense to think to modify the planes for size until relatively recently. I don't know what I'd have been afraid of in the past - maybe modifying the nicker seemed like an issue.

If I built kitchen cabinets a second time, I'd use the dado plane for every dado in the cabinets. It was no slower than a router given the lack of stationary machinery that can work the center of a cabinet side and back a the same time, and with a router, you're still just running battens and pinning sides and backs together. And the errors are much more garish than a little bit of torn wood.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#10

Re: Planing perfect dados

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One small criticism of your otherwise excellent discussion: you don't discuss ergonomics. I am sure that the Gordon, and any vintage plane, would crush the metal planes on this score.

Thanks Steve.

I usually target ergonomics, but did not do so this time. The reason was that I was focussed on the result, the dado.

As plough planes go, the Veritas Small Plow is a delight to use. It is light and nimble, and so well balanced. The Veritas Combination Plane is just a larger version. What it loses in nimbleness, it more than makes up for in control. Here, too, the Veritas is comfortable to hold and easy to control.

The Stanley is equally, perhaps a tad better, balanced. Where it loses out to the Veritas is that the rods extend on the left. The 8" ones I have are too long for comfort. I have a set of 5" on the way, and I may even cut them down a little.

Now this may surprise you: both the Veritas and the Stanley were nicer to push than the HNT Gordon. The handle focused the force better, and the wooden body on the HNT Gordon ... after using the handles for a while ... cut into the palm a little. I would not have noticed this if I had been using the Gordon exclusively. In the years past it has been a comfortable plane to hold. I guess that it is a bit like switching between a coffin and a handled smoother. It could just be about preference.

The high cutting angle of the HNT Gordon planes is welcomed in Oz. I am not so sure that this is needed on a dado plane, however, since cutting across the grain is easier with a lower cutting angle. Yet it works, and works really well ... one could say the same of Terry's shoulder planes - they also have 60 degree beds. They should not cut so easily, but they do.

The bottom line for me is that the Veritas Combination Plane is brilliant in the two most needed modes - ploughing grooves and planing dados.

The next article will be on match planing. I will include my LN #49 as part of the demo. Perhaps a Stanley #45 or #46.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planing perfect dados

#11

Re: Planing perfect dados

Patrick Chase

Were you using back-beveled irons on the plough/combo planes in this instance? If so, what was the effective cutting angle?

I'm asking because cutting angle determines planing force, which in turn drives comfort independent of ergonomics. I can't help but wonder if the comfort deficit with the HNT Gordon was influenced more by its 60 degree cutting angle than by the tool's shape or lack of a tote.

Re: Planing perfect dados

Edited #12

Were you using back-beveled irons on the plough/combo planes in this instance? If so, what was the effective cutting angle?
I'm asking because cutting angle determines planing force, which in turn drives comfort independent of ergonomics. I can't help but wonder if the comfort deficit with the HNT Gordon was influenced more by its 60 degree cutting angle than by the tool's shape or lack of a tote.



Hi Patrick

No back bevels for any of the planes. This would be counter productive across the grain. The lowest practical cutting angles are sought in this instance.

Technically, you are correct when querying the high cutting angle of the HNT Gordon as a factor why it was harder to push. However, while this might add to the effort, it does not influence the grip, per se. What it will do is make one more sensitive to the ergonomics of the grip.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planing perfect dados

#13

Re: Planing perfect dados

David Weaver

I'm curious as to why Gordon places the mouth so far back on the plane. I've never noticed the beech versions to be uncomfortable but not sure what the difference would be with the gordon..The rear looks pretty traditional, it's just the mouth that's off.

Re: Planing perfect dados

Edited #14

Hi David

Firstly, I hope that I did not give the impression that the HNT Gordon was uncomfortable. That is not was I said, or my intention. In comparison with the handled planes, it was less comfortable. I was aware of the curve of the body. It was not an uncomfortable plane. I have used it very happily for some years and not thought it so. The comfort comment was a statement of relativity in the context of ergonomics.

Why is the mouth so far back? I do not consider it far back. The plane is beautifully balanced. It may be further back than US or English planes - keep in mind that Terry Gordon's influence is Chinese Malaysia. The bench planes I have have mouths that are set back.

HNT Gordon Trying Plane and Smoother ...

The%20HNT%20Gordon%20Smoother%20and%20Trying%20Plane_html_m19bfbb92.jpg

Regards from Perth
Derek

Re: Planing perfect dados

#15

Metal-bodied dedicated dado planes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Derek,

Have you tested or considered testing these against the dedicated dado planes? The Stanley 39 is better known, but the Sargent series (Nos. 32 to 38, the last digit expressing width in eighths) seems to have better ergonomics, with the little rhino horn on the front to grip.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#16

Re: Metal-bodied dedicated dado planes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

The article is not a review or comparison of dado planes, per se. It was not intended to determine which is the best dado plane. I hope it did not come across like that.

My reason for writing this piece was ..

(1) to offer a protocol for setting up the Veritas Combination Plane to create the best possible dado. The other planes were really used to assess whether it was doing "the best possible" (as well as another combination plane, the Stanley).

(2) to determine whether the Veritas Combination Plane would perform as well as a dedicated dado plane (here, the HNT Gordon).

No doubt there are better planes, no doubt there are better methods of setting up or using a combination plane, and no doubt there are better ways of creating a dado ... :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planing perfect dados

#17

Re: Metal-bodied dedicated dado planes

TMStock

I'm guessing the 39's would suffer a bit on ergonomics, given that they are on the UN list of devices banned from use by civilized nations conducting any form of interrogation. Good gloves and 800mg Ibuprofen help...a little.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#18

Re: Planing perfect dados

david weaver

I got that much (that none were said to be uncomfortable), but was curious because I always considered the stanley planes to be awkward compared to wooden planes.

I thought about the mouth location (after typing the first message) being made that way due to the chinese plane style basis, but think this is one where the european format would've been more comfortable to use and a bit easier to keep level through the cut (if not using the depth adjuster).

Re: Planing perfect dados

#19

Well, that was why I mentioned the Sargents

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I probably shouldn't have mentioned the Sargents, since I'm still looking for a 3/8" size; but they do seem to be a superior design as far as ergonomics.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#20

Re: Well, that was why I mentioned the Sargents

david weaver

As uncomfortable as the 39 has a reputation for being, I wonder if there's something we don't know about its grip or use.

For years on SMC, there was post after post about how uncomfortable shoulder planes of the old pattern are. They were always from people trying to hold them like rabbet planes.

Two hands and lay them on their side working astride rather than behind and suddenly the discomfort goes away without the need for all kinds of fixtures (and they sure do make miserable rabbet planes when they pack full of shavings....not to mention all of the friction).

Re: Planing perfect dados

#21

Re: Well, that was why I mentioned the Sargents

TMStock

Think I saw that one...

Stanleys & Demons: A Hallmark Mystery (2016). A aging hand tool aficionado attempts to solve the hundred year old mystery of why a major tool manufacturer created uncomfortable-to-use tools. Not recommended.

I did like the part where that crazy albino dude is tricked into using a #444 by the Ron Swanson character...so cool when he bleeds out after attempting the second test cut.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#22

Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Here is a video of Terry Gordon using a 1/4" dado plane (which he pronounces "daddo") to build a drawer joint. This will offer a better idea of how smoothly it works and how easily it is held ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JxOgPAEtUuk

There is another, this one of Terry planing dados to make sliding dovetails ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U-jO6UPwmZk

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planing perfect dados

#23

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

david weaver

Ahh, he's pulling it in one of the videos. That came to mind to me, too (that a push me pull you plane with a mouth in the middle does do that well).

Terry is excellent at demonstrating his planes and the results look different.

I think the 60 degree bed isn't really much of an issue in a dado plane given how easily most grain floats across wood. I'd be curious about your specific thoughts of whether or not it seems like much more effort.

Watch Terry use it suggests to me that thinner shaving and more hand speed sort of evens things out - presumably the pace was different when you were cutting dados?

Re: Planing perfect dados

Edited #24

Re: Metal-bodied dedicated dado planes

roger lance

"......and, no doubt, there are better ways to create a dado....."

That might make for an interesting topic.....another time.....another place (as various methods might involve power tools-which could cause some here to have palpitations).

Re: Planing perfect dados

#25

Re: Metal-bodied dedicated dado planes

david weaver

A dado set and a set stop (or group of set stops) on a crosscut sled is pretty nice!!

(I haven't cut a dado like that in about 10 years, but do recall the speed once set up)